Defining the pathogenesis of human mtDNA mutations using a yeast model: the case of T8851C.

More and more mutations are found in the mitochondrial DNA of various patients but ascertaining their pathogenesis is often difficult. Due to the conservation of mitochondrial function from yeast to humans, the unique ability of yeast to survive without production of ATP by oxidative phosphorylation, and the amenability of the yeast mitochondrial genome to site-directed mutagenesis, yeast is an excellent model for investigating the consequences of specific human mtDNA mutations. Here we report the construction of a yeast model of a point mutation (T8851C) in the mitochondrially-encoded subunit a/6 of the ATP synthase that has been associated with bilateral striatal lesions, a group of rare human neurological disorders characterized by symmetric degeneration of the corpus striatum. The biochemical consequences of this mutation are unknown. The T8851C yeast displayed a very slow growth phenotype on non-fermentable carbon sources, both at 28°C (the optimal temperature for yeast growth) and at 36°C. Mitochondria from T8851C yeast grown in galactose at 28°C showed a 60% deficit in ATP production. When grown at 36°C the rate of ATP synthesis was below 5% that of the wild-type, indicating that heat renders the mutation much more deleterious. At both growth temperatures, the mutant F(1)F(o) complex was correctly assembled but had only very weak ATPase activity (about 10% that of the control), both in mitochondria and after purification. These findings indicate that a block in the proton-translocating domain of the ATP synthase is the primary cause of the neurological disorder in the patients carrying the T8851C mutation. This article is part of a Directed Issue entitled: Bioenergetic dysfunction, adaptation and therapy.

Rotor architecture in the yeast and bovine F1-c-ring complexes of F-ATP synthase.

The F(1)F(O)-ATP synthase is a rotary molecular nanomotor. F(1) is a chemical motor driven by ATP hydrolysis while F(O) is an electrical motor driven by the proton flow. The two stepping motors are mechanically coupled through a common rotary shaft. Up to now, the three available crystal structures of the F(1)c(10) sub-complex of the yeast F(1)F(O)-ATP synthase were isomorphous and then named yF(1)c(10)(I). In this crystal form, significant interactions of the c(10)-ring with the F(1)-head of neighboring molecules affected the overall conformation of the F(1)-c-ring complex. The symmetry axis of the F(1)-head and the inertia axis of the c-ring were tilted near the interface between the F(1)-central stalk and the c-ring rotor, resulting in an unbalanced machine. We have solved a new crystal form of the F(1)c(10) complex, named yF(1)c(10)(II), inhibited by adenylyl-imidodiphosphate (AMP-PNP) and dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD), at 6.5Å resolution in which the crystal packing has a weaker influence over the conformation of the F(1)-c-ring complex. yF(1)c(10)(II) provides a model of a more efficient generator. yF(1)c(10)(II) and bovine bF(1)c(8) structures share a common rotor architecture with the inertia center of the F(1)-stator close to the rotor axis.

Evidence of the proximity of ATP synthase subunits 6 (a) in the inner mitochondrial membrane and in the supramolecular forms of Saccharomyces cerevisiae ATP synthase.

The involvement of subunit 6 (a) in the interface between yeast ATP synthase monomers has been highlighted. Based on the formation of a disulfide bond and using the unique cysteine 23 as target, we show that two subunits 6 are close in the inner mitochondrial membrane and in the solubilized supramolecular forms of the yeast ATP synthase. In a null mutant devoid of supernumerary subunits e and g that are involved in the stabilization of ATP synthase dimers, ATP synthase monomers are close enough in the inner mitochondrial membrane to make a disulfide bridge between their subunits 6, and this proximity is maintained in detergent extract containing this enzyme. The cross-linking of cysteine 23 located in the N-terminal part of the first transmembrane helix of subunit 6 suggests that this membrane-spanning segment is in contact with its counterpart belonging to the ATP synthase monomer that faces it and participates in the monomer-monomer interface.

Crystal structure of the Mg·ADP-inhibited state of the yeast F1c10-ATP synthase.

The F(1)c(10) subcomplex of the yeast F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase includes the membrane rotor part c(10)-ring linked to a catalytic head, (αß)(3), by a central stalk, γδε. The Saccharomyces cerevisiae yF(1)c(10)·ADP subcomplex was crystallized in the presence of Mg·ADP, dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD), and azide. The structure was solved by molecular replacement using a high resolution model of the yeast F(1) and a bacterial c-ring model with 10 copies of the c-subunit. The structure refined to 3.43-Å resolution displays new features compared with the original yF(1)c(10) and with the yF(1) inhibited by adenylyl imidodiphosphate (AMP-PNP) (yF(1)(I-III)). An ADP molecule was bound in both ß(DP) and ß(TP) catalytic sites. The α(DP)-ß(DP) pair is slightly open and resembles the novel conformation identified in yF(1), whereas the α(TP)-ß(TP) pair is very closed and resembles more a DP pair. yF(1)c(10)·ADP provides a model of a new Mg·ADP-inhibited state of the yeast F(1). As for the original yF(1) and yF(1)c(10) structures, the foot of the central stalk is rotated by ∼40 ° with respect to bovine structures. The assembly of the F(1) central stalk with the F(0) c-ring rotor is mainly provided by electrostatic interactions. On the rotor ring, the essential cGlu(59) carboxylate group is surrounded by hydrophobic residues and is not involved in hydrogen bonding.

Hydrogenated and fluorinated surfactants derived from Tris(hydroxymethyl)-acrylamidomethane allow the purification of a highly active yeast F1-F0 ATP-synthase with an enhanced stability.

Loss of stability and integrity of large membrane protein complexes as well as their aggregation in a non-lipidic environment are the major bottlenecks to their structural studies. We have tested C(12)H(25)-S-poly-Tris-(hydroxymethyl)acrylamidomethane (H(12)-TAC) among many other detergents for extracting the yeast F(1)F(0) ATP-synthase. H(12)-TAC was found to be a very efficient detergent for removing the enzyme from mitochondrial membranes without altering its sensitivity towards specific ATP-synthase inhibitors. This extracted enzyme was then solubilized by either dodecyl maltoside (DDM), H(12)-TAC or fluorinated surfactants such as C(2)H(5)-C(6)F(12)-C(2)H(4)-S-poly-Tris-(hydroxymethyl)acrylamidomethane (H(2)F(6)-TAC) or C(6)F(13)-C(2)H(4)-S-poly-Tris-(hydroxymethyl)acrylamidomethane (F(6)-TAC), two surfactants exhibiting a comparable polar head to H(12)-TAC but bearing a fluorinated hydrophobic tail. Preparations from enzymes purified in the presence of H(12)-TAC were found to be more adapted for AFM imaging than ATP-synthase purified with DDM. Keeping H(12)-TAC during the Ni-NTA IMAC purification step or replacing it by DDM at low concentrations did not however allow preserving enzyme activity, while fluorinated surfactants H(2)F(6)-TAC and F(6)-TAC were found to enhance enzyme stability and integrity as indicated by sensitivity towards inhibitors. ATPase specific activity was higher with F(6)-TAC than with H(2)F(6)-TAC. When enzymes were mixed with egg phosphatidylcholine, ATP-synthases purified in the presence of H(2)F(6)-TAC or F(6)-TAC were more stable upon time than the DDM purified enzyme. Furthermore, in the presence of lipids, an activation of ATP-synthases was observed that was transitory for enzymes purified with DDM, but lasted for weeks for ATP-synthases isolated in the presence of molecules with Tris polyalcoholic moieties. Relipidated enzymes prepared with fluorinated surfactants remained highly sensitive towards inhibitors, even after 6 weeks.

Mitochondrial F1F0-ATP synthase and organellar internal architecture.

The mitochondrial F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase adopts supramolecular structures. The interaction domains between monomers involve components belonging to the F(0) domains. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, alteration of these components destabilizes the oligomeric structures, leading concomitantly to the appearance of monomeric species of ATP synthase and anomalous mitochondrial morphologies in the form of onion-like structures. The mitochondrial ultrastructure at the cristae level is thus modified. Electron microscopy on cross-sections of wild type mitochondria display many short cristae with narrowed intra-cristae space, whereas yeast mutants defected in supramolecular ATP synthases assembly present a low number of large lamellar cristae of constant thickness and traversing the whole organelle. The growth of these internal structures leads finally to mitochondria with sphere-like structures with a mean diameter of 1 microm that are easily identified by epifluorescence microscopy. As a result, ATP synthase is an actor of the mitochondrial ultrastructure in yeast. This paper reviews the ATP synthase components whose modifications lead to anomalous mitochondrial morphology and also provides a schema showing the formation of the so-called onion-like structures.

Supramolecular organization of the yeast F1Fo-ATP synthase.

BACKGROUND INFORMATION: The yeast mitochondrial F(1)F(o)-ATP synthase is a large complex of 600 kDa that uses the proton electrochemical gradient generated by the respiratory chain to catalyse ATP synthesis from ADP and P(i). For a large range of organisms, it has been shown that mitochondrial ATP synthase adopts oligomeric structures. Moreover, several studies have suggested that a link exists between ATP synthase and mitochondrial morphology. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION: In order to understand the link between ATP synthase oligomerization and mitochondrial morphology, more information is needed on the supramolecular organization of this enzyme within the inner mitochondrial membrane. We have conducted an electron microscopy study on wild-type yeast mitochondria at different levels of organization from spheroplast to isolated ATP synthase complex. Using electron tomography, freeze-fracture, negative staining and image processing, we show that cristae form a network of lamellae, on which ATP synthase dimers assemble in linear and regular arrays of oligomers. CONCLUSIONS: Our results shed new light on the supramolecular organization of the F(1)F(o)-ATP synthase and its potential role in mitochondrial morphology.

Characterization of domain interfaces in monomeric and dimeric ATP synthase.

We disassembled monomeric and dimeric yeast ATP synthase under mild conditions to identify labile proteins and transiently stable subcomplexes that had not been observed before. Specific removal of subunits alpha, beta, oligomycin sensitivity conferring protein (OSCP), and h disrupted the ATP synthase at the gamma-alpha(3)beta(3) rotor-stator interface. Loss of two F(1)-parts from dimeric ATP synthase led to the isolation of a dimeric subcomplex containing membrane and peripheral stalk proteins thus identifying the membrane/peripheral stalk sectors immediately as the dimerizing parts of ATP synthase. Almost all subunit a was found associated with a ring of 10 c-subunits in two-dimensional blue native/SDS gels. We therefore postulate that c10a1-complex is a stable structure in resting ATP synthase until the entry of protons induces a breaking of interactions and stepwise rotation of the c-ring relative to the a-subunit in the catalytic mechanism. Dimeric subunit a was identified in SDS gels in association with two c10-rings suggesting that a c10a2c10-complex may constitute an important part of the monomer-monomer interface in dimeric ATP synthase that seems to be further tightened by subunits b, i, e, g, and h. In contrast to the monomer-monomer interface, the interface between dimers in higher oligomeric structures remains largely unknown. However, we could show that the natural inhibitor protein Inh1 is not required for oligomerization.

Yeast cells depleted in Atp14p fail to assemble Atp6p within the ATP synthase and exhibit altered mitochondrial cristae morphology.

Within the yeast mitochondrial ATP synthase, subunit h is a small nuclear encoded protein belonging to the so-called "peripheral stalk" that connects the enzyme catalytic F(1) component to the mitochondrial inner membrane. This study examines the role of subunit h in ATP synthase function and assembly using a regulatable, doxycycline-repressible subunit h gene to overcome the strong instability of the mtDNA previously observed in strains lacking the native subunit h gene. Yeast cells expressing less than 3% of subunit h, but still containing intact mitochondrial genomes, grew poorly on respiratory substrates because of a major impairment of ATP synthesis originating from the ATP synthase, whereas the respiratory chain complexes were not affected. The lack of ATP synthesis in the subunit h-depleted (deltah) mitochondria was attributed to defects in the assembly/stability of the ATP synthase. A main feature of deltah-mitochondria was a very low content (<6%) in the mitochondrially encoded Atp6p subunit, an essential component of the enzyme proton channel, which was in large part because of a slowing down in translation. Interestingly, depletion of subunit h resulted in dramatic changes in mitochondrial cristae morphology, which further supports the existence of a link between the ATP synthase and the folding/biogenesis of the inner mitochondrial membrane.

The intermembrane space loop of subunit b (4) is a major determinant of the stability of yeast oligomeric ATP synthases.

The involvement of the b-subunit, subunit 4 in yeast, a component of the peripheral stalk of the ATP synthase, in the dimerization/oligomerization process of this enzyme was investigated. Increasing deletions were introduced by site-directed mutagenesis in the loop located in the mitochondrial intermembrane space and linking the two transmembrane (TM) segments of subunit 4. The resulting strains were still able to grow on nonfermentable media, but defects were observed in ATP synthase dimerization/oligomerization along with concomitant mitochondrial morphology alterations. Surprisingly, such defects, already depicted in the absence of the so-called dimer-specific subunits e and g, were found in a mutant harboring a full amount of subunit g associated to the monomeric form of the ATP synthase. Deletion of the intermembrane space loop of subunit 4 modified the profile of cross-linking products involving cysteine residues belonging to subunits 4, g, 6, and e. This suggests that this loop of subunit 4 participates in the organization of surrounding hydrophobic membranous components (including the two TM domains of subunit 4) and thus is involved in the stability of supramolecular species of yeast ATP synthase in the mitochondrial membrane.

Protein-protein contacts in solubilized membrane proteins, as detected by cross-linking.

The amount of detergent required for the solubilization of membrane proteins needs to be optimised as an excess may cause loss of activity and insufficiency may result in poor solubilization or heterogeneous samples. With sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+ -ATPase as an example we show by cross-linking that it can be misleading to choose the proper amount of detergent based on clarification of membrane suspensions, because clarification -as detected by turbidity measurements, for instance- precedes full protein solubilization as monomers. We demonstrate that to assess the extent of sample homogeneity at a given detergent/protein ratio, cross-linking followed by HPLC gel filtration in detergent usefully complements cross-linking followed by SDS-PAGE.

The peripheral stalk participates in the yeast ATP synthase dimerization independently of e and g subunits.

It is now clearly established that dimerization of the F(1)F(o) ATP synthase takes place in the mitochondrial inner membrane. Interestingly, oligomerization of this enzyme seems to be involved in cristae morphogenesis. As they were able to form homodimers, subunits 4, e, and g have been proposed as potential ATP synthase dimerization subunits. In this paper, we provide evidence that subunit h, a peripheral stalk component, is located either at or near the ATP synthase dimerization interface. Subunit h homodimers were formed in mitochondria and were found to be associated to ATP synthase dimers. Moreover, homodimerization of subunit h and of subunit i turned out to be independent of subunits e and g, confirming the existence of an ATP synthase dimer in the mitochondrial inner membrane in the absence of subunits e and g. For the first time, this dimer has been observed by BN-PAGE. Finally, from these results we are now able to update our model for the supramolecular organization of the ATP synthase in the membrane and propose a role for subunits e and g, which stabilize the ATP synthase dimers and are involved in the oligomerization of the complex.

The modification of the conserved GXXXG motif of the membrane-spanning segment of subunit g destabilizes the supramolecular species of yeast ATP synthase.

The supernumerary subunit g is found in all mitochondrial ATP synthases. Most of the conserved amino acid residues are present in the membrane C-terminal part of the protein that contains a dimerization motif GXXXG. In yeast, alteration of this motif leads to the loss of subunit g and of supramolecular structures of the ATP synthase with concomitant appearance of anomalous mitochondrial morphologies. Disulfide bond formation involving an engineered cysteine in position 109 of subunit g and the endogenous cysteine 28 of subunit e promoted g + g, e + g, and e + e adducts, thus revealing the proximity in the mitochondrial membrane of several subunits e and g. Disulfide bond formation between two subunits g in mitochondria increased the stability of an oligomeric structure of the ATP synthase in digitonin extracts. These data suggest the participation of the dimerization motif of subunit g in the formation of supramolecular structures and is in favor of the existence of ATP synthase associations, in the inner mitochondrial membrane, whose masses are higher than those of ATP synthase dimers.

The modulation in subunits e and g amounts of yeast ATP synthase modifies mitochondrial cristae morphology.

Subunits e and g of Saccharomyces cerevisiae ATP synthase are required to maintain ATP synthase dimeric forms. Mutants devoid of these subunits display anomalous mitochondrial morphologies. An expression system regulated by doxycycline was used to modulate the expression of the genes encoding the subunits e and g. A decrease in the amount of subunit e induces a decrease in the amount of subunit g, but a decrease in the amount of subunit g does not affect subunit e. The loss of subunit e or g leads to the loss of supramolecular structures of ATP synthase, which is fully reversible upon removal of doxycycline. In the absence of doxycycline, mitochondria present poorly defined cristae. In the presence of doxycycline, onion-like structures are formed after five generations. When doxycycline is removed after five generations, cristae are mainly observed. The data demonstrate that the inner structure of mitochondria depends upon the ability of ATP synthase to make supramolecular structures.

Functional transitions of F0F1-ATPase mediated by the inhibitory peptide IF1 in yeast coupled submitochondrial particles.

The mechanism of inhibition of yeast F(0)F(1)-ATPase by its naturally occurring protein inhibitor (IF1) was investigated in submitochondrial particles by studying the IF1-mediated ATPase inhibition in the presence and absence of a protonmotive force. In the presence of protonmotive force, IF1 added during net NTP hydrolysis almost completely inhibited NTPase activity. At moderate IF1 concentration, subsequent uncoupler addition unexpectedly caused a burst of NTP hydrolysis. We propose that the protonmotive force induces the conversion of IF1-inhibited F(0)F(1)-ATPase into a new form having a lower affinity for IF1. This form remains inactive for ATP hydrolysis after IF1 release. Uncoupling simultaneously releases ATP hydrolysis and converts the latent form of IF1-free F(0)F(1)-ATPase back to the active form. The relationship between the different steps of the catalytic cycle, the mechanism of inhibition by IF1 and the interconversion process is discussed.

Topological and functional study of subunit h of the F1Fo ATP synthase complex in yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Subunit h, a 92-residue-long, hydrophilic, acidic protein, is a component of the yeast mitochondrial F1Fo ATP synthase. This subunit, homologous to the mammalian factor F6, is essential for the correct assembly and/or functioning of this enzyme since yeast cells lacking it are not able to grow on nonfermentable carbon sources. Chemical cross-links between subunit h and subunit 4 have previously been shown, suggesting that subunit h is a component of the peripheral stalk of the F1Fo ATP synthase. The construction of cysteine-containing subunit h mutants and the use of bismaleimide reagents provided insights into its environment. Cross-links were obtained between subunit h and subunits alpha, f, d, and 4. These results and secondary structure predictions allowed us to build a structural model and to propose that this subunit occupies a central place in the peripheral stalk between the F1 sector and the membrane. In addition, subunit h was found to have a stoichiometry of one in the F1Fo ATP synthase complex and to be in close proximity to another subunit h belonging to another F1Fo ATP synthase in the inner mitochondrial membrane. Finally, functional characterization of mitochondria from mutants expressing different C-terminal shortened subunit h suggested that its C-terminal part is not essential for the assembly of a functional F1Fo ATP synthase.

The two rotor components of yeast mitochondrial ATP synthase are mechanically coupled by subunit delta.

The mitochondrial ATP synthase is made of a membrane-integrated F0 component that forms a proton-permeable pore through the inner membrane and a globular peripheral F1 domain where ATP is synthesized. The catalytic mechanism is thought to involve the rotation of a 10-12 c subunit ring in the F0 together with the gamma subunit of F1. An important and not yet resolved question is to define precisely how the gamma subunit is connected with the c-ring. In this study, using a doxycycline-regulatable expression system, we provide direct evidence that the rest of the enzyme can assemble without the delta subunit of F1, and we show that delta-less mitochondria are uncoupled because of an F0-mediated proton leak. Based on these observations, and taking into account high-resolution structural models, we propose that subunit delta plays a key role in the mechanical coupling of the c-ring to subunit gamma.

Investigation of the role and mechanism of IF1 and STF1 proteins, twin inhibitory peptides which interact with the yeast mitochondrial ATP synthase.

Inhibition of the yeast F(0)F(1)-ATP synthase by the regulatory peptides IF1 and STF1 was studied using intact mitochondria and submitochondrial particles from wild-type cells or from mutants lacking one or both peptides. In intact mitochondria, endogenous IF1 only inhibited uncoupled ATP hydrolysis and endogenous STF1 had no effect. Addition of alamethicin to mitochondria readily made the mitochondrial membranes permeable to nucleotides, and bypassed the kinetic control exerted on ATP hydrolysis by the substrate carriers. In addition, alamethicin made the regulatory peptides able to cross mitochondrial membranes. At pH 7.3, F(0)F(1)-ATPase, initially inactivated by either endogenous IF1 or endogenous STF1, was completely reactivated hours or minutes after alamethicin addition, respectively. Previous application of a membrane potential favored the release of endogenous IF1 and STF1. These observations showed that IF1 and STF1 can fully inhibit ATP hydrolysis at physiological concentrations and are sensitive to the same effectors. However, ATP synthase has a much lower affinity for STF1 than for IF1, as demonstrated by kinetic studies of ATPase inhibition in submitochondrial particles by externally added IF1 and STF1 at pHs ranging from 5.5 to 8.0. Our data do not support previously proposed effects of STF1, like the stabilization of the IF1-F(0)F(1) complex or the replacement of IF1 on its binding site in the presence of the proton-motive force or at high pH, and raise the question of the conditions under which STF1 could regulate ATPase activity in vivo.

Hydrogen/deuterium exchange on yeast ATPase supramolecular protein complex analyzed at high sensitivity by MALDI mass spectrometry.

To evaluate the ability of hydrogen/deuterium exchange of amide protons followed by mass spectrometry (HXMS) to yield topological information about supramolecular protein complexes, this approach has been tested with the 370 kDa hetero-oligomeric complex of yeast F1-ATPase. The study was focused on the epsilon subunit (6612 Da) of the complex. Deuterium back exchange due to the chromatographic isolation step of this subunit was strongly reduced by means of fast micro-chromatography, and MALDI-MS was used to analyze either the intact subunit or peptide mixtures resulting from its proteolytic cleavage. A deuterium labeling kinetic study was conducted with epsilon subunit being a part of the F1 native complex. The effect of a secondary structure was also investigated by means of HXMS on the isolated epsilon subunit. Finally, to determine which regions of epsilon subunit are accessible to solvent in F1-ATPase during exchange, the complex was submitted to hydrogen/deuterium exchange, the epsilon subunit was purified by micro-chromatography, digested by pepsin, and resulting peptide fragments were analyzed by MALDI-MS. The combination of hydrogen/deuterium exchange, fast micro-chromatography and MALDI-MS was shown to be a fast and efficient way to obtain detailed topological information for the epsilon subunit when it is engaged in the ATPase complex.

The GxxxG motif of the transmembrane domain of subunit e is involved in the dimerization/oligomerization of the yeast ATP synthase complex in the mitochondrial membrane.

A conserved putative dimerization GxxxG motif located in the unique membrane-spanning segment of the ATP synthase subunit e was altered in yeast both by insertion of an alanine residue and by replacement of glycine by leucine residues. These alterations led to the loss of subunit g and the loss of dimeric and oligomeric forms of the yeast ATP synthase. Furthermore, as in null mutants devoid of either subunit e or subunit g, mitochondria displayed anomalous morphologies with onion-like structures. By taking advantage of the presence of the endogenous cysteine 28 residue in the wild-type subunit e, disulfide bond formation between subunits e in intact mitochondria was found to increase the stability of an oligomeric structure of the ATP synthase in digitonin extracts. The data show the involvement of the dimerization motif of subunit e in the formation of supramolecular structures of mitochondrial ATP synthases and are in favour of the existence in the inner mitochondrial membrane of associations of ATP synthases whose masses are higher than those of ATP synthase dimers.