Dystrophin levels and clinical severity in Becker muscular dystrophy patients.

OBJECTIVE: Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) is characterised by broad clinical variability. Ongoing studies exploring dystrophin restoration in Duchenne muscular dystrophy ask for better understanding of the relation between dystrophin levels and disease severity. We studied this relation in BMD patients with varying mutations, including a large subset with an exon 45-47 deletion. METHODS: Dystrophin was quantified by western blot analyses in a fresh muscle biopsy of the anterior tibial muscle. Disease severity was assessed using quantitative muscle strength measurements and functional disability scoring. MRI of the leg was performed in a subgroup to detect fatty infiltration. RESULTS: 33 BMD patients participated. No linear relation was found between dystrophin levels (range 3%-78%) and muscle strength or age at different disease milestones, in both the whole group and the subgroup of exon 45-47 deleted patients. However, patients with less than 10% dystrophin all showed a severe disease course. No relation was found between disease severity and age when analysing the whole group. By contrast, in the exon 45-47 deleted subgroup, muscle strength and levels of fatty infiltration were significantly correlated with patients' age. CONCLUSIONS: Our study shows that dystrophin levels appear not to be a major determinant of disease severity in BMD, as long as it is above approximately 10%. A significant relation between age and disease course was only found in the exon 45-47 deletion subgroup. This suggests that at higher dystrophin levels, the disease course depends more on the mutation site than on the amount of the dystrophin protein produced.

Comparative analysis of antisense oligonucleotide sequences for targeted skipping of exon 51 during dystrophin pre-mRNA splicing in human muscle.

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene that result in the absence of functional protein. In the majority of cases these are out-of-frame deletions that disrupt the reading frame. Several attempts have been made to restore the dystrophin mRNA reading frame by modulation of pre-mRNA splicing with antisense oligonucleotides (AOs), demonstrating success in cultured cells, muscle explants, and animal models. We are preparing for a phase I/IIa clinical trial aimed at assessing the safety and effect of locally administered AOs designed to inhibit inclusion of exon 51 into the mature mRNA by the splicing machinery, a process known as exon skipping. Here, we describe a series of systematic experiments to validate the sequence and chemistry of the exon 51 AO reagent selected to go forward into the clinical trial planned in the United Kingdom. Eight specific AO sequences targeting exon 51 were tested in two different chemical forms and in three different preclinical models: cultured human muscle cells and explants (wild type and DMD), and local in vivo administration in transgenic mice harboring the entire human DMD locus. Data have been validated independently in the different model systems used, and the studies describe a rational collaborative path for the preclinical selection of AOs for evaluation in future clinical trials.

Therapeutic modulation of DMD splicing by blocking exonic splicing enhancer sites with antisense oligonucleotides.

Antisense oligonucleotides (AONs) can be used to correct the disrupted reading frame of Duchenne muscular dystophy patients (DMD). We have a collection of 121 AONs, of which 79 are effective in inducing the specific skipping of 38 out of the 79 different DMD exons. All AONs are located within exons and were hypothesized to act by steric hindrance of serine-arginine rich (SR) protein binding to exonic splicing enhancer (ESE) sites. Indeed, retrospective in silico analysis of effective versus ineffective AONs revealed that the efficacy of AONs is correlated to the presence of putative ESE sites (as predicted by the ESEfinder and RESCUE-ESE software). ESE predicting software programs are thus valuable tools for the optimization of exon-internal antisense target sequences.

FRG2, an FSHD candidate gene, is transcriptionally upregulated in differentiating primary myoblast cultures of FSHD patients.

BACKGROUND: Autosomal dominant facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is associated with partial deletion of the subtelomeric D4Z4 repeat array on chromosome 4qter. This chromosomal rearrangement may result in regional chromatin relaxation and transcriptional deregulation of genes nearby. METHODS AND RESULTS: Here we describe the isolation and characterisation of FRG2, a member of a chromosomally dispersed gene family, mapping only 37 kb proximal to the D4Z4 repeat array. Homology and motif searches yielded no clues to the function of the predicted protein. FRG2 expression is undetectable in all tissues tested except for differentiating myoblasts of FSHD patients, which display low, yet distinct levels of FRG2 expression, partly from chromosome 4 but predominantly originating from its homologue on chromosome 10. However, in non-FSHD myopathy patients only distantly related FRG2 homologues are transcribed, while differentiating myoblasts from healthy controls fail to express any member of this gene family. Moreover, fibroblasts of FSHD patients and control individuals undergoing forced Ad5-MyoD mediated myogenesis show expression of FRG2 mainly originating from chromosome 10. Luciferase reporter assays show that the FRG2 promoter region can direct high levels of expression but is inhibited by increasing numbers of D4Z4 repeat units. Transient transfection experiments with FRG2 fusion-protein constructs reveal nuclear localisation and apparently FRG2 overexpression causes a wide range of morphological changes. CONCLUSION: The localisation of FRG2 genes close to the D4Z4 repeats on chromosome 4 and 10, their transcriptional upregulation specifically in FSHD myoblast cultures, potential involvement in myogenesis, and promoter properties qualify FRG2 as an attractive candidate for FSHD pathogenesis.

Comparative analysis of antisense oligonucleotide analogs for targeted DMD exon 46 skipping in muscle cells.

As small molecule drugs for Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), antisense oligonucleotides (AONs) have been shown to restore the disrupted reading frame of DMD transcripts by inducing specific exon skipping. This allows the synthesis of largely functional Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD)-like dystrophins and potential conversion of severe DMD into milder BMD phenotypes. Thus far we have used 2'-O-methyl phosphorothioate (2OMePS) AONs. Here, we assessed the skipping efficiencies of different AON analogs containing morpholino-phosphorodiamidate, locked nucleic acid (LNA) or peptide nucleic acid (PNA) backbones. In contrast to PNAs and morpholinos, LNAs have not yet been tested as splice modulators. Compared to the most effective 2OMePS AON directed at exon 46, the LNA induced higher skipping levels in myotubes from a human control (85 versus 20%) and an exon 45 deletion DMD patient (98 versus 75%). The morpholino-induced skipping levels were only 5-6%, whereas the PNA appeared to be ineffective. Further comparative analysis of LNA and 2OMePS AONs containing up to three mismatches revealed that LNAs, while inducing higher skipping efficiencies, show much less sequence specificity. This limitation increases the risk of adverse effects elsewhere in the human genome. Awaiting further improvements in oligochemistry, we thus consider 2OMePS AONs currently the most favorable compounds, at least for targeted DMD exon 46 skipping.

Antisense-induced exon skipping restores dystrophin expression in DMD patient derived muscle cells.

Due to frame-shifting mutations in the DMD gene that cause dystrophin deficiency, Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) patients suffer from lethal muscle degeneration. In contrast, mutations in the allelic Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) do not disrupt the translational reading frame, resulting in a less severe phenotype. In this study, we explored a genetic therapy aimed at restoring the reading frame in muscle cells from DMD patients through targeted modulation of dystrophin pre-mRNA splicing. Considering that exon 45 is the single most frequently deleted exon in DMD, whereas exon (45+46) deletions cause only a mild form of BMD, we set up an antisense-based system to induce exon 46 skipping from the transcript in cultured myotubes of both mouse and human origin. In myotube cultures from two unrelated DMD patients carrying an exon 45 deletion, the induced skipping of exon 46 in only approximately 15% of the mRNA led to normal amounts of properly localized dystrophin in at least 75% of myotubes. Our results provide first evidence of highly effective restoration of dystrophin expression from the endogenous gene in DMD patient-derived muscle cells. This strategy may be applicable to not only >65% of DMD mutations, but also many other genetic diseases.

Dystrophin nonsense mutation induces different levels of exon 29 skipping and leads to variable phenotypes within one BMD family.

Within one X-linked muscular dystrophy family, different phenotypes for three males occurred: (1) a severely affected Becker patient with cardiomyopathy, (2) a mildly affected Becker patient, and (3) an apparently healthy male with elevated serum CK levels. In the muscle biopsy specimen of patient2 one out of four antibodies (NCL-DYS1) showed absence of dystrophin. The protein truncation test detected a truncated dystrophin for both muscle tissue and lymphocytes of this patient next to an additional near normal size fragment in muscle. Genomic sequence analysis revealed a nonsense mutation in exon 29 (4148C > T) of the dystrophin gene. Sequence analysis of the mRNA fragment of the larger peptide showed skipping of exon 29, restoring an open reading frame. Consequently, the epitope of the antibody NCL-DYS1 is mapped to exon 29. The variable clinical features of the three relatives from healthy to severely affected therefore seems to be related to the level of skipping of exon 29. This finding underscores the future potential of gene therapeutic strategies aimed at inducing exon skipping in Duchenne muscular dystrophy, to generate a much milder disease.

Identification of a novel beta-tubulin subfamily with one member (TUBB4Q) located near the telomere of chromosome region 4q35.

The human beta-tubulin supergene family consists of several isotypes with many associated pseudogenes. Here we report the identification of yet another beta-tubulin sequence designated TUBB4Q. This tubulin maps 80 kb proximal to the facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD1) associated D4Z4 repeats on chromosome 4q35. The genomic structure contains four exons encoding a putative protein of 434 amino acids. The TUBB4Q nucleotide and protein sequence show 87% and 86% homology to beta2-tubulin, respectively. Although the genomic structure shows all functional aspects of a genuine gene, no transcript could be detected. TUBB4Q-related sequences were identified on multiple chromosomes. Since these sequences mutually exhibit a high nucleotide sequence homology, they presumably belong to a novel subfamily of beta-tubulin genes. Although the chromosome 4q35 tubulin-member probably represents a pseudogene, ectopic expression due to a postulated position effect variegation (PEV), makes TUBB4Q an ideal dominant-negative candidate gene for FSHD1.

Extended tropism of an adenoviral vector does not circumvent the maturation-dependent transducibility of mouse skeletal muscle.

BACKGROUND: Efficient adenoviral gene delivery to mature skeletal muscle has been hindered by different factors. The low levels of adenoviral attachment receptor (CAR) that have been reported in this tissue may be a limiting factor. Therefore, adenoviral transduction of mature muscle may be improved by extending the tropism of the adenoviral vectors to attachment receptors that are highly expressed in mature myofibers. In this study, we have investigated whether an extended tropism adenoviral vector which additionally attaches to the broadly expressed heparan-containing receptors (AdPK) can bypass the maturation-dependent adenoviral transducibility of mouse skeletal muscle. METHODS: The adenoviral vector AdPK carrying the LacZ gene was evaluated as a gene delivery vehicle in mouse skeletal muscle at different maturities in vitro and in vivo. The viral transduction efficiencies were determined by histochemical and ONPG analysis of the beta-galactosidase activity level. RESULTS: Higher transduction efficiencies were detected in immature muscle from normal mice, and in mature muscle from merosin-deficient dy/dy mice (carrying myofibers with an impaired extracellular matrix) and dystrophin-deficient mdx mice (showing a high level of myoblast activity) when compared to mature muscle from normal mice. CONCLUSION: Despite the enhanced attachment characteristics, the extended tropism adenoviral vector is, similarly to the wild-type adenoviral vector in previous studies, still hindered by both a protective extracellular matrix and the diminished myoblast-mediation in mature muscle.

Development of approaches to improve cell survival in myoblast transfer therapy.

Myoblast transplantation has been extensively studied as a gene complementation approach for genetic diseases such as Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy. This approach has been found capable of delivering dystrophin, the product missing in Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy muscle, and leading to an increase of strength in the dystrophic muscle. This approach, however, has been hindered by numerous limitations, including immunological problems, and low spread and poor survival of the injected myoblasts. We have investigated whether antiinflammatory treatment and use of different populations of skeletal muscle-derived cells may circumvent the poor survival of the injected myoblasts after implantation. We have observed that different populations of muscle-derived cells can be isolated from skeletal muscle based on their desmin immunoreactivity and differentiation capacity. Moreover, these cells acted differently when injected into muscle: 95% of the injected cells in some populations died within 48 h, while others richer in desmin-positive cells survived entirely. Since pure myoblasts obtained from isolated myofibers and myoblast cell lines also displayed a poor survival rate of the injected cells, we have concluded that the differential survival of the populations of muscle-derived cells is not only attributable to their content in desmin-positive cells. We have observed that the origin of the myogenic cells may influence their survival in the injected muscle. Finally, we have observed that myoblasts genetically engineered to express an inhibitor of the inflammatory cytokine, IL-1, can improve the survival rate of the injected myoblasts. Our results suggest that selection of specific muscle-derived cell populations or the control of inflammation can be used as an approach to improve cell survival after both myoblast transplantation and the myoblast-mediated ex vivo gene transfer approach.

Inter- and intrachromosomal sub-telomeric rearrangements on 4q35: implications for facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) aetiology and diagnosis.

The autosomal dominant myopathy facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is causally related to a short Eco RI fragment detected by probe p13E-11. This remnant fragment is the result of a deletion of an integral number of tandemly arrayed 3.3 kb repeat units (D4Z4) on 4q35. Despite intensive efforts, no transcribed sequences have been identified within this array. Previously, we have shown that these repeats on 4q35 have been exchanged for a similar highly homologous repeat locus on 10q26 in 20% of the population and that a short chromosome 10-like array on 4q35 also results in FSHD. Here, we describe the hybrid structure of some of these repeat arrays, reflecting additional sub-telomeric instability. In three healthy individuals carrying a 4-like repeat on chromosome 10 or vice versa, one repeat array was shown to consist of hybrid clusters of 4-derived and 10-derived repeat units. Moreover, employing pulsed field gel electrophoresis analysis, we identified two unrelated individuals carrying deletions of a chromosomal segment (p13E-11) proximal to the repeat locus. These deletions were not associated with FSHD. In one of these cases, however, an expansion of the deletion into the repeat array was observed in one of his children suffering from FSHD. These data provide additional evidence for instability of this sub-telomeric region and suggests that the length of the repeat, and not its intrinsic properties, is crucial to FSHD. Moreover, they are in agreement with the hypothesis that FSHD is caused by a position effect in which the repeat structure influences the expression of genes nearby. Therefore, the region deleted proximal to the repeat locus in healthy individuals can be instrumental to refine the critical region for FSHD1.

Muscle maturation: implications for gene therapy.

Skeletal muscle is a promising target tissue for gene therapy, for both muscle and non-muscle disorders. A variety of methods have been studied to transfer genes into skeletal muscle, including retroviral, adenoviral and herpes simplex viral vectors. However, various factors impede muscle-based viral gene therapy. Here, we discuss why some viral vectors cannot efficiently transduce mature muscle fibers, and describe some new approaches to overcome this barrier.

Implications of maturation for viral gene delivery to skeletal muscle.

Different viral vectors have been analyzed as gene delivery vehicles to skeletal muscle for potentially therapeutic purposes. In this review, we evaluate the application of retroviral, adenoviral, and herpes simplex viral vectors to deliver genes to skeletal muscle and focus on the dramatic loss of viral transduction detected throughout muscle maturation. Recent results suggested that there are several factors involved in the reduced viral transducibility of mature skeletal muscle: muscle cells become post-mitotic in an early stage, the extracellular matrix develops into a physical barrier, and a loss of myoblast mediation occurs since myoblasts progressively become quiescent. Approaches to improve viral gene delivery to mature skeletal muscle may include the use of particular enzymes to increase the permeability of the extracellular matrix, the pre-treatment of the muscle with a myonecrotic agent to induce myoblast mediation, or the application of the myoblast-mediated ex vivo gene transfer.

The mouse homolog of FRG1, a candidate gene for FSHD, maps proximal to the myodystrophy mutation on chromosome 8.

The human autosomal dominant neuromuscular disorder facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is associated with deletions within a complex tandem DNA repeat (D4Z4) on Chromosome (Chr) 4q35. The molecular mechanism underlying this association of FSHD with DNA rearrangements is unknown, and, thus far, no gene has been identified within the repeat. We isolated a gene mapping 100 kb proximal to D4Z4 (FSHD Region Gene 1:FRG1), but were unable to detect any alterations in total or allele-specific mRNA levels of FRG1 in FSHD patients. Human Chr 4q35 exhibits synteny homology with the region of mouse Chr 8 containing the gene for the myodystrophy mutation (myd), a possible mouse homolog of FSHD. We report the cloning of the mouse gene (Frg1) and show that it maps to mouse Chr 8. Using a cross segregating the myd mutation and the European Collaborative Interspecific Backcross, we showed that Frg1 maps proximal to the myd locus and to the Clc3 and Ant1 genes.

Evidence for subtelomeric exchange of 3.3 kb tandemly repeated units between chromosomes 4q35 and 10q26: implications for genetic counselling and etiology of FSHD1.

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is an autosomal dominant myopathy, clinically characterized by asymmetric weakness of muscles in the face, shoulder girdle and upper arm. Deletion of an integral number of 3.3 kb repeated units within a highly polymorphic EcoRI fragment at chromosome 4q35, generating a relatively short EcoRI fragment (< 35 kb), has been shown to cause FSHD1. Probe p13E-11 detects these short fragments in FSHD1 patients, and has therefore been used for diagnostic DNA analysis. However, the reliability of this analysis has been hampered by cross-hybridization of p13E-11 to chromosome 10q26-linked EcoRI fragments of comparable size, which also contain a variable number of 3.3 kb repeated units. Recently, a BinI restriction site was identified within each of the repeated units derived from chromosome 10q26, which enables differentiation of the two polymorphic p13E-11 loci in most cases without haplotype analysis. Remarkably, applying the differential analysis to screen DNA of 160 Dutch cases referred to us for FSHD1 diagnosis, we obtained evidence for subtelomeric exchange of 3.3 kb repeated units between chromosomes 4q35 and 10q26 in affected and unaffected individuals. Subsequently, analysis of 50 unrelated control samples indicated such exchange between chromosomes 4q35 and 10q26 in at least 20% of the population. These subtelomeric rearrangements have generated a novel interchromosomal polymorphism, which has implications for the specificity and sensitivity of the differential restriction analysis for diagnostic purposes. Moreover, the high frequency of the interchromosomal exchanges of 3.3 kb repeated units suggests that they probably do not contain (part of) the FSHD1 gene, and supports position effect variegation as the most likely mechanism for FSHD1.

Identification of the first gene (FRG1) from the FSHD region on human chromosome 4q35.

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is an autosomal dominant, neuromuscular disorder characterized by progressive weakness of muscles in the face, shoulder and upper arm. Deletion of integral copies of a 3.3 kb repeated unit from the subtelomeric region on chromosome 4q35 has been shown to be associated with FSHD. These repeated units which are apparently not transcribed, map very close to the 4q telomere and belong to a 3.3 kb repeat family dispersed over heterochromatic regions of the genome. Hence, position effect variegation (PEV), inducing allele-specific transcriptional repression of a gene located more centromeric, has been postulated as the underlying genetic mechanism of FSHD. This hypothesis has directed the search for the FSHD gene to the region centromeric to the repeated units. A CpG island was identified and found to be associated with the 5' untranslated region of a novel human gene, FRG1 (FSHD Region Gene 1). This evolutionary conserved gene is located about 100 kb proximal to the repeated units and belongs to a multigene family with FRG1 related sequences on multiple chromosomes. The mature chromosome 4 FRG1 transcript is 1042 bp in length and contains nine exons which encode a putative protein of 258 amino acid residues. Transcription of FRG1 was detected in several human tissues including placenta, lymphocytes, brain and muscle. To investigate a possible PEV mechanism, allele-specific FRG1 steady-state transcript levels were determined using RNA-based single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis. A polymorphic fragment contained within the first exon of FRG1 was amplified from reverse transcribed RNA from lymphocytes and muscle biopsies of patients and controls. No evidence for PEV mediated repression of allelic transcription was obtained in these tissues. However, detection of PEV in FSHD patients may require analysis of more specific cell types at particular developmental stages.

Mutation in DHP receptor alpha 1 subunit (CACLN1A3) gene in a Dutch family with hypokalaemic periodic paralysis.

Hypokalaemic periodic paralysis (HypoPP) is characterised by transient attacks of muscle weakness of varying duration and severity accompanied by a drop in serum potassium concentration during the attacks. The largest known HypoPP family is of Dutch origin and consists of 277 members in the last five generations, 55 of whom have HypoPP inherited in an autosomal dominant pattern. Forty-eight persons including 28 patients with a proven diagnosis of HypoPP were used for linkage analysis. Microsatellite markers were used to exclude 45 to 50% of the genome and linkage to chromosome 1q31-32 was found. No recombinants were found between HypoPP and D1S412 and a microsatellite contained within the DHP receptor alpha 1 subunit (CACLN1A3) gene. A previously reported G to A mutation causing an arginine to histidine substitution at residue 528 in the transmembrane segment IIS4 of the CACLN1A3 gene was shown in patients by restriction analysis of genomic PCR products.

Search for the FSHD gene using cDNA selection in a region spanning 100 kb on chromosome 4q35.

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is caused by deletions of 3.3-kb tandemly repeated units contained within a large polymorphic EcoRI fragment close to the telomere of chromosome 4q. Since the rearrangements were assumed to interfere with the structure or function of the putative FSHD gene, the gene search was focused on cosmids containing these repeat units and, in addition, cosmids spanning 75 kb of upstream sequences. cDNA selection hybridization was applied to four overlapping cosmid clones, yielding a total of 150 putative cDNA clones. These clones showed a random distribution across the cosmid contig, except for three regions which contained a much larger number of clones. Nine cDNA clones hybridized to a 2.2-kb EcoRI fragment, located 22 kb centromeric to the 3.3-kb repeated units. This 2.2-kb fragment showed evolutionary conservation, and analysis of the sequence by "GRAIL" predicted the presence of several exons. Transcripts homologous to this fragment could be identified but none of them originated from the 4q35 locus. Strikingly, most clones revealed 4-10 homologous loci, and no single copy clones could be isolated. These findings are in line with earlier observations by fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) showing hybridization of individual cosmid clones to multiple chromosomes. The presence of homologous regions on other chromosomes seriously complicates the cloning of the FSHD gene.

Search for the FSHD gene using cDNA selection in a region spanning 100 kb on chromosome 4q35.

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is caused by deletions of 3.3-kb tandemly repeated units contained within a large polymorphic EcoRI fragment close to the telomere of chromosome 4q. Since the rearrangements were assumed to interfere with the structure or function of the putative FSHD gene, the gene search was focused on cosmids containing these repeat units and, in addition, cosmids spanning 75 kb of upstream sequences. cDNA selection hybridization was applied to four overlapping cosmid clones, yielding a total of 150 putative cDNA clones. These clones showed a random distribution across the cosmid contig, except for three regions which contained a much larger number of clones. Nine cDNA clones hybridized to a 2.2-kb EcoRI fragment, located 22 kb centromeric to the 3.3-kb repeated units. This 2.2-kb fragment showed evolutionary conservation, and analysis of the sequence by "GRAIL" predicted the presence of several exons. Transcripts homologous to this fragment could be identified but none of them originated from the 4q35 locus. Strikingly, most clones revealed 4-10 homologous loci, and no single copy clones could be isolated. These findings are in line with earlier observations by fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) showing hybridization of individual cosmid clones to multiple chromosomes. The presence of homologous regions on other chromosomes seriously complicates the cloning of the FSHD gene.