Hotspots and future trends of phosphorus recycling from livestock manure: A bibliometric review.

In recent decades, the importance of managing the earth's dwindling phosphorus (P) has grown exponentially, as have efforts to develop a circular economy. Livestock manure represents a P-rich waste product, so recycling P from livestock manure has garnered the attention of scholars worldwide. Based on a global database from 1978 to 2021, this study presents the current status of recycling P from livestock manure and proposes strategies for efficient P utilization. Unlike traditional review articles, this work establishes a visual collaborative network on P recycling from livestock manure of research areas, countries, institutions, and authors through a bibliometric analysis using Citespace and VOSviewer software. The co-citation analysis of literature revealed the development of the main research content in this field, and further clustering analysis illustrated the current key research directions. Keyword co-occurrence analysis identified the hotspots and new frontiers of research in this field. According to the results, the United States was the most influential and actively contributing nation, and China was the country with the tightest international ties. The most popular research area was environmental science, and the Bioresource Technology published the largest number of papers in this area. The research priority was the technologies development of P recycling from livestock manure, of which the most used method was struvite precipitation and biochar adsorption. Subsequently, evaluation is also essential, including the economic benefits and environmental impacts of the recycling process by life cycle assessment and substance flow analysis, as well as the agronomic efficiency of the recycled products. New directions for technological innovation in recycling P from livestock manure and potential risks in the recycling process are explored. The results of this study may provide a framework for understanding the mechanisms of P utilization in livestock manure, and support the overall popularization of P recycling technology from livestock manure.

Comparison of phosphorus species in livestock manure and digestate by different detection techniques.

Phosphorus (P) species characterize the effectiveness of the P fertilizer. In this study, the P species and distribution in different manures (pig manure, dairy manure and chicken manure) and their digestate were systematically investigated through combined characterization methods of Hedley fractionation (H2OP, NaHCO3-P, NaOH-P, HCl-P, and Residual), X-ray diffraction (XRD) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques. The results from Hedley fractionation showed that >80 % of P in the digestate was inorganic and the HCl-P content in manure increased significantly during anaerobic digestion (AD). XRD manifested that insoluble hydroxyapatite and struvite belonging to HCl-P were presented during AD, which was in agreement with the result of Hedley fractionation. 31P NMR spectral analysis revealed that some orthophosphate monoesters were hydrolyzed during AD, meanwhile the orthophosphate diester organic phosphorus like DNA and phospholipids content has increased. After characterizing P species by combining these methods, it was found that chemical sequential extraction could be an effective way to fully understand the P in livestock manure and digestate, with other methods used as auxiliary tool depending on the purpose of studies. Meanwhile, this study provided a basic knowledge of utilizing digestate as P fertilizer and minimizing the risk of P loss from livestock manure. Overall, applying digestates can minimize the risk of P loss from directly applied livestock manure while satisfying plant demands, and is an environmentally friendly P fertilizer.