ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Significant changes in medical education have occurred in recent decades because of new challenges in the health sector and new learning theories and practices. This might have contributed to the decision of medical schools throughout the world to adopt community-based learning activities. The community-based learning approach has been promoted and supported by the World Health Organization and has emerged as an efficient learning strategy. The aim of the present paper is to describe the characteristics of a community immersion clerkship for third-year undergraduate medical students, its evolution over 15 years, and an evaluation of its outcomes. METHODS: A review of the literature and consensus meetings with a multidisciplinary group of health professionals were used to define learning objectives and an educational approach when developing the program. Evaluation of the program addressed students' perception, achievement of learning objectives, interactions between students and the community, and educational innovations over the years. RESULTS: The program and the main learning objectives were defined by consensus meetings among teaching staff and community health workers, which strengthened the community immersion clerkship. Satisfaction, as monitored by a self-administered questionnaire in successive cohorts of students, showed a mean of 4.4 on a five-point scale. Students also mentioned community immersion clerkship as a unique community experience. The learning objectives were reached by a vast majority of students. Behavior evaluation was not assessed per se, but specific testimonies show that students have been marked by their community experience. The evaluation also assessed outcomes such as educational innovations (eg, students teaching other students), new developments in the curriculum (eg, partnership with the University of Applied Health Sciences), and interaction between students and the community (eg, student development of a website for a community health institution). CONCLUSION: The community immersion clerkship trains future doctors to respond to the health problems of individuals in their complexity, and strengthens their ability to work with the community.
ABSTRACT
PURPOSE: advances in the assessment of clinical competence have prompted medical schools and licensing authorities to complement written and oral tests with practical ones. The purposes of this project were to (1) determine how clinical competencies not effectively addressed on the present Swiss federal examinations can be assessed adequately on a standardised patient-based practical examination (SCE) and (2) evaluate the SCE validity, reliability and feasibility. METHOD: a bilingual, three-hour standardised patient-based clinical examination was pilot tested in 2003 with 48 volunteered fifth and sixth-year students from the five Swiss medical schools. All students took the same eight 15-minute patient cases. To ensure the test content validity, test cases were selected by a multi-disciplinary and -institutional committee of clinical faculty on the basis of predefined exam blueprint criteria and in reference to the Swiss catalogue of learning objectives. RESULTS: moderate correlations between the SCE and the existing Federal final written examinations (0.46) and the newly pilot-tested structured oral examination or SOE (0.56) [3] suggested that they were complementary to one another and that each might emphasise aspects of the clinical competence which others might not. The reliability (a coefficient) of the SCE scores ranged from 0.73 to 0.77. CONCLUSIONS: limited experiences gathered throughout the SCE pilot project demonstrated its feasibility. Preliminary results suggested that SCE scores had a good level of construct validity and reliability and seemed to complement scores obtained on the final certification written examinations and the newly tested SOE. These results, however, need to be further confirmed with larger samples studies.
