ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: We here describe treatment outcomes in two adenosine deaminase (ADA)-deficiency patients (pt) who received stem cell gene therapy (SCGT) with no cytoreductive conditioning. As this protocol has features distinct from those of other clinical trials, its results provide insights into SCGT for ADA deficiency. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Pt 1 was treated at age 4.7 years, whereas pt 2, who had previously received T-cell gene therapy, was treated at age 13 years. Bone marrow CD34(+) cells were harvested after enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) was withdrawn; following transduction of ADA cDNA by the γ-retroviral vector GCsapM-ADA, they were administered intravenously. No cytoreductive conditioning, at present considered critical for therapeutic benefit, was given before cell infusion. Hematological/immunological reconstitution kinetics, levels of systemic detoxification, gene-marking levels, and proviral insertion sites in hematopoietic cells were assessed. RESULTS: Treatment was well tolerated, and no serious adverse events were observed. Engraftment of gene-modified repopulating cells was evidenced by the appearance and maintenance of peripheral lymphocytes expressing functional ADA. Systemic detoxification was moderately achieved, allowing temporary discontinuation of ERT for 6 and 10 years in pt 1 and pt 2, respectively. Recovery of immunity remained partial, with lymphocyte counts in pts 1 and 2, peaked at 408/mm(3) and 1248/mm(3), approximately 2 and 5 years after SCGT. Vector integration site analyses confirmed that hematopoiesis was reconstituted with a limited number of clones, some of which were shown to have myelo-lymphoid potential. CONCLUSIONS: Outcomes in SCGT for ADA-SCID are described in the context of a unique protocol, which used neither ERT nor cytoreductive conditioning. Although proven safe, immune reconstitution was partial and temporary. Our results reiterate the importance of cytoreductive conditioning to ensure greater benefits from SCGT.
Subject(s)
Adenosine Deaminase/deficiency , Adenosine Deaminase/genetics , Agammaglobulinemia/genetics , Agammaglobulinemia/therapy , Genetic Therapy , Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation , Severe Combined Immunodeficiency/genetics , Severe Combined Immunodeficiency/therapy , Adenosine Deaminase/immunology , Adenosine Deaminase/therapeutic use , Adolescent , Agammaglobulinemia/diagnosis , Agammaglobulinemia/immunology , Age of Onset , Cell Differentiation , Child, Preschool , Enzyme Activation , Enzyme Replacement Therapy , Gammaretrovirus/genetics , Gene Expression , Genetic Vectors/genetics , Hematopoiesis , Hematopoietic Stem Cells/cytology , Hematopoietic Stem Cells/metabolism , Humans , Immunity , Immunophenotyping , Infant , Infant, Newborn , Japan , Lymphocyte Subsets/immunology , Lymphocyte Subsets/metabolism , Mutation , Severe Combined Immunodeficiency/diagnosis , Severe Combined Immunodeficiency/immunology , Transduction, Genetic , Transgenes , Treatment OutcomeABSTRACT
The present study compares immune reconstitution after allogeneic cord blood transplantation (CBT) and CD34+ stem cell transplantation (CD34-SCT) with that after bone marrow transplantation (BMT). Eighty-eight children who underwent CBT (20 patients), BMT (58), and CD34-SCT (10) were enrolled, and lymphocytes and T-, B-, and natural killer-lymphocyte subsets were monitored for more than 5 years after transplantation. CBT recipients showed significant ircreases in (1) total lymphocyte counts (P < .001), (2) CD4+/CD8+ cell ratios (P < .01), (3) CD4+ and CD4+CD45RA+ cells (P < .001), (4) CD8+CD11b+ cells (P < .001), and (5) CD19+ and CD19+CD5+ cells (P < .0001) and marked decreases in the frequencies of CD8+ and CD8+CD11b- cells (P < .0001). CD34-SCT recipients showed lower lymphocyte counts in the first 6 months and an emergence of lymphocyte and CD4+CD45RA+ cells at approximately 9 months and 1 year. Both CBT and CD34-SCT recipients showed increased frequencies of CD56+ cells at 1 month (CD34-SCT versus BMT, P < .001) but decreased frequencies after 6 months (CBT versus BMT, P < .001). Lymphoproliferative responses to exogenous interleukin 2 were constantly lower in CBT and CD34-SCT recipients than in BMT recipients. These results suggest that the delay in immune reconstitution after CBT in the early phase was mainly qualitative and related to the immaturity of cells, whereas the delay in CD34-SCT was mainly quantitative in the first several months.
