The Cleavage Profile of Protein Substrates by ClpXP Reveals Deliberate Starts and Pauses.

Cells rely on protein degradation by AAA+ proteases. A well-known example is the hexameric ClpX unfoldase, which captures ATP hydrolysis to feed substrates into the oligomeric ClpP peptidase. Recent studies show that an asymmetric ClpX spiral cycles protein translocation upon ATP hydrolysis. However, how this cycle affects peptide products is less explored in part because ClpP cleavage is thought to be solely defined by sequence constraints. Here, we comprehensively characterize peptides from Caulobacter crescentus ClpXP degradation of three different substrates using high-resolution mass spectrometry and find that cleavage of translocated substrates is driven by factors other than sequence. We report that defined locations in a translocated protein are especially sensitive to cleavage spaced on average every 10-13 residues. These sites are not exclusively controlled by sequence and are independent of bulk changes in catalytic peptidase sites, ATP hydrolysis, or the efficiency of initial recognition. These results fit a model in which processive translocation through ClpX starts at a specific location in a polypeptide and pauses during reset of the ClpX hexamer after a cycle of translocation. Our work suggests that defined peptides, which could be used as signaling molecules, can be generated from a given substrate by a nonspecific peptidase.

The Essential Role of ClpXP in Caulobacter crescentus Requires Species Constrained Substrate Specificity.

The ClpXP protease is a highly conserved AAA+ degradation machine that is present throughout bacteria and in eukaryotic organelles. ClpXP is essential in some bacteria, such as Caulobacter crescentus, but dispensible in others, such as Escherichia coli. In Caulobacter, ClpXP normally degrades the SocB toxin and increased levels of SocB result in cell death. ClpX can be deleted in cells lacking this toxin, but these ΔclpX strains are still profoundly deficient in morphology and growth supporting the existence of additional important functions for ClpXP. In this work, we characterize aspects of ClpX crucial for its cellular function. Specifically, we show that although the E. coli ClpX functions with the Caulobacter ClpP in vitro, this variant cannot complement wildtype activity in vivo. Chimeric studies suggest that the N-terminal domain of ClpX plays a crucial, species-specific role in maintaining normal growth. We find that one defect of Caulobacter lacking the proper species of ClpX is the failure to properly proteolytically process the replication clamp loader subunit DnaX. Consistent with this, growth of ΔclpX cells is improved upon expression of a shortened form of DnaX in trans. This work reveals that a broadly conserved protease can acquire highly specific functions in different species and further reinforces the critical nature of the N-domain of ClpX in substrate choice.

Protease regulation and capacity during Caulobacter growth.

Cell growth requires the removal of proteins that are unwanted or toxic. In bacteria, AAA+ proteases like the Clp family and Lon selectively destroy proteins defined by intrinsic specificity or adaptors. Caulobacter crescentus is a gram-negative bacterium that undergoes an obligate developmental transition every cell division cycle. Here we highlight recent work that reveals how a hierarchy of adaptors targets the degradation of key proteins at specific times during this cell cycle, integrating protein destruction with other cues. We describe recent insight into how Caulobacter manages DNA replication and repair through Lon and Clp proteases. Because proteases must manage a broad substrate repertoire there must be methods to compensate for protease saturation and we discuss these scenarios.

Two ways to skin a cat: acyldepsipeptides antibiotics can kill bacteria through activation or inhibition of ClpP activity.

Infection by Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) has had a devastating effect on the world population. Acyldepsipeptide antibiotics (ADEPs) are known to kill some bacteria by over activating the bacterial ClpP peptidase. ADEP antibiotics also target Mtb, with the assumption that uncontrolled ADEP-activated proteolysis by ClpP is the common mode of killing. In this issue of Molecular Microbiology, Famulla, et al. now show that ADEP's effectiveness in mycobacteria is likely due to inhibition of ClpP-dependent protease activity rather than activation. This finding of how the same antibiotic can kill bacteria by either inhibiting or activating proteases illustrates the utility of targeting these enzymes for sorely needed new antibiotics.

A Phosphosignaling Adaptor Primes the AAA+ Protease ClpXP to Drive Cell Cycle-Regulated Proteolysis.

The response regulator CpdR couples phosphorylation events in Caulobacter crescentus with the AAA+ protease ClpXP to provide punctuated degradation of crucial substrates involved in cell cycle regulation. CpdR functions like an adaptor to alter substrate choice by ClpXP; however, it remains unclear how CpdR influences its multiple targets. Here we show that, unlike canonical ClpXP adaptors, CpdR alone does not strongly bind its substrate. Instead, CpdR binds the N-terminal domain of ClpX and prepares (primes) the unfoldase for substrate engagement. This priming creates a recruitment interface that docks multiple substrates and additional adaptor components. We show that adaptor-dependent priming of ClpX avoids concentration-dependent inhibition that limits traditional scaffolding adaptors. Phosphosignaling disrupts the adaptor-protease interaction, and mutations in CpdR that impact ClpX binding tune adaptor activity and biological function. Together, these results reveal how a single adaptor can command global changes in proteome composition through priming of a protease.

Critical clamp loader processing by an essential AAA+ protease in Caulobacter crescentus.

Chromosome replication relies on sliding clamps that are loaded by energy-dependent complexes. In Escherichia coli, the ATP-binding clamp loader subunit DnaX exists as both long (τ) and short (γ) forms generated through programmed translational frameshifting, but the need for both forms is unclear. Here, we show that in Caulobacter crescentus, DnaX isoforms are unexpectedly generated through partial proteolysis by the AAA+ protease casein lytic proteinase (Clp) XP. We find that the normally processive ClpXP protease partially degrades DnaX to produce stable fragments upon encountering a glycine-rich region adjacent to a structured domain. Increasing the sequence complexity of this region prevents partial proteolysis and generates a τ-only form of DnaX in vivo that is unable to support viability on its own. Growth is restored when γ is provided in trans, but these strains are more sensitive to DNA damage compared with strains that can generate γ through proteolysis. Our work reveals an unexpected mode of partial processing by the ClpXP protease to generate DnaX isoforms, demonstrates that both τ and γ forms of DnaX are required for Caulobacter viability, and identifies a role for clamp loader diversity in responding to DNA damage. The conservation of distinct DnaX isoforms throughout bacteria despite fundamentally different mechanisms for producing them suggests there may be a conserved need for alternate clamp loader complexes during DNA damaging conditions.

Identification of ClpP substrates in Caulobacter crescentus reveals a role for regulated proteolysis in bacterial development.

Energy-dependent proteases ensure the timely removal of unwanted proteins in a highly selective fashion. In Caulobacter crescentus, protein degradation by the ClpXP protease is critical for cell cycle progression; however, only a handful of substrates are currently known. Here, we use a trapping approach to identify putative substrates of the ClpP associated proteases in C. crescentus. Biochemical validation of several of these targets reveals specific protease recognition motifs and suggests a need for ClpXP-specific degradation beyond degradation of known cell cycle regulators. We focus on a particular instance of regulated proteolysis in Caulobacter by exploring the role of ClpXP in degrading the stalk synthesis transcription factor TacA. We show that TacA degradation is controlled during the cell cycle dependent on the ClpXP regulator CpdR and that stabilization of TacA increases degradation of another ClpXP substrate, CtrA, while restoring deficiencies associated with prolific CpdR activity. Together, our work reveals a number of new validated ClpXP substrates, clarifies rules of protease substrate selection, and demonstrates how regulated protein degradation is critical for Caulobacter development and cell cycle progression.