Proton transport in photooxidation of water: A new perspective on photosynthesis.

The currently prevalent concept of the generation of photosynthetic reducing power in oxygen-evolving cells envisions a linear (noncyclic) electron flow from water to ferredoxin (and thence to NADP(+)) that requires the collaboration of photosystems I and II (PSI and PSII) joined by plastoquinone and other electron carriers (the Z scheme). The essence of the Z scheme is that only PSI can reduce ferredoxin-i.e., that, after being energized to an intermediate reducing potential by PSII, electrons from water are transported via plastoquinone to PSI which energizes the electrons to their ultimate reducing potential adequate for the reduction of ferredoxin. Basic to the Z scheme is the function of plastoquinone as the obligatory link in electron transport from PSII to PSI. However, we have found that, when plastoquinone function was inhibited, ferredoxin was photoreduced by water without the collaboration of PSI. We now report evidence for an important function of plastoquinone in the translocation of protons liberated inside the thylakoid membrane by photooxidation of water. When the oxygenic photoreduction (i.e., by water) of ferredoxin was blocked by plastoquinone inhibitors, dibromothymoquinone or dinitrophenol ether of iodonitrothymol, the photoreduction of ferredoxin was restored by each of four chemically diverse uncouplers, similar only in their ability to facilitate proton movement across membranes. Similar results were obtained for the oxygenic reduction of NADP(+). Our results suggest that the light-induced electron flow from water cannot be maintained unless the simultaneously liberated protons are removed from inside the membrane via plastoquinone. The new evidence is embodied in a concept of an oxygenic photosystem for photosynthetic electron and proton transport, which we propose as an alternative to the Z scheme, to account for photoreduction of ferredoxin-NADP(+) by water and the coupled oxygenic (formerly noncyclic) ATP formation without involving PSI. The role of the anoxygenic photosystem (formerly called PSI) is ATP formation by cyclic photophosphorylation.

Contrasts between oxygenic and anoxygenic photoreduction of ferredoxin: Incompatibilities with prevailing concepts of photosynthetic electron transport.

An investigation by paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy of the photoreduction of ferredoxin, oxygenically by water and anoxygenically by a direct electron donor to photosystem I, led to the unexpected findings that different reductive mechanisms may be involved. Ferredoxin photoreduced by water was not reoxidized in the light under aerobic conditions and, under anaerobic conditions, it was remarkably resistant to reoxidation in the dark. By contrast, ferredoxin photoreduced by a donor to photosystem I was readily reoxidized in the light by air and, under anaerobic conditions, by exposure to darkness. Furthermore, when electron transport linking photosystems I and II was inhibited by a plastoquinone antagonist, ferredoxin was photoreduced by water with no evidence for an accompanying photoreduction of the more electronegative bound iron-sulfur centers in chloroplasts. These findings are at variance with the now prevalent concepts of photosynthetic electron transport.

Electron paramagentic resonance studies of photosynthetic electron transport: photoreduction of ferredoxinand membrane-bound iron-sulfur centers.

Electron paramagnetic resonance spectrometry was used to investigate, at physiological temperatures, light-induced electron transport from membrane-bound iron-sulfur components (bound ferredoxin) to soluble ferredoxin and NADP(+) in membrane fragments (from the blue-green alga, Nostoc muscorum) that had high rates of electron transport from water to NADP(+) and from an artificial electron donor, reduced dichlorophenolindophenol (DCIPH(2)) to NADP(+). Illumination at 20 degrees resulted in the photoreduction of membrane-bound iron-sulfur centers A and B. Photoreduction by water gave electron paramagnetic resonance signals of both centers A and B; photoreduction by DCIPH(2) was found to generate a strong electron paramagnetic signal of only center B. When water was the reductant, the addition and photoreduction of soluble ferredoxin generated additional signals characteristics of soluble ferredoxin without causing a decrease in the amplitude of the signals due to centers A and B. The further addition of NADP(+) (and its photoreduction) greatly diminished signals due to the bound iron-sulfur centers and to soluble ferredoxin. An outflow of electrons from center B to soluble ferredoxin and NADP(+) was particularly pronounced when DCIPH(2) was the reductant. These observations provide the first evidence for a light-induced electron transport between membrane-bound iron-sulfur centers and ferredoxin-NADP(+). The relationship of these observations to current concepts of photosynthetic electron transport is discussed.

Effect of NADP on light-induced cytochrome changes in membrane fragments from a blue-green alga.

The effect of NADP+ on light-induced steady-state redox changes of membrane-bound cytochromes was investigated in membrane fragements prepared from the blue-green algae Nostoc muscorum (Strain 7119) that had high rates of electron transport from water to NADP+ and from an artificial electron donor, reduced dichlorophenolindophenol (DCIPH2) to NDAP+. The membrane fragments contained very little phycocyanin and had excellent optical properties for spectrophotometric assays. With DCIPH2 as the electron donor, NADP+ had no effect on the light-induced redox changes of cytochromes: with or without NADP+, 715- or 664-nm illumination resulted mainly in the oxidation of cytochrome f and of other component(s) which may include a c-type cytochrome with an alpha peak at 549nm. With 664 nm illumination and water as the electron donor, NADP+ had a pronounced effect on the redox state of cytochromes, causing a shift toward oxidation of a component with a peak at 549 nm (possibly a c-type cytochrome), cytochrome f, and particularly cytochrome b559. Cytochrome b559 appeared to be a component of the main noncyclic electron transport chain and was photooxidized at physiological temperatures by Photosystem II. This photooxidation was apparent only in the presence of a terminal acceptor (NADP+) for the electron flow from water.

Effects of magnesium and chloride ions on light-induced electron transport in membrane fragments from a blue-green alga.

The effects of magnesium and chloride ions on photosynthetic electron transport were investigated in membrane fragments of a blue-green alga, Nostoc muscorum (Strain 7119), noted for their stability and high rates of electron transport from water or reduced dichlorophenolindophenol to NADP+. Magnesium ions were required not only for light-induced electron transport from water to NADP+ but also for protection in the dark of the integrity of the water-photooxidizing system (Photosystem II). Membrane fragments suspended in the dark in a medium lacking Mg2+ lost the capacity to photoreduce NADP+ with water on subsequent illumination. Chloride ions could substitute, but less effectively, for each of these two effects of Chloride ions could substitute, but less effectively, for each of these two effects of magnesium ions. By contrast, the photoreduction of NADP+ by DCIPH2 was independent of Mg2+ (or Cl-) for the protection of the electron transport system in the dark or during the light reaction proper. Furthermore, high concentration of MgGl2 produced a strong inhibition of NADP+ photoreduction with DCIPH2 without significantly affecting the rate of NADP+ photoreduction with water. The implications of these findings for the differential involvement of Photosystem I and Photosystem II in the photoreduction of NADP+ with different electron donors are discussed.

Evidence from chloroplast fragments for three photosynthetic light reactions.

Previous reports from this laboratory described a new concept of three light reactions in plant photosynthesis comprising two short-wavelength (lambda < 700 nm) photoreactions belonging to Photosystem II and one long-wavelength (lambda > 700 nm) photoreaction belonging to Photosystem I. Among the electron carriers assigned to Photosystem II were cytochrome b(559) and plastocyanin and to Photosystem I, cytochrome f.According to a widely held view, the light-induced reduction of NADP by water requires the collaboration of Photosystems I and II and involves specifically cytochrome f and P700 (a portion of chlorophyll a peculiar to Photosystem I). By contrast, the new concept ascribes the light-induced reduction of NADP by water solely to the two photoreactions of Photosystem II, without the participation of Photosystem I and its components, cytochrome f and P700.Further evidence in support of the new concept has now been obtained from chloroplast fragments. Two kinds of chloroplast fragments have been prepared: (a) one with Photosystem II activity, capable-in the presence of plastocyanin-of photoreducing NADP with water but lacking P700 and functional cytochrome f and (b) another having only Photosystem I activity, lacking plastocyanin, and enriched in P700.

Differential effects of desaspidin on photosynthetic phosphorylation.

Sensitivity to low concentrations of desaspidin (5 x 10(-7)m) sharply distinguishes the photophosphorylations associated with the photooxidation of water from all other types of photophosphorylation by isolated chloroplasts. Contrary to recent reports in the literature, the effects of desapidin were not altered by changes in the redox conditions as influenced by the concentration of ascorbate and by the presence or absence of oxygen. Desaspidin consistently inhibited all types of cyclic photophosphorylation and the photophosphorylation coupled with the reduction of NADP by ascorbate-dichlorophenol indophenol. The same concentration of desaspidin gave little or no inhibition of photophosphorylation that are coupled with the photooxidation of water.