Novel methods to monitor antigen-specific cytotoxic T-cell responses in cancer immunotherapy.

Monitoring cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses to tumor antigens that have been defined at the molecular level has become essential to assess novel approaches to the specific immunotherapy of cancer. Nevertheless, because of the low affinity of the interactions between T-cell receptors and their ligands, there are no straightforward, well-standardized methods to meet this need. In this review, we describe several novel methods to track antigen-specific CTL responses.

Immunization of BALB/c mice with Helicobacter urease B induces a T helper 2 response absent in Helicobacter infection.

BACKGROUND & AIMS: Infection with Helicobacter induces a T helper type 1 response in mice and humans. Mice can be cured or protected from infection with Helicobacter by mucosal immunization with recombinant H. pylori urease B subunit (rUreB). This study characterizes the immune response of infected mice immunized with rUreB. METHODS: BALB/c mice were infected with H. felis. Two weeks later, they were orally immunized four times with rUreB and cholera toxin (CT) at weekly intervals. Controls were only infected or sham-immunized with CT. Animals were killed at various times after immunization. Splenic CD4(+) cells were obtained and cultured in vitro with rUreB to evaluate antigen-specific proliferation and induction of interferon gamma and interleukin 4 secretion. RESULTS: All rUreB-immunized mice (n = 8) were cured from infection 3 weeks after the fourth immunization. Immunization induced a proliferative response of splenic CD4(+) cells, a progressive decrease in interferon gamma secretion, and a concomitant increase in interleukin 4 secretion after each immunization. A simultaneous increase in rUreB specific serum immunoglobulin G1 levels was observed in infected/immunized mice. CONCLUSIONS: In BALB/c mice, therapeutic mucosal immunization with rUreB induces progressively a Th2 CD4(+) T cell response resulting in the elimination of the pathogen.

Melanoma-reactive human cytotoxic T lymphocytes derived from skin biopsies of delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions induced by injection of an autologous melanoma cell line.

The expression by melanomas of multiple antigens that are recognized by specific MHC class I-restricted CTLs has been clearly demonstrated. The goal of many immunotherapy protocols being developed is, therefore, the induction and/or augmentation of CTLs specific for such antigens. One approach has been to immunize using irradiated autologous melanoma cells. Responses to this type of immunization and others are often subsequently measured by delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reactions. The aim of this work was to characterize whether specific CTL responses occur at such DTH sites. Cutaneous DTH reactions were observed following injection of irradiated autologous melanoma cells expressing known tumor antigens. We isolated lymphocytes from biopsies of DTH reaction sites and could measure melanoma-specific CTL activity after 2-3 weeks of culture. The T-cell receptor-Vbeta repertoire of the cultured lymphocytes, assessed by flow cytometry, was highly skewed in both the CD4(+) and CD8(+) T-cell subsets. The repertoires were different among cultures derived from independent biopsies of simultaneous or subsequent DTH reaction sites and very different to that of fresh peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) or PBLs cultured under the same conditions. No particular T-cell expansions dominated several DTH reaction sites, nor could they be detected in PBLs. It appears that T-cell responses to this type of immunization may be limited to the local microenvironment. Establishing the value of DTH reactions in determining levels of systemic antitumor immunity requires further investigation; however, such reactions may indicate a patient's competence to mount an antitumor immune response and enable the isolation of tumor-specific CTLs for use in tumor antigen identification.

Quantitation of endogenous mouse mammary tumor virus superantigen expression by lymphocyte subsets.

Superantigens (SAg) encoded by endogenous mouse mammary tumor viruses (Mtv) interact with the V beta domain of the T cell receptor (TcR-V beta). Presentation of Mtv SAg can lead to stimulation and/or deletion of the reactive T cells, but little is known about the quantitative aspects of SAg presentation. Although monoclonal antibodies have been raised against Mtv SAg, they have not been useful in quantitating SAg protein, which is present in very low amounts in normal cells. Alternative attempts to quantitate Mtv SAg mRNA expression are complicated by the fact that Mtv transcription occurs from multiple loci and in different overlapping reading frames. In this report we describe a novel competitive polymerase chain reaction assay which allows the locus-specific quantitation of SAg expression at the mRNA level in lymphocyte subsets from mouse strains with multiple endogenous Mtv loci. In B cells as well as T cells (CD4+ or CD8+), Mtv-6 SAg is expressed at the highest levels, followed by Mtv-7 SAg and (to a much lesser extent) Mtv-8,9. Consistent with functional Mtv-7 SAg presentation studies, we find that Mtv-7 SAg expression is higher in B cells than in CD8+ T cells and very low in the CD4+ subset. The overall hierarchy in Mtv SAg expression (i.e. Mtv-6 > Mtv-7 > Mtv 8,9) was also observed for mRNA isolated from neonatal thymus. Furthermore, the kinetics of intrathymic deletion of the corresponding TcR-V beta domains during ontogeny correlated with the levels of Mtv SAg expression. Collectively our data suggest that T cell responses to Mtv SAg are largely controlled by SAg expression levels on presenting cells.

Expansion of gamma delta+ T cells in BALB/c mice infected with Leishmania major is dependent upon Th2-type CD4+ T cells.

T cells belong to either the alpha beta+ or gamma delta+ lineage as defined by their antigen receptor. Although both T-cell subsets have been shown to be involved in the immune response to the parasite Leishmania major, very little is known about possible interactions between these two populations. In this study, using a mouse model of infection with L. major, we showed that expansion of a subset of gamma delta+ T cells in vivo is dependent upon the presence of alpha beta+ CD4+ T cells. Moreover, this effect appears to be mediated via the secretion of lymphokines by CD4+ cells with a T-helper 2 (Th2) functional phenotype. Results showing that activation of Th2-type cells in mice treated with anti-immunoglobulin D antibodies or infected with Nippostrongylus brasiliensis also results in gamma delta+ T-cell expansion suggest that this effect of the Th2-type CD4+ cells is a general phenomenon not restricted to infection with L. major.

Mouse interleukin-2 receptor alpha gene expression. Delimitation of cis-acting regulatory elements in transgenic mice and by mapping of DNase-I hypersensitive sites.

The alpha chain of the interleukin-2 receptor (IL-2R alpha) is a key regulator of lymphocyte proliferation. To analyze the mechanisms controlling its expression in normal cells, we used the 5'-flanking region (base pairs -2539/+93) of the mouse gene to drive chloramphenicol acetyltransferase expression in four transgenic mouse lines. Constitutive transgene activity was restricted to lymphoid organs. In mature T lymphocytes, transgene and endogenous IL-2R alpha gene expression was stimulated by concanavalin A and up-regulated by IL-2 with very similar kinetics. In thymic T cell precursors, IL-1 and IL-2 cooperatively induced transgene and IL-2R alpha gene expression. These results show that regulation of the endogenous IL-2R alpha gene occurs mainly at the transcriptional level. They demonstrate that cis-acting elements in the 5'-flanking region present in the transgene confer correct tissue specificity and inducible expression in mature T cells and their precursors in response to antigen, IL-1, and IL-2. In a complementary approach, we screened the 5' end of the endogenous IL-2R alpha gene for DNase-I hypersensitive sites. We found three lymphocyte specific DNase-I hypersensitive sites. Two, at -0.05 and -5.3 kilobase pairs, are present in resting T cells. A third site appears at -1.35 kilobase pairs in activated T cells. It co-localizes with IL-2-responsive elements identified by transient transfection experiments.

Reverse transcriptase-dependent and -independent phases of infection with mouse mammary tumor virus: implications for superantigen function.

Mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) encodes a superantigen (SAg) that promotes stable infection and virus transmission. Upon subcutaneous MMTV injection, infected B cells present SAg to SAg-reactive T cells leading to a strong local immune response in the draining lymph node (LN) that peaks after 6 d. We have used the reverse transcriptase inhibitor 3'-azido-3'-deoxythymidine (AZT) to dissect in more detail the mechanism of SAg-dependent enhancement of MMTV infection in this system. Our data show that no detectable B or T cell response to SAg occurs in AZT pretreated mice. However, if AZT treatment is delayed 1-2 d after MMTV injection, a normal SAg-dependent local immune response is observed on day 6. Quantitation of viral DNA in draining LN of these infected mice indicates that a 4,000-fold increase in the absolute numbers of infected cells occurs between days 2 and 6 despite the presence of AZT. Furthermore MMTV DNA was found preferentially in surface IgG+ B cells of infected mice and was not detectable in SAg-reactive T cells. Collectively our data suggest that MMTV infection occurs preferentially in B cells without SAg involvement and is completed 1-2 d after virus challenge. Subsequent amplification of MMTV infection between days 2 and 6 requires SAg expression and occurs in the absence of any further requirement for reverse transcription. We therefore conclude that clonal expansion of infected B cells via cognate interaction with SAg-reactive T cells is the predominant mechanism for increasing the level of MMTV infection. Since infected B cells display a memory (surface IgG+) phenotype, both clonal expansion and possibly longevity of the virus carrier cells may contribute to stable MMTV infection.

MHC class II hierarchy of superantigen presentation predicts efficiency of infection with mouse mammary tumor virus.

Superantigens (SAgs) encoded by infectious mouse mammary tumor viruses (MMTVs) play a crucial role in the viral life cycle. Their expression by infected B cells induces a proliferative immune response by SAg-reactive T cells which amplifies MMTV infection. This response most likely ensures stable MMTV infection and transmission to the mammary gland. Since T cell reactivity to SAgs from endogenous Mtv loci depends on MHC class II molecules expressed by B cells, we have determined the ability of MMTV to infect various MHC congenic mice. We show that MHC class II I-E+ compared with I-E- mouse strains show higher levels of MMTV infection, most likely due to their ability to induce a vigorous SAg-dependent immune response following MMTV encounter. Inefficient infection is observed in MHC class II I-E- mice, which have been shown to present endogenous SAgs poorly. Therefore, during MMTV infection the differential ability of MHC class II molecules to form a functional complex with SAg determines the magnitude of the proliferative response of SAg-reactive T cells. This in turn influences the degree of T cell help provided to infected B cells and therefore the efficiency of amplification of MMTV infection.

Superantigens and retroviral infection: insights from mouse mammary tumor virus.

Superantigens induce a vigorous immune response by stimulating T cells that express particular T-cell receptor V beta chains. Mouse mammary tumor virus is a milk-transmitted retrovirus that encodes such a superantigen. Paradoxically, as discussed by Werner Held and colleagues, the strong superantigen-induced immune response permits the survival of the virus via T-cell dependent clonal expansion of infected B cells.

Selective expansion of activated V delta 4+ cells during experimental infection of mice with Leishmania major.

Previous work from this laboratory has revealed that infection of mice with Leishmania major leads to an expansion of gamma delta+ T cells in the spleen. Further examination of the gamma delta+ T cells expanding in infected mice has shown that the majority of these cells in the spleen, lymph nodes, blood and liver expressed the V delta 4 gene segment. Cell cycle analysis, using propidium iodide incorporation, demonstrated that while only 1% of alpha beta+ T cells in the spleen were in either S + G2/M phase, up to 10% of the gamma delta+ T cells were in cycling phase 8 weeks after infection. Comparison of the state of activation of the two populations in different organs after infection, confirmed that gamma delta+ T cells are actively dividing in lymph nodes, liver and blood, but not in the thymus or among intraepithelial lymphocytes. Examination of the expression of different activation markers on the surface of gamma delta+ T cells in the spleen of both normal and chronically infected BALB/c mice by FACS analysis, revealed increased expression of LFA-1, CD25, CD44, 4F2, CD28 and the heat-stable antigen, whereas Thy-1 and CD5 decreased. Collectively, these results suggest an oligoclonal expansion and activation of gamma delta+ T cells in response to L. major infection.

A lymphostromal molecule, thymic shared Ag-1, regulates early thymocyte development in fetal thymus organ culture.

Previously, we detailed the characterization of thymic shared Ag-1, a unique marker of immature thymocytes and isolated thymic stromal cells, defined by the mAb MTS 35. In this study, the functional relevance of this molecule to thymopoiesis was investigated by the addition of purified MTS 35 to fetal thymus organ culture. It down-regulated thymic shared Ag-1 expression and dramatically reduced thymocyte cell yield through inhibition of alpha beta-TcR+ T cell differentiation, post CD3-CD4-CD8- triple negative thymocytes. These effects were specific for the mAb MTS 35, because controls, which include both isotype-matched and other lymphostromal mAb, showed no similar effects. These results demonstrate that thymic shared Ag-1 is a functionally important marker of early thymocyte differentiation, particularly with regard to the alpha beta-TcR lineage.

Superantigen-induced immune stimulation amplifies mouse mammary tumor virus infection and allows virus transmission.

Endogenous and infectious mouse mammary tumor viruses (MMTVs) encode in their 3' long terminal repeat a protein that exerts superantigen activity; that is, it is able to interact with T cells via the variable domain of the T cell receptor (TCR) beta chain. We show here that transmission of an infectious MMTV is prevented when superantigen-reactive cells are absent through either clonal deletion due to the expression of an endogenous MTV with identical superantigen specificity or exclusion due to expression of a transgenic TCR beta chain that does not interact with the viral superantigen. A strict requirement for superantigen-reactive T cells is also seen for a local immune response following MMTV infection. This immune response locally amplifies the number of MMTV-infected B cells, most likely owing to their clonal expansion. Collectively, our data indicate that a superantigen-induced immune response is critical for the MMTV life cycle.

Peripheral T cell activation and deletion induced by transfer of lymphocyte subsets expressing endogenous or exogenous mouse mammary tumor virus.

Murine T cell reactivity with products of the minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls) locus correlates with the expression of particular variable (V) domains of the T cell receptor (TCR) beta chain. It was recently demonstrated that Mls antigens are encoded by an open reading frame (ORF) in the 3' long terminal repeat of either endogenous or exogenous mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV). Immature thymocytes expressing reactive TCR-V beta domains are clonally deleted upon exposure to endogenous Mtv's. Mature T cells proliferate vigorously in response to Mls-1a (Mtv-7) in vivo, but induction of specific anergy and deletion after exposure to Mtv-7-expressing cells in the periphery has also been described. We show here that B cells and CD8+ (but not CD4+) T cells from Mtv-7+ mice efficiently induce peripheral deletion of reactive T cells upon transfer to Mtv-7- recipients, whereas only B cells stimulate specific T cell proliferation in vivo. In contrast to endogenous Mtv-7, transfer of B, CD4+, or CD8+ lymphocyte subsets from mice maternally infected with MMTV(SW), an infectious homologue of Mtv-7, results in specific T cell deletion in the absence of a detectable proliferative response. Finally, we show by secondary transfers of infected cells that exogenous MMTV(SW) is transmitted multidirectionally between lymphocyte subsets and ultimately to the mammary gland. Collectively our data demonstrate heterogeneity in the expression and/or presentation of endogenous and exogenous MMTV ORF by lymphocyte subsets and emphasize the low threshold required for induction of peripheral T cell deletion by these gene products.

Superantigen-reactive CD4+ T cells are required to stimulate B cells after infection with mouse mammary tumor virus.

Superantigens are defined by their ability to stimulate a large fraction of T cells via interaction with the T cell receptor (TCR) V beta domain. Endogenous superantigens, classically termed minor lymphocyte-stimulating (Mls) antigens, were recently identified as products of open reading frames (ORF) in integrated proviral copies of mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV). We have described an infectious MMTV homologue of the classical endogenous superantigen Mls-1a (Mtv-7). The ORF molecules of both the endogenous Mtv-7 and the infectious MMTV(SW) interact with T cells expressing the TCR V beta 6, 7, 8.1, and 9 domains. Furthermore, the COOH termini of their ORF molecules, thought to confer TCR specificity, are very similar. Since successful transport of MMTV from the site of infection in the gut to the mammary gland depends on a functional immune system, we were interested in determining the early events after and requirements for MMTV infection. We show that MMTV(SW) infection induces a massive response of V beta 6+ CDC4+ T cells, which interact with the viral ORF. Concomitantly, we observed a B cell response and differentiation that depends on both the presence and stimulation of the superantigen-reactive T cells. Furthermore, we show that B cells are the main target of the initial MMTV infection as judged by the presence of the reverse-transcribed viral genome and ORF transcripts. Thus, we suggest that MMTV infection of B cells leads to ORF-mediated B-T cell interaction, which maintains and possibly amplifies viral infection.

Skewed T cell receptor V alpha repertoire among superantigen reactive murine T cells.

Reactivity of murine T cells with viral or bacterial superantigens is clearly correlated with the expression of TCR V beta domains. Thus, T cells responding to the minor lymphocyte stimulatory locus (Mls-1a) or staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB) express predominantly TCR V beta 6 or V beta 8.2 respectively. We have investigated the involvement of the other major variable element of the TCR, the V alpha domain, in these superantigen responses. Using a panel of anti-TCR V alpha mAbs, it is demonstrated that the TCR V alpha repertoire among superantigen stimulated V beta 6+ or V beta 8.2+ blasts (responding to Mls-1a or SEB respectively in vitro) is altered in comparison with anti-CD3 stimulated cells expressing the same V beta domains. Furthermore, the TCR V alpha repertoire is strongly skewed in TCR V beta 8.2 transgenic mice that have undergone extensive peripheral clonal deletion after SEB injection. These data imply that the V alpha domain influences superantigen recognition by the TCR.

The viral superantigen Mls-1a induces interferon-gamma secretion by specifically primed CD8+ cells but fails to trigger cytotoxicity.

Superantigens can be operationally defined by their ability to stimulate CD4+ and CD8+ T cells via the T cell receptor beta chain variable domain (TcR V beta). We show here that effector functions of CD8+ T cells specific for superantigens differ depending upon the nature of the superantigen involved. Hence, activated CD8+ T cells bearing TcR V beta specific for the superantigen Mls-1a [encoded in the open reading frame of the 3' long terminal repeat of endogenous mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV)] are unable to lyse Mls-1a-bearing target cells despite the fact that they release interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) upon Mls-1a stimulation. In contrast CD8+ T cells specific for the exogenous superantigen staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB) readily mediate both lysis and IFN-gamma secretion when exposed to SEB-bearing target cells. This dissociation between lysis and IFN-gamma production by Mls-1a-specific CD8+ T cells is independent of the initial stimulus used for activation and appears not to be simply explained by a low Mls-1a determinant density. We suggest that this phenomenon reflects differing TcR affinity thresholds for lymphokine secretion and cytolysis. Such differences may be exploited by retroviruses such as MMTV in order to escape immunosurveillance.

Treatment of fetal thymic organ culture with IL-1 leads to accelerated differentiation of subsets of CD4-CD8- cells.

Using fetal thymic organ culture (FTOC), we describe the effects of IL-1 on T cell differentiation, particularly within the CD4-CD8- subset. While treatment of FTOC with IL-1 led to a modest reduction in total thymocyte yield, it induced an increase in the percentage of CD4-CD8- cells that express IL-2R early in culture and a decrease in the number of their precursors (CD44+IL-2R- cells). The increase in the percentage of cells expressing IL-2R was not accompanied by an increase in the number of these cells. At later time points these IL-2R+ cells (and their precursors) were reduced relative to controls. The total number of CD4-CD8-CD3- precursor cells in IL-1-treated cultures was reduced to approximately half that in controls at Day 12 of culture. However, only minor inhibition of total cell number was observed, which, taken together with the greater frequency of IL-2R+ precursors, suggests that this depletion of the pool of precursors may have been due to the induction of premature differentiation rather than to its inhibition.

Infectious minor lymphocyte stimulating (Mls) antigens.

Minor lymphocyte stimulating (Mls) antigens have profound effects on the murine immune system and have been very important for our current understanding of immune tolerance. It has recently been discovered that these Mls antigens are encoded in an open reading frame located in the 3' long terminal repeat of endogenous and infectious mouse mammary tumor viruses (MMTV). In this review we will discuss the effects of a novel infectious MMTV with properties of Mls-1a on the neonatal and adult immune system in comparison to the effects of endogenous Mtv-7 (Mls-1a).

Hierarchy of responsiveness in vivo and in vitro among T cells expressing distinct Mls-1a-reactive v beta domains.

In this report we have compared responses of T cells bearing different T cell receptor (TcR) V beta domains, including V beta 6, 7, 8.1 and 9, to the minor lymphocyte stimulatory locus (Mls-1a). The virtually complete deletion of peripheral T cells using these TcR V beta domains in mice expressing Mls-1a verified their Mls-1a reactivity. However, varied responses among these cells following stimulation with Mls-1a in vitro suggested a hierarchy of TcR reactivities for Mls-1a with V beta 6 and V beta 9 greater than V beta 8.1 much greater than V beta 7. This hierarchy was further supported by in vivo studies which showed that V beta 6+CD4+ cells dominated responses to Mls-1a.