Retrotransposon expression as a defining event of genome reprogramming in fertilized and cloned bovine embryos.

Genome reprogramming is the ability of a nucleus to modify its epigenetic characteristics and gene expression pattern when placed in a new environment. Low efficiency of mammalian cloning is attributed to the incomplete and aberrant nature of genome reprogramming after somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) in oocytes. To date, the aspects of genome reprogramming critical for full-term development after SCNT remain poorly understood. To identify the key elements of this process, changes in gene expression during maternal-to-embryonic transition in normal bovine embryos and changes in gene expression between donor cells and SCNT embryos were compared using a new cDNA array dedicated to embryonic genome transcriptional activation in the bovine. Three groups of transcripts were mostly affected during somatic reprogramming: endogenous terminal repeat (LTR) retrotransposons and mitochondrial transcripts were up-regulated, while genes encoding ribosomal proteins were downregulated. These unexpected data demonstrate specific categories of transcripts most sensitive to somatic reprogramming and likely affecting viability of SCNT embryos. Importantly, massive transcriptional activation of LTR retrotransposons resulted in similar levels of their transcripts in SCNT and fertilized embryos. Taken together, these results open a new avenue in the quest to understand nuclear reprogramming driven by oocyte cytoplasm.

First birth of an animal from an extinct subspecies (Capra pyrenaica pyrenaica) by cloning.

Two experiments have been performed to clone the bucardo, an extinct wild goat. The karyoplasts were thawed fibroblasts derived from skin biopsies, obtained and cryopreserved in 1999 from the last living specimen, a female, which died in 2000. Cytoplasts were mature oocytes collected from the oviducts of superovulated domestic goats. Oocytes were enucleated and coupled to bucardo's fibroblasts by electrofusion. Reconstructed embryos were cultured for 36h or 7d and transferred to either Spanish ibex or hybrid (Spanish ibex malex domestic goat) synchronized recipients. Embryos were placed, according to their developmental stage, into the oviduct or into the uterine horn ipsilateral to an ovulated ovary. Pregnancy was monitored through their plasmatic PAG levels. In Experiment 1, 285 embryos were reconstructed and 30 of them were transferred at the 3- to 6-cells stage to 5 recipients. The remaining embryos were further cultured to day 7, and 24 of them transferred at compact morula/blastocyst stage to 8 recipients. In Experiment 2, 154 reconstructed embryos were transferred to 44 recipients at the 3- to 6-cells stage. Pregnancies were attained in 0/8 and 7/49 of the uterine and oviduct-transferred recipients, respectively. One recipient maintained pregnancy to term, displaying very high PAG levels. One morphologically normal bucardo female was obtained by caesarean section. The newborn died some minutes after birth due to physical defects in lungs. Nuclear DNA confirmed that the clone was genetically identical to the bucardo's donor cells. To our knowledge, this is the first animal born from an extinct subspecies.

Attempt to rescue sex-reversal by transgenic expression of the PISRT1 gene in XX PIS-/- goats.

The Polled Intersex Syndrome (PIS mutation) in goats leads to an absence of horn and to an early sex-reversal of the XX gonads. This mutation is a deletion of an 11.7-kb DNA fragment showing a tissue-specific regulatory activity. Indeed, in XX PIS(-/-) gonads the deletion of PIS leads to the transcriptional extinction of at least 3 neighboring genes, FOXL2, PFOXic and PISRT1. Among them, only FOXL2 is a 'classical' gene, encoding a highly conserved transcription factor. On the other hand, knock-out of Foxl2 in mice results in an early blocking of follicle formation without sex-reversal. This phenotype discrepancy leads to two hypotheses, either FOXL2 is responsible for XX sex-reversal in goat assuming distinct functions of its protein during ovarian differentiation in different mammals, or other PIS-regulated genes are involved. To assess the second possibility, PISRT1 expression was constitutively restored in XX PIS(-/-) gonads. Six transgenic fetuses were obtained by nuclear transfer and studied at 2 developmental stages, 41 and 46 days post-reconstruction. The gonads of these fetuses appear phenotypically identical to those of cloned non-transgenic controls. Conclusively, this result argues for FOXL2 being responsible for the PIS gonad-associated phenotype. Its invalidation in goat will help to better understand this complex syndrome.

Nuclear reprogramming and pluripotency of embryonic cells: Application to the isolation of embryonic stem cells in farm animals.

Despite their biological and biotechnological interest, pluripotent embryonic stem cell lines (ES cells) have been isolated from cultured embryos only in a very limited number of mammalian species. Here we review the main molecular mechanisms that have been shown in mouse or primates to regulate the maintenance of pluripotency in vitro. We describe the main signaling pathways that participate in the self-renewal of ES cells and provide an outlook on the epigenetic associated mechanisms. We also propose a practical approach to stem cell differentiation that examines the relationships between the genotype of embryos and their culture conditions and consider nuclear reprogramming as a valuable approach in ES cell derivation in farm animals.

Quality and safety of bovine clones and their products.

A multidisciplinary research programme was developed to get a scientific expertise for the quality assessment of products obtained from cloned livestock. Thirty-seven bovine Holstein female clones of five different genotypes and their products were analysed in comparison with 38 control animals obtained by conventional artificial insemination and raised under the same conditions at the same experimental farm. Animal evaluation included over 150 criteria and more than 10 000 measurements to check the physiological status and health over a 3-year period. All the parameters studied were in the normal range for age and breed, but some significant differences were detected between clone and control groups in terms of delayed onset of puberty in clones, higher neutrophil counts in haematology or lower biochemical plasma concentrations of gamma glutamyl transferase. Milk and meat analyses were conformable to expected values. We, however, found some differences in fatty acid (FA) composition of milk and muscle suggesting a possible deviation in lipid metabolism as assessed by higher delta-9 desaturase activity indexes in both milk and muscles from clones compared with controls. Repeated muscle biopsies in the semitendinosus muscle of the same animals demonstrated a higher oxidative activity in muscle of young clones (8 months of age) compared with controls, suggesting a delayed muscle maturation in clones. Nutritional evaluation of milk and meat using the rat feeding trials did not show any difference between clone and control products for food intake, growth rate, body composition of the rats, nor for possible allergenicity. Possible reactivation of bovine endogenous retroviruses (BERVs) was analysed and compared between normal and cloned cattle. As expected, these BERV sequences are not transcribed and no RNA was detected in the blood of clones, donor animals or controls; therefore, it may be assumed that the sanitary risk associated with BERV sequences is not higher in cattle derived from somatic nuclear transfer than in cattle born from conventional reproduction. Our results confirm that the quality and safety of products (milk and meat) from adult and clinically healthy cloned cattle is globally similar to normal animals. However, from a strictly biological point of view, the slightly delayed maturation we observed in the muscle of clones together with some marginal differences identified in FA composition of both muscle and milk, point to the need for more refined analysis to totally exclude any risks from the consumption of those products.

Large offspring or large placenta syndrome? Morphometric analysis of late gestation bovine placentomes from somatic nuclear transfer pregnancies complicated by hydrallantois.

Somatic nuclear transfer (NT) in cattle is often complicated by fetal oversize (i.e., large offspring syndrome), hydrallantois, and placentomegaly in late gestation. The aims of this work were to obtain data on the placentome structure in NT-recipient cows with hydrallantois (NTH) and to relate these with fetal and placental weights to better understand the abnormalities observed in NTH pregnancies during the third trimester. Pregnant cows were slaughtered between Gestation Days 180 and 280. The fetuses were weighed, and the placentomes were numbered and weighed. Placentomes were examined by histologic and stereological techniques. Macroscopic data showed that placental overgrowth preceded fetal overgrowth, and the ratio of the fetal to the total placentome weight in the NTH group was lower than that in controls after Gestation Day 220. This suggests that placental overgrowth is due to placental default rather than due to fetal overgrowth, as shown also by stereological analysis showing primary deregulation of the growth of cotyledonary tissues. Observed alterations, such as thinning of the maternal epithelium within placentomes and increased trophoblastic surface, could be secondary adaptations. Thus, placental growth deregulations would be due to modifications of the expression of placental factors. Various examples of placental deficiency were observed, suggesting that some fetal abnormalities observed in NTH calves, such as enlarged heart, enlarged umbilical cord, and abdominal ascites, are consequences of placental dysfunction. Therefore, the condition described by the term "large offspring syndrome" might better be described by "large placenta syndrome," because this syndrome affects an average of 50% of late-gestation NT pregnancies. No conclusion can be drawn from this work on apparently normal pregnancies.

Bovine muscle 20S proteasome. II: Contribution of the 20S proteasome to meat tenderization as revealed by an ultrastructural approach.

The role of the 20S proteasome proteolytic effects was revisited using an ultrastructural approach with the aim to explain some particular structural changes identified in type I muscles and in high pH meat. In both types of meat, major changes observed after ageing are an increase in the thickness of the Z-line followed by the appearance of an amorphous protein structure spreading out over the I-band. This was followed by a total degradation of this amorphous structure and of the Z-line. Partial transversal fragmentation of the myofibrils within the I-band can also be detected. The data reported clearly demonstrate that the 20S proteasome was able to mimic these sequential structural changes, a feature never obtained with either calpains or cathepsins. It is the first time that a direct implication of this complex in postmortem muscle is postulated.

Zootechnical performance of cloned cattle and offspring: preliminary results.

This paper presents information on the evolution of sets of cloned heifers of Holstein breed in comparison to that of control heifers derived from artificial insemination (AI) in the same farm, as well as data on a set of cloned bulls and their semen characteristics. Preliminary observations on a group of calves sired by a cloned bull and offspring of cloned females are reported. Mean birth weight in the clone group (50 females) was statistically higher than that of 68 contemporary female controls obtained by AI (49.27 +/- 10.98 vs. 40.57 +/- 5.55 kg, respectively, p < 0.05). Growth rate was within normal values for Holstein heifers (from 0.7 to 0.8 kg/day) and daily gain was not influenced by the high or low birth weight of clones. Within animals of the same clone, variability of daily gain was reduced compared to their control counterparts. Semen production from three cloned bulls was within the parameters expected for young bull of the same age. A direct comparison of morphological analysis was made between the frozen thawed semen of the donor bull and of his three clones collected at the same age. The overall semen picture appeared within acceptable limits and the clones presented similar percentages of sperm abnormalities (80% of morphologically normal spermatozoa) as the donor. These preliminary results suggest no deleterious effect of cloning on the semen picture of cloned sires. Frozen semen from one clone bull was used for an AI trial, resulting in 65% pregnancies, 25 live calves were naturally delivered. Concerning the offspring of both female and male clones, the phenotypical and clinical observation of the calves in the first week of age did not reveal any clinical abnormality, suggesting that the deviations observed in clones are not transmitted to the progeny.

Novel approaches and hurdles to somatic cloning in cattle.

The overall efficiency of somatic cloning in cattle is still low. Many factors are necessary for successful birth of live offspring. Among them, the source of donor cells reveals the importance of the donor genotype but also the influence of the cell line itself. The cell cycle stage has been intensively investigated, and recent results indicate that, in cattle, the G0 stage of the donor nuclei is not a prerequisite for reprogramming, as highly proliferating cultured fibroblasts also result in live offspring after nuclear transfer. A technical approach using direct microinjection of fibroblast nuclei, instead of fusion of the whole cell, has proved to result in high in vitro development rates in cattle. However, full-term development of somatic cloned embryos is still limited by long-lasting effects and a high incidence of losses at periimplantation time (as well as in late gestation and around calving).

Clinical, hormonal, and hematologic characteristics of bovine calves derived from nuclei from somatic cells.

Although healthy animals are born after nuclear transfer with somatic cells nuclei, the success of this procedure is generally poor (2%-10%) with high perinatal losses. Apparently normal surviving animals may have undiagnosed pathologies that could develop later in life. The gross pathology of 16 abnormal bovine fetuses produced by nuclear transfer (NT) and the clinical, endocrinologic (insulin-like growth factors I and II [IGF-I and IGF-II], IGF binding proteins, post-ACTH stimulation cortisol, leptin, glucose, and insulin levels), and biochemical characteristics of a group of 21 apparently normal cloned calves were compared with those of in vitro-produced (IVP) controls and controls resulting from artificial insemination. Oocytes used for NT or IVP were matured in vitro. NT to enucleated oocytes was performed using cultured adult or fetal skin cells. After culture, Day 7, grade 1-2 embryos were transferred (one per recipient). All placentas and fetuses from clones undergoing an abnormal pregnancy showed some degree of edema due to hydrops. Mean placentome number was lower and mean placentome weight was higher in clones than in controls (69.9 +/- 9.2 placentomes with a mean weight of 144.3 +/- 21.4 g in clones vs. 99 and 137 placentomes with a mean individual weight of 34.8 and 32.4 g in two IVP controls). Erythrocyte mean cell volume was higher at birth (P < 0.01), and body temperature and plasma leptin concentrations were higher and T4 levels were lower during the first 50 days and the first week (P < 0.05), respectively, in clones. Plasma IGF-II concentrations were higher at birth and lower at Day 15 in clones (P < 0.05). Therefore, apparently healthy cloned calves cannot be considered as physiologically normal animals until at least 50 days of age.

Nuclear transfer technologies: between successes and doubts.

Cloning of mammals by nuclear transfer can lead to the birth of healthy adult animals but more often compromises the development of the reconstructed embryos. A high incidence of fetal and postnatal losses has been observed in several species, revealing the existence of long-lasting effects induced by the nuclear transfer procedures. Remodeling of donor chromatin by the recipient cytoplasm after nuclear transfer is frequently associated with the deregulation of specific genes, and recent observations point to the potential importance of time-dependent DNA methylation events in the occurrence of these alterations. Screening strategies to design nuclear transfer procedures that would mimic the epigenetic remodeling occurring in normal embryos are being designed, and improvement in the efficiency of procedures could imply a pre-conditioning of donor cells. Early mammalian development appears to be rather tolerant to epigenetic abnormalities, raising the possibility that even a fully functional reprogrammed genome may have been subjected to some epigenetic alterations. Bringing nuclear transfer to routine practice requires greater knowledge and understanding of the basic biological processes underlying epigenetic controls of nuclear activities. An important issue at present is to limit the production of those aberrant phenotypes that may result in significant insult to the nature and welfare of animals.

Nucleolar changes in bovine nucleotransferred embryos.

This study focused on nucleolar changes in bovine embryos reconstructed from enucleated mature oocytes fused with blastomeres of morulae or with cultured, serum unstarved bovine fetal skin fibroblasts (embryonic vs. somatic cloning). The nucleotransferred (NT) embryos were collected and fixed at time intervals of 1-2 h (early 1-cell stage), 10-15 h (late 1-cell stage), 22-24 h (2-cell stage), 37-38 h (4-cell stage), 40-41 h (early 8-cell stage), 47-48 h (late 8-cell stage), and 55 h (16-cell stage) after fusion. Immunocytochemistry by light and electron microscopy was used for structure-function characterization of nucleolar components. Antibodies against RNA, protein B23, protein C23, and fibrillarin were applied. In addition, DNA was localized by the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT) technique, and the functional organization of chromatin was determined with the nick-translation immunogold approach. The results show that fully reticulated (active) nucleoli observed in donor cells immediately before fusion as well as in the early 1-cell stage after fusion were progressively transformed into nucleolar bodies displaying decreasing numbers of vacuoles from the 2- to 4-cell stage in both types of reconstructed embryos. At the late 8-cell stage, morphological signs of resuming nucleolar activity were detected. Numerous new small vacuoles appeared, and chromatin blocks reassociated with the nucleolar body. During this period, nick-translation technique revealed numerous active DNA sites in the periphery of chromatin blocks associated with the nucleolar body. Fully reticulated nucleoli were again observed as early as the 16-cell stage of embryonic cloned embryos. In comparison, the embryos obtained by fetal cloning displayed a lower tendency to develop, mainly during the first cell cycle and during the period of presumed reactivation. Correlatively, the changes in nucleolar morphology (desegregation and rebuilding) were at least delayed in many somatic NT embryos in comparison with the embryonic NT group. It is concluded that complete reprogramming of rRNA gene expression is part of the general nuclear reprogramming necessary for development after NT.

Frequency and occurrence of late-gestation losses from cattle cloned embryos.

Nuclear transfer from somatic cells still has limited efficiency in terms of live calves born due to high fetal loss after transfer. In this study, we addressed the type of donor cells used for cloning in in vivo development. We used a combination of repeated ultrasonography and maternal pregnancy serum protein (PSP60) assays to monitor the evolution of pregnancy after somatic cloning in order to detect the occurrence of late-gestation losses and their frequency, compared with embryo cloning or in vitro fertilization (IVF). Incidence of loss between Day 90 of gestation and calving was 43.7% for adult somatic clones and 33.3% for fetal somatic clones, compared with 4.3% after embryo cloning and 0% in the control IVF group. Using PSP60 levels in maternal blood as a criterion for placental function, we observed that after somatic cloning, recipients that lost their pregnancy before Day 100 showed significantly higher PSP60 levels by Day 50 than those that maintained pregnancy (7.77 +/- 3.3 ng/ml vs. 2.45 +/- 0.27 ng/ml for normal pregnancies, P < 0.05). At later stages of gestation, between 4 mo and calving, mean PSP60 concentrations were significantly increased in pathologic pregnancy after somatic cloning compared with other groups (P < 0.05 by Day 150, P < 0.001 by Day 180, and P < 0.01 by Day 210). In those situations, and confirmed by ultrasonographic measurements, recipients developed severe hydroallantois together with larger placentome size. Our findings suggest that assessing placental development with PSP60 and ultrasonography will lead to better care of recipient animals in bovine somatic cloning.

Tenderization of beef by lactic acid injected at different times post mortem.

The potential to tenderize beef muscles by the injection of lactic acid (0.5 M, 10% w/w) was studied using the pectoralis profundus muscle from cull cows. The injection was performed either 1 h (pre rigor) or 24 h (post rigor) post mortem, and the meat was stored for 2 or 14 days post mortem. Both treatments caused a rapid pH drop to around 5.0 within 4 h of injection. Other effects were: (1) an accelerated release of lysosomal enzymes into the cytosol; (2) a greater degradation of myosin heavy chains; (3) ultrastructural alterations of the myofibrils which included a general weakening or rupture in the M-lines and, to a lesser extent, in the I-bands; (4) a decreased heat stability of perimysial collagen indicated by a lower insoluble collagen content, lower differential scanning calorimetry transition temperature, and lower transition temperatures in isometric tension tests on muscle strips. The lactic acid injections improved significantly the textural traits of the meat (shear value, tensile strength, sensory scores) at 2 days post mortem with little further improvement when storage was extended to 14 days post mortem. Changes in texture were of similar amplitude at both post mortem injection times. The tenderization mechanisms of lactic acid injection are discussed.

[Cloning: present and perspectives]. / Clonage: le présent et les perspectives.

Human embryonic cells obtained through somatic cloning would allow selfgrafting for therapeutical purposes. Data available from animal research indicate that this issue should be considered with great care.

Lymphoid hypoplasia and somatic cloning.

BACKGROUND: Adult somatic cloning by nuclear transfer is associated with high rate of perinatal mortality but there is still no evidence that nuclear transfer itself is responsible for these failures. We report on a longlasting defect linked to somatic cloning. METHODS: Skin cells grown from an ear biopsy specimen from a 15-day-old calf were used as a source of nuclei. The donor animal was a clone of three females obtained from embryonic cells. Clinical examination, haematological, and biochemical profiles, and echocardiography of the somatic clone were done from birth to death. FINDINGS: After 6 weeks of normal development, the somatic cloned calf had a sudden and rapid fall in lymphocyte count and a decrease in haemoglobin. The calf died on day 51 from severe anaemia. Necropsy revealed no abnormality except thymic atrophy and lymphoid hypoplasia. INTERPRETATION: Somatic cloning may be the cause of long-lasting deleterious effects. Our observation should be taken into account in debates on reproductive cloning in human beings.

Effects of high-intensity high-frequency ultrasound on ageing rate, ultrastructure and some physico-chemical properties of beef.

High-intensity and high-frequency ultrasound was tested for its ability to accelerate meat ageing and increase beef tenderness. Samples (≈50g) of semimembranosus muscles from 8 cull cows were assigned to ultrasonic treatment (2.6MHz; 10W/cm(2); 2 ×15s) either pre-rigor (day 0, pH 6.2) or post-rigor (day 1, pH 5.4). When applied pre-rigor, ultrasound induced a slight delay in rigor mortis onset, a stretching (12-15%) of the sarcomeres (p<0.05), an ultrastructural alteration in the Z-line region and an immediate increase (around 30%) in the release of calcium in the cytosol (p<0.05). However, no conclusive effect on meat ageing rate was observed. Post-rigor ultrasonic treatment did not induce any structural modification but slightly improved the ageing index after 6 days (p<0.05). However, no improvement in the final (day 14) ageing index was observed compared to the controls. As ultrasound had also no effect on the thermal stability of collagen, at both postmortem times, no improvement in meat tenderness can be expected under the conditions used.

Endocytosis of lutropin by Leydig cells through a pathway distinct from the high-affinity receptor.

In porcine Leydig cells in primary culture, 95% of the internalization of [125I]porcine lutropin ([125I]pLH, which bears sulfated GalNAc) could not be ascribed to the high-affinity LH receptor (LHR). In contrast, >40% of [125I]human choriogonadotropin (hCG, with sialylated sugar chains) uptake was performed by the LHR itself. When the LHR was down-regulated by excess unlabeled hormone, the LHR-independent incorporation of [125I]pLH could be inhibited in a dose-dependent fashion by sulfated polysaccharides such as fucoidan or chondroitin-(4 or 6)-sulfate, but not by other polyanionic compounds, nor by sulfated chondroitin disaccharides. Endocytosis occurred through a clathrin-dependent pathway and was inhibited by low temperature, endocytosis inhibitors, increased ionic strength, or by EDTA and dithiothreitol. Taken together, these results suggest that a Leydig cell membrane protein (possibly a lectin, or a glycosaminoglycan receptor) could perform specific LH clearance in the testis via recognition of its sulfated sugars.

Developmental potential of bovine embryos reconstructed from enucleated matured oocytes fused with cultured somatic cells.

Muscle and skin biopsies taken from bovine fetuses and young calves have been used as a source of donor nuclei for cloning experiments. After culture, cells were individually fused to enucleated matured oocytes and the resulting blastocysts obtained after 7 d of culture (3-8% depending on the cell type) were transferred to foster recipient heifers. Two calves, a female and a male, both originating from muscle cells were born, and four additional pregnancies have surpassed mild-term gestation. The pregnancies include one fetus established from a transgenic nucleus from a fetal skin cell, and another one resulting from a skin biopsy performed on a female calf. Our data demonstrate that nuclei from cultured bovine somatic cells obtained from differentiated tissues can be made multipotent.

Cloning in cattle: from embryo splitting to somatic nuclear transfer.

The ability to obtain genetically identical offspring in cattle (clones) is useful for research and for potential applications to breeding schemes. Experimental possibilities for generating such animals have evolved considerably in the last two decades. Embryo splitting has become a relatively simple technique but is limited to twinning. Embryonic nuclear transfer has improved and is associated with sexing to generate sets of clones despite a great variability of results between parent embryos. The factors of progress are reviewed here. Recently, somatic cells used as a source of nuclei in bovine nuclear transfer has been demonstrated. Here we present the results of the developmental potential of nuclei from skin and muscle cells.