Cationic ligands - from monodentate to pincer systems.

For a long time, the small group of cationic ligands stood out as obscure systems within the general landscape of coordinative chemistry. However, this situation has started to change rapidly during the last decade, with more and more examples of metal-coordinated cationic species being reported. The growing interest in these systems is not only of purely academic nature, but also driven by accumulating evidence of their high catalytic utility. Overcoming the inherently poor coordinating ability of cationic species often required additional structural stabilization. In numerous cases this was realized by functionalizing them with a pair of chelating side-arms, effectively constructing a pincer-type scaffold. This comprehensive review aims to encompass all cationic ligands possessing such pincer architecture reported to date. Herein every cationic species that has ever been embedded in a pincer framework is described in terms of its electronic structure, followed by an in-depth discussion of its donor/acceptor properties, based on computational studies (DFT) and available experimental data (IR, NMR or CV). We then elaborate on how the positive charge of these ligands affects the spectroscopic and redox properties, as well as the reactivity, of their complexes, compared to those of the structurally related neutral ligands. Among other systems discussed, this review also surveys our own contribution to this field, namely, the introduction of sulfonium-based pincer ligands and their complexes, recently reported by our group.

Sulfonium Cation in the Service of π-Acid Catalysis.

While still rare, cationic ligands offer much promise as tunable electron-withdrawing ligands for π-acid catalysis. Recently, we introduced pincer-type sulfonium cations into the list of available strongly π-acidic ancillary ligands. However, the M-S bond in sulfonium complexes of these ligands was found highly labile, precluding their catalytic applications. Herein we demonstrate that this obstacle can be overcome by increasing the rigidity of the sulfonium pincer scaffold. X-ray analyses confirm that despite bearing a formal positive charge, the sulfur atom of this newly designed sulfonium ligand maintains its coordination to the Pt(II)-center, while DFT calculations indicate that by doing so it strongly enhances the electrophilic character of the metal. Kinetic studies carried out on three model cycloisomerization reactions prove that such a tris-cationic sulfonium-Pt(II) complex is highly reactive, compared to its thioether-based analogue. This proof-of-concept study presents the first example of employing sulfonium-based ligands in homogeneous catalysis.

Effect of Internal Ligand Strain on Coordination Behavior of PSP Pincer Ligands.

Chelating ligands and most specifically pincer ligands, with their characteristic co-planar binding, usually undergo deformations upon coordination, resulting in a significant ligand strain. Such an effect on the properties of the so formed complex has rarely been explored. This study is an attempt to analyze this strain and its contribution to the overall binding energy and coordination behavior of PSP pincer ligands. Hence, we designed a rigid thioxanthone-based PSP pincer ligand (I) and studied the difference in the coordination properties with the more flexible thioxanthene and thioether-based PSP pincer ligands (II and III). Although with one equivalent of Pd(II) precursor, the three ligands exhibited a similar coordination behavior leading to similar κ3-P,S,P pincer complexes, an in-depth computational analysis pointed out the different contributions of the internal strain energy in lowering the binding energy of these complexes. This effect was clearly reflected when we calculated the enthalpy change of these ligand-exchange reactions. As these exchange reactions are enthalpy-driven, these results could also be confirmed experimentally. With two equivalents of Pd(II), the three ligands diverged in their coordination behavior. Specifically, ligands I and III gave each a binuclear complex, with different coordination modes, whereas the pincer complex of ligand II remained unaffected by excess of Pd(II). Our calculations suggest that the driving force for the formation of binuclear Pd(II) complexes is the relief of the internal ligand strain. With Pt(II), only the mononuclear κ3-P,S,P pincer complexes were obtained irrespectively of the amount of the Pt(II) precursor. In these cases, we assume that kinetic inertness of the formed mononuclear pincer Pt(II) complexes prevents binding of an additional Pt(II) nucleus. This study points out the important role of the internal ligand strain in PSP pincer ligand coordination behavior. We believe that our findings can be extended to other pincer ligands systems as well.

Sulfonium cations as versatile strongly π-acidic ligands.

More than a century old, sulfonium cations are still intriguing species in the landscape of organic chemistry. On one hand they have found broad applications in organic synthesis and materials science, but on the other hand, while isoelectronic to the ubiquitous tertiary phosphine ligands, their own coordination chemistry has been neglected for the last three decades. Here we report the synthesis and full characterization of the first Rh(i) and Pt(ii) complexes of sulfonium. Moreover, for the first time, coordination of an aromatic sulfonium has been established. A thorough computational analysis of the exceptionally short S-Rh bonds obtained attests to the strongly π-accepting nature of sulfonium cations and places them among the best π-acceptor ligands available today. Our calculations also show that embedding within a pincer framework enhances their π-acidity even further. Therefore, in addition to the stability and modularity that these frameworks offer, our pincer complexes might open the way for sulfonium cations to become powerful tools in π-acid catalysis.