Current Trainee and Workforce Patterns for Thyroid and Parathyroid Surgery in the United States.

OBJECTIVE: Thyroid and parathyroid surgery is performed by both general surgeons and otolaryngologists. We describe the proportion of surgeries performed by specialty, providing data to support decisions about when and to whom to direct research, education, and quality improvement interventions. METHODS: We tabulated case numbers for privately insured patients undergoing thyroid and parathyroid surgery in Marketscan: 2010-2016 and trainee case logs for residents and fellows in general surgery and otolaryngology. Summary statistics and tests for trends and differences were calculated. RESULTS: Marketscan data captured 114 500 thyroid surgeries. The proportion performed by each specialty was not significantly different. Otolaryngologists performed 58 098 and general surgeons performed 56 402. Otolaryngologists more commonly performed hemithyroidectomy (n = 25 148, 43.29% of all thyroid surgeries performed by otolaryngologists) compared to general surgeons (n = 20 353, 36.09% of all thyroid surgeries performed by general surgeons). Marketscan data captured 21 062 parathyroid surgeries: 6582 (31.25%) were performed by otolaryngologists, and 14 480 (68.75%) were performed by general surgeons. The case numbers of otolaryngology and general surgery trainees completing residency and fellowship varied 6- to 9-fold across different sites. The wide variation may reflect both the level of exposure a particular training program offers and trainee level of interest. CONCLUSION: Thyroid surgical care is equally provided by general surgeons and otolaryngologists. Both specialties contribute significantly to parathyroid surgical care. Both specialties should provide input into and be targets of research, quality, and education interventions.

Lessons Learned From a Single-Surgeon Experience of More Than 1700 Parathyroidectomies.

OBJECTIVE: To define critical elements that contribute to successful parathyroidectomy based on a high-volume single-surgeon experience and explore learning curve characteristics. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic analysis of prospectively maintained quality assurance database. SETTING: Academic tertiary care endocrine surgery practice. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: In total, 4737 consecutive patients who underwent thyroid or parathyroid surgery from 2004 to 2020 were identified. Demographic data acquisition was undertaken on a subset of these patients who had initial surgery for primary hyperparathyroidism during the academic years 2005 to 2018. Patients with renal or syndromic hyperparathyroidism and those undergoing reoperative surgery were excluded. RESULTS: From 1710 patients who underwent parathyroid surgery, 1082 met inclusion criteria in order to focus on a homogeneous data set. These patients had a mean age of 60.1 ± 12.5 years and 76.4% were female. The overall cure rate was 98.3%, reflecting a success rate that increased from 95.5% during the first 200 cases to 99.7% over the final 300 cases. The complication rate was 1.7%. Over 2 decades, the patient phenotype evolved toward milder disease and smaller adenomas. A learning curve of 200 cases was required to become a proficient parathyroid surgeon; to achieve exceptional results required several hundred additional cases. Parathyroid surgery represents a higher proportion of an endocrine surgery practice than previously (54.0% in 2019 compared with 25.5% in 2004). CONCLUSION: A focused practice dedicated to endocrine surgery yields surgical volumes exceeding 500 cases annually. There has been a steady shift toward parathyroid surgery. A lengthy learning curve can be shortened by pursuit of several specific strategies that are outlined in detail.

In Search of a Performing Seal: Rethinking the Design of Tight-Fitting Respiratory Protective Equipment Facepieces for Users With Facial Hair.

BACKGROUND: Air-purifying, tight-fitting facepieces are examples of respiratory protective equipment and are worn to protect workers from potentially harmful particulate and vapors. Research shows that the presence of facial hair on users' face significantly reduces the efficacy of these devices. This article sets out to establish if an acceptable seal could be achieved between facial hair and the facepiece. The team also created and investigated a low-cost "pressure testing" method for assessing the efficacy of a seal to be used during the early design process for a facepiece designed to overcome the facial hair issue. METHODS: Nine new designs for face mask seals were prototyped as flat samples. A researcher developed a test rig, and a test protocol was used to evaluate the efficacy of the new seal designs against facial hair. Six of the seal designs were also tested using a version of the conventional fit test. The results were compared with those of the researcher-developed test to look for a correlation between the two test methods. RESULTS: None of the seals performed any better against facial hair than a typical, commercially available facepiece. The pressure testing method devised by the researchers performed well but was not as robust as the fit factor testing. CONCLUSION: The results show that sealing against facial hair is extremely problematic unless an excessive force is applied to the facepiece's seal area pushing it against the face. The means of pressure testing devised by the researchers could be seen as a low-cost technique to be used at the early stages of a the design process, before fit testing is viable.

American Head and Neck Society Endocrine Surgery Section update on parathyroid imaging for surgical candidates with primary hyperparathyroidism.

Health care consumer organizations and insurance companies increasingly are scrutinizing value when considering reimbursement policies for medical interventions. Recently, members of several American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head & Neck Surgery (AAO-HNS) committees worked closely with one insurance company to refine reimbursement policies for preoperative localization imaging in patients undergoing surgery for primary hyperparathyroidism. This endeavor led to an AAO-HNS parathyroid imaging consensus statement (https://www.entnet.org/content/parathyroid-imaging). The American Head and Neck Society Endocrine Surgery Section gathered an expert panel of authors to delineate imaging options for preoperative evaluation of surgical candidates with primary hyperparathyroidism. We review herein the current literature for preoperative parathyroid localization imaging, with discussion of efficacy, cost, and overall value. We recommend that planar sestamibi imaging, single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), SPECT/CT, CT neck/mediastinum with contrast, MRI, and four dimensional CT (4D-CT) may be used in conjunction with high-resolution neck ultrasound to preoperatively localize pathologic parathyroid glands. PubMed literature on parathyroid imaging was reviewed through February 1, 2019.

Routine bilateral neck exploration and four-gland dissection remains unnecessary in modern parathyroid surgery.

OBJECTIVE: Recent advances in preoperative imaging techniques and intraoperative parathyroid hormone (ioPTH) assays have made single-gland, minimally invasive parathyroidectomy (MIP) the preferred treatment option for most patients with primary hyperparathyroidism (pHPT). Despite this evolution, a recommendation for bilateral neck exploration (BNE) with four-gland dissection in all patients has recently been advocated by a parathyroid surgical group. The current study compares the long-term outcomes of MIP with those of conventional BNE with four-gland dissection in patients with pHPT. METHODS: In order to objectively assess a recommendation in the literature that universal BNE with four-gland dissection is advisable, all patients undergoing an initial MIP with ioPTH assessment for pHPT in a tertiary endocrine practice during a 10-year period were reviewed. The cure rates from this procedure were compared with published results of conventional BNE with four-gland dissection. RESULTS: Of the 561 patients undergoing parathyroidectomy during the study period, 337 had initial surgery for pHPT; 282 of these patients met inclusion criteria and 212 had sufficient follow-up data available. A single adenoma was identified in 87.3% of cases. Preoperative imaging studies were co-localizing in 148 (69.8%), and 127 (85.8%) of these patients with co-localizing imaging required only single-gland surgery. Imaging studies did not co-localize in 49 patients, yet 32 (65.3%) of these patients were still cured with unilateral surgery. The cure rate for patients undergoing MIP was 98.6%, with a long-term recurrence rate of <2%. CONCLUSION: When coupled with the ioPTH assay, patients with at least one preoperative localizing study can undergo MIP and anticipate a cure rate of 99%, which is as good as or better than the published rates for conventional BNE with four-gland dissection. With unilateral surgery, the risks of permanent hypoparathyroidism and airway obstruction from bilateral vocal fold paralysis are completely eliminated. Therefore, despite recommendations to the contrary, most patients with pHPT should not have a planned four-gland exploration. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III or IV.

Neck Dissection in the Surgical Treatment of Thyroid Cancer.

The incidence of thyroid cancer is increasing, largely attributable to overdetection related to prevalent diagnostic and radiologic imaging modalities. Papillary thyroid cancer remains the most common thyroid malignancy. It has a high tendency for regional metastasis to the cervical lymph nodes. The optimal management of the neck in patients with thyroid carcinoma has long been an important topic of debate. This article addresses central and lateral neck dissection, providing a simplified guide to the most up-to-date and evidence-based practices.

Protocol driven outcomes in renal parathyroid surgery.

BACKGROUND: Patients who require surgery for renal hyperparathyroidism represent a special population that is at high risk for postoperative complications. To optimize their treatment, we developed a multidisciplinary approach to the perioperative management of these patients undergoing parathyroidectomy. METHODS: The Augusta University endocrine surgery parathyroid database was interrogated to identify dialysis-dependent patients undergoing parathyroidectomy from 2005 to 2015. Numerous clinical parameters were quantified. Patients were stratified into protocol patients and nonprotocol patients. RESULTS: A total of 42 patients undergoing renal parathyroidectomy who met the inclusion criteria were identified. Serious adverse events were nearly twice as common in the patients not treated on protocol. The length of stay was nearly 2 days shorter in the protocol group. Lowest calcium level and ionized calcium was higher in the protocol cohort despite a lower postoperative parathyroid hormone. The protocol group had fewer laboratory draws. CONCLUSION: Implementation of a multidisciplinary renal hyperparathyroidism protocol has resulted in improved perioperative outcomes.

Evolving phenotype of the head and neck surgeon.

OBJECTIVE: Characterize the evolution of head and neck (H&N) surgical practices in the United States over two decades by using resident case log data as a surrogate. METHODS: National residency case log data from all Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education-accredited otolaryngology residency programs was reviewed for the past 20 academic years (1996-2015). Key indicator procedures in each subcategory of H&N were analyzed to characterize standard ablative H&N surgical practices. Mean number of cases completed per resident each year was calculated. RESULTS: The proportion of H&N surgeries contributing to the total number of otolaryngology cases performed yearly remained relatively stable during the study period, ranging from 6.4% to 8.7%, indicating concurrent growth of H&N cases with all otolaryngology surgeries. Although each subcategory within H&N demonstrated modest increases in the number of cases performed per resident each year over the study period, the most significant growth occurred in the endocrine surgery subcategory: a 288% increase from 18.4 in 1996 to 71.5 in 2015. The proportion of H&N cases represented by each subcategory decreased, except for endocrine, which more than doubled in proportion from 21% in 1996 to 43% in 2015. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest that the modern H&N surgeon is increasingly becoming an endocrine and H&N surgeon. The proportion of endocrine surgeries performed in residency, which serves as a surrogate for H&N practices, has more than doubled over the past 20 years and now represents the largest subcategory of H&N surgery. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: NA Laryngoscope, 129:1150-1154, 2019.

Baseline intraoperative intact parathyroid hormone levels in parathyroid surgery.

BACKGROUND: We sought to evaluate the relationship between the preoperative core-laboratory parathyroid hormone (CL-PTH) level and the baseline intraoperative PTH (IOPTH) level and assess the impact of any differences on clinical decision making in consecutive surgical patients with primary hyperparathyroidism undergoing parathyroidectomy. METHODS: The CL-PTH and baseline IOPTH levels were compared. The influence of relying on either the CL-PTH or baseline PTH levels for intraoperative decision making was determined. RESULTS: Data were available for 316 patients. Baseline IOPTH measurements were usually higher than the CL-PTH (247 patients; 78.2%) measurements, with a mean difference of 68.2 pg/mL (P < .001). Using the CL-PTH as a surrogate for the baseline parathyroid hormone (PTH) would have prolonged the operation in 23 patients (7.3%). CONCLUSION: Baseline point-of-care IOPTH levels were higher than the preoperative CL-PTH levels in >75% of patients undergoing parathyroidectomy. Using the CL-PTH in lieu of an IOPTH baseline value would prolong the operation in some patients.

AHNS Series: Do you know your guidelines? Optimizing outcomes in reoperative parathyroid surgery: Definitive multidisciplinary joint consensus guidelines of the American Head and Neck Society and the British Association of Endocrine and Thyroid Surgeons.

BACKGROUND: Revision parathyroid is challenging due to possible diagnostic uncertainty as well as the technical challenges it can present. METHODS: A multidisciplinary panel of distinguished experts from the American Head and Neck Society (AHNS) Endocrine Section, the British Association of Endocrine and Thyroid Surgeons (BAETS), and other invited experts have reviewed this topic with the purpose of making recommendations based on current best evidence. The literature was also reviewed on May 12, 2017. PubMed (1946-2017), Cochrane SR (2005-2017), CT databases (1997-2017), and Web of Science (1945-2017) were searched with the following strategy: revision and reoperative parathyroidectomy to ensure completeness. RESULTS: Guideline recommendations were made in 3 domains: preoperative evaluation, surgical management, and alternatives to surgery. Eleven guideline recommendations are proposed. CONCLUSION: Reoperative parathyroid surgery is best avoided if possible. Our literature search and subsequent recommendations found that these cases are best managed by experienced surgeons using precision preoperative localization, intraoperative parathyroid hormone (PTH), and the team approach.

Surgical management of the recurrent laryngeal nerve in thyroidectomy: American Head and Neck Society Consensus Statement.

"I have noticed in operations of this kind, which I have seen performed by others upon the living, and in a number of excisions, which I have myself performed on the dead body, that most of the difficulty in the separation of the tumor has occurred in the region of these ligaments…. This difficulty, I believe, to be a very frequent source of that accident, which so commonly occurs in removal of goiter, I mean division of the recurrent laryngeal nerve." Sir James Berry (1887).

Outpatient thyroidectomy is safe in the elderly and super-elderly.

OBJECTIVES: 1) Determine the safety of outpatient thyroidectomy in the geriatric patient population. 2) Analyze the risk of postoperative complications from thyroid surgery in patients aged over 65 years (elderly) and aged over 80 years (super-elderly) undergoing ambulatory thyroidectomy compared to patients aged 21 through 40 years. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective analysis of consecutive patients undergoing thyroidectomy between January 2008 and July 2015 at a tertiary academic institution. METHOD: Patients were stratified by age, and three subsets within this population were considered and analyzed further: youthful/control (aged 21-40 years), elderly (aged 65-79 years), and super-elderly (≥ 80 years). Patient demographics, surgical and pathological data, admission status, complication, and readmission rates were recorded. RESULTS: A total of 1,429 thyroidectomies were accomplished; of these, 1,207 (84.5%) were outpatient operations. Among the outpatients, 85.2% were female, 14.1% were male, and the mean age was 50.3 ± 15.2 years. The control (youthful) group was comprised of 328 patients with a mean age of 33.3 years; the elderly group of 201 patients had a mean age of 70.3 years; and 16 patients in the super-elderly group had a mean age 82.7 years. The complication rates (5.2%, 5.0%, and 6.3%, respectively; P = 0.98) and re-admission rates (1.5%, 1.5%, and 0.0%, respectively; P = 0.89) were not different among these groups. CONCLUSION: Outpatient thyroid surgery is as safe in appropriately selected elderly and super-elderly patients as it is in a control group of youthful patients. Therefore, age should not be a contraindication to conducting thyroidectomy on an ambulatory basis. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4. Laryngoscope, 128:290-294, 2018.

Aesthetics in Thyroid Surgery: The Patient Perspective.

Objectives To define characteristics that influence patient perceptions of thyroidectomy scar cosmesis. Study Design Prospective cohort study. Setting Tertiary endocrine surgery practice in an academic medical center. Subjects and Methods Institutional review board-approved trial in which 136 subjects were recruited from a population of patients being seen for either thyroid or sinus surgery and evaluated standardized photographs, superimposed with computer-generated thyroidectomy scars of varying lengths (2, 4, and 6 cm) and widths (1 and 2 mm), and graded their perception of the scars using the observer scar assessment scale (OSAS) domains of the patient and observer scar assessment scale. Results There were 69 subjects in the thyroid group and 67 in the nonthyroid group. Controlling for width, longer scars were perceived as worse than shorter scars; controlling for length, thicker scars were perceived as worse than thinner scars ( P < .01). Beyond 2 cm, thick scars were judged to be worse than thin scars, even when they were shorter. There was no difference in the mean overall OSAS scores between surgery, sex, or age groups. Nonwhites tended to judge scars as being worse than whites did ( P < .01). Conclusion As expected, patients of all demographics prefer shorter scars compared with longer scars and thinner scars over thick scars. Ethnic differences in scar perception were identified and deserve additional study. Surgeons should endeavor to perform thyroid surgery through the smallest incision that allows the operation to be performed safely to minimize the cosmetic impact of the operation.

Persistently elevated parathyroid hormone after successful parathyroid surgery.

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Explore potential causes of persistently elevated parathyroid hormone levels after curative parathyroidectomy in patients with primary hyperparathyroidism due to single gland disease. STUDY DESIGN: Case series with planned data collection. METHODS: An analysis was undertaken of 314 patients with primary hyperparathyroidism undergoing parathyroid surgery in a tertiary academic practice between January 2009 and April 2013. There were 187 patients with single-gland disease; 68 failed to meet inclusion criteria, resulting in a study population of 119 patients. Preoperative parathyroid hormone, calcium, ionized calcium, 25-OH-vitamin D, creatinine, and glomerular filtration rate values were determined, along with postoperative calcium, ionized calcium, and parathyroid hormone levels. Patients were divided into two groups based on their postoperative parathyroid hormone values: elevated parathyroid hormone and normal parathyroid hormone. RESULTS: Thirty (25.2%) patients achieved postoperative normocalcemia but had elevated parathyroid hormone levels. This group had significantly higher preoperative levels of parathyroid hormone (P =.002) and creatinine (P =.007), and a lower glomerular filtration rate (P =.002) than patients with normal postoperative parathyroid hormone levels. The preoperative 25-OH-vitamin D level was not significantly associated with an elevated parathyroid hormone (odds ratio [OR]: 1.56). Preoperative impaired renal function, specifically an abnormal glomerular filtration rate (OR: 12.8), was significantly associated with an elevated parathyroid hormone. CONCLUSIONS: Parathyroid hormone remains elevated in 25% of patients who are cured (eucalcemic) after surgery for primary hyperparathyroidism. This phenomenon was associated with higher preoperative parathyroid hormone levels and impaired renal function rather than low 25-OH-vitamin D levels. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4. Laryngoscope, 127:1720-1723, 2017.

An update on the status of nerve monitoring for thyroid/parathyroid surgery.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) injury is one of the most common and serious complications associated with thyroid and parathyroid surgery. Although routine visual identification of the RLN is considered the current standard of care, the role of intraoperative neuromonitoring (IONM) of the RLN is more controversial. RECENT FINDINGS: Despite initial enthusiasm that IONM might substantially reduce the rate of RLN injury, most studies failed to show a significant difference in the rate of RLN injury when the use of IONM was compared with visualization of the RLN alone. However, a small number of investigators have reported statistically significant differences in the rates of nerve injury when IONM is used to augment visualization alone, particularly in certain high-risk situations. Despite a lack of conclusive data showing benefit, the use of IONM as an adjunct to visual identification of the RLN has gained increasing acceptance among surgeons. IONM remains an excellent tool to help verify the identity of the RLN, confirm its functional integrity, and pinpoint the site of nerve injury in the event of dysfunction. SUMMARY: The utility of IONM in reducing the rate of RLN injury is largely unproven and remains controversial. However, the use of IONM may be helpful in certain high-risk cases. Promising new technology, such as vagal nerve monitoring, may allow more real-time monitoring of the functional integrity of the RLN and allow the surgeon to react in a timely manner to evolving dysfunction in order to abort maneuvers that may risk definitive injury.

Remote Access Robotic Facelift Thyroidectomy: A Multi-institutional Experience.

BACKGROUND: Robotic facelift thyroidectomy (RFT) was developed as a new surgical approach to the thyroid gland using a remote incision site. Early favorable results led to this confirmatory multi-institutional experience. METHODS: Prospectively collected data on consecutive patients undergoing RFT in five North American academic endocrine surgical practices were compiled. Surgical indications, operative times, final pathology, nodule size, complications, and postoperative management (drain use and length of hospital stay) were evaluated. RESULTS: A total of 102 RFT procedures were undertaken in 90 patients. All but one of the patients (98.9 %) were female, and the mean age was 41.9 ± 13.1 years (range 12-69 years). The indication for surgery was nodular disease in 91.2 % of cases; 8.8 % were completion procedures performed for a diagnosis of cancer. The mean size of the largest nodule was 1.9 cm (range 0-5.6 cm). The mean total operative time for a thyroid lobectomy was 162 min (range 82-265 min). No permanent complications occurred. There were 4 cases (3.9 %) of transient recurrent laryngeal nerve weakness, no cases of hypocalcemia, and 3 (2.9 %) hematomas. There were no conversions to an anterior cervical approach. The majority of patients were managed on an outpatient basis (61.8 %) and without a drain (65.7 %). CONCLUSIONS: RFT is technically feasible and safe in selected patients. RFT can continue to be offered to carefully selected patients as a way to avoid a visible cervical scar. Future prospective studies to compare this novel approach to other remote access approaches are warranted.