Comprehensive characterization and optimization of Caco-2 cells enabled the development of a miniaturized 96-well permeability assay.

Assessment of compound permeability through a Caco-2 cell monolayer is a well-accepted model to evaluate its in-vivo permeability potential and transporter interaction. While this assay has commonly been conducted using a 24-well assay plate format, a miniaturised 96-well assay format is highly desirable to achieve greater capacity and higher efficiency.Previous attempts to convert this assay from 24-well to 96-well format at our lab, however, had met with varied efflux capacities and unacceptable efflux ratios for digoxin, a substrate of P-glycoprotein (Pgp), which indicated inadequate Pgp transporter expression in the 96-well format.These challenges in converting the assays were attributed to the heterogeneous and unstable nature of the Caco-2 cells. To overcome the challenges, single-cell sorting of Caco-2 cells was conducted by flow cytometry to obtain a more homogeneous and stable cell population. The sorted cells were then seeded to 96-well transwell plates and the Pgp expression under various cell culture conditions was monitored by a LC-MS/MS-based targeted proteomics method.Through cell sorting and direct Pgp expression measurement, Caco-2 cells with adequate and sustained Pgp expression in a 96-well format were obtained, which led to the successful development and implementation of a 96-well Caco-2 assay with significant efficiency gain and faster turnaround time than the historical 24-well assay.

Microscale purification in support of high-throughput medicinal chemistry.

In recent years, successful assay miniaturization has enabled the exploration of synthesis scale reduction in pharmaceutical discovery. Miniaturization of pharmaceutical synthesis and purification allows a reduction in material consumption and shortens timelines, which ultimately reduces the cost per experiment without compromising data quality. Isolating and purifying the compounds of interest is a key step in the library synthesis process. In this manuscript we describe a high-throughput purification workflow in support of microscale (1-5 µmol or 0.5-2 mg) library synthesis. The optimized microscale purification system can routinely purify 384-well reaction plates with an analysis time of 4 min per sample. Instrument optimization, critical parameters such as column loading, delay time calibration, ultrafast pre- and post-purification analysis and library purification examples are provided.

Rapid Compound Integrity Assessment for High-Throughput Screening Hit Triaging.

Hits from high-throughput screening (HTS) assays are typically evaluated using cheminformatics and/or empirical approaches before a decision for follow-up (activity confirmation and/or sample resynthesis) is made. However, the compound integrity (i.e., identity and purity) of these hits often remains largely unknown at this stage, since many compounds in the screening collection could undergo various changes such as degradation, polymerization, and precipitation during storage over time. When compound integrity is actually assessed for HTS hits postassay to address this issue, the process often increases the overall cycle time by weeks due to the reacquisition of the samples and the lengthy liquid chromatography-ultraviolet/mass spectrometric analysis time. Here we present a novel approach where compound integrity data are collected concurrently with the concentration-response curve (CRC) stage of HTS, with both assays occurring either in parallel on two distributions from the same liquid sample or serially using the original source liquid sample. The rapid generation of compound integrity data has been enabled by a high-speed ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography-ultraviolet/mass spectrometric platform capable of analyzing ~2000 samples per instrument per week. From this parallel approach, both compound integrity and CRC potency results for screening hits become available to medicinal chemists at the same time, which has greatly enhanced the decision-making process for hit follow-up and progression. In addition, the compound integrity results from recent hits provide a real-time and representative "snapshot" of the sample integrity of the entire compound collection, and the data can be used for in-depth analyses of the screening collection.

Enabling direct and definitive free fraction determination for highly-bound compounds in protein binding assay.

Protein binding determination for highly-bound compounds using equilibrium dialysis remains a challenge in drug discovery. The reasons are mainly three-fold; 1. due to their slow diffusion rate, highly-bound compounds require a much longer incubation time to reach dialysis equilibrium than typically needed; 2. highly-bound compounds are often hydrophobic and prone to non-specific binding in dialysis; 3. free drug concentration in the post incubation dialysate is too low for reliable analytical quantification. Modified equilibrium dialysis approaches include using diluted plasma for dialysis, or pre-saturating the non-specific binding sites in the dialysis device with compounds of interest prior to dialysis. In this study, we developed a customized equilibrium dialysis assay with an extended incubation time of 24 h, followed by microflow (µF) LC-MS/MS for bioanalysis, for direct and definitive free fraction determination of highly protein-bound compounds. The extended incubation time ensured the dialysis to reach equilibrium and saturating the non-specific binding sites, while µFLC-MS/MS provided far better sensitivity than the conventional LC-MS/MS typically used for post incubation bioanalysis. For a group of commercially available, highly protein-bound compounds, the free fraction data generated by the developed assay correlated very well with the literature values generated with diluted plasma method or pre-saturation method. This novel assay approach has been successfully used to generate protein binding results for highly-bound compounds to support ongoing drug discovery research.

Acoustic Ejection/Full-Scan Mass Spectrometry Analysis for High-Throughput Compound Quality Control.

High-throughput analysis of compound dissolved in DMSO and arrayed in multiwell plates for quality control (QC) purposes has widespread utility in drug discovery, ranging from the QC of assay-ready plates dispatched by compound management, to compound integrity check in the screening collection, to reaction monitoring of chemical syntheses in microtiter plates. Due to the large number of samples (thousands per batch) involved, these workflows can put a significant burden on the liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) platform typically used. To achieve the required speed of seconds per sample, several chromatography-free MS approaches have previously been used with mixed results. In this study, we demonstrated the feasibility of acoustic ejection-mass spectrometry (AE-MS) in full-scan mode for high-throughput compound QC in miniaturized formats, featuring direct, contactless liquid sampling, minimal sample consumption, and ultrafast analytical speed. The sample consumption and analysis time by AE-MS represent, respectively, a 1000-fold and 30-fold reduction compared with LC-MS. In qualitative QC, AE-MS generated comparable results to conventional LC-MS in identifying the presence and absence of expected compounds. AE-MS also demonstrated its utility in relative quantifications of the same compound in serial dilution plates, or substrate in chemical synthesis. To facilitate the processing of a large amount of data generated by AE-MS, we have developed a data processing platform using commercially available tools. The platform demonstrated fast and straightforward data extraction, reviewing, and reporting, thus eliminating the need for the development of custom data processing tools. The overall AE-MS workflow has effectively eliminated the analytical bottleneck in the high-throughput compound QC work stream.

Ultrahigh-Throughput and Chromatography-Free Bioanalysis of Polar Analytes with Acoustic Ejection Mass Spectrometry.

Bioanalysis of polar analytes using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) remains a significant challenge because of their poor chromatographic retention on the commonly used reversed-phase LC columns and the resulting severe ionization suppression from coeluting matrix components. Here we present a novel approach to perform ultrahigh-throughput and chromatography-free bioanalysis of polar compounds using a prototype acoustic ejection mass spectrometer (AEMS) platform. Previously developed for direct analysis of solid or liquid samples by MS, the open port interface (OPI) has recently been modified and coupled to an acoustic nanoliter dispenser to enable high-speed direct MS analysis from 384-well plates with a reported speed as fast as 0.5 s/sample. Ionization suppression was reduced due to the >1000 fold dilution of the original sample by the carrier solvent in the AE-OPI-MS operation. Taking full advantage of the chromatography-free and suppression-reducing features of this prototype instrument, we successfully demonstrated the ultrahigh-throughput bioanalysis of metformin, a small polar substrate commonly used in high-throughput in vitro transporter inhibition assays in the early ADME profiling space in drug discovery. The AEMS platform achieved a speed of 2.2 s/sample using only 10 nL of sample volume. Similar bioanalytical and biological results from actual assay samples were obtained by AEMS when compared to those obtained by the fastest LC-MS/MS method previously reported, along with a 15-fold speed advantage and ∼500-fold less sample consumption to enable future assay miniaturization. The general applicability of this novel approach to bioanalysis of several classes of polar analytes including ethambutol, isoniazid, ephedrine, and gemcitabine in biological matrices was further demonstrated.

Optimization of microflow LC-MS/MS and its utility in quantitative discovery bioanalysis.

Aim: The sensitivity advantage of microflow LC (µFLC)-MS/MS is potentially impactful for challenging compounds not detectable by conventional flow LC-MS/MS in drug discovery bioanalysis. Relatively new to µFLC technology, discovery bioanalytical scientists would benefit from an effective strategy for method development and optimization. Results: A systematic µFLC-MS/MS method optimization approach was developed in this study. With optimized conditions, µFLC-MS/MS demonstrated an improved sensitivity compared with conventional LC-MS/MS analysis, ranging from 6× to 49× (by peak area) depending on the compounds, with acceptable analytical performance and robustness. The optimized conditions demonstrated universal applicability to various compounds of diverse properties. Conclusion: The systematic method optimization strategy, and the general applicability of the optimized conditions could facilitate the routine utilization of µFLC in quantitative discovery bioanalysis.

Addition of Optimized Bovine Serum Albumin Level in a High-Throughput Caco-2 Assay Enabled Accurate Permeability Assessment for Lipophilic Compounds.

The Caco-2 permeability assay is a well-accepted in vitro model to evaluate compounds' potential for oral absorption at early discovery. However, for many lipophilic compounds, no meaningful Caco-2 data could be generated due to their low solubility in assay buffer and/or poor recovery from the assay. In our previous study, we reported an organic catch approach to improve compound recovery. To further reduce compound loss and increase solubility in aqueous buffer, we explored the addition of bovine serum albumin (BSA). However, in contrast to the commonly used BSA level at 4%, a lower level of BSA was selected in an effort to minimize the potential risk of missing the identification of efflux substrates, and to avoid the extensive sample cleanup needed for 4% BSA. Through a systematic evaluation, it was found that 0.5% BSA was effective in enhancing compound solubility and reducing nonspecific binding, which allowed reliable assessment of the permeability and efflux potential for lipophilic compounds. Also, with an optimized sample handling process, no extra sample cleanup was required before liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) analysis. The implementation of this assay has enabled accurate permeability assessment for compounds that had poor solubility and/or poor mass balance under the non-BSA assay conditions.

HPLC biogram analysis: a powerful tool used for hit confirmation in early drug discovery.

High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) biogram methodology is a powerful pharmaceutical screening hit confirmation strategy that couples analytical HPLC data with functional bioassay data. It is used primarily for screening hit chemical validation and triaging in support of early phase discovery programs and enables further investigation of the source of bioactivity in screening hits. The process combines semi-preparative separation technologies, automated compound handling and distribution, high-throughput biological screening, and informatics tools. The final output is an HPLC retention time versus bioactivity graphical overlay report. In this manner, biograms allow the analyst to determine which component in the sample is responsible for the biological activity, enabling decision making toward chemotype selection and prioritization from a pool of potential candidates. Another powerful aspect of the biogram assay lies in its utility in investigating biological activity in atypical samples, such as degraded samples or mixtures, for detection of minor active impurities or in addressing lot-to-lot activity discrepancies for a given test compound. Biograms are employed to track, isolate, and identify the source of biological activity in such samples, often yielding important information for program decisions.

Development of an LC-MS/MS method for high throughput quantification of metformin uptake in transporter inhibition assays.

A high throughput LC-MS/MS method for quantification of metformin substrate uptake enables conversion of radiometric transporter inhibition assays for multidrug and toxin extrusion transporters (MATE 1 and 2) and organic cation transporter 2 (OCT2) to a nonradioactive format. Such conversion greatly simplifies assay complexity and reduces assay costs. The development of a quantitative LC-MS/MS method for metformin in support of the high throughput transporter inhibition assays faced specific challenges of achieving both adequate chromatographic retention and rapid analytical turnaround. Here we report a method that circumvents both challenges. The utilization of a porous graphitic carbon column (Hypercarb) ensured adequate retention of highly polar metformin in biological samples. The combined employment of a ballistic gradient on a 3 mm × 30 mm, 5 µm Hypercarb column, and dual staggered chromatography coupled with multiple injection chromatography acquisition, yielded a fast injection-to-injection cycle time of 30s. The method demonstrated good accuracy, precision and excellent robustness for high throughput applications, and has been successfully implemented in the development and validation of the nonradioactive transporter inhibition assays for MATEs and OCT2.

Comparative assessment of achiral stationary phases for high throughput analysis in supercritical fluid chromatography.

Supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) using open bed fraction collection is becoming more widely used for purification of diverse collections of compounds for drug discovery. This application requires predictable chromatography on scale up from analytical to preparative conditions. We have discovered that the selectivities of many columns used for SFC change over time when ammonium acetate additive is present in the mobile phase as a result of changes in silanophilic interactions. This makes scale up predictions difficult. To address this challenge we have developed a nontraditional comprehensive column ranking. Our system is based on the long-term retention repeatability of basic drugs in ammonium acetate containing mobile phase. The decreases in retention over time were used as a measure of changing silanophilicity of the stationary phases and became the basis for a column ranking system. This system, along with results for 24 commonly used silica-based columns, is presented in this paper.

A high-speed liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry platform using multiplexed multiple-injection chromatography controlled by single software and its application in discovery ADME screening.

RATIONALE: Multiplexed liquid chromatography (LC) coupled with multiple-injection-chromatogram acquisition has emerged as the method of choice for high-speed discovery bioanalysis, because it significantly reduces injection-to-injection cycle time while maintaining the chromatography quality. Historically, systems utilizing this approach had been custom built, and therefore relied on custom software tools to communicate with multiple vendor software for system control, which lacked transferability, flexibility and robustness. METHODS: In this study, we refined a multiplexed bioanalytical system previously reported, by implementing open-deck auto-sampler manifold and multiple-injection-chromatogram acquisition, all on a commercially available system with single software control. RESULTS: As a result of these improvements, the developed LC/tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) method on the system was nearly three times faster than the previous method, while demonstrating comparable analytical accuracy, precision and robustness. This system has been evaluated for in vitro ADME screening assays including metabolic stability, CYP inhibition and Caco-2. The biological data generated on the developed system displayed good correlation with those from the previous LC/MS/MS approaches. CONCLUSIONS: The developed platform demonstrated applicability to the in vitro screening assays evaluated and has been successfully implemented to support the high-throughput metabolic stability assay, with a significantly improved bioanalytical throughput, capacity and data turnaround.

Comparison of chromatographic techniques for diastereomer separation of a diverse set of drug-like compounds.

Preparative supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) has proven value for isocratic bulk separation of both diastereomers and enantiomers. With the recent availability of SFC equipment suitable for rapid gradient separation [Ebinger et al. JALA (2011) 16 (3) 241], we have become interested in comparing the effectiveness of traditional reverse phase high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with SFC using non-chiral columns for the separation of diastereomeric mixtures. The success rates for separation of a diverse set of 258 synthetic diastereomer pairs were used to determine the relative utility of the aforementioned two techniques. Our results suggest that gradient non-chiral SFC was more successful than the traditional non-chiral HPLC technique for diastereomer separations of the diverse sample set of 258 drug-like compounds.

Addressing the medicinal chemistry bottleneck: a lean approach to centralized purification.

The use of standardized lean manufacturing principles to improve drug discovery productivity is often thought to be at odds with fostering innovation. This manuscript describes how selective implementation of a lean optimized process, in this case centralized purification for medicinal chemistry, can improve operational productivity and increase scientist time available for innovation. A description of the centralized purification process is provided along with both operational and impact (productivity) metrics, which indicate lower cost, higher output, and presumably more free time for innovation as a result of the process changes described.

Approach to improve compound recovery in a high-throughput Caco-2 permeability assay supported by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry.

The Caco-2 cell culture system is widely employed as an in vitro model for prediction of intestinal absorption of test compounds in early drug discovery. Poor recovery is a commonly encountered issue in Caco-2 assay, which can lead to difficulty in data interpretation and underestimation of the apparent permeability of affected compounds. In this study, we systematically investigated the potential sources of compound loss in our automated, high-throughput Caco-2 assay, sample storage, and analysis processes, and as a result found the nonspecific binding to various plastic surfaces to be the major cause of poor compound recovery. To minimize the nonspecific binding, we implemented a simple and practical approach in our assay automation by preloading collection plates with organic solvent containing internal standard prior to transferring incubations samples. The implementation of this new method has been shown to significantly increase recovery in many compounds previously identified as having poor recovery in the Caco-2 permeability assay. With improved recovery, permeability results were obtained for many compounds that were previously not detected in the basolateral samples. In addition to recovery improvement, this new approach also simplified sample preparation for liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometric analysis and therefore achieved time and cost savings for the bioanalyst.

Cassette incubation followed by bioanalysis using high-resolution MS for in vitro ADME screening assays.

BACKGROUND: High-resolution MS (HRMS) has recently received a considerable interest in quantitative bioanalysis using full-scan acquisition mode. The benefits include complete elimination of compound-specific MS method development, and simultaneous collection of mass spectral data on both targeted and non-targeted components. One additional advantage that has not been widely discussed is its suitability for simultaneous quantitation of, theoretically, an unlimited number of compounds, which is not possible with selected reaction monitoring (SRM) on a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer. MATERIALS & METHODS: We took advantage of this unique bioanalytical capability of HRMS and developed a novel in vitro ADME workflow of cassette incubation of as many as 32 compounds, followed by quantitative bioanalysis using full-scan acquisition on an Orbitrap HRMS. The workflow was evaluated for a serum protein-binding assay and a parallel artificial membrane permeability (PAMPA) assay. RESULTS: The bioanalytical assay displayed acceptable sensitivity, selectivity and linearity for all compounds in the cassettes, and the biological results obtained using this approach were similar to those from discrete incubation and analysis, demonstrating the feasibility of the workflow. Additional benefits of this platform include a saving of analysis time due to the reduced sample numbers from the cassette approach, as well as cost saving due to the reduction in the required assay reagents. CONCLUSION: Cassette incubation with bioanalysis using HRMS is a feasible approach for high-throughput in vitro ADME assays evaluated in this study.

Evaluation of a new preparative supercritical fluid chromatography system for compound library purification: the TharSFC SFC-MS Prep-100 system.

Preparative HPLC-MS is often the method of choice for purification of small amounts (<100mg) of diverse new molecules, such as compound libraries for drug discovery. The method is robust, well proven, and widely applicable. In contrast, preparative supercritical fluid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (SFC-MS) has seen only slow acceptance for the same application--despite some potential scientific and economic advantages. One of the reasons for slow adoption of SFC-MS is the lack of well-proven, robust, and commercially available instrumentation. In early 2009, TharSFC (a Waters Company, Pittsburgh, PA) introduced a new fully integrated system for preparative SFC-MS: The SFC-MS Prep-100. We report herein an objective evaluation of the SFC-MS Prep-100, including tests for pump and autosampler performance, sample recovery, sample carryover, fraction triggering, detector/fraction collector synchronization, and overall robustness. Our results suggest that the SFC-MS Prep-100 represents a significant advance over previous generation instrumentation.

Ultrafast mass spectrometry based bioanalytical method for digoxin supporting an in vitro P-glycoprotein (P-gp) inhibition screen.

The evaluation of interactions between drug candidates and transporters such as P-glycoprotein (P-gp) has gained considerable interest in drug discovery and development. Inhibition of P-gp can be assessed by performing bi-directional permeability studies with in vitro P-gp-expressing cellular model systems such as Caco-2 (human colon carcinoma) cells, using digoxin as a substrate probe. Existing methodologies include either assaying (3)H-digoxin with liquid scintillation counting (LSC) detection or assaying non-labeled digoxin with liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometric (LC-MS/MS) analysis at a speed of several minutes per sample. However, it is not feasible to achieve a throughput high enough using these approaches to sustain an early liability screen that generates more than a thousand samples on a daily basis. To address this challenge, we developed an ultrafast (9 s per sample) bioanalytical method for digoxin analysis using RapidFire™, an on-line solid-phase extraction (SPE) system, with MS/MS detection. A stable isotope labeled analog, d3-digoxin, was used as internal standard to minimize potential ionization matrix effect during the RF-MS/MS analysis. The RF-MS/MS method was more than 16 times faster than the LC-MS/MS method but demonstrated similar sensitivity, selectivity, reproducibility, linearity and robustness. P-gp inhibition results of multiple validation compounds obtained with this RF-MS/MS method were in agreement with those generated by both the LC-MS/MS method and the (3)H-radiolabel assay. This method has been successfully deployed to assess P-gp inhibition potential as an important early liability screen for drug-transporter interaction.

An integrated bioanalytical platform for supporting high-throughput serum protein binding screening.

Quantification of small molecules using liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry (LC/MS/MS) on a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer has become a common practice in bioanalytical support of in vitro adsorption, distribution, metabolism and excretion (ADME) screening. The bioanalysis process involves primarily three indispensable steps: MS/MS optimization for a large number of new chemical compounds undergoing various screening assays in early drug discovery, high-throughput sample analysis with LC/MS/MS for those chemically diverse compounds using the optimized MS/MS conditions, and post-acquisition data review and reporting. To improve overall efficiency of ADME bioanalysis, an integrated system was proposed featuring an automated and unattended MS/MS optimization, a staggered parallel LC/MS/MS for high-throughput sample analysis, and a sophisticated software tool for LC/MS/MS raw data review as well as biological data calculation and reporting. The integrated platform has been used in bioanalytical support of a serum protein binding screening assay with high speed, high capacity, and good robustness. In this new platform, a unique sample dilution scheme was also introduced. With this dilution design, the total number of analytical samples was reduced; therefore, the total operation time was reduced and the overall throughput was further improved. The performance of the protein binding screening assay was monitored with two controls representing high and low binding properties and an acceptable inter-assay consistency was achieved. This platform has been successfully used for the determination of serum protein binding in multiple species for more than 4000 compounds.

Orthogonality of SFC versus HPLC for small molecule library separation.

Preparative HPLC and HPLC-MS are well established as the methods of choice for purification of pharmaceutical library compounds. Recent advances in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) have now made SFC a viable alternative to HPLC for this application. One of the potential arguments for using SFC in place of, or in addition to, HPLC is that it may offer different selectivity and thus has the potential for improved separation success rates. In this paper, we examine relative success rates for SFC and HPLC in obtaining adequate selectivity for successful separation. Our results suggest that use of SFC in addition to HPLC may result in a slight (1-2%) improvement in success rate compared to use of HPLC alone.