Mechanism of a Dually Catalyzed Enantioselective Oxa-Pictet-Spengler Reaction and the Development of a Stereodivergent Variant.

Enantioselective oxa-Pictet-Spengler reactions of tryptophol with aldehydes proceed under weakly acidic conditions utilizing a combination of two catalysts, an indoline HCl salt and a bisthiourea compound. Mechanistic investigations revealed the roles of both catalysts and confirmed the involvement of oxocarbenium ion intermediates, ruling out alternative scenarios. A stereochemical model was derived from density functional theory calculations, which provided the basis for the development of a highly enantioselective stereodivergent variant with racemic tryptophol derivatives.

A Lewis Acid-Controlled Enantiodivergent Epoxidation of Aldehydes.

Two epoxidation catalysts, one of which consists of two VANOL ligands and an aluminum and the other that consists of two VANOL ligands and a boron, were compared. Both catalysts are highly effective in the catalytic asymmetric epoxidation of a variety of aromatic and aliphatic aldehydes with diazoacetamides, giving high yields and excellent asymmetric inductions. The aluminum catalyst is effective at 0 °C and the boron catalyst at -40 °C. Although both the aluminum and boron catalysts of (R)-VANOL give very high asymmetric inductions (up to 99% ee), they give opposite enantiomers of the epoxide. The mechanism, rate- and enantioselectivity-determining step, and origin of enantiodivergence are evaluated using density functional theory calculations.

Isotope Effects Reveal the Catalytic Mechanism of the Archetypical Suzuki-Miyaura Reaction.

Experimental and theoretical 13C kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) are utilized to obtain atomistic insight into the catalytic mechanism of the Pd(PPh3)4-catalyzed Suzuki-Miyaura reaction of aryl halides and aryl boronic acids. Under catalytic conditions, we establish that oxidative addition of aryl bromides occurs to a 12-electron monoligated palladium complex (Pd-(PPh3)). This is based on the congruence of the experimental KIE for the carbon attached to bromine (KIEC-Br = 1.020) and predicted KIEC-Br for the transition state for oxidative addition to the Pd(PPh3) complex (1.021). For aryl iodides, the near-unity KIEC-I of ~1.003 suggests that the first irreversible step in the catalytic cycle precedes oxidative addition and is likely the binding of the iodoarene to Pd(PPh3). Our results suggest that the commonly proposed oxidative addition to the 14-electron Pd(PPh3)2 complex can occur only in the presence of excess added ligand or under stoichiometric conditions; in both cases, experimental KIEC-Br of 1.031 is measured, which is identical to the predicted KIEC-Br for the transition state for oxidative addition to the Pd(PPh3)2 complex (1.031). The transmetalation step, under catalytic conditions, is shown to proceed via a tetracoordinate boronate (8B4) intermediate with a Pd-O-B linkage based on the agreement between an experimental KIE for the carbon atom involved in transmetalation (KIEC-Boron = 1.035) and a predicted KIEC-Boron for the 8B4 transmetalation transition state (1.034).

Rapid Evaluation of the Mechanism of Buchwald-Hartwig Amination and Aldol Reactions Using Intramolecular 13C Kinetic Isotope Effects.

A practical approach is introduced for the rapid determination of 13C kinetic isotope effects that utilizes a "designed" reactant with two identical reaction sites. The mechanism of the Buchwald-Hartwig amination of tert-butylbromobenzene with primary and secondary amines is investigated under synthetically relevant catalytic conditions using traditional intermolecular 13C NMR methodology at natural abundance. Switching to 1,4-dibromobenzene, a symmetric bromoarene as the designed reactant, the same experimental 13C KIEs are determined using an intramolecular KIE approach. This rapid methodology for KIE determination requires substantially less material and time compared to traditional approaches. Details of the Buchwald-Hartwig amination mechanism are investigated under varying synthetic conditions, namely a variety of halides and bases. The enantioselectivity-determining step of the l-proline catalyzed aldol reaction is also evaluated using this approach. We expect this mechanistic methodology to gain traction among synthetic chemists as a practical technique to rapidly obtain high-resolution information regarding the transition structure of synthetically relevant reactions under catalytic conditions.

Study of Ground State Interactions of Enantiopure Chiral Quaternary Ammonium Salts and Amides, Nitroalkanes, Nitroalkenes, Esters, Heterocycles, Ketones and Fluoroamides.

Chiral phase-transfer catalysis provides high level of enantiocontrol, however no experimental data showed the interaction of catalysts and substrates. 1 H NMR titration was carried out on Cinchona and Maruoka ammonium bromides vs. nitro, carbonyl, heterocycles, and N-F containing compounds. It was found that neutral organic species and quaternary ammonium salts interacted via an ensemble of catalyst + N-C-H and (sp2 )C-H, specific for each substrate studied. The correspondent BArF salts interacted with carbonyls via a diverse set of + N-C-H and (sp2 )C-H compared to bromides. This data suggests that BArF ammonium salts may display a different enantioselectivity profile. Although not providing quantitative data for the affinity constants, the data reported proofs that chiral ammonium salts coordinate with substrates, prior to transition state, through specific C-H positions in their structures, providing a new rational to rationalize the origin of enantioselectivity in their catalyses.

A Selenourea-Thiourea Brønsted Acid Catalyst Facilitates Asymmetric Conjugate Additions of Amines to α,ß-Unsaturated Esters.

ß-Amino esters are obtained with high levels of enantioselectivity via the conjugate addition of cyclic amines to unactivated α,ß-unsaturated esters. A related strategy enables the kinetic resolution of racemic cyclic 2-arylamines, using benzyl acrylate as the resolving agent. Reactions are facilitated by an unprecedented selenourea-thiourea organocatalyst. As elucidated by DFT calculations and 13C kinetic isotope effect studies, the rate-limiting and enantiodetermining step of the reaction is the protonation of a zwitterionic intermediate by the catalyst. This represents a rare case in which a thiourea compound functions as an asymmetric Brønsted acid catalyst.

Transition state analysis of an enantioselective Michael addition by a bifunctional thiourea organocatalyst.

The mechanism of the enantioselective Michael addition of diethyl malonate to trans-ß-nitrostyrene catalyzed by a tertiary amine thiourea organocatalyst is explored using experimental 13C kinetic isotope effects and density functional theory calculations. Large primary 13C KIEs on the bond-forming carbon atoms of both reactants suggest that carbon-carbon bond formation is the rate-determining step in the catalytic cycle. This work resolves conflicting mechanistic pictures that have emerged from prior experimental and computational studies.

Isotope Effects Reveal an Alternative Mechanism for "Iminium-Ion" Catalysis.

A novel mechanism for the epoxidation of enals with hydrogen peroxide catalyzed by diarylprolinol silyl ether supported by experimental 13C kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) and density functional theory calculations is presented. Normal 13C KIEs, measured on both the carbonyl- and ß-carbon atoms of the enal, suggest participation of both carbon atoms in the rate-determining step. Calculations show that the widely accepted iminium-ion mechanism does not account for this experimental observation. A syn-SN2' substitution mechanism, which avoids formation of a discrete iminium-ion intermediate, emerges as the most likely mechanism based on agreement between experimental and predicted KIEs.

13 C Kinetic Isotope Effects as a Quantitative Probe To Distinguish between Enol and Enamine Mechanisms in Aminocatalysis.

A combination of experimental 13 C kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) and high-level density functional theory (DFT) calculations is used to distinguish between "enamine" and "enol" mechanisms in the Michael addition of acetone to trans-ß-nitrostyrene catalyzed by Jacobsen's primary amine thiourea catalyst. In light of the recent findings that the widely used 18 O-incorporation probe for these mechanisms is flawed, the results described in this communication demonstrate an alternative probe to distinguish between these pathways. A key advantage of this probe is that quantitative mechanistic information is obtained without modifying experimental conditions. This approach is expected to find application in resolving mechanistic debates, while providing valuable information about the key transition state of organocatalyzed reactions involving the α-functionalization of carbonyls.

Asymmetric Induction via a Helically Chiral Anion: Enantioselective Pentacarboxycyclopentadiene Brønsted Acid-Catalyzed Inverse-Electron-Demand Diels-Alder Cycloaddition of Oxocarbenium Ions.

An enantioselective catalytic inverse-electron-demand Diels-Alder reaction of salicylaldehyde acetal-derived oxocarbenium ions and vinyl ethers to generate 2,4-dioxychromanes is described. Chiral pentacarboxycyclopentadiene (PCCP) acids are found to be effective for a variety of substrates. Computational and X-ray crystallographic analyses support the unique hypothesis that an anion with point-chirality-induced helical chirality dictates the absolute sense of stereochemistry in this reaction.

Pyro-Borates, Spiro-Borates, and Boroxinates of BINOL-Assembly, Structures, and Reactivity.

VANOL and VAPOL ligands are known to react with three equivalents of B(OPh)3 to form a catalytic species that contains a boroxinate core with three boron atoms, and these have proven to be effective catalysts for a number of reactions. However, it was not known whether the closely related BINOL ligand will likewise form a boroxinate species. It had simply been observed that mixtures of BINOL and B(OPh)3 were very poor catalysts compared to the same mixtures with VANOL or VAPOL. Borate esters of BINOL have been investigated as chiral catalysts, and these include meso-borates, spiro-borates, and diborabicyclo-borate esters. Borate esters are often in equilibrium, and their structures can be determined by stoichiometry and/or thermodynamics, especially in the presence of a base. The present study examines the structures of borate esters of BINOL that are produced with different stoichiometric combinations of BINOL with B(OPh)3 in the presence and absence of a base. Depending on conditions, pyro-borates, spiro-borates, and boroxinate species can be generated and their effectiveness in a catalytic asymmetric aziridination was evaluated. The finding is that BINOL borate species are not necessarily inferior catalysts to those of VANOL and VAPOL but that, under the conditions, BINOL forms two different catalytic species (a boroxinate and a spiro-borate) that give opposite asymmetric inductions. However, many BINOL derivatives with substitutents in the 3- and 3'-positions gave only the boroxinate species and the 3,3'-Ph2BINOL ligand gave a boroxinate catalyst that gives excellent inductions in the aziridination reaction. BINOL derivatives with larger groups in the 3,3'-position will not form either spiro-borates or boroxinate species and thus are not effective catalysts at all.

A Designed Approach to Enantiodivergent Enamine Catalysis.

The rational design and implementation of enantiodivergent enamine catalysis is reported. A simple secondary amine catalyst, 2-methyl-l-proline, and its tetrabutylammonium salt function as an enantiodivergent catalyst pair delivering the enantiomers of α-functionalized aldehyde products in excellent enantioselectivities. This novel concept of designed enantiodivergence is applied to the enantioselective α-amination, aldol, and α-aminoxylation/α-hydroxyamination reactions of aldehydes.

Catalytic Enantioselective Synthesis of Lactams through Formal [4+2] Cycloaddition of Imines with Homophthalic Anhydride.

An amide-thiourea compound, operating through a novel ion pairing mechanism, is an efficient organocatalyst for the asymmetric reaction of homophthalic anhydride with imines. N-aryl and N-alkyl imines readily undergo formal [4+2] cycloaddition to provide lactams with high levels of enantio- and diastereoselectivity. The nature of the key chiral ion pair intermediate was elucidated by DFT calculations.

Bifunctional Ammonium Salt Catalyzed Asymmetric α-Hydroxylation of ß-Ketoesters by Simultaneous Resolution of Oxaziridines.

Chiral bifunctional urea-containing ammonium salts were found to be very efficient catalysts for asymmetric α-hydroxylation reactions of ß-ketoesters with oxaziridines under base-free conditions. The reaction is accompanied by a simultaneous kinetic resolution of the oxaziridine and a plausible and so far unprecedented bifunctional transition-state model has been obtained by means of DFT calculations.

Nucleophile-Assisted Alkene Activation: Olefins Alone Are Often Incompetent.

Emerging work on organocatalytic enantioselective halocyclizations naturally draws on conditions where both new bonds must be formed under delicate control, the reaction regime where the concerted nature of the AdE3 mechanism is of greatest importance. Without assistance, many simple alkene substrates react slowly or not at all with conventional halenium donors under synthetically relevant reaction conditions. As demonstrated earlier by Shilov, Cambie, Williams, Fahey, and others, alkenes can undergo a concerted AdE3-type reaction via nucleophile participation, which sets the configuration of the newly created stereocenters at both ends in one step. Herein, we explore the modulation of alkene reactivity and halocyclization rates by nucleophile proximity and basicity, through detailed analyses of starting material spectroscopy, addition stereopreferences, isotope effects, and nucleophile-alkene interactions, all obtained in a context directly relevant to synthesis reaction conditions. The findings build on the prior work by highlighting the reactivity spectrum of halocyclizations from stepwise to concerted, and suggest strategies for design of new reactions. Alkene reactivity is seen to span the range from the often overgeneralized "sophomore textbook" image of stepwise electrophilic attack on the alkene and subsequent nucleophilic bond formation, to the nucleophile-assisted alkene activation (NAAA) cases where electron donation from the nucleophilic addition partner activates the alkene for electrophilic attack. By highlighting the factors that control reactivity across this range, this study suggests opportunities to explain and control stereo-, regio-, and organocatalytic chemistry in this important class of alkene additions.

Isotope Effects Reveal the Mechanism of Enamine Formation in l-Proline-Catalyzed α-Amination of Aldehydes.

The mechanism of l-proline-catalyzed α-amination of 3-phenylpropionaldehyde was studied using a combination of experimental kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) and theoretical calculations. Observation of a significant carbonyl (13)C KIE and a large primary α-deuterium KIE support rate-determining enamine formation. Theoretical predictions of KIEs exclude the widely accepted mechanism of enamine formation via intramolecular deprotonation of an iminium carboxylate intermediate. An E2 elimination mechanism catalyzed by a bifunctional base that directly forms an N-protonated enamine species from an oxazolidinone intermediate accounts for the experimental KIEs. These findings provide the first experimental picture of the transition-state geometry of enamine formation and clarify the role of oxazolidinones as nonparasitic intermediates in proline catalysis.

Catalytic asymmetric synthesis of alkynyl aziridines: both enantiomers of cis-aziridines from one enantiomer of the catalyst.

Alkynyl aziridines can be obtained from the catalytic asymmetric aziridination (AZ reaction) of alkynyl imines with diazo compounds in high yields and high asymmetric inductions mediated by a chiral boroxinate or BOROX catalyst. In contrast to the AZ reaction with aryl- and alkyl-substituted imines, alkynyl imines react to give cis-substituted aziridines with both diazo esters and diazo acetamides. Remarkably, however, the two diazo compounds give different enantiomers of the cis-aziridine from the same enantiomer of the catalyst. Theoretical considerations of the possible transition states for the enantiogenic step reveal that the switch in enantiomers results from a switch from Si-face to Re-face addition to the imine, which in turn is related to a switch from reaction with an E-imine in the former and a Z-isomer of the imine in the latter.

Transition state analysis of enantioselective Brønsted base catalysis by chiral cyclopropenimines.

Experimental (13)C kinetic isotope effects have been used to interrogate the rate-limiting step of the Michael addition of glycinate imines to benzyl acrylate catalyzed by a chiral 2,3-bis(dicyclohexylamino) cyclopropenimine catalyst. The reaction is found to proceed via rate-limiting carbon-carbon bond formation. The origins of enantioselectivity and a key noncovalent CH···O interaction responsible for transition state organization are identified on the basis of density functional theory calculations and probed using experimental labeling studies. The resulting high-resolution experimental picture of the enantioselectivity-determining transition state is expected to guide new catalyst design and reaction development.

Distortional binding of transition state analogs to human purine nucleoside phosphorylase probed by magic angle spinning solid-state NMR.

Transition state analogs mimic the geometry and electronics of the transition state of enzymatic reactions. These molecules bind to the active site of the enzyme much tighter than substrate and are powerful noncovalent inhibitors. Immucillin-H (ImmH) and 4'-deaza-1'-aza-2'-deoxy-9-methylene Immucillin-H (DADMe-ImmH) are picomolar inhibitors of human purine nucleoside phosphorylase (hPNP). Although both molecules are electronically similar to the oxocarbenium-like dissociative hPNP transition state, DADMe-ImmH is more potent than ImmH. DADMe-ImmH captures more of the transition state binding energy by virtue of being a closer geometric match to the hPNP transition state than ImmH. A consequence of these similarities is that the active site of hPNP exerts greater distortional forces on ImmH than on DADMe-ImmH to "achieve" the hPNP transition state geometry. By using magic angle spinning solid-state NMR to investigate stable isotope-labeled ImmH and DADMe-ImmH, we have explored the difference in distortional binding of these two inhibitors to hPNP. High-precision determinations of internuclear distances from NMR recoupling techniques, rotational echo double resonance, and rotational resonance, have provided unprecedented atomistic insight into the geometric changes that occur upon binding of transition state analogs. We conclude that hPNP stabilizes conformations of these chemically distinct analogs having distances between the cation and leaving groups resembling those of the known transition state.

Isotope effects and mechanism of the asymmetric BOROX Brønsted acid catalyzed aziridination reaction.

The mechanism of the chiral VANOL-BOROX Brønsted acid catalyzed aziridination reaction of imines and ethyldiazoacetate has been studied using a combination of experimental kinetic isotope effects and theoretical calculations. A stepwise mechanism where reversible formation of a diazonium ion intermediate precedes rate-limiting ring closure to form the cis-aziridine is implicated. A revised model for the origin of enantio- and diastereoselectivity is proposed based on relative energies of the ring-closing transition structures.