Response of thoracolumbar vertebral bodies to high rate compressive loading - biomed 2013.

Underbody blast (UBB) events created by improvised explosive devices are threats to warfighter survivability. High intensity blast waves emitted from these devices transfer large forces through vehicle structures to occupants, often resulting in injuries including debilitating spinal fractures. The vertical loading vector through the spine generates significant compressive forces at high strain rates. To better understand injury mechanisms and ultimately better protect vehicle occupants against UBB attacks, high-fidelity computational models are being developed to predict the human response to dynamic loading characteristic of these events. This effort details the results from a series of 23 high-rate compression tests on vertebral body specimen. A high-rate servo-hydraulic test system applied a range of compressive loading rates (.01 mm/s to 1238 mm/s) to vertebral bodies in the thoracolumbar region (T7-L5). The force-deflection curves generated indicate rate dependent sensitivity of vertebral stiffness, ultimate load and ultimate deflection. Specimen subjected to high-rate dynamic loading to failure experienced critical structural damage at 5.5% ± 2.1% deflection. Compared to quasi-static loading, vertebral bodies had greater stiffness, greater force to failure, and lower ultimate failure deflection at high rates. Post-failure, an average loss in height of 15% was observed, along with a mean reduction in strength of 48%. The resulting data from these tests will allow for enhanced biofidelity of computational models by characterizing the vertebral stiffness response and ultimate deflection at rates representative of UBB events.

Evaluation of cervical laminectomy and laminoplasty. A longitudinal study in the goat model.

STUDY DESIGN: An evaluation of the longitudinal radiologic changes up to 6 months induced by multilevel laminectomy and laminoplasty and the biomechanical responses in the goat model, complemented by biomechanical studies of intact specimens. OBJECTIVES: To determine the long-term radiographic differences and biomechanical responses of laminectomy and laminoplasty in an in vivo animal model. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Previous clinical and laboratory studies have indicated that multilevel laminectomy can cause increased flexibility in the cervical spinal column. Although the potential for laminoplasty to resolve these changes has been suggested, other evaluations have not supported this contention. Clarification of this controversy with long-term in vivo studies has not been performed. METHODS: Ten adult goats were divided into two groups, one undergoing C3-C5 laminectomy and the other open-door laminoplasty. Lateral cervical spine radiographs were obtained at 4-week intervals for a 6-month period. After the goats were killed, biomechanical testing was performed using pure moment loading on the surgically treated specimens and on three intact (without surgery) cervical spinal columns. RESULTS: In the laminectomy preparations, the cervical curvature index was noted to decrease by 59% at 16 weeks (P < 0.028) and by 70% at 24 weeks (P < 0.002), whereas the decrease in laminoplasty was not significantly different. Biomechanical testing indicated a significantly increased sagittal-plane slack motion in the laminectomy group (55 degrees) compared with that in intact specimens (39 degrees), but no significant difference between the laminoplasty and intact groups with respect to this motion. Laminectomy was found to be significantly stiffer (36%) in flexion than in extension, whereas the contrary was true for laminoplasty (37%). CONCLUSIONS: Radiographic and biomechanical results in the goat model suggest that laminoplasty is superior to laminectomy in maintaining cervical alignment and preventing postoperative spinal deformities.

Static and dynamic bending responses of the human cervical spine.

The quasi-static and dynamic bending responses of the human mid-lower cervical spine were determined using cadaver intervertebral joints fixed at the base to a six-axis load cell. Flexion bending moment was applied to the superior end of the specimen using an electrohydraulic piston. Each specimen was tested under three cycles of quasi-static load-unload and one high-speed dynamic load. A total of five specimens were included in this study. The maximum intervertebral rotation ranged from 11.0 to 15.4 deg for quasi-static tests and from 22.9 to 34.4 deg for dynamic tests. The resulting peak moments at the center of the intervertebral joint ranged from 3.8 to 6.9 Nm for quasi-static tests and from 14.0 to 31.8 Nm for dynamic tests. The quasi-static stiffness ranged from 0.80 to 1.35 Nm/deg with a mean of 1.03 Nm/deg (+/- 0.11 Nm/deg). The dynamic stiffness ranged from 1.08 to 2.00 Nm/deg with a mean of 1.50 Nm/deg (+/- 0.17 Nm/deg). The differences between the two stiffnesses were statistically significant (p < 0.01). Exponential functions were derived to describe the quasi-static and dynamic moment-rotation responses. These results provide input data for lumped-parameter models and validation data for finite element models to better investigate the biomechanics of the human cervical spine.

Finite element analysis of cervical facetectomy.

STUDY DESIGN: Moment-rotation responses and disc anulus stresses of intact and facetectomized C4-C6 cervical spinal units were analyzed using detailed, three-dimensional, finite element models. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate biomechanical effects of progressive unilateral and bilateral facet resections on cervical spine segmental mobility (external response) and disc anulus stress (internal response). SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Experimental studies have demonstrated that facetectomy significantly increases segmental mobility of the cervical spine. The biomechanical effects of facetectomy on the internal response, however, have not been investigated. METHODS: Moment-rotation responses of C4 with respect to C6 and von Mises stress in the disc anulus were examined using finite element models of a 0% (intact), 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100% unilaterally and bilaterally facetectomized cervical spinal unit. The model simulations were conducted under the pure-moment loading of 1.8 Nm in flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial torsion. The intact model also was validated experimentally under the same conditions. RESULTS: The moment-rotation responses of the intact unit were within the ranges of experimental data. Cervical rotations increased with the increased degree of facet resection. The greatest change occurred between 50% and 75% facet resections in bilateral facetectomy. Similar patterns were found for disc anulus stresses, but to a greater extent. The maximum increase in rotation (11%) and in anulus stress (30%) occurred in lateral bending. Torsion was the least affected loading mode. The effects of unilateral facetectomy were considerably less than those of 75% bilateral facetectomy. CONCLUSIONS: Facetectomy has a greater effect on anulus stress than on intervertebral joint stiffness. Significant increase in anulus stresses and segmental mobility may occur when bilateral facet resection exceeds 50%.

Finite element modeling of cervical laminectomy with graded facetectomy.

In this study, an anatomically accurate three-dimensional finite element model of the human lower cervical spine (C4-C6) was used to study the biomechanical effects of cervical laminectomy with and without graded facetectomy. The intact finite element model was validated under flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial torsion load vectors of 1.8 Nm magnitude. The moment rotation response of the finite element model matched well with experimental data. The gross external (angular motion) and the internal (superior and inferior intervertebral disc stress) responses were delineated under the four physiological loading modes for these iatrogenic changes. Results indicated that laminectomy markedly altered the cervical angular motion and the disc stress under flexion compared with all other loading modes. Facetectomy increased the angular motion and the inferior disc stress notably under flexion but did not affect the adjacent superior disc stress. Facet resection of > 50% caused pronounced increases in angular rotation and intervertebral disc stresses. These findings suggest that the resection of more than one-half of this structure may require additional procedures to restore the strength of the cervical column. Although gross external motion response can be obtained by experimental studies, the internal stress response can only be determined using mathematical models such as the finite element model used in the present study. The accentuated changes in the disc stress compared with the changes in the external rotation may be clinically relevant because increased internal load/stress can result in disc degeneration. The present three-dimensional finite element model offers additional information to better understand the extrinsic and intrinsic responses of the iatrogenically altered cervical spine.

Response of the ligamentous lumbar spine to cyclic bending loads.

The effect of a "pure" cyclic flexion bending moment on the three-dimensional load-displacement behavior of fresh ligamentous lumbar spine was investigated. The load-displacement behavior, for 11 L1-sacrum specimens, pre- and post-cyclic fatigue bending tests were quantified using a Selspot II system. A special fixture was designed to mount the specimen within the MTS system to administer "pure" cyclic flexion bending, under displacement control, for 5 hours. The testing was accomplished in a 100% humidity chamber at 0.5 Hz. The maximum cyclic bending moment, based on the literature dealing with loads experienced by the spine during activities involving lifting, was set at 3.0 Nm. An increase in motion of the order of 10% in the extension loading mode was observed. The increase in motion in other loading modes was not significant. In the extension loading mode, the increase in the anteroposterior displacement (retrodisplacement) in general was higher than the corresponding rotation component. The results suggest that the bending moment of low magnitude, usually experienced by the spine during activities of daily living, alone may not trigger the mechanical failure processes in the disc. The presence of high axial compressive loads on the disc seems to be the main contributing factor in this process. The presence of bending moments and axial twist along with axial compressive load may accelerate the unstable processes leading to low back pain.