Evolution of air-borne vocalization: Insights from neural studies in the archeobatrachian species Bombina orientalis.

Vocalization of tetrapods evolved as an air-driven mechanism. Thus, it is conceivable that the underlaying neural network might have evolved from more ancient respiratory circuits and be made up of homologous components that generate breathing rhythms across vertebrates. In this context, the extant species of stem anurans provide an opportunity to analyze the connection of the neural circuits of lung ventilation and vocalization. Here, we analyzed the fictive lung ventilation and vocalization behavior of isolated brains of the Chinese fire-bellied toad Bombina orientalis during their mating season by nerve root recordings. We discovered significant differences in durations of activation of male brains after stimulation of the statoacoustic nerve or vocalization-relevant forebrain structures in comparison to female brains. The increased durations of motor nerve activities in male brains can be interpreted as fictive calling, as male's advertisement calls in vivo had the same general pattern compared to lung ventilation, but longer duration periods. Female brains react to the corresponding stimulations with the same shorter activity pattern that occurred spontaneously in both female and male brains and thus can be interpreted as fictive lung ventilations. These results support the hypothesis that vocal circuits evolved from ancient respiration networks in the anuran caudal hindbrain. Moreover, we could show that the terrestrial stem archeobatrachian Bombina spec. is an appropriate model to study the function and evolution of the shared network of lung ventilation and vocal generation.

Anuran Vocal Communication: Effects of Genome Size, Cell Number and Cell Size.

Significant variation in genome size occurs among anuran amphibians and can affect cell size and number. In the gray treefrog complex in North America, increases in cell size in autotriploids of the diploid (Hyla chrysoscelis) altered the temporal structure of mate-attracting vocalizations and auditory selectivity for these properties. Here, we show that the tetraploid species (Hyla versicolor) also has significantly fewer brain neurons than H. chrysoscelis. With regard to cell size in tissues involved in vocal communication, spinal motor neurons were larger in tetraploids than in diploids and comparable to differences in erythrocyte size; smaller increases were found in one of the three auditory centers in the torus semicircularis. Future studies should address questions about how environmental conditions during development affect cell numbers and size and the causal relationships between these cellular changes and the vocal communication system.

Input of sensory, limbic, basal ganglia and pallial/cortical information into the ventral/lateral habenula: Functional principles in anuran amphibians.

The habenula - a phylogenetically old brain structure present in all vertebrates - is involved in pain processing, reproductive behaviors, sleep-wake cycles, stress responses, reward, and learning. We performed intra- and extracellular recordings of ventral habenula (VHb) neurons in the isolated brain of anurans and revealed similar cell and response properties to those reported for the lateral habenula of mammals. We identified tonic regular, tonic irregular, rhythmic firing, and silent VHb neurons. Transitions between these firing patterns were observed during spontaneous activity. Electrical stimulation of various brain areas demonstrated VHb input of auditory, optic, limbic, basal ganglia, and pallial information. This resulted in three different response behaviors in VHb neurons: excitation, inhibition, or alternating facilitation and suppression of neuronal activity. Spontaneously changing activity patterns were observed to modulate, reset, or suppress the response behavior of VHb neurons, indicating a gating mechanism. This could be a network status or context dependent selection mechanism for which information are transmitted to task relevant brain areas (i.e., sensory system, limbic system, basal ganglia). Furthermore, alternating facilitation and suppression sequences upon auditory nerve stimulation correlated positively fictive motor activities recorded via the compound potential of the vagal nerve. Stimulation of the auditory nerve or the habenula led to facilitation, suppression, or alternating facilitation and suppression of neuronal activity in putative dopaminergic neurons. Due to complex habenula feedback loops with basal ganglia, limbic, and sensory systems, the habenula involvement in a variety of functions might therefore be explained by a modulatory effect on a task-relevant input stream.

Refinement of the dopaminergic system of anuran amphibians based on connectivity with habenula, basal ganglia, limbic system, pallium, and spinal cord.

Whereas our understanding of the dopaminergic system in mammals allows for a distinction between ventral tegmental area (VTA) and substantia nigra pars compacta (SNc), no clear evidence for separate structures in anamniotes has been presented to date. To broaden the insight into the organization and regulation of neuromodulatory systems in anuran amphibians, tracing and immunohistochemical investigations were performed in the Oriental fire-bellied toad, Bombina orientalis. Topographically organized catecholaminergic "nigrostriatal," "mesolimbic," "mesocortical," and spinal cord projections arising from the posterior tubercle and mesencephalic tegmentum were identified. We compared these results with published data from lampreys, chondrichthyes, teleosts, amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals. Based on the pattern of organization, as well as the differential innervation by the habenular nuclei, domains gradually comparable to the mammalian paranigral VTA, ventral tier of the SNc, interfascicular nucleus of the VTA, and supramamillary/retromamillary area were identified. Additionally, we could demonstrate topographic separate populations of habenula neurons projecting via a direct excitatory or indirect GABAergic pathway onto the catecholaminergic VTA/SNc homologs and serotonergic raphe nuclei. The indirect GABAergic habenula pathway derives from neurons in the superficial mamillary area, which in terms of its connectivity and chemoarchitecture resembles the mammalian rostromedial tegmental nucleus. These results demonstrate a much more elaborate interconnection principle of the anuran dopaminergic system than previously assumed. Based on the data presented it seems that most features of the dopaminergic system of amniotes had already evolved when the amphibian line of evolution diverged from that leading up to mammals, reptiles, and birds.

The habenula as an evolutionary conserved link between basal ganglia, limbic, and sensory systems-A phylogenetic comparison based on anuran amphibians.

Based on anatomical and functional data, the habenula-a phylogenetically old brain structure present in all vertebrates-takes part in the integration of limbic, sensory, and basal ganglia information to guide effective response strategies appropriate to environmental conditions. In the present study, we investigated the connections of the habenular nuclei of the oriental fire-bellied toad, Bombina orientalis, and compared them with published data from lampreys, chondrichthyes, teleosts, reptiles, birds, and mammals. During phylogenetic development, the primordial habenula circuitry underwent various evolutionary adaptations and in the tetrapod line, the circuit complexity increased. The habenula circuitry of anuran amphibians, decedents of the first land-living tetrapods, seem to exhibit a mix of ancient as well as modern features. The anuran medial and lateral habenula homologs receive differential input from the septum, nucleus of the diagonal band of Broca, preoptic area, hypothalamus, rostral pallium, nucleus accumbens, ventral pallidum, and bed nucleus of the stria terminalis. Additional input arises from a border region in the ventral prethalamus, here discussed as a putative homolog of the entopeduncular nucleus of rodents. The habenular subnuclei also differentially innervate the interpeduncular nucleus, raphe nuclei, substantia nigra pars compacta and ventral tegmental area homologs, superficial mamillary area, laterodorsal tegmental nucleus, locus coeruleus, inferior and superior colliculus homologs, hypothalamus, preoptic area, septum, nucleus of the diagonal band of Broca, and main olfactory bulb. It seems likely that the main connectivity between the habenula and the basal ganglia, limbic, and sensory systems was already present in the common tetrapod ancestor.

Individual Dopaminergic Neurons of Lamprey SNc/VTA Project to Both the Striatum and Optic Tectum but Restrict Co-release of Glutamate to Striatum Only.

Dopaminergic neurons in the substantia nigra (SNc) innervate both striatum and the superior colliculus in mammals, as well as its homolog the optic tectum in lampreys, belonging to the oldest group of living vertebrates [1-3]. In the lamprey, we have previously shown that the same neuron sends axonal branches to both striatum and the optic tectum [3]. Here, we show that most neurons in the lamprey SNc and ventral tegmental area (VTA) (also referred to as the nucleus of the posterior tuberculum) express not only tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), in lamprey a marker of dopaminergic neurons [4], but also the vesicular glutamate transporter (vGluT), suggesting that glutamate is a co-transmitter. Remarkably, the axonal branches that project to striatum elicit both dopaminergic and glutamatergic synaptic effects on striatal neurons, whereas the axonal projections to the optic tectum only evoke dopaminergic effects. Thus, axonal branches from the same neuron can use two transmitters in one branch and only one in the other. Previous studies suggest that, along an individual dopaminergic axon, there can be microdomains of either TH or vGluT [5-8]. In addition, the present results demonstrate that entire axonal branches to one target structure can differ from that of branches to another target, both originating from the same dopamine neuron. This implies that a given dopamine neuron can exert different effects on two different target structures. The combined release of dopamine and glutamate may be appropriate in striatum, whereas the effects exerted on the tectal motor center may be better served with a selective dopaminergic modulation.

Multivariate Meta-Analysis of Brain-Mass Correlations in Eutherian Mammals.

The general assumption that brain size differences are an adequate proxy for subtler differences in brain organization turned neurobiologists toward the question why some groups of mammals such as primates, elephants, and whales have such remarkably large brains. In this meta-analysis, an extensive sample of eutherian mammals (115 species distributed in 14 orders) provided data about several different biological traits and measures of brain size such as absolute brain mass (AB), relative brain mass (RB; quotient from AB and body mass), and encephalization quotient (EQ). These data were analyzed by established multivariate statistics without taking specific phylogenetic information into account. Species with high AB tend to (1) feed on protein-rich nutrition, (2) have a long lifespan, (3) delayed sexual maturity, and (4) long and rare pregnancies with small litter sizes. Animals with high RB usually have (1) a short life span, (2) reach sexual maturity early, and (3) have short and frequent gestations. Moreover, males of species with high RB also have few potential sexual partners. In contrast, animals with high EQs have (1) a high number of potential sexual partners, (2) delayed sexual maturity, and (3) rare gestations with small litter sizes. Based on these correlations, we conclude that Eutheria with either high AB or high EQ occupy positions at the top of the network of food chains (high trophic levels). Eutheria of low trophic levels can develop a high RB only if they have small body masses.

The Influence of Genome and Cell Size on Brain Morphology in Amphibians.

In amphibians, nerve cell size is highly correlated with genome size, and increases in genome and cell size cause a retardation of the rate of development of nervous (as well as nonnervous) tissue leading to secondary simplification. This yields an inverse relationship between genome and cell size on the one hand and morphological complexity of the tectum mesencephali as the main visual center, the size of the torus semicircularis as the main auditory center, the size of the amphibian papilla as an important peripheral auditory structure, and the size of the cerebellum as a major sensorimotor center. Nervous structures developing later (e.g., torus and cerebellum) are more affected by secondary simplification than those that develop earlier (e.g., the tectum). This effect is more prominent in salamanders and caecilians than in frogs owing to larger genome and cells sizes in the former two taxa. We hypothesize that because of intragenomic evolutionary processes, important differences in brain morphology can arise independently of specific environmental selection.

A miniature microdrive for recording auditory evoked potentials from awake anurans.

Electrical activity recording from the brains of awake animals is a corner stone in the study of the neurophysiological basis of behavior. To meet this need, a microelectrode driver suitable for the animal of interest has to be developed. In the present study a miniature microdrive was developed specifically for the leopard toad, Bufo regularis, however, it can be used for other small animals. The microdrive was designed to meet the following requirements: small size, light weight, simple and easy way of attaching and removing, advancing and withdrawing of microelectrode in the animal brain without rotation, can be reused and made from inexpensive materials. To assess the performance of the developed microdrive, we recorded auditory evoked potentials from different auditory centers in the toad's brain. The potentials were obtained from mesencephalic, diencephalic and telencephalic auditory sensitive areas in response to simple and complex acoustic stimuli. The synthetic acoustical tones introduced to the toad were carrying the dominant frequencies of their mating calls.

An indirect basal ganglia pathway in anuran amphibians?

The mammalian subthalamic nucleus (STN) is a glutamatergic cell group within the indirect pathway of the basal ganglia. It receives input from the external globus pallidus (GP) and in turn projects to the internal GP and the substantia nigra pars reticulata (SNr). While the direct pathway from striatum to SNr is well established in anurans, it is unknown whether they possess an indirect pathway including a STN homologue. The subthalamic region comprises the dorsocaudal suprachiasmatic nucleus (dcSC), the posterior entopeduncular nucleus (EP), and the ventral part of the ventral thalamus (vVM/VL). In the fire-bellied toad Bombina orientalis we investigated whether one of these areas match the criteria established for the mammalian STN. We delineated the SNr in the midbrain tegmentum by labeling the striatonigral terminal field by means of GABA-, substance P-, and enkephalin immunohistochemistry and striatal tracer injections. Subsequently, we used double fluorescence tracing with injections into the SNr and GP to stain different parts of the indirect pathway. Confocal laser scan analysis revealed that dcSC, EP, and vVM/VL contain retrogradely labeled neurons projecting to the SNr, contacted by anterogradely labeled terminals arising in the GP. Immunohistochemical stainings with antibodies against glutamate and the glutamate transporters EAAC1 and vGluT2 demonstrated that the investigated nuclei contain glutamatergic neurons. Our results suggest that all regions in the subthalamic region fulfill our morphological criteria, except the connection back to the GP. An indirect basal ganglia pathway seems to be present in anuran amphibians, although we cannot exclusively delineate an STN homologue.

GABAergic projection neurons in the basal ganglia of the green tree frog (Hyla cinerea).

The basal ganglia of tetrapods have been considered to be a conservative system sharing a common pattern with respect to connectivity and transmitters. One important transmitter found in mammalian basal ganglia is gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) which is used by nearly all striatal and pallidal projection neurons. In order to investigate whether GABAergic projection neurons exist in the basal ganglia of anurans as well, we combined tracer applications in the diencephalic portion of the lateral forebrain bundle with GABA immunohistochemistry in an isolated brain preparation of the green tree frog Hyla cinerea. Additionally, double-labeling studies using antibodies against GABA, GAD 65, and GAD 67 helped to clarify which neurons could be regarded as GABAergic. On average 7.29-7.40% of striatal and 3.29-3.98% of pallidal projection neurons were strongly GABA-immunoreactive; lightly labeled neurons were disregarded. We conclude that GABAergic projection neurons are present in the striatum and dorsal pallidum of H. cinerea, but their numbers are much lower compared to the same regions in mammals.

The septal complex of the fire-bellied toad Bombina orientalis: chemoarchitecture.

In order to investigate whether chemoarchitecture would support the subdivision of the anuran septum based on cytoarchitectonic and hodological studies, we performed enzyme-histochemical detection of NADPH-diaphorase and immunohistological demonstration of choline-acetyl transferase (ChAT), aspartate, calretinin, gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), 5-hydroxy-tryptamine, tyrosine hydroxylase, neuropeptide Y (NPY), somatostatin, Leu- and Leu + Met-enkephalin, and substance P in the fire-bellied toad Bombina orientalis. Labeling of cell bodies matched well the previously defined subnuclei: The dorsolateral septal nucleus contains enkephalin-immunoreactive (-ir) and weakly stained GABA-ir neurons; calretinin-ir and weakly labeled GABA-ir neurons are found in the ventrolateral septal nucleus. The medial septal nucleus is characterized by the presence of numerous ChAT-ir and some tyrosine hydroxylase-ir neurons, while the dorsal septal nucleus is outlined by its NPY-ir neurons. Many ChAT-ir and some aspartate-ir and somatostatin-ir neurons are found in the diagonal band of Broca, and the central septal nucleus contains some GABA-ir and ChAT-ir neurons. In contrast, labeled fibers form a pattern which does not match the boundaries of septal subnuclei. Comparing the anuran septal complex with that of other vertebrates reveals that the complexity of the lateral septum has increased during the evolution from anamniote to amniote vertebrates. In spite of this fact, many similarities in chemoarchitecture between anurans and other vertebrates are evident. Some basal septal functions such as involvement in learning and memory formation or inhibition of sexual behavior appear to have persisted during vertebrate evolution.

Hodological characterization of the septum in anuran amphibians: I. Afferent connections.

On the basis of Nissl-stained sections, we subdivided the septum of the gray treefrog Hyla versicolor in the lateral, central, and medial septal complex. The afferent projections of the different septal nuclei were studied by combined retrograde and anterograde tracing with biotin ethylendiamine (Neurobiotin). The central and medial septal complex receives direct input from regions of the olfactory bulb and from all other limbic structures of the telencephalon (e.g., amygdalar regions, nucleus accumbens), whereas projections to the lateral septal complex are absent or less extensive. The medial pallium projects to all septal nuclei. In the diencephalon, the anterior thalamic nucleus provides the main ascending input to all subnuclei of the anuran septum, which can be interpreted as a limbic/associative pathway. The ventromedial thalamic nucleus projects to the medial and lateral septal complex and may thereby transmit multisensory information to the limbic system. Anterior preoptic nucleus, suprachiasmatic nucleus, and hypothalamic nuclei innervate the central and lateral septal complex. Only the nuclei of the central septal complex receive input from the brainstem. Noteworthy is the relatively strong projection from the nucleus raphe to the central septal complex, but not to the other septal nuclei.

Hodological characterization of the septum in anuran amphibians: II. Efferent connections.

The efferent connections of the septum of the gray treefrog Hyla versicolor were studied by combining anterograde and retrograde tracing with biotin ethylendiamine (Neurobiotin). The lateral septal complex projects mainly to the medial pallium, limbic regions (e.g., amygdala and nucleus accumbens), and hypothalamic areas but also to sensory nuclei in the diencephalon and midbrain. The central septal complex strongly innervates the medial pallium, limbic, and hypothalamic areas but also specific sensory (including olfactory) regions. The medial septal complex sends major projections to all olfactory nuclei and a weaker projection to the hypothalamus. Our results indicate that all septal nuclei may modify the animal's internal state via efferents to limbic and hypothalamic areas. Via projections to the medial pallium, lateral and central septal complexes may be involved in learning processes as well. Because of their connections to specific sensory areas, all septal areas are in a position to influence sensory processing. Furthermore, our data suggest that both the postolfactory eminence and the bed nucleus of the pallial commissure are not part of the septal complex, rather, the postolfactory eminence seems to be comparable to the mammalian primary olfactory cortex, whereas the bed nucleus may be analogous to the mammalian subfornical organ.

6-hydroxydopamine lesions in anuran amphibians: a new model system for Parkinson's disease?

We investigated the effects of dopamine depletion on acoustically guided behavior of anurans by conducting phonotaxis experiments with female gray treefrogs (Hyla versicolor) before and 90 min after bilateral injections of 3, 6, or 12 microg 6-hydroxydopamine (6-OHDA) into the telencephalic ventricles. In experiments with one loudspeaker playing back a standard artificial mating call, we analyzed the effects of 6-OHDA on phonotactic response time. In choice tests we measured the degree of distraction from the standard call (20 pulses/s) by three different variants with altered pulse-rate (30/s, 40/s, 60/s). Five days after experiments, brains were immunostained for tyrosine hydroxylase. Labeled neurons were counted in the suprachiasmatic nucleus, posterior tuberculum, interpeduncular nucleus, and locus coeruleus, and correlation between neuronal numbers and behavioral scores was tested. Response times increased together with 6-OHDA concentrations, which was mainly due to longer immobile periods before the animals started movement. In choice tests the most irrelevant stimulus (60/s) distracted 6-OHDA injected females from the standard stimulus, while sham injected controls were undistracted. The number of catecholaminergic neurons decreased with increasing 6-OHDA concentration in the suprachiasmatic nucleus, posterior tuberculum, and interpeduncular nucleus. The normalized number of immunoreactive neurons in the posterior tuberculum was positively correlated with phonotaxis scores in the one-speaker test, demonstrating that motor deficits are a function of tubercular cell loss. We conclude that bilateral 6-OHDA lesions in anuran amphibians cause motor (difficulty to start movements) as well as cognitive symptoms (higher distraction by irrelevant stimuli) that have also been described for human Parkinson patients.

Dorsal striatopallidal system in anurans.

The dorsal striatopallidal system of tetrapods consists of the dorsal striatum (caudate-putamen in mammals) and the dorsal pallidum. Although the existence of striatal and pallidal structures has been well documented in anuran amphibians, the exact boundaries of these structures have so far been a matter of debate. To delineate precisely the dorsal striatopallidal system of anurans, we used quantitative analysis of leucine-enkephalin immunohistochemistry (in Bombina orientalis, Discoglossus pictus, Xenopus laevis, and Hyla versicolor), retrograde neurobiotin tracing studies (injections in the central and ventromedial thalamic nuclei in H. versicolor), and double-labeling tracing studies (injections in the lateral forebrain bundle and the caudal striatum in B. orientalis). Immunohistochemistry revealed that enkephalin-positive neurons are located mainly in the rostral and intermediate striatum. Neurobiotin tracing studies demonstrated that neurons projecting to the central and ventromedial thalamic nuclei are found in the intermediate and caudal striatum. Double-labeling studies revealed that the population of neurons in the rostral and intermediate striatum innervating the caudal striatum is separated from neurons projecting into the lateral forebrain bundle. Neurons that project to both the caudal striatum and the lateral forebrain bundle are found only in the dorsal part of the intermediate striatum. Taken together, our results suggest that the rostral striatum of anurans is homologous to the striatum proper of mammals, whereas the caudal striatum is comparable to the dorsal pallidum. The intermediate striatum represents a transition area between the two structures.

Roles of the auditory midbrain and thalamus in selective phonotaxis in female gray treefrogs (Hyla versicolor).

Diencephalic and midbrain auditory nuclei are involved in the processing of auditory communication signals in anurans [Comparative Hearing: Fish and Amphibians, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1999, p. 218], but their exact roles in acoustically guided behavior, such as female phonotaxis, are unclear. To address this question, behavioral experiments were combined with lesions of dorsal thalamic nuclei and the midbrain torus semicircularis. Females were tested in two-alternative-forced-choice phonotactic experiments before and after a defined brain area was lesioned. During phonotactic tests, females had to choose between a "standard" synthetic call and one of three different variants, each of which had a single acoustic property (pulse rate, pulse rise-time, sound spectrum) that differed from the standard synthetic call. Results showed that dorsomedial thalamus lesions produced little or no effect on phonotaxis. In contrast, superficial and deep thalamus lesions, as well as lesions of the torus semicircularis, significantly decreased the number of phonotactic responses and increased the response time. Superficial thalamus lesions also abolished or reversed preferences for the standard call in the rise-time and sound spectrum tests. This effect is likely to have been caused by an imbalance in the stimulation of the thalamus by the low- and high-frequency pathways because these preferences were not affected in animals with more extensive lesions that included the superficial thalamus. Our data suggest that the torus semicircularis, but not the dorsal thalamus is crucial for phonotaxis in gravid, reproductively active females. Although dorsal thalamic nuclei seem to play a role in spectral sensitivity, they may additionally have motivational or attentional functions that contribute to achieving a state of phonotactic readiness.