A further clue to understanding the mobility of mitochondrial yeast cytochrome c: a (15)N T1rho investigation of the oxidized and reduced species.

A new approach was developed to overproduce 15N-enriched yeast iso-1-cytochrome c in the periplasm of Escherichia coli in order to perform a study of the motions in the ms-micros time scale on the oxidized and reduced forms through rotating frame 15N relaxation rates and proton/deuterium exchange studies. It is confirmed that the reduced protein is rather rigid whereas the oxidized species is more flexible. The regions of the protein that display increased internal mobility upon oxidation are easily identified by the number of residues experiencing conformational equilibria and by their exchange rates. These data complement the information already available in the literature and provide a comprehensive picture of the mobility in the protein. In particular, oxidation mobilizes the loop containing Met80 and, through specific contacts, affects the mobility of helix 3 and possibly of helix 5, and of a section of protein connecting the heme propionates to helix 2. The relevance of internal motions to molecular recognition and to the early steps of the unfolding process of the oxidized species is also discussed. In agreement with the reported data, subnanosecond mobility is found to be less informative than the ms-micros with respect to redox dependent properties.

Side chain mobility as monitored by CH-CH cross correlation: the example of cytochrome b5.

The mobility of betaCH2 moieties in oxidized and reduced cytochrome b5 was studied by analyzing the 13C relaxation of the J-split components, in terms of C-H dipole-C-H dipole cross correlation rates. A 2D 13C-1H experiment is proposed to measure these rates that provide the internal effective reorientation correlation time for each CH2 moiety. It is found that higher mobility is present in the alpha helices forming the heme pocket. On the contrary, the beta strands, which form the hydrophobic core of the molecule, have the lowest mobility. The general pattern is the same for the oxidized and reduced species, indicating that any oxidation-dependent property detected for backbone NH moieties does not affect the CH2 mobility.

Crystallization and preliminary X-ray analysis of two pH-dependent forms of cytochrome c2 from Rhodopseudomonas palustris.

Cytochrome c(2) from Rhodopseudomonas palustris has been crystallized in two different crystal forms: a monoclinic form I at pH 4.4 from both reduced and oxidized protein solution and a trigonal form II at pH 9.0 from reduced protein solution. Complete 1. 7 and 1.4 A resolution data sets were collected from the oxidized form I and from the form II, respectively. The preliminary structures show an important change in the iron coordination environment in the trigonal form obtained at basic pH arising from the substitution of the Met ligand by an ammonia molecule.

Backbone dynamics of human Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase and of its monomeric F50E/G51E/E133Q mutant: the influence of dimerization on mobility and function.

The backbone assignment of reduced human dimeric Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD) was performed on a sample 100% enriched in (15)N, (13)C and 70% enriched in (2)H. (15)N T(1), T(2), and T(1)(rho) and (15)N-(1)H NOE assignment was performed at 600 MHz proton frequency on both wild-type SOD and the monomeric F50E/G51E/E133Q mutant. This allowed a comparison of the mobility in the subnanosecond and in the millisecond to microsecond time scales of the two systems. Both proteins are rather rigid, although some breathing of the beta sheets is detected in the wild type dimer. The monomer displays large mobility in the loops in the first part of the sequence, in loop IVa where point mutations have been introduced and at the C-terminus. The dimeric wild type is rigidified at loop IVa and at the C-terminus. Only loop VII shows a higher mobility in the dimer (besides some individual NH moieties). Conformational equilibria are displayed in the monomeric form around cysteines 57 and 146, thus explaining the disorder of arginine 143 which is the most important residue in guiding O(2)(-) toward the copper ion. The larger mobility in the wild type form with respect to the monomer in the picosecond to nanosecond time scale of helix alpha1 and loop VIIb, which provides the correct electrostatic driving force for O(2)(-) in the active channel, has been discussed in terms of favoring the activity of SOD.

Structural and functional studies of monomeric mutant of Cu-Zn superoxide dismutase without Arg 143.

Mutation of arginine (Arg) 143 with Ile in the monomeric mutant (Phe50Glu, Gly51Glu, Vall48Lys, Ile151Lys) of copper-zinc superoxide dismutase (R143I M4SOD, where M4SOD is the above mutant) leads to a protein with low copper content. Cobalt(II) binds the demetalized protein with a low and comparable affinity for the two metal sites, whereas it binds first and stochiometrically at the zinc site in the M4SOD protein and in the dimeric wild type SOD. However, a CuCo SOD derivative can be obtained whose NMR spectra indicate the structural changes induced by monomerization plus those induced by the Arg ---> Ile mutation. The electronic, circular dichroism, and EPR spectra provide structural information on the copper site. The low activity of the enzyme is accounted for on the basis of the structural properties of the active cavity.

The crystal structure of the monomeric human SOD mutant F50E/G51E/E133Q at atomic resolution. The enzyme mechanism revisited.

The crystal structure of the engineered monomeric human Cu,ZnSOD triple mutant F50E/G51E/E133Q (Q133M2SOD) is reported at atomic resolution (1.02 A). This derivative has about 20 % of the wild-type activity. Crystals of Q133M2SOD have been obtained in the presence of CdCl2. The metal binding site is disordered, with both cadmium and copper ions simultaneously binding to the copper site. The cadmium (II) ions occupy about 45 % of the copper sites by binding the four histidine residues which ligate copper in the native enzyme, and two further water molecules to complete octahedral coordination. The copper ion is tri-coordinate, and the fourth histidine (His63) is detached from copper and bridges cadmium and zinc. X-ray absorption spectroscopy performed on the crystals suggests that the copper ion has undergone partial photoreduction upon exposure to the synchrotron light. The structure is also disordered in the disulfide bridge region of loop IV that is located at the subunit/subunit interface in the native SOD dimer. As a consequence, the catalytically relevant Arg143 residue is disordered. The present structure has been compared to other X-ray structures on various isoenzymes and to the solution structure of the same monomeric form. The structural results suggest that the low activity of monomeric SOD is due to the disorder in the conformation of the side-chain of Arg143 as well as of loop IV. It is proposed that the subunit-subunit interactions in the multimeric forms of the enzyme are needed to stabilize the correct geometry of the cavity and the optimal orientation of the charged residues in the active channel. Furthermore, the different coordination of cadmium and copper ions, contemporaneously present in the same site, are taken as models for the oxidized and reduced copper species, respectively. These properties of the structure have allowed us to revisit the enzymatic mechanism.

The solution structure of a monomeric, reduced form of human copper,zinc superoxide dismutase bearing the same charge as the native protein.

The solution structure of a mutated (Phe50Glu, Gly51Glu, Val148Lys, Ile151Lys), reduced, monomeric form of human copper,zinc superoxide dismutase (SOD; 153 amino acids) has been determined through 2237 meaningful nuclear Overhauser enhancements, out of 2492, and 43 dihedral angle constraints. A characteristic of this mutant is that of having the same overall charge as the dimeric protein, but an activity of only 20% with respect to wild-type SOD. This protein, at variance with a previously characterized monomeric form (Phe50Glu, Gly51Glu, Glu133Gln), does not contain mutations in the active site. Therefore, its characterization allows us to understand the structural changes independently induced by the monomerization and by the active site mutation. The family of 36 conformers, which have a target function with respect to the experimental constraints lower than 1.5 A2, has RMSD values with respect to the average structure of 0.94 +/- 0.14 A2 and 1.50 +/- 0.14 A2 for the backbone and the heavy atoms, respectively. The overall folding, which includes the classical eight-stranded Greek-key beta-barrel and a short alpha-helix, is very close to that of the previously characterized monomeric mutant E133QM2SOD and to that of wild-type SOD. The region involved in the subunit-subunit interactions in the dimeric protein is confirmed to be disordered in the monomeric species. It is also observed that a sizable rearrangement of the charged groups of the electrostatic loop and of Arg143 takes place in the monomeric species. The width of the active site channel, both at its entrance and at the bottleneck of the active site, is discussed in the light of the influence on the enzymatic activity and the latter with respect to the overall charge. It is also confirmed that the NH proton of His63 shields the Cu(I) from the bulk solvent, thus supporting the suggestion that superoxide may interact with the reduced metal ion in an outer-sphere fashion.

Solution structure of reduced monomeric Q133M2 copper, zinc superoxide dismutase (SOD). Why is SOD a dimeric enzyme?.

Copper, zinc superoxide dismutase is a dimeric enzyme, and it has been shown that no cooperativity between the two subunits of the dimer is operative. The substitution of two hydrophobic residues, Phe 50 and Gly 51, with two Glu's at the interface region has disrupted the quaternary structure of the protein, thus producing a soluble monomeric form. However, this monomeric form was found to have an activity lower than that of the native dimeric species (10%). To answer the fundamental question of the role of the quaternary structure in the catalytic process of superoxide dismutase, we have determined the solution structure of the reduced monomeric mutant through NMR spectroscopy. Another fundamental issue with respect to the enzymatic mechanism is the coordination of reduced copper, which is the active center. The three-dimensional solution structure of this 153-residue monomeric form of SOD (16 kDa) has been determined using distance and dihedral angle constraints obtained from 13C, 15N triple-resonance NMR experiments. The solution structure is represented by a family of 36 structures, with a backbone rmsd of 0.81 +/- 0.13 A over residues 3-150 and of 0.56 +/- 0.08 A over residues 3-49 and 70-150. This structure has been compared with the available X-ray structures of reduced SODs as well as with the oxidized form of human and bovine isoenzymes. The structure contains the classical eight-stranded Greek key beta-barrel. In general, the backbone and the metal sites are not affected much by the monomerization, except in the region involved in the subunit-subunit interface in the dimeric protein, where a large disorder is present. Significative changes are observed in the conformation of the electrostatic loop, which forms one side of the active site channel and which is fundamental in determining the optimal electrostatic potential for driving the superoxide anions to the copper site which is the rate-limiting step of the enymatic reaction under nonsaturating conditions. In the present monomer, its conformation is less favorable for the diffusion of the substrate to the reaction site. The structure of the copper center is well-defined; copper(I) is coordinated to three histidines, at variance with copper(II) which is bound to four histidines. The hydrogen atom which binds the histidine nitrogen detached from copper(I) is structurally identified.

An NMR study of the 7Fe-8S ferredoxin from Rhodopseudomonas palustris and reinterpretation of data on similar systems.

The oxidized 7Fe-8S ferredoxin from Rhodopseudomonas palustris is shown to possess a unique 1H NMR spectrum displaying at least one hyperfine-shifted beta-CH2 signal for each cysteine bound to the [3Fe-4S] cluster. COSY and TOCSY spectra and 1- and 2-dimensional NOE experiments, in conjunction with a thorough reexamination of the 1H NMR data on similar systems, permitted the sequential assignment of all of the cysteine beta-CH2 protons even in the absence of the amino acid sequence. The sequential assignment stems on the homology of the hyperfine shift pattern with those of other sequenced 7Fe-8S ferredoxins, which points to a substantial homology in tertiary structure. From the assignment, an analysis of the antiferromagnetic coupling in the [3Fe-4S] system was performed on the basis of a general model of exchange coupling. The NMR signal patterns of [3Fe-4S] clusters in both 3Fe-4S and 7Fe-8S ferredoxins have been discussed, and some correlations are proposed between signal patterns and the primary sequence.

Synthesis and characterization of a monomeric mutant Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase with partially reconstituted enzymic activity.

A monomeric analog of human Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (F50E/G51E SOD), previously characterized and found to have reduced enzymic activity, was here further modified by replacing Glu133 with Gln. This substitution does not dramatically affect the coordination geometry at the active site, but enhances enzymic activity, and also increases the affinity for anions at the active site. This behavior parallels earlier published results in which this point mutation was made in the dimeric wild-type enzyme. The analog described here has afforded for the first time a monomeric superoxide dismutase with substantial activity. This point mutation does not significantly influence the protein structure but interactions with anions, including superoxide, are altered with respect to the monomeric form. The present monomeric Glu133Gln mutant has partially restored enzymic activity. The diminished activity of the monomeric analogs is discussed in the light of possible minor structural changes and some of their characteristics are compared with those of naturally occurring mutants associated with various neurological diseases.

Mutation of the metal-bridging proton-donor His63 residue in human Cu, Zn superoxide dismutase. Biochemical and biophysical analysis of the His63-->Cys mutant.

The bridging His63 residue in human Cu, Zn superoxide dismutase, which binds both metals, has been replaced by a Cys residue. The mutant protein has been purified from Escherichia coli and appears to be a normal dimer. Spectroscopic techniques (electronic spectroscopies, EPR, nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion) show that Cys63 binds the zinc ion, but not the copper ion, and that the latter is probably five co-ordinated with three histidine ligands and two water molecules. The reduction potential of the copper ion in the Cu2+/Cu+ pair decreases from 0.41 V to 0.27 V at neutral pH but still remains intermediate between those of the O2/O2- and O2-/H2O2 pairs so that copper can both oxidize and reduce the O2- substrate, a requirement for dismutase activity. The enzyme binds the substrate-analogue azide (N3-), which displaces one water molecule, with near normal affinity, whereas the enzyme activity with the O2- substrate is reduced to less than 1% of wild-type levels at pH 7.8. The properties of the mutant enzyme are discussed in relation to the superoxide-copper electron transfer process and to the catalytic mechanism.

Sequence-specific assignment of the 1H and 15N nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of the reduced recombinant high-potential iron-sulfur protein I from Ectothiorhodospira halophila.

A 1H and 15N NMR investigation through two-dimensional and three-dimensional spectroscopy has been performed on the reduced form ([Fe4S4]2+) of the recombinant high-potential iron-sulfur protein (HiPIP) I from Ectothiorhodospira halophila expressed in Escherichia coli. [Fe4S4]2+ clusters in proteins are paramagnetic with a relatively low mu eff of about 0.8 mu B/iron ion, but the paramagnetic effects on nuclear relaxation are so strong as to yield T1 values of a few milliseconds and linewidths of hundreds of hertz for the nuclei closet to the paramagnetic center. Despite these features, 71 out of 73 residues were identified, most of which were assigned completely as far as proton resonances are concerned; as many as 68 residues could be assigned without any reference to the existing X-ray structure. A total of 88% of all protein protons and 58 out of 69 peptide HN nitrogen signals were assigned. To the best of our knowledge, this is the most extensive 1H assignment of a paramagnetic protein to date. Protons sensitive to the proximity of the cluster were assigned through suitable NOE spectroscopy experiments. Three out of the four coordinated cysteines were assigned, and two residues have been identified whose peptide HN protons give rise to H bonds with coordinated sulfur atoms. The inter-residue NOE cross peaks are in qualitative agreement with the secondary and tertiary structure as obtained from the available X-ray crystallographic analysis of the wild-type protein at 250-pm resolution. It is therefore shown that the expressed protein is properly folded and that it is a reliable model for the wild-type protein. These data are meaningful for the detection of structural differences among mutants in future studies.

X-band ESEEM spectroscopy of 15N substituted native and inhibitor-bound superoxide dismutase. Hyperfine couplings with remote nitrogen of histidine ligands.

The hyperfine couplings of the remote nitrogens of histidine ligands are determined for the first time by an X-band ESEEM spectroscopy study of 15N-substituted superoxide dismutase (SOD). They show a significant difference between two groups of ligands with different orientation relative to the metal ion. The ESEEM spectra of 15N SOD with cyanide as an inhibitor containing 14N and 15N are also discussed. They allow some conclusions to be drawn about structural changes upon inhibitor binding and indicate the necessity of further multifrequency investigations.

A spectroscopic characterization of a monomeric analog of copper, zinc superoxide dismutase.

A mutated protein of human Cu(II)2Zn(II)2 SOD in which residues Phe50 and Gly51 at the dimer interface were substituted by Glu's, thus producing a monomeric species, has been characterized by electronic absorption spectroscopy, EPR, relaxivity and 1H NMR techniques. Such substitutions and/or accompanying remodeling and exposure of the dimer interface to solvent, alter the geometry of the active site: increases in the axiality of the copper chromophore and the Cu-OH2 distance have been observed. The affinity of both metal binding sites for Co(II) is also altered. The observed NMR parameters of the Co(II) substituted derivative have been interpreted as a function of the decrease of rotational correlation time as a consequence of the lower molecular weight of the mutated protein. Sharper NMR signals are also obtained for the reduced diamagnetic enzyme. Results are consistent with an active site structure similar to that observed for the dimeric analog. Thr137Ile characterized elsewhere. An observed proportional decrease in enzymatic activity and affinity for the N3-anion suggests the importance of electrostatic forces during substrate docking and catalysis.

An essential role for the conserved Glu-133 in the anion interaction with superoxide dismutase.

Negatively charged glutamic acid residues at positions 132 and 133 in human Cu2Zn2SOD are located at the entrance to the active site cavity and affect electrostatic interactions with the negatively charged substrate. The mutants in which these residues have been neutralized separately and together by conversion to glutamine residues or changed to a positive group on position 133 have been characterized through a variety of biophysical techniques. The structure around the metal ions, as monitored by spectroscopic measurements, is the same in the mutants and native enzyme. The mutants have been characterized with respect to the affinity for the anion N3-. The mutants have larger affinity for azide than the WT, as a result of the removal of one or two negative charges or of the introduction of a positive group. The pattern of the azide affinity constants parallels that of the rate of O2- dismutation. The substitution of the negative Glu-133 with a positive group does not induce a larger increase in the affinity as well as in the catalytic rates with respect to its neutralization. These patterns cannot, therefore, be rationalized only in terms of electrostatic interactions. The behavior of the mutants towards the substrate (O2-) and substrate analogue (N3-) is discussed on the basis of theoretical predictions available in the literature.

The role of the active site amino acid residues on the catalytic activity of Cu2Zn2SOD.

Copper, zinc superoxide dismutase, the enzyme that catalyzes the dismutation of the superoxide ion, is a key enzyme for neurodegenerative processes caused by the formation into tissues of this reactive free radical. Although the structure of enzyme is known, the catalytic mechanism has not yet fully elucidated. The copper ion represents the center, which exchanges electrons with the superoxide ion, but other residues present in the active site seem to play a relevant role. The most recent advancements in clarifying the structure-function relationship in this enzyme are discussed.

Investigation of a new Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase mutant: the Thr-->Arg 137 derivative.

The preparation and biophysical characterization of a mutant of superoxide dismutase in which the native Thr 137 has been substituted with a positive Arg residue are reported. Thr 137 forms, together with Arg 143, a bottleneck at the entrance to the active-site Cu ion. The geometry of the Cu ligands shows only minor changes after the above substitution. However, the enzymatic activity of the Arg 137 mutant is smaller than that of the wild type at physiological ionic strength and approaches that of wild type in the limit of zero ionic strength. The binding constant of the anion N3-, which had previously been shown to be a good probe of the O2- substrate, is increased about 20-fold in the mutant with respect to the value found in the wild type. These results are discussed on the bases of the whole charge of the cavity and the possible change in the conformation of the active-site channel.

Faster superoxide dismutase mutants designed by enhancing electrostatic guidance.

The enzyme Cu, Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD) protects against oxidative damage by dismuting the superoxide radical O2-. to molecular oxygen and hydrogen peroxide at the active-site Cu ion in a reaction that is rate-limited by diffusion and enhanced by electrostatic guidance. SOD has evolved to be one of the fastest enzymes known (V(max) approximately 2 x 10(9) M-1 s-1). The new crystal structures of human SOD show that amino-acid site chains that are implicated in electrostatic guidance (Glu 132, Glu 133 and Lys 136) form a hydrogen-bonding network. Here we show that site-specific mutants that increase local positive charge while maintaining this orienting network (Glu----Gln) have faster reaction rates and increased ionic-strength dependence, matching brownian dynamics simulations incorporating electrostatic terms. Increased positive charge alone is insufficient: one charge reversal (Glu----Lys) mutant is slower than the equivalent charge neutralization (Glu----Gln) mutant, showing that the newly introduced positive charge disrupts the orienting network. Thus, electrostatically facilitated diffusion rates can be increased by design, provided the detailed structural integrity of the active-site electrostatic network is maintained.

Assignment of active-site protons in the 1H-NMR spectrum of reduced human Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase.

600-MHz 1H-NMR and nuclear Overhauser enhancement spectroscopy (NOESY) spectra in 2H2O and H2O, as well as truncated driven NOE difference spectra in H2O of reduced human Cu(II)2Zn(II)2 superoxide dismutase (Cu/Zn SOD) have been recorded and used to assign the active-site proton signals. A derivative with histidines selectively deuteriated in the C2 position has been used for the detection of the HC2 histidine protons, 16 out of 17 observed signals of the 18 active-site histidine ring protons have been assigned. The results are compared with previous proposals based on more limited data sets. The numerous cross peaks confirm that the structure in solution is essentially similar to the crystallographic data obtained on the oxidized form. Probably this holds also for His63 which in the reduced form is not bridging any more the two metal ions. The effects of azide binding on the exchangeable 1H-NMR signals of the reduced protein are also reported.

A characterization of copper/zinc superoxide dismutase mutants at position 124. Zinc-deficient proteins.

Substitution of the completely conserved aspartic acid residue at position 124 of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase with asparagine and glycine has been performed through site-directed mutagenesis on the human enzyme. Asp124 is H-bonded to the NH of two histidines, one of which is bound to copper and the other to zinc. The mutant proteins, as expressed in Escherichia coli, result in an essential zinc-free enzyme which is similar to that obtained from the wild-type derivative through chemical manipulation. Only by extensive dialysis against 0.5 M ZnCl2 or CoCl2 at pH 5.4 was it possible to reconstitute approximately 50% of the molecules in the Cu2Zn2 or Cu2Co2 form. The new derivatives have been characterized through EPR, CD and nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion techniques. The Cu2Cox derivatives (x approximately 1) were used to monitor, through electronic and 1H-NMR spectroscopies, the metal sites which are found to be similar to those of the wild type. In addition, a double substitution with asparagine has been made, replacing the invariant aspartate at position 124 and the highly conserved aspartate at position 125. The behavior is similar to that of the other mutants in most respects. The Cu2E2 (E = empty) derivatives of the mutants are stable, even in the pH range 8-10, whereas in the case of the Cu2E2 derivative of the wild type, copper migration occurs at high pH, producing both Cu2Cu2 and apo derivatives. The activity measurements indicate that the various Cu2E2 derivatives have the same activity at low pH and similar to that of the holoenzyme. A full profile up to pH 10.5 was obtained for the mutants.