Association Between Entrustable Professional Activities and Milestones Evaluations: Real-time Assessments Correlate With Semiannual Reviews.

OBJECTIVE: Entrustable professional activities (EPAs) have been developed to refine competency-based education. The American Board of Surgery has initiated a 2-year pilot study to evaluate the impact of EPAs on the evaluation and feedback of surgical residents. The ACGME Milestones in Surgery is a semiannual competency-based evaluation program to measure resident progression through 16 professional attributes across 8 practice domains. The correlation between these 2 evaluation tools remains unclear. The purpose of this study is to evaluate this correlation through comparison of an EPA with the corresponding elements of the ACGME Milestones. DESIGN: From July, 2018 to October, 2019, all residents submitting EPA evaluations for gall bladder disease were evaluated for preoperative, intraoperative, and/or postoperative entrustability. The ratings were converted to a numerical rank from 0 to 4. Milestones scores from May 2019 and November 2019 were obtained for each resident, with scores ranging from 0 to 4. The gall bladder EPA incorporates the operative PC3 and MK2 and nonoperative PC1, PC2, and ICS3 components. Spearman rank correlation was conducted to evaluate the association between each resident's median EPA ranking and his/her milestones scores. SETTING: SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY, a university-based hospital. PARTICIPANTS: General surgery residents. RESULTS: Among 24 residents, 106 intraoperative EPA evaluations were. For both the May and November milestones, significant positive correlations were noted for PC3 (correlation coefficient ρ = 0.690, p < 0.001; ρ = 0.876, p < 0.001). Similarly, for MK2, a significant positive correlation was noted (ρ = 0.882, p < 0.001; ρ = 0.759, p < 0.001). Interestingly, significant positive correlations were also identified between the 3 nonoperative milestones and the intraoperative entrustability ranking. CONCLUSIONS: We observed significant correlations between EPAs for cholecystectomy and associated milestones evaluation scores. These findings indicate that EPAs may provide more timely and specific feedback than existing tools and, on aggregate, may improve upon existing formative feedback practices provided through the biannual evaluation of surgical residents.

Does Perceived Resident Operative Autonomy Impact Patient Outcomes?

OBJECTIVE: We investigated the association of perceived trainee autonomy with patient clinical outcomes following colorectal surgery. DESIGN: This was a prospective multi-institutional study that consisted of surgery trainees completing a survey tool immediately after participating in colorectal resections to rate their self-perceived autonomy and case characteristics. Self-perception of autonomy was classified as observer, assistant, surgeon, or teacher. The completed trainee surveys were linked with patient information available through each hospital's internal NSQIP directory. The primary outcome was death and serious morbidity (DSM) and secondary outcome was 30-day readmissions. Separate mixed effects regression models were used to examine the association between perceived trainee autonomy and DSM or 30-day readmissions. Fixed effects were used to control for the effects of the training environment. The models were constructed to adjust for patient and trainee characteristics associated with each outcome independently. SETTING: This study was conducted at 7 general surgery training programs (5 academic medical centers and 2 independent training programs) with general surgery or colorectal surgery services. PARTICIPANTS: This study included a total of 63 residents and fellows rotating on surgery services that performed colorectal resections at the included 7 general surgery training programs from January until March 2016. RESULTS: The 63 trainees that participated in this study completed 417 surveys with over a 95% response rate. National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP) patient records were available for 67% (n = 273) of completed surveys. The clinical year of the trainees were 6.1% PGY 1/2, 36% Post graduate year (PGY) 3, 40.9% PGY 4/5, and 17% fellows. Residents perceived their participation in the case to be that of an observer in 9.2% of surveys, an assistant in 51.6% of surveys, and the surgeon/teacher in 39.3% of surveys. About 50% of patients were male, 80% were White, the majority had an American Society of Anesthesiologists classification of 3, almost half had prior abdominal surgery, and over 80% of surgeries were elective. The primary operation types performed were laparoscopic (40.3%) and open (35.9%) partial colectomies. The rate of DSM in patients was approximately 24% when trainees perceived their role as observers, 23% when trainees perceived their role as assistants, and 18% when trainees perceived their role as surgeons/teachers. After adjustment for patient, trainee, and training environment, we found that the perceived level of trainee autonomy of a surgeon/teacher was associated with a 4-fold lower rate of DSM (odds ratio: 0.23, confidence of interval: 0.05-0.97, p = 0.045) compared to observers. The rate of readmissions was approximately 20% when trainees perceived their role as observers, 14% when trainees perceived their role as assistants and 9% when trainees perceived their role as surgeons/teachers. After adjustment for patient, trainee, and training environment, we found that the perceived level of trainee autonomy of a surgeon/teacher was significantly associated with a 10-fold lower rate of 30-day readmissions (odds ratio: 0.09, confidence of interval: 0.01-0.70, p = 0.022) compared to observers. CONCLUSIONS: There was an association between increased perceived trainee autonomy and improved patient outcomes, suggesting that when trainees identify with an increased role in the operation, patients may have improved care. Further research is needed to understand this association further.

Quantification of Resident Work in Colorectal Surgery.

OBJECTIVE: To examine resident intraoperative participation, perceived autonomy, and communication patterns between residents and attending surgeons using a novel survey tool. DESIGN: This was a prospective multi-institutional study. Operative residents completed the survey tool immediately after each colorectal resection performed during the study period. Resident intraoperative participation was quantified including degree of involvement in the technical aspects of the case, self-perception of autonomy, and communication strategies between the resident and attending. SETTING: This study was conducted at 7 general surgery residency programs: 5 academic medical centers, and 2 independent training programs. PARTICIPANTS: Residents and fellows rotating on a colorectal surgery service or general surgery service. RESULTS: Sixty-three residents participated in this study with 417 surveys completed (range 19-79 per institution) representing a 95.4% response rate across all sites. Respondents ranged from clinical year 1 (CY1) to fellows. CY3s (35.7%) and CY5s (34.7%) were most heavily represented. Residents completed ≥50% of the skin closure in 88.7% of cases, ≥50% of the fascial closure in 87.1%, and t ≥ 50% of the anastomosis in 78.4% of the cases. Increasing resident participation was associated with advancing resident CY across all technical aspects of the case. This trend remained significant when controlling for site (p < 0.001). Resident self-perception of autonomy revealed learners of all stages: Observer (11.5%, n = 48), Assistant (53.7%, n = 224), Surgeon (33.8%, n = 141), and Teacher (0.96%, n = 4). Level of perceived autonomy increased with resident CY when controlling for site (p < 0.001). Residents who discussed the case before the day of surgery were twice as likely to rate themselves as Surgeon or Teacher (OR = 2.01) when controlling for CY (p = 0.011). CONCLUSIONS: Brief surveys can easily capture resident work in the operating room. Resident intraoperative involvement and perceived autonomy are associated with CY. Early communication with the attending is significantly associated with increased perception of autonomy regardless of CY.

A Giant Adrenal Mass in a Super Obese Patient.

Giant pheochromocytomas (Pheo) are rare entities requiring clinical suspicion coupled with strategic diagnostic evaluation to confirm the diagnosis. The majority of cases are discovered incidentally. The diagnosis consists of biochemical evaluation and imaging study to localize the mass. Pathological examination confirms the diagnosis. The female patient in this case report presented with chest pain, palpitation of three weeks duration and was found on evaluation to have an abdominal mass concerning for pheochromocytoma. She was treated with surgical resection. The pheo measured 20.5 x 18 x 10 cm and weighed 2,582 grams. Pathological examination confirmed the diagnosis of pheochromocytoma.

The Educational Toolbox: Kick Start Your Educational Program in Quality Improvement.

OBJECTIVE: To disseminate materials and learning from the proceedings of the Association of Program Directors 2014 Annual Meeting workshop on the integration of quality improvement (QI) education into the existing educational infrastructure. BACKGROUND: Modern surgical practice demands an understanding of QI methodology. Yet, today׳s surgeons are not formally educated in QI methodology. Therefore, it is hard to follow the historical mantra of "see one, do one, teach one" in the quality realm. METHODS: Participants were given a brief introduction to QI approaches. A number of concrete examples of how to incorporate QI education into training programs were presented, followed by a small group session focused on the identification of barriers to incorporation. Participants were provided with a worksheet to help navigate the initial incorporation of QI education in 3 steps. RESULTS: Participants were representative of all types of training programs, with differing levels of existing QI integration. Barriers to QI education included lack of resident interest/buy-in, concerns over the availability of educational resources (i.e., limited time to devote to QI), and a limited QI knowledge among surgical educators. The 3 steps to kick starting the educational process included (1) choosing a specific method of QI education, (2) incorporation via barrier, infrastructure, and stakeholder identification, and (3) implementation and ongoing assessment. CONCLUSIONS: Recent changes in the delivery of surgical care along with the new accreditation system have necessitated the development of QI education programs for use in surgical education. To continue to make surgery safer and ensure optimal patient outcomes, surgical educators must teach each resident to adopt quality science methodology in a meaningful way.

Perceptions of graduating general surgery chief residents: are they confident in their training?

BACKGROUND: Debate exists within the surgical education community about whether 5 years is sufficient time to train a general surgeon, whether graduating chief residents are confident in their skills, why residents choose to do fellowships, and the scope of general surgery practice today. STUDY DESIGN: In May 2013, a 16-question online survey was sent to every general surgery program director in the United States for dissemination to each graduating chief resident (CR). RESULTS: Of the 297 surveys returned, 76% of CRs trained at university programs, 81% trained at 5-year programs, and 28% were going directly into general surgery practice. The 77% of CRs who had done >950 cases were significantly more comfortable than those who had done less (p < 0.0001). Only a few CRs were uncomfortable performing a laparoscopic colectomy (7%) or a colonoscopy (6%), and 80% were comfortable being on call at a Level I trauma center. Compared with other procedures, CRs were most uncomfortable with open common bile duct explorations (27%), pancreaticoduodenectomies (38%), hepatic lobectomies (48%), and esophagectomies (60%) (p < 0.00001). Of those going into fellowships, 67% said they truly had an interest in that specialty and only 7% said it was because they were not confident in their surgical skills. CONCLUSIONS: Current graduates of general surgery residencies appear to be confident in their skills, including care of the trauma patient. Fellowships are being chosen primarily because of an interest in the subspecialty. General surgery residency no longer provides adequate training in esophageal or hepatopancreatobiliary surgery.

Ventral hernia repair: outcomes change with long-term follow-up.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Ventral hernia repairs continue to have high recurrence rates. The surgical literature is lacking data assessing the time trend to hernia recurrence after ventral hernia repairs and whether over time the recurrence rates change with laparoscopic technique compared to open repairs. Our aim was to carry out a long-term comparative analysis of ventral hernia repairs performed at our hospital over the last 10-y period to assess if outcomes change during the follow-up period. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective observational study analyzing electronic medical records of all consecutive patients who had a ventral hernia repair from January 2001 to February 2010 at our hospital. RESULTS: During the study period, 436 ventral hernia repairs were performed: laparoscopic repairs (n=156; 36%), laparoscopic converted to open (n=8; 2%), and open repairs (n=272; 62%). We analyzed the time distribution to hernia recurrence after surgery and found that 85% of recurrences after laparoscopic repairs and 77% of recurrences after open repairs occurred within 2 y of surgery. We did a Kaplan-Meier analysis for the subgroup of patients for whom we had a minimum 4-y follow-up and found that there continued to be a low subsequent yearly recurrence rate for open repairs after the initial 2-y follow-up. CONCLUSION: Most hernia recurrences occur within 2 y after surgery for ventral hernias. There appears to be a continued although low subsequent yearly rate of recurrence for open repairs.

Biliary dyskinesia: how effective is cholecystectomy?

INTRODUCTION: Studies on biliary dyskinesia have been based on short-term surgical follow-up and do not take into consideration that most patients are discharged from surgical follow-up after the first postoperative visit and that for persistent or recurrent symptoms they are frequently seen by primary care providers and subsequently referred to gastroenterologists. We aimed to study this pattern and assess which factors predict patients that will benefit from cholecystectomy. METHOD: This is a retrospective analysis of medical records of patients who underwent cholecystectomy for biliary dyskinesia from February 2001 to January 2010 with a minimum postoperative follow-up of 6 months. RESULTS: At initial surgical follow-up, 19 of 141 (13.4%) patients said they had persistent symptoms. However, when subsequent visits were analyzed, 61 of 141 (43.3%) patients with persistent or recurrent symptoms saw their primary care provider. These symptoms were epigastric or right upper quadrant pain in 43 patients or 30% of those undergoing cholecystectomy. The only factor that distinguished patients with and without resolution of symptoms after cholecystectomy was the pathologic finding of inflammation (p = 0.02). CONCLUSION: Cholecystectomy does not appear to be as effective for biliary dyskinesia when long-term follow-up is evaluated.

Characteristics of perforated appendicitis: effect of delay is confounded by age and gender.

INTRODUCTION: The effect of age and gender on time to perforation in acute appendicitis has not been well characterized. This study examined the relationship between duration of disease and appendiceal perforation in different subgroups of age and gender. METHODS: This study is a retrospective analysis of 380 patients who underwent an appendectomy from January 2000 to June 2005 at a rural teaching hospital. RESULTS: Factors associated with perforated appendicitis included age, symptom duration, CT scan, and distance from the hospital. Factors associated with increased patient time included age, temperature >101.5 F, and referral from an outside institution. Factors associated with shorter system time included right lower quadrant tenderness, classic or severe presentation, and leading diagnosis of acute appendicitis. Preoperative CT scan increased system time by approximately 3 h. Analyzing symptom duration and time to perforation, males have a higher prevalence of perforated appendicitis compared to females with similar duration of symptoms. In patients older than 55 years of age, 29% had perforated appendicitis at 36 h of symptoms and 67% at 36 to 48 h of symptoms. In a multivariate regression analysis, age greater than 55 years (odds ratio (OR) 3.0, P value 0.007), fever (OR 4.3, P 0.007), and symptom duration more than 24 h (OR 4.1, P 0.001) were significant predictors of perforated appendicitis. CONCLUSIONS: There is an early risk of perforated appendicitis even within the first 36 h of symptoms. This risk appears to be higher in males and patients older than 55 years, a quarter of whom are perforated within the first 36 h of symptom duration. Additionally, perforation in acute appendicitis may be more of a continuous phenomena worsening exponentially with duration of symptoms rather than a threshold phenomenon.

Intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm: a clinicopathologic review.

Intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm (IPMN) is an intraductal mucin-producing epithelial neoplasm that arises from the main pancreatic duct (MD-IPMN), secondary branch ducts (BD-IPMN), or both (mixed type; Mix-IPMN). Neoplastic progression from benign adenoma to invasive adenocarcinoma has not been proven but is generally thought to occur. With increasing recognition of IPMN, our understanding of the diagnosis and management of the tumors is evolving. At present, treatment options for patients with IPMN range from observation to pancreatic resection depending on the natural history of the lesion. This review focuses on currently available data that guide management decisions for patients with IPMN.

Malignant transformation in perianal fistulas of Crohn's disease: a systematic review of literature.

INTRODUCTION: Malignant transformation of perineal fistula in Crohn's disease has rarely been reported. The aim of this study is to define the patient's characteristics and clinical presentation of this rare disease. METHODS: A systematic review of case series and reports published in English language between 1950 and 2008 was conducted. All cases with malignancy in low pelvic/perineal fistula in patients with Crohn's disease were included. All selected cases were then analyzed with respect to age, gender, duration of Crohn's disease and fistula, location of fistula, presenting symptoms, method of diagnosis, delay in diagnosis, histopathology, treatment, and outcome. Data analyses were done using chi-squared or Fisher's exact test and the Mann-Whitney test. RESULTS: Literature review revealed 61 cases of carcinomas arising in perineal fistulas in Crohn's disease. Sixty-one percent (37) of the patients were females. Females were significantly younger than males at the time of diagnosis of cancer (47 vs. 53 years, P < 0.032). Males were also noted to have significantly longer duration of Crohn's disease compared to females (24 vs. 18 years, P = 0.005). However, females were noted to have the fistula for significantly shorter duration prior to cancer transformation when compared to males (8.3 vs. 16 years, P = 0.0035). On initial examination, malignancy was suspected and proven only in 20% of patients (n = 12). Adenocarcinoma was the most common histology (59%, n = 36), followed by squamous cell carcinoma (31%, n = 19). In most patients (59%, n = 36), the fistula was rectal in origin. CONCLUSIONS: A high suspicion for malignancy in chronic perineal fistulas associated with Crohn's disease should be maintained in spite of negative biopsies. Especially in women, the shorter duration of Crohn's fistulas prior to malignant degeneration necessitates an aggressive approach to rule out cancer.

CT scans and acute appendicitis: a five-year analysis from a rural teaching hospital.

INTRODUCTION: Studies examining the relationship between computed tomography (CT) scans and appendiceal perforation have largely been conducted in urban centers. The present study sought to evaluate this relationship in a rural hospital. METHODS AND PROCEDURES: This is a retrospective analysis of 445 patients who underwent appendectomies from January 2000 to June 2005 at a rural teaching hospital. RESULTS: Four hundred forty-five patients were analyzed in two groups; those who underwent CT scans (N = 245) and those who did not (N = 200). Patients undergoing CT scans were significantly older (median age 38 vs. 22 years, P < 0.0001), were more likely to have perforated appendicitis (P 0.001), were less likely to undergo a negative appendectomy (P = 0.003), and had a significantly longer length of stay than those who did not (P 0.009). Analysis by gender showed that perforation rates continued to be significantly higher in males undergoing CT scans (P 0.004). To examine the possibility that sicker patients were more likely to receive CT scans and also be found to have perforated appendicitis, a sensitivity analysis was performed. Patients showing perforated appendicitis on initial CT scans were excluded and the analysis was repeated. The difference in perforation rates continued to remain significant (P 0.037). CONCLUSION: Males undergoing CT scans are significantly more likely to have perforated appendicitis. A protocol-driven rational approach to CT evaluation of suspected appendicitis may lower perforation rates, especially in males.