Targeted blood-to-brain drug delivery --10 key development criteria.

Drug delivery to the brain remains challenging due to the presence of the blood-brain barrier. In this review, 10 key development criteria are presented that are important for successful drug development to treat CNS diseases by targeted drug delivery systems. Although several routes of delivery are being investigated, such as intranasal delivery, direct injections into the brain or CSF, and transient opening of the blood-brain barrier, the focus of this review is on physiological strategies aiming to target endogenous transport mechanisms. Examples from literature, focusing on targeted drug delivery systems that are being commercially developed, will be discussed to illustrate the 10 key development criteria. The first four criteria apply to the targeting of the blood-brain barrier: (1) a proven inherently safe receptor biology, (2) a safe and human applicable ligand, (3) receptor specific binding, and (4) applicable for acute and chronic indications. Next to an efficient and safe targeting strategy, as captured in key criteria 1 to 4, a favorable pharmacokinetic profile is also important (key criterion 5). With regard to the drug carriers, two criteria are important: (6) no modification of active ingredient and (7) able to carry various classes of molecules. The final three criteria apply to the development of a drug from lab to clinic: (8) low costs and straightforward manufacturing, (9) activity in all animal models, and (10) strong intellectual property (IP) protection. Adhering to these 10 key development criteria will allow for a successful brain drug development.

Targeted delivery across the blood-brain barrier.

The safest and most effective way of targeting drugs to the entire brain is via delivery systems directed at endogenous receptor-mediated uptake mechanisms present at the cerebral capillaries. Such systems have been shown to be effective in animal models including primates, but no clinical trials have been performed so far. This review focuses on the well-characterised transferrin and insulin receptor-targeted systems, as well as on the more recently described systems that use the low-density lipoprotein-related protein 1 receptor, the low-density lipoprotein-related protein 2 receptor (also known as megalin and glycoprotein 330) or the diphtheria toxin receptor (which is the membrane-bound precursor of heparin-binding epidermal growth factor-like growth factor). The possibilities and limitations of these systems are compared and their future for human application is discussed.

Targeting liposomes with protein drugs to the blood-brain barrier in vitro.

In this study, we aim to target pegylated liposomes loaded with horseradish peroxidase (HRP) and tagged with transferrin (Tf) to the BBB in vitro. Liposomes were prepared with the post-insertion technique: micelles of polyethylene glycol (PEG) and PEG-Tf were inserted into pre-formed liposomes containing HRP. Tf was measured indirectly by measuring iron via atomic absorption spectroscopy. All liposomes were around 100 nm in diameter, contained 5-13 microg HRP per mumol phospholipid and 63-74 Tf molecules per liposome (lipo Tf) or no Tf (lipo C). Brain capillary endothelial cells (BCEC) were incubated with liposomes at 4 degrees C (to determine binding) or at 37 degrees C (to determine association, i.e. binding+endocytosis) and the HRP activity, rather than the HRP amount was determined in cell lysates. Association of lipo Tf was two- to three-fold higher than association of lipo C. Surprisingly, the binding of lipo Tf at 4 degrees C was four-fold higher than the association of at 37 degrees C. Most likely this high binding and low endocytosis is explained by intracellular degradation of endocytosed HRP. In conclusion, we have shown targeting of liposomes loaded with protein or peptide drugs to the BCEC and more specifically to the lysosomes. This is an advantage for the treatment of lysosomal storage disease. However, drug targeting to other intracellular targets also results in intracellular degradation of the drug. Our experiments suggest that liposomes release some of their content within the BBB, making targeting of liposomes to the TfR on BCEC an attractive approach for brain drug delivery.

Coupling of metal containing homing devices to liposomes via a maleimide linker: use of TCEP to stabilize thiol-groups without scavenging metals.

Liposomes for drug delivery are often prepared with maleimide groups on the distal end of PEG to enable coupling of homing devices, such as antibodies, or other proteins. EDTA is used to stabilize the thiol group in the homing device for attachment to the maleimide. However, when using a homing device that contains a metal, EDTA inactivates this by scavenging of the metal. Holo-transferrin (Tf) containing two iron atoms (Fe(3+)), has a much higher affinity for the Tf receptor than apo-Tf (which does not contain any Fe(3+)). To couple Tf to a liposome, the introduction of a thiol group is necessary. During this process, by using N-succinimidyl S-acetylthioacetate (SATA), followed by 2-3 h coupling to the liposomes, Fe(3+) is scavenged by EDTA. This causes a decreased affinity of Tf for its receptor, resulting in a decreased targeting efficiency of the liposomes. Tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP) hydrochloride is a sulfhydryl reductant that is often used in protein biochemistry. We found that TCEP (0.01 mM) does not scavenge Fe(3+) from Tf and is able to protect thiol groups for the coupling to maleimide. Furthermore, TCEP does not interfere with the maleimide coupling itself. In this communication, we describe the preparation of liposomes, focussing on the coupling of Tf to the maleimide linker at the distal end of PEG, without loosing Fe(3+) from Tf. This method can be applied to other metal-containing homing devices as well.

Validation of the transferrin receptor for drug targeting to brain capillary endothelial cells in vitro.

Recently, we have shown that transferrin (Tf) is actively endocytosed by the Tf R on primary cultured bovine brain capillary endothelial cells (BCEC). The objective of this investigation is to determine whether the Tf R can facilitate endocytosis of a (protein) model drug, using Tf as a targeting vector. Secondly, the mechanism of endocytosis was investigated. Horseradish peroxidase (HRP, 40 kDa) was chosen as a model drug, since it normally does not cross the blood-brain barrier (BBB) and its concentration in biological media can be easily quantified. Tf-HRP conjugates (1:1) are actively and specifically endocytosed by BCEC in vitro in a concentration and time-dependent manner. At an applied concentration of 3 microg/ml, association (a combination of binding and endocytosis) of Tf-HRP reached equilibrium at a concentration of 2 ng/mg cell protein after 1 h of incubation at 37 degree C. This was approximately 3-fold higher compared to binding at 4 degree C (0.6 ng/mg cell protein). Association of Tf-HRP was compared to BSA-HRP. After 2 h of incubation at 37 degree C association levels were 5.2 and 2.5 ng/mg cell protein, for Tf-HRP and BSA-HRP, respectively. Under those conditions, association of Tf-HRP could be inhibited to approximately 30% of total association by an excess of non-conjugated Tf, but not with BSA, while association of BSA-HRP could be inhibited by both proteins. Furthermore, by using specific inhibitors of endocytotic processes, it was shown that association of Tf-HRP is via clathrin-coated vesicles. Association of Tf-HRP is inhibited by phenylarsine oxide (an inhibitor of clathrin-mediated endocytosis) to 0.4 ng/mg cell protein, but not by indomethacin, which inhibits formation of caveolae. Finally, following iron scavenging by deferoxamine mesylate (DFO, resulting in a higher Tf R expression) a 5-fold increase in association of Tf-HRP to 15.8 ng/mg cell protein was observed. In conclusion, the Tf R is potentially suitable for targeting of a (protein) cargo to the BBB and to facilitate its endocytosis by the BCEC.

Characterization and modulation of the transferrin receptor on brain capillary endothelial cells.

PURPOSE: The expression level of the transferrin receptor (TfR) on brain capillary endothelial cells (BCECs) and the endocytosis of 125I-transferrin (125I-Tf) by this receptor was investigated. Furthermore, the influence of iron, the iron scavenger deferoxamine mesylate (DFO), astrocytic factors, a GTP-ase inhibitor (tyrphostin-A8, T8), lipopolysaccharide (LPS), and the radical scavenger N-acetyl-L-cysteine (NAC) on the TfR expression was studied to gain insight in the use and optimization of the TfR for drug targeting to the brain. METHODS: Experiments were performed with primary cultured bovine BCECs that were incubated with 125I-Tf at 4 degrees C (to determine binding) or at 37 degrees C (to determine endocytosis) in the absence or presence of the modulators. For full saturation curves in the absence or presence of iron or DFO, analysis was performed with a population approach using NONMEM, allowing us to estimate a single value for affinity (Kd, concentration of 50% receptor occupancy) and separate values for maximum receptor occupancy (B(max). RESULTS: On BCECs, the TfR is expressed extracellularly (B(max) of 0.13 fmol/microg cell protein), but also has a large intracellular pool (total B(max) of 1.37 fmol/microg cell protein), and is actively endocytosing Tf via clathrin-coated vesicles. At 4 degrees C, a Kd of 2.38 microg/ml was found, whereas the Kd at 37 degrees C was 5.03 microg/ml. Furthermore, DFO is able to increase both the extracellular as well as the total binding capacity to 0.63 and 3.67 fmol/microg cell protein, respectively, whereas it had no influence on Kd. B(max) at 37 degrees C after DFO preincubation was also increased from 0.90 to 2.31 fmol/microg cell protein. Other modulators had no significant influence on the TfR expression levels, though LPS increased cellular protein concentrations after 2-h preincubation. CONCLUSIONS: The TfR is expressed on BCECs and actively endocytoses Tf, making it a suitable target for drug delivery to the bloodbrain barrier and the CNS. DFO up-regulates the TfR expression level, which may influence targeting efficiency.