Keeping profitable cows in the herd: A lifetime cost-benefit assessment to support culling decisions.

Increasing the productive lifespan of dairy cows is important to achieve a sustainable dairy industry, but making strategic culling decisions based on cow profitability is challenging for farmers. The objective of this study was to carry out a lifetime cost-benefit analysis based on production and health records and to explore different culling decisions among farmers. The cost-benefit analysis was conducted for 22 747 dairy cows across 114 herds in Quebec, Canada for which feed costs and the occurrence of diseases were reported. Costs and revenues related to productive lifespan were compared among cohorts of cows that left their respective herd at the end of their last completed lactation or stayed for a complete additional lactation. Hierarchical clustering analysis was carried out based on costs and revenues to explore different culling decisions among farmers. Our results showed that the knowledge of lifetime cumulative costs and revenues was of great importance to identify low-profitable cows at an earlier lactation, while only focusing on current lactation costs and revenues can lead to an erroneous assessment of profitability. While culling decisions were mostly based on current lactation costs and revenues and disregarded the occurrence of costly events on previous lactations, there was variation among farmers as we identified three different culling decision clusters. Monitoring cumulative costs and revenues would help farmers to identify low-profitable cows at an earlier lactation and make the decision to increase herd productive lifespan and farm profitability by keeping the most profitable cows.

Effect of feeding system and grain source on lactation characteristics and milk components in dairy cattle.

The objective of this study was to examine the effect of feeding systems [component and total mixed rations (TMR)] and dietary grain sources (barley, commercial concentrate, corn grain, and high-moisture corn) on lactation characteristics and milk composition. A total of 852,242 test-day records, information on animal characteristics, feed composition, and feeding systems from 104,129 Holstein cows in 4,319 herds covering a period of 5 yr were obtained from Quebec's Dairy Herd Improvement Association (Valacta). We performed descriptive statistics and graphical representations of the data for each type of feeding system and grain source by parity (1 to 3). The milk records were binned in 15-d in milk blocks. Mixed models using a combination of forward and backward stepwise selections were developed to predict milk and milk component yields. The TMR-fed cows had greater yield of milk, fat, protein, and lactose and lower milk urea N (MUN) concentration than component-fed cows at all parities. Cows fed a TMR had higher peak milk yields and greater persistency after peak lactation compared with component-fed cows. In addition, greater yields of milk fat and protein from peak to mid-lactation were found in TMR- versus component-fed cows. In general, greater milk fat and protein yields as well as lower MUN concentration were observed in cows fed corn grain or high-moisture corn compared with barley or commercial concentrate, but parity influenced these relationships. The feeding system by day in milk blocks interaction was significant in models of milk and components yields for all parities, but only for second-lactation cows for MUN concentration. This means that effect of TMR and component feeding differs with stage of lactation. In conclusion, feeding TMR and corn-based diets are associated with greater yield of milk and milk components under commercial conditions.

A survey of dairy calf management practices in Canada that affect animal welfare.

There is growing interest among the public in farm animal welfare and a need for methods to assess animal welfare on farm. A survey on calf rearing practices that might affect dairy calf welfare was performed via a 1-h interview on 115 dairy farms (mean +/- SD: herd size=52.5+/-20.9 cows; milk production=8,697+/-1,153L) distributed throughout the province of Quebec. Despite frequent recommendations, many dairy producers continue to use management practices that increase the health risks of milk-fed calves. Major risk factors for poor calf welfare identified were 1) no use of calving pen in 51.3% of herds and low level of surveillance of calvings, especially at nighttime (once every 12h), 2) no disinfection of newborn's navel in 36.8% of herds, and delayed identification and, hence, calf monitoring (3 d), 3) 15.6% of farms relied on the dam to provide colostrum and none checked colostrum quality or passive transfer of immunity, 4) dehorning and removal of extra teats proceeded at late ages (6.4 wk and 6.7 mo, respectively) and without adequate pain control, 5) use of traditional restrictive milk feeding and waste milk distributed to unweaned calves without precaution in 48.2% of herds, 6) abrupt weaning performed in 16.5% of herds, and 7) calves housed individually in 87.9% of herds, and most inappropriate housing systems (crate=27.0%, tie-stall=13.9%, attached against a wall=5.7%) remained. This risk factor assessment was the first step in an intervention strategy to improve calf welfare on dairy farms.

A case-acquisition and decision-support system for the analysis of group-average lactation curves.

A case-acquisition and decision-support system was developed to support the analysis of group-average lactation curves and to acquire example cases from domain specialists. This software was developed through several iterations of a three-step approach involving 1) problem analysis and formulation in consultation with two dairy nutrition specialists; 2) development of a case-acquisition and decision-support prototype by the system developer; and 3) use of the prototype by the domain specialists to analyze and classify milk-recording data from example herds. The overall problem was decomposed into three subproblems: removal of outlier tests and lactation curves of individual cows; interpretation of group-average lactation curves; and diagnosis of detected abnormalities at the herd level through the identification of potential management deficiencies. For each subproblem, a software module was developed allowing the user to analyze both graphical and numerical performance representations and classify these representations using predefined linguistic descriptors. The example-based method for the development of the program proved to be very useful, facilitating the communication between system developer and domain specialists, and allowing the specialists to explore the appropriateness of the various prototypes developed. The resulting software represents a formalization of the approach to group-average lactation curve analysis, elicited from the two domain specialists. In future research, the case-acquisition and decision-support system will be complemented with knowledge to automate identified classification tasks, which will be captured through the application of machine-learning techniques to example cases, acquired from domain specialists using the software.

Method and effect of adjustment for heterogeneous variance of Holstein conformation traits.

Type classification records of Canadian Holsteins were investigated for evidence of heterogeneous variance across herds. Data consisted of records for 1,139,104 cows from 20,226 herds with classifications on 26 conformation traits collected from 1982 through 1992 and 338,046 cows from 9600 herds with classifications on 2 additional traits from 1990 through 1992. Phenotypic standard deviations of herd-round-classifier were fitted to a mixed model that included round, classifier, and region as fixed effects, herd size as a covariant, and herd as a random effect. Estimates of the variance components, solutions of fixed effects, and BLUP estimates for herd were obtained by maximum likelihood procedures. Repeatability of within-herd standard deviation across rounds ranged from 1.4 to 10.3% for the 28 traits. Type classification data were subsequently standardized for phenotypic standard deviations of herd-round-classifier that were derived from estimates of the fixed effects and the BLUP estimate of the herd effect. Genetic evaluations for cows and bulls were produced from adjusted and unadjusted data. Correlations between 3754 sire and 1,142,782 cow estimated transmitting abilities obtained from unadjusted and adjusted data were essentially unity. Although some evidence of heterogeneous variance existed across herds for 28 conformation traits, standardization of the classification records had only a minor effect on genetic evaluations.