Hierarchical Silica Composites for Enhanced Water Adsorption at Low Humidity.

To combat water scarcity in remote areas around the world, adsorption-based atmospheric water harvesting (AWH) has been proposed as a technology that can be used alongside existing water production capabilities. However, commonly used adsorbents either have low water adsorption loadings or are difficult to regenerate. In this work, we developed two novel hierarchical silica-salt composites that both exhibit high water adsorption loadings under dry and humid conditions. The total water vapor loading, kinetics, and heats of water adsorption for both silica-salt composites were investigated. As hierarchical silicas have tunable pores and large pore volumes, these materials serve as effective host matrixes for the hygroscopic salt LiCl. Our results suggest that hierarchical pores play a significant role in water adsorption: micropores and some smaller mesopores act as "storage" sites for hygroscopic salt, whereas larger mesopores and macropores increase the accessibility of water vapor into the silica. Using this mix of pores, we achieved greater than 0.4 g H2O/g composite at 10% RH and 27 °C. Additionally, we found that the salt-impregnated silica and bare silica had the same heat of adsorption: 80-90 kJ/mol. The results suggest that the H-bond interactions are similar for both systems and that the primary mechanism at play here is water cluster adsorption/desorption. Despite the similar energies, the LiCl-containing materials exhibited considerably slower kinetics than bare silica materials. Of equal importance to the adsorption capacity and kinetics of these composites is their mechanical stability. To assess their mechanical stability, high-energy ball milling of silica was conducted to create more uniform particle sizes. However, reduced particle sizes came at a cost─the BET surface areas and pore volumes were drastically decreased after more than 1 h of ball milling. Findings from this study suggest that short-term ball milling may be a viable large-scale option to reduce particle size in silica materials without sacrificing significant performance.

Determining Surface Areas and Pore Volumes of Metal-Organic Frameworks.

The surface area and pore volume of a metal-organic framework (MOF) can provide insight into its structure and potential applications. Both parameters are commonly determined using the data from nitrogen sorption experiments; commercial instruments to perform these measurements are also widely available. These instruments will calculate structural parameters, but it is essential to understand how to select input data and when calculation methods apply to the sample MOF. This article outlines the use of the Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) method and Barrett-Joyner-Halenda (BJH) method for the calculation of surface area and pore volume, respectively. Example calculations are performed on the representative MOF UiO-66. Although widely applicable to MOFs, sample materials and adsorption data must meet certain criteria for the calculated results to be considered accurate, in addition to proper sample preparation. The assumptions and limitations of these methods are also discussed, along with alternative and complementary techniques for the MOF pore space characterization.

Single-Component Adsorption Equilibria of CO2, CH4, Water, and Acetone on Tapered Porous Carbon Molecular Sieves.

Engineered carbon molecular sieves (CMSs) with tapered pores, high surface area, and high total pore volume were investigated for their CO2, CH4, water, and acetone adsorption properties at 288.15, 298.15, 308.15 K, and pressures of <1 bar. The results were compared with BPL carbon. The samples exhibited higher adsorption capacity for CO2 compared to BPL carbon, with Carboxen 1005 being the highest due to the presence of ultramicropores (pores smaller than 0.8 nm). Similar observations were made for CH4 except at 288.15 K. Although the CMSs exhibited higher hydrophobicity than BPL carbon, the latter had the highest acetone uptake for all investigated temperatures due to its higher oxygen content, which facilitates stronger interactions with polar VOC molecules. Heats of adsorption were calculated using the Clausius-Clapeyron equation after fitting the isotherms with the dual-site Langmuir-Freundlich model, and results largely corroborated the order of adsorption capacities of CO2, CH4, and water on the carbon materials.

Does Mixed Linker-Induced Surface Heterogeneity Impact the Accuracy of IAST Predictions in UiO-66-NH2?

To move toward more energy-efficient adsorption-based processes, there is a need for accurate multicomponent data under realistic conditions. While the Ideal Adsorbed Solution Theory (IAST) has been established as the preferred prediction method due to its simplicity, limitations and inaccuracies for less ideal adsorption systems have been reported. Here, we use amine-functionalized derivatives of the UiO-66 structure to change the extent of homogeneity of the internal surface toward the adsorption of the two probe molecules carbon dioxide and ethylene. Although it might seem plausible that more functional groups lead to more heterogeneity and, thus, less accurate predictions by IAST, we find a mixed-linker system with increased heterogeneity in terms of added adsorption sites where IAST predictions and experimental loadings agree exceptionally well. We show that incorporating uncertainty analysis into predictions with IAST is important for assessing the accuracy of these predictions. Energetic investigations combined with Grand Canonical Monte Carlo simulations reveal almost homogeneous carbon dioxide but heterogeneous ethylene adsorption in the mixed-linker material, resulting in local, almost pure phases of the individual components.

Adaptive Pore Opening to Form Tailored Adsorption Sites in a Cooperatively Flexible Framework Enables Record Inverse Propane/Propylene Separation.

A proposed low-energy alternative to the separation of alkanes from alkenes by energy-intensive cryogenic distillation is separation by porous adsorbents. Unfortunately, most adsorbents preferentially take up the desired, high-value major component alkene, requiring frequent regeneration. Adsorbents with inverse selectivity for the minor component alkane would enable the direct production of purified, reagent-grade alkene, greatly reducing global energy consumption. However, such materials are exceedingly rare, especially for propane/propylene separation. Here, we report that through adaptive and spontaneous pore size and shape adaptation to optimize an ensemble of weak noncovalent interactions, the structurally responsive metal-organic framework CdIF-13 (sod-Cd(benzimidazolate)2) exhibits inverse selectivity for propane over propylene with record-setting separation performance under industrially relevant temperature, pressure, and mixture conditions. Powder synchrotron X-ray diffraction measurements combined with first-principles calculations yield atomic-scale insight and reveal the induced fit mechanism of adsorbate-specific pore adaptation and ensemble interactions between ligands and adsorbates. Dynamic column breakthrough measurements confirm that CdIF-13 displays selectivity under mixed-component conditions of varying ratios, with a record measured selectivity factor of α ≈ 3 at 95:5 propylene:propane at 298 K and 1 bar. When sequenced with a low-cost rigid adsorbent, we demonstrated the direct purification of propylene under ambient conditions. This combined atomic-level structural characterization and performance testing firmly establishes how cooperatively flexible materials can be capable of unprecedented separation factors.

Surprising Use of the Business Innovation Bass Diffusion Model To Accurately Describe Adsorption Isotherm Types I, III, and V.

Using adsorption isotherm data to determine heats of adsorption or predict mixture adsorption using the ideal adsorbed solution theory (IAST) relies on accurate fits of the data with continuous, mathematical models. Here, we derive an empirical two-parameter model to fit isotherm data of IUPAC types I, III, and V in a descriptive way based on the Bass model for innovation diffusion. We report 31 isotherm fits to existing literature data covering all six types of isotherms, various adsorbents, such as carbons, zeolites, and metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), as well as different adsorbing gases (water, carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrogen). We find several cases, especially for flexible MOFs, where previously reported isotherm models reached their limits and either failed to fit the data or could not sufficiently be fitted due to stepped type V isotherms. Moreover, in two instances, models specifically developed for distinct systems are fitted with a higher R2 value compared to the models in the original reports. Using these fits, it is demonstrated how the new Bingel-Walton isotherm can be used to qualitatively assess the hydrophilic or hydrophobic behavior of porous materials from the relative magnitude of the two fitting parameters. The model can also be employed to find matching heats of adsorption values for systems with isotherm steps using one, continuous fit instead of partial, stepwise fits or interpolation. Additionally, using our single, continuous fit to model stepped isotherms in IAST mixture adsorption predictions leads to good agreement with the results from the osmotic framework adsorbed solution theory that was specifically developed for these systems using a stepwise, approximate fitting, which is yet far more complex. Our new isotherm equation accomplishes all of these tasks with only two fitted parameters, providing a simple, accurate method for modeling a variety of adsorption behavior.

Interrogating Encapsulated Protein Structure within Metal-Organic Frameworks at Elevated Temperature.

Encapsulating biomacromolecules within metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) can confer thermostability to entrapped guests. It has been hypothesized that the confinement of guest molecules within a rigid MOF scaffold results in heightened stability of the guests, but no direct evidence of this mechanism has been shown. Here, we present a novel analytical method using small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) to solve the structure of bovine serum albumin (BSA) while encapsulated within two zeolitic imidazolate frameworks (ZIF-67 and ZIF-8). Our approach comprises subtracting the scaled SAXS spectrum of the ZIF from that of the biocomposite BSA@ZIF to determine the radius of gyration of encapsulated BSA through Guinier, Kratky, and pair distance distribution function analyses. While native BSA exposed to 70 °C became denatured, in situ SAXS analysis showed that encapsulated BSA retained its size and folded state at 70 °C when encapsulated within a ZIF scaffold, suggesting that entrapment within MOF cavities inhibited protein unfolding and thus denaturation. This method of SAXS analysis not only provides insight into biomolecular stabilization in MOFs but may also offer a new approach to study the structure of other conformationally labile molecules in rigid matrices.

Unblocking a rigid purine MOF for kinetic separation of xylenes.

The separation of xylene isomers still remains an industrially challenging task. Here, porous purine-based metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have been synthesized and studied for their potential in xylene separations. In particular, Zn(purine)I showed excellent para-xylene/ortho-xylene separation capability with a diffusion selectivity of 6 and high equilibrium adsorption selectivity as indicated by coadsorption experiments. This high selectivity is attributed to the shape and size of the channel aperture within the rigid framework of Zn(purine)I.

Effect of Loading on the Water Stability of the Metal-Organic Framework DMOF-1 [Zn(bdc)(dabco)0.5].

In this work, the degradation of the metal-organic framework (MOF) DMOF-1 as a function of water adsorption was investigated. As the quantity of water vapor adsorbed by DMOF-1 increases, degradation of the MOF from hydrolysis accelerates. Degradation was attributed to clustering of water molecules in the void space of DMOF-1, as seen in NVT Monte Carlo simulations. Our molecular simulations strongly suggest that degradation of DMOF-1 by water is driven by water adsorption at defect sites in the MOF. Interestingly, it was observed that DMOF-1 can remain stable if it adsorbs less water than the 1 mmol/g necessary to initiate degradation within the framework. Even though the rate of hydrolysis increases at higher temperatures, the degradation threshold for DMOF-1 remains 1 mmol/g regardless of temperature. This suggests that at sufficiently elevated temperatures (above ∼50 °C) DMOF-1 is stable toward water vapor at all relative humidities.

An automated multi-component gas adsorption system (MC GAS).

The knowledge gap on adsorption of complex mixtures in the literature relative to single component data represents a persistent obstacle to developing accurate process models for adsorption separations. The collection of mixed gas adsorption data is an imminent need for improved understanding of the behavior of adsorbent systems in these diverse adsorption applications. Current approaches to understanding mixture adsorption using predictive theories based on pure component adsorption experiments often fail to capture the behavior of more complex, non-ideal systems. In this work, we present an automated volumetric instrument for the measurement of mixed gas adsorption isotherms. This instrument was validated by comparison to other in-house instruments and data available in the literature, and the binary adsorption measurements were found to be thermodynamically consistent. The automation of this instrument allows for rapid collection of high-quality mixture adsorption data.

Anisotropic Thermal Expansion in an Anionic Framework Showing Guest-Dependent Phases.

Crystalline materials generally show small positive thermal expansion along all three crystallographic axes because of increasing anharmonic vibrational amplitudes between bonded atoms or ions pairs on heating. In very rare cases, structural peculiarities may give rise to negative, anomalously large or zero thermal expansion behaviors, which remain poorly understood. Host-guest composites may exhibit such anomalous behavior if guest motions controllable. Here we report an anionic framework of helical nanotubes comprising three parallel helical chains. The anisotropic interaction between the guest and the framework, results in anisotropic thermal expansion in this framework. A series of detailed structural determination at 50 K intervals enable process visualization at the molecular level and the observed guest-dependent phases of the framework strongly support our proposed mechanism.

Tuning the Wettability of Metal-Organic Frameworks via Defect Engineering for Efficient Oil/Water Separation.

Zirconium-based metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have attracted interest due to their chemical and thermal stabilities and structural tunability. In this work, we demonstrate the tuning of the wettability of a UiO-66 structure via defect-engineering for efficient oil/water separation. UiO-66 crystals with controlled levels of missing-linker defects were synthesized using a modulation approach. As a result, the hydrophilicity of the defect-engineered UiO-66 (d-UiO-66) can be varied. In addition, a thin layer of hydrophilic d-UiO-66 was successfully fabricated on a series of stainless steel meshes (d-UiO-66@mesh), which exhibited excellent superhydrophilic and underwater superoleophobic properties and displayed interesting separation performance for various oil/water mixtures.

In situ visualization of loading-dependent water effects in a stable metal-organic framework.

Competitive water adsorption can have a significant impact on metal-organic framework performance properties, ranging from occupying active sites in catalytic reactions to co-adsorbing at the most favourable adsorption sites in gas separation and storage applications. In this study, we investigate, for a metal-organic framework that is stable after moisture exposure, what are the reversible, loading-dependent structural changes that occur during water adsorption. Herein, a combination of in situ synchrotron powder and single-crystal diffraction, infrared spectroscopy and molecular modelling analysis was used to understand the important role of loading-dependent water effects in a water stable metal-organic framework. Through this analysis, insights into changes in crystallographic lattice parameters, water siting information and water-induced defect structure as a response to water loading were obtained. This work shows that, even in stable metal-organic frameworks that maintain their porosity and crystallinity after moisture exposure, important molecular-level structural changes can still occur during water adsorption due to guest-host interactions such as water-induced bond rearrangements.

Room-Temperature Synthesis of Metal-Organic Framework Isomers in the Tetragonal and Kagome Crystal Structure.

Two metal-organic framework (MOF) isomers with the chemical formula Zn2(X)2(DABCO) [X = terephthalic acid (BDC), dimethyl terephthalic acid (DM), 2-aminoterephthalic acid (NH2), 2,3,5,6-tetramethyl terephthalic acid (TM), and anthracene dicarboxylic acid (ADC); DABCO = 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane] have been synthesized via a fast, room-temperature synthesis procedure. The synthesis solvent was found to play a vital role in directing the formation of the Kagome lattice (ZnBD) versus tetragonal topology (DMOF-1). When N, N-dimethylformamide (DMF) or dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) was used as the synthesis solvent, the reaction resulted in the formation of ZnBD, whereas methanol, ethanol, acetone, N, N-diethylformamide (DEF), and acetonitrile each produced DMOF-1. Water adsorption isotherms of ZnBD and DMOF-1 were collected, and the materials were found to have similar adsorption characteristics and stabilities. Both MOFs degraded upon exposure to water at a relative pressure ( P/ Po) of 0.5 at 25 °C, but both are hydrophobic below a P/ Po of 0.4, displaying very little water adsorption. Additionally, CO2 adsorption isotherms of ZnBD were collected and compared to those previously reported for DMOF-1. ZnBD adsorbs less CO2 at low pressure compared to DMOF-1 but reaches a similar capacity at 20 bar. This adsorption behavior can be explained by the structural features of the materials, where ZnBD possesses large hexagonal pores (15 Å) compared to the smaller pore opening (7.5 Å) in DMOF-1. The heat of adsorption of CO2 on ZnBD was calculated to be ∼22 kJ/mol at zero coverage. Attempts to functionalize the Kagome lattice proved to be unsuccessful but instead resulted in a new method for producing functionalized DMOF-1 at room temperature. This was hypothesized to be a result of the steric effects imposed by the functional groups that prevent the formation of the Kagome lattice.

Does Chemical Engineering Research Have a Reproducibility Problem?

Concerns have been raised in multiple scientific fields in recent years about the reproducibility of published results. Systematic efforts to examine this issue have been undertaken in biomedicine and psychology, but less is known about this important issue in the materials-oriented research that underpins much of modern chemical engineering. Here, we relate a dramatic historical episode from our own institution to illustrate the implications of performing reproducible research and describe two case studies based on literature analysis to provide concrete information on the reproducibility of modern materials-oriented research. The two case studies deal with the properties of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), a class of materials that have generated tens of thousands of papers. We do not claim that research on MOFs is less (or more) reproducible than other subfields; rather, we argue that the characteristics of this subfield are common to many areas of materials-oriented research. We conclude with specific recommendations for action by individual researchers, journal editors, publishers, and research communities.

Probing Metal-Organic Framework Design for Adsorptive Natural Gas Purification.

Parent and amine-functionalized analogues of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), UiO-66(Zr), MIL-125(Ti), and MIL-101(Cr), were evaluated for their hydrogen sulfide (H2S) adsorption efficacy and post-exposure acid gas stability. Adsorption experiments were conducted through fixed-bed breakthrough studies utilizing multicomponent 1% H2S/99% CH4 and 1% H2S/10% CO2/89% CH4 natural gas simulant mixtures. Instability of MIL-101(Cr) materials after H2S exposure was discovered through powder X-ray diffraction and porosity measurements following adsorbent pelletization, whereas other materials retained their characteristic properties. Linker-based amine functionalities increased H2S breakthrough times and saturation capacities from their parent MOF analogues. Competitive CO2 adsorption effects were mitigated in mesoporous MIL-101(Cr) and MIL-101-NH2(Cr), in comparison to microporous UiO-66(Zr) and MIL-125(Ti) frameworks. This result suggests that the installation of H2S binding sites in large-pore MOFs could potentially enhance H2S selectivity. In situ Fourier transform infrared measurements in 10% CO2 and 5000 ppm H2S environments suggest that framework hydroxyl and amine moieties serve as H2S physisorption sites. Results from this study elucidate design strategies and stability considerations for engineering MOFs in sour gas purification applications.

Structured Growth of Metal-Organic Framework MIL-53(Al) from Solid Aluminum Carbide Precursor.

The conventional synthesis of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) through soluble metal-salt precursors provides little control over the growth of MOF crystals. The use of alternative metal precursors would provide a more flexible and cost-effective strategy for direction- and shape-controlled MOF synthesis. Here, we demonstrate for the first time the use of insoluble metal-carbon matrices to foster directed growth of MOFs. Aluminum carbide was implemented as both the metal precursor and growth-directing agent for the generation of MIL-53(Al). A unique needle-like morphology of the MOF was grown parallel to the bulk surface in a layer-by-layer manner. Importantly, the synthesis scheme was found to be transferrable to the production of different linker analogues of the MOF and other topologies. Given the variety of metal carbides available, these findings can be used as a blueprint for controlled, efficient, and economical MOF syntheses and set a new milestone toward the industrial use of MOFs at large-scale.

Flexible Force Field Parameterization through Fitting on the Ab Initio-Derived Elastic Tensor.

Constructing functional forms and their corresponding force field parameters for the metal-linker interface of metal-organic frameworks is challenging. We propose fitting these parameters on the elastic tensor, computed from ab initio density functional theory calculations. The advantage of this top-down approach is that it becomes evident if functional forms are missing when components of the elastic tensor are off. As a proof-of-concept, a new flexible force field for MIL-47(V) is derived. Negative thermal expansion is observed and framework flexibility has a negligible effect on adsorption and transport properties for small guest molecules. We believe that this force field parametrization approach can serve as a useful tool for developing accurate flexible force field models that capture the correct mechanical behavior of the full periodic structure.

Monolith-Supported Amine-Functionalized Mg2(dobpdc) Adsorbents for CO2 Capture.

The potential of using an amine-functionalized metal organic framework (MOF), mmen-M2(dobpdc) (M = Mg and Mn), supported on a structured monolith contactor for CO2 capture from simulated flue gas is explored. The stability of the unsupported MOF powders under humid conditions is explored using nitrogen physisorption and X-ray diffraction analysis before and after exposure to humidity. Based on its superior stability to humidity, mmen-Mg2(dobpdc) is selected for further growth on a honeycomb cordierite monolith that is wash-coated with α-alumina. A simple approach for the synthesis of an Mg2(dobpdc) MOF film using MgO nanoparticles as the metal precursor is used. Rapid drying of MgO on the monolith surface followed by a hydrothermal treatment is demonstrated to allow for the synthesis of a MOF film with good crystallite density and favorable orientation of the MOF crystals. The CO2 adsorption behavior of the monolith-supported mmen-Mg2(dobpdc) material is assessed using 10% CO2 in helium and 100% CO2, demonstrating a CO2 uptake of 2.37 and 2.88 mmol/g, respectively. Excellent cyclic adsorption/desorption performance over multiple cycles is also observed. This is one of the first examples of the deployment of an advanced MOF adsorbent in a scalable, low-pressure drop gas-solid contactor. Such demonstrations are critical to the practical application of MOF materials in adsorptive gas separations, as structured contactors have many practical advantages over packed or fluidized beds.

Predicting Multicomponent Adsorption Isotherms in Open-Metal Site Materials Using Force Field Calculations Based on Energy Decomposed Density Functional Theory.

For the design of adsorptive-separation units, knowledge is required of the multicomponent adsorption behavior. Ideal adsorbed solution theory (IAST) breaks down for olefin adsorption in open-metal site (OMS) materials due to non-ideal donor-acceptor interactions. Using a density-function-theory-based energy decomposition scheme, we develop a physically justifiable classical force field that incorporates the missing orbital interactions using an appropriate functional form. Our first-principles derived force field shows greatly improved quantitative agreement with the inflection points, initial uptake, saturation capacity, and enthalpies of adsorption obtained from our in-house adsorption experiments. While IAST fails to make accurate predictions, our improved force field model is able to correctly predict the multicomponent behavior. Our approach is also transferable to other OMS structures, allowing the accurate study of their separation performances for olefins/paraffins and further mixtures involving complex donor-acceptor interactions.