Feasibility of Linear Irreversible Electroporation Ablation in the Coronary Sinus.

INTRODUCTION: Previous studies demonstrated that the coronary sinus (CS) is an important target for ablation in persistent atrial fibrillation. However, radiofrequency ablation in the CS is associated with coronary vessel damage and tamponade. Animal data suggest irreversible electroporation (IRE) ablation can be a safe ablation modality in vicinity of coronary arteries. We investigated the feasibility of IRE in the CS in a porcine model. METHODS: Ablation and pacing was performed in the CS in six pigs (weight 60-75 kg) using a modified 9-French steerable linear hexapolar Tip-Versatile Ablation Catheter. Pacing maneuvers were performed from distal to proximal segments of the CS to assess atrial capture thresholds before and after IRE application. IRE ablations were performed with 100 J IRE pulses. After 3-week survival animals were euthanized and histological sections from the CS were analyzed. RESULTS: A total of 27 IRE applications in six animals were performed. Mean peak voltage was 1509 ± 36 V, with a mean peak current of 22.9 ± 1.0 A. No complications occurred during procedure and 3-week survival. At 30 min post ablation 100% isolation was achieved in all animals. At 3 weeks follow-up pacing thresholds were significant higher as compared to baseline. Histological analysis showed transmural ablation lesions in muscular sleeves surrounding the CS. CONCLUSION: IRE ablation of the musculature along the CS using a multi-electrode catheter is feasible in a porcine model.

Multielectrode Contact Measurement Can Improve Long-Term Outcome of Pulmonary Vein Isolation Using Circular Single-Pulse Electroporation Ablation.

BACKGROUND: Irreversible electroporation (IRE) ablation is generally performed with multielectrode catheters. Electrode-tissue contact is an important predictor for the success of pulmonary vein (PV) isolation; however, contact force is difficult to measure with multielectrode ablation catheters. In a preclinical study, we assessed the feasibility of a multielectrode impedance system (MEIS) as a predictor of long-term success of PV isolation. In addition, we present the first-in-human clinical experience with MEIS. METHODS: In 10 pigs, one PV was ablated based on impedance (MEIS group), and the other PV was solely based on local electrogram information (EP group). IRE ablations were performed at 200 J. After 3 months, recurrence of conduction was assessed. Subsequently, in 30 patients undergoing PV isolation with IRE, MEIS was evaluated and MEIS contact values were compared to local electrograms. RESULTS: In the porcine study, 43 IRE applications were delivered in 19 PVs. Acutely, no reconnections were observed in either group. After 3 months, 0 versus 3 (P=0.21) PVs showed conduction recurrence in the MEIS and EP groups, respectively. Results from the clinical study showed a significant linear relation was found between mean MEIS value and bipolar dV/dt (r2=0.49, P<0.001), with a slope of 20.6 mV/s per Ohm. CONCLUSIONS: Data from the animal study suggest that MEIS values predict effective IRE applications. For the long-term success of electrical PV isolation with circular IRE applications, no significant difference in efficacy was found between ablation based on the measurement of electrode interface impedance and ablation using the classical EP approach for determining electrode-tissue contact. Experiences of the first clinical use of MEIS were promising and serve as an important basis for future research.

Characteristics and time course of acute and chronic myocardial lesion formation after electroporation ablation in the porcine model.

INTRODUCTION: Electroporation ablation creates deep and wide myocardial lesions. No data are available on time course and characteristics of acute lesion formation. METHODS: For the acute phase of myocardial lesion development, seven pigs were investigated. Single 200 J applications were delivered at four different epicardial right ventricular sites using a linear suction device, yielding a total of 28 lesions. Timing of applications was designed to yield lesions at seven time points: 0, 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, and 60 min, with four lesions per time point. After killing, lesion characteristics were histologically investigated. For the chronic phase of myocardial lesion development, tissue samples were used from previously conducted studies where tissue was obtained at 3 weeks and 3 months after electroporation ablation. RESULTS: Acute myocardial lesions induce a necrosis pattern with contraction band necrosis and interstitial edema, immediately present after electroporation ablation. No further histological changes such as hemorrhage or influx of inflammatory cells occurred in the first hour. After 3 weeks, the lesions consisted of sharply demarcated loose connective tissue that further developed to more fibrotic scar tissue after 3 months without additional changes. Within the scar tissue, arteries and nerves were unaffected. CONCLUSION: Electroporation ablation immediately induces contraction band necrosis and edema without additional tissue changes in the first hour. After 3 weeks, a sharply demarked scar has been developed that remains stable during follow-up of 3 months. This is highly relevant for clinical application of electroporation ablation in terms of the electrophysiological endpoint and waiting period after ablation.

Comparison of In Vivo Tissue Temperature Profile and Lesion Geometry for Radiofrequency Ablation With High Power-Short Duration and Moderate Power-Moderate Duration: Effects of Thermal Latency and Contact Force on Lesion Formation.

[Figure: see text].

Efficacy of multi-electrode linear irreversible electroporation.

AIMS: We investigated the efficacy of linear multi-electrode irreversible electroporation (IRE) ablation in a porcine model. METHODS AND RESULTS: The study was performed in six pigs (weight 60-75 kg). After median sternotomy and opening of the pericardium, a pericardial cradle was formed and filled with blood. A linear seven polar 7-Fr electrode catheter with 2.5 mm electrodes and 2.5 mm inter-electrode spacing was placed in good contact with epicardial tissue. A single IRE application was delivered using 50 J at one site and 100 J at two other sites, in random sequence, using a standard monophasic defibrillator connected to all seven electrodes connected in parallel. The pericardium and thorax were closed and after 3 weeks survival animals were euthanized. A total of 82 histological sections from all 18 electroporation lesions were analysed. A total of seven 50 J and fourteen 100 J epicardial IRE applications were performed. Mean peak voltages at 50 and 100 J were 1079.2 V ± 81.1 and 1609.5 V ± 56.8, with a mean peak current of 15.4 A ± 2.3 and 20.2 A ± 1.7, respectively. Median depth of the 50 and 100 J lesions were 3.2 mm [interquartile range (IQR) 3.1-3.6] and 5.5 mm (IQR 4.6-6.6) (P < 0.001), respectively. Median lesion width of the 50 and 100 J lesions was 3.9 mm (IQR 3.7-4.8) and 5.4 mm (IQR 5.0-6.3), respectively (P < 0.001). Longitudinal sections showed continuous lesions for 100 J applications. CONCLUSION: Epicardial multi-electrode linear application of IRE pulses is effective in creating continuous deep lesions.

In vivo analysis of the origin and characteristics of gaseous microemboli during catheter-mediated irreversible electroporation.

AIMS: Irreversible electroporation (IRE) ablation is a non-thermal ablation method based on the application of direct current between a multi-electrode catheter and skin electrode. The delivery of current through blood leads to electrolysis. Some studies suggest that gaseous (micro)emboli might be associated with myocardial damage and/or (a)symptomatic cerebral ischaemic events. The aim of this study was to compare the amount of gas generated during IRE ablation and during radiofrequency (RF) ablation. METHODS AND RESULTS: In six 60-75 kg pigs, an extracorporeal femoral shunt was outfitted with a bubble-counter to detect the size and total volume of gas bubbles. Anodal and cathodal 200 J IRE applications were delivered in the left atrium (LA) using a 14-electrode circular catheter. The 30 and 60 s 40 W RF point-by-point ablations were performed. Using transoesophageal echocardiography (TOE), gas formation was visualized. Average gas volumes were 0.6 ± 0.6 and 56.9 ± 19.1 µL (P < 0.01) for each anodal and cathodal IRE application, respectively. Also, qualitative TOE imaging showed significantly less LA bubble contrast with anodal than with cathodal applications. Radiofrequency ablations produced 1.7 ± 2.9 and 6.7 ± 7.4 µL of gas, for 30 and 60 s ablation time, respectively. CONCLUSION: Anodal IRE applications result in significantly less gas formation than both cathodal IRE applications and RF applications. This finding is supported by TOE observations.

Pulmonary Vein Isolation With Single Pulse Irreversible Electroporation: A First in Human Study in 10 Patients With Atrial Fibrillation.

BACKGROUND: Irreversible electroporation (IRE) is a promising new nonthermal ablation technology for pulmonary vein (PV) isolation in patients with atrial fibrillation. Experimental data suggest that IRE ablation produces large enough lesions without the risk of PV stenosis, artery, nerve, or esophageal damage. This study aimed to investigate the feasibility and safety of single pulse IRE PV isolation in patients with atrial fibrillation. METHODS: Ten patients with symptomatic paroxysmal or persistent atrial fibrillation underwent single pulse IRE PV isolation under general anesthesia. Three-dimensional reconstruction and electroanatomical voltage mapping (EnSite Precision, Abbott) of left atrium and PVs were performed using a conventional circular mapping catheter. PV isolation was performed by delivering nonarcing, nonbarotraumatic 6 ms, 200 J direct current IRE applications via a custom nondeflectable 14-polar circular IRE ablation catheter with a variable hoop diameter (16-27 mm). A deflectable sheath (Agilis, Abbott) was used to maneuver the ablation catheter. A minimum of 2 IRE applications with slightly different catheter positions were delivered per vein to achieve circular tissue contact, even if PV potentials were abolished after the first application. Bidirectional PV isolation was confirmed with the circular mapping catheter and a post ablation voltage map. After a 30-minute waiting period, adenosine testing (30 mg) was used to reveal dormant PV conduction. RESULTS: All 40 PVs could be successfully isolated with a mean of 2.4±0.4 IRE applications per PV. Mean delivered peak voltage and peak current were 2154±59 V and 33.9±1.6 A, respectively. No PV reconnections occurred during the waiting period and adenosine testing. No periprocedural complications were observed. CONCLUSIONS: In the 10 patients of this first-in-human study, acute bidirectional electrical PV isolation could be achieved safely by single pulse IRE ablation.

In vitro analysis of the origin and characteristics of gaseous microemboli during catheter electroporation ablation.

INTRODUCTION: Recent studies demonstrated that irreversible electroporation (IRE) ablation may be an alternative method for thermal ablation for pulmonary vein isolation. Development of gaseous microemboli during catheter ablation might lead to asymptomatic ischemic events and is therefore an important research topic. Gas formation during arcing with direct current catheter ablation has been studied in the past, however not for nonarcing IRE-ablation. OBJECTIVE: The aim of the present study was to visualize, quantify, and characterize gas formation during nonarcing millisecond IRE-pulses using a multielectrode circular catheter. METHODS: In vitro, gas formation during IRE-pulses was studied using a high-speed imaging, direct volume measurements, and a bubble counter. Gas formation was compared between cathodal and anodal IRE-pulses and between a small and large catheter hoop diameter. RESULTS: High-speed images showed the location and dynamics of gas formation during cathodal and anodal millisecond IRE-pulses. The direct volume measurements demonstrated a significantly larger volume for cathodal than for anodal IRE-pulses (P < .001), and no significant difference between small and large hoop diameters. A strong linear relationship was found between delivered charge and total gas volume (r = 0.99). Bubble counter measurements showed that cathodal IRE-pulses produced more and larger gas bubbles than anodal IRE-pulses. The ratio of total gas volume between cathodal and anodal IRE-pulses is different as predicted from electrolysis theory. CONCLUSION: In vitro, millisecond anodal IRE-pulses produce significantly less and smaller gas bubbles than millisecond cathodal IRE-pulses. In vivo experiments are required to investigate the clinical implication of these observations.

High-frequency irreversible electroporation for cardiac ablation using an asymmetrical waveform.

BACKGROUND: Irreversible electroporation (IRE) using direct current (DC) is an effective method for the ablation of cardiac tissue. A major drawback of the use of DC-IRE, however, are two problems: requirement of general anesthesia due to severe muscle contractions and the formation of bubbles containing gaseous products from electrolysis. The use of high-frequency alternating current (HF-IRE) is expected to solve both problems, because HF-IRE produces little to no muscle spasms and does not cause electrolysis. METHODS: In the present study, we introduce a novel asymmetric, high-frequency (aHF) waveform for HF-IRE and present the results of a first, small, animal study to test its efficacy. RESULTS: The data of the experiments suggest that the aHF waveform creates significantly deeper lesions than a symmetric HF waveform of the same energy and frequency (p = 0.003). CONCLUSION: We therefore conclude that the use of the aHF enhances the feasibility of the HF-IRE method.

Electroporation and its Relevance for Cardiac Catheter Ablation.

Irreversible electroporation can be used as a nonthermal energy source to ablate tissue. Cardiac catheter ablation by irreversible electroporation may be a safe and effective alternative for thermal ablation techniques such as radiofrequency or cryoablation. Total applied current, not delivered power (watts), energy (joules), or voltage, is the parameter that most directly relates to the local voltage gradient that causes electroporation. Electroporation can be achieved with various modalities: direct current, alternating current, pulsed direct current, or any combination of these. Experimental cardiac and noncardiac studies have demonstrated tissue specificity with survival of arteries and nerves in large lesions. In addition, porcine data suggest that application inside a pulmonary vein does not lead to pulmonary vein stenosis and that the esophagus is remarkably insensitive to electroporation. Therefore, irreversible electroporation is a very promising technique for cardiac catheter ablation and especially for electrical pulmonary vein isolation.

Novel method for electrode-tissue contact measurement with multi-electrode catheters.

Aims: With multi-electrode catheters, measuring contact force (CF) on each electrode is technically challenging. Present electrical methods, like the electrical coupling index (ECI) may yield false positive values in pulmonary veins. We developed a novel method that measures electrode-interface resistance (IR) by applying a very local electrical field between neighbouring catheter electrodes while measuring voltage between each catheter electrode and a skin patch. The aim of this study was to evaluate the new IR method to measure electrode-tissue contact. Methods and results: In vitro, effects of remote high-impedance structures were studied. In addition, both ECI and IR were directly compared with true electrode-tissue CF. In five pigs, the influence of high-impedance pulmonary tissue on ECI and IR was investigated while navigating the free floating catheter into the caval veins. Inside the left atrium (LA), IR was directly compared with CF. Finally, multi-electrode IR measurements in the LA and inferior pulmonary vein (IPV) were compared. In vitro, IR is much less affected by remote high-impedance structures than ECI (3% vs. 32%). Both IR and ECI strongly relate to electrode-tissue CF (r2 = 0.84). In vivo, and in contrast to ECI, IR was not affected by nearby pulmonary tissue. Inside the LA, a strong relation between IR and CF was found. This finding was confirmed by simultaneous multi-electrode measurements in LA and IPV. Conclusion: Data of the present study suggest that electrode-tissue contact affects the IR while being highly insensitive to remote structures. This method facilitates electrode-tissue contact measurements with circular multi-electrode ablation catheters.

Clinical and pathological outcomes after irreversible electroporation of the pancreas using two parallel plate electrodes: a porcine model.

BACKGROUND: Irreversible electroporation (IRE) by inserting needles around the tumor as treatment for locally advanced pancreatic cancer entails several disadvantages, such as incomplete ablation due to field inhomogeneity, technical difficulties in needle placement and a risk of pancreatic fistula development. This experimental study evaluates outcomes of IRE using paddles in a porcine model. METHODS: Six healthy pigs underwent laparotomy and were treated with 2 separate ablations (in head and tail of the pancreas). Follow-up consisted of clinical and laboratory parameters and contrast-enhanced computed tomography (ceCT) imaging. After 2 weeks, pancreatoduodenectomy was performed for histology and the pigs were terminated. RESULTS: All animals survived 14 days. None of the animals developed signs of infection or significant abdominal distention. Serum amylase and lipase peaked at day 1 postoperatively in all pigs, but normalized without signs of pancreatitis. On ceCT-imaging the ablation zone was visible as an ill-defined, hypodense lesion. No abscesses, cysts or ascites were seen. Histology showed a homogenous fibrotic lesion in all pigs. CONCLUSION: IRE ablation of healthy porcine pancreatic tissue using two plate electrodes is feasible and safe and creates a homogeneous fibrotic lesion. IRE-paddles should be tested on pancreatic adenocarcinoma to determine the effect in cancer tissue.

Acute and Long-Term Effects of Full-Power Electroporation Ablation Directly on the Porcine Esophagus.

BACKGROUND: Esophageal ulceration and fistula are complications of pulmonary vein isolation using thermal energy sources. Irreversible electroporation is a novel, nonthermal ablation modality for pulmonary vein isolation. A single 200 J application can create deep myocardial lesions. Acute and chronic effects of this new energy source on the esophagus are unknown. METHODS AND RESULTS: In 8 pigs (±70 kg), the suprasternal esophagus was surgically exposed. A linear suction device with a single 35-mm long and 6-mm wide protruding linear electrode inside a plastic suction cup was used for ablation. Single, nonarcing, nonbarotraumatic, cathodal 100 and 200 J applications were delivered at 2 different sites on the anterior esophageal adventitia. No proton-pump inhibitors were administered during follow-up. Esophagoscopy was performed at days 2 and 7. After euthanasia at day 60, the esophagus was evaluated visually and histologically. All ablations were uneventful. Esophagoscopy at day 2 showed small white densities in the ablated areas, which appeared to be small intraepithelial vesicles. No epithelial erythema, erosions, or ulcerations were seen. At day 7, all densities had disappeared, and all esophaguses appeared completely normalized. After euthanasia, there were no macroscopically visible lesions on the adventitia or epithelium. Histologically, a small scar was observed at the outer part of the muscular layer, whereas the mucosa and submucosa were normal. CONCLUSIONS: Esophageal architecture remains unaffected 2 months after irreversible electroporation, purposely targeting the adventitia. Irreversible electroporation seems to be a safe modality for catheter ablation near the esophagus.

Irreversible Electroporation of the Pancreas Using Parallel Plate Electrodes in a Porcine Model: A Feasibility Study.

BACKGROUND: Irreversible electroporation (IRE) with needle electrodes is being explored as treatment option in locally advanced pancreatic cancer. Several studies have shown promising results with IRE needles, positioned around the tumor to achieve tumor ablation. Disadvantages are the technical difficulties for needle placement, the time needed to achieve tumor ablation, the risk of needle track seeding and most important the possible occurrence of postoperative pancreatic fistula via the needle tracks. The aim of this experimental study was to evaluate the feasibility of a new IRE-technique using two parallel plate electrodes, in a porcine model. METHODS: Twelve healthy pigs underwent laparotomy. The pancreas was mobilized to enable positioning of the paddles. A standard monophasic external cardiac defibrillator was used to perform an ablation in 3 separate parts of the pancreas; either a single application of 50 or 100J or a serial application of 4x50J. After 6 hours, pancreatectomy was performed for histology and pigs were terminated. RESULTS: Histology showed necrosis of pancreatic parenchyma with neutrophil influx in 5/12, 11/12 and 12/12 of the ablated areas at 50, 100, and 4x50J respectively. The electric current density threshold to achieve necrosis was 4.3, 5.1 and 3.4 A/cm2 respectively. The ablation threshold was significantly lower for the serial compared to the single applications (p = 0.003). The content of the ablated areas differed between the applications: areas treated with a single application of 50 J often contained vital areas without obvious necrosis, whereas half of the sections treated with 100 J showed small islands of normal looking cells surrounded by necrosis, while all sections receiving 4x 50 J showed a homogeneous necrotic lesion. CONCLUSION: Pancreatic tissue can be successfully ablated using two parallel paddles around the tissue. A serial application of 4x50J was most effective in creating a homogeneous necrotic lesion.

Low vulnerability of the right phrenic nerve to electroporation ablation.

BACKGROUND: Circular electroporation ablation is a novel ablation modality for electrical pulmonary vein isolation. With a single 200-J application, deep circular myocardial lesions can be created. However, the acute and chronic effects of this energy source on phrenic nerve (PN) function are unknown. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to analyze nerve vulnerability to electroporation ablation in a porcine model. METHODS: In 20 animals (60-75 kg), the course of the right PN was pace-mapped inside the superior caval vein (SCV). Thereafter, a single 200-J circular electroporation ablation was performed via a multipolar circular catheter in firm contact with the inner SCV wall. RESULTS: In 19 of 20 animals, the PN could be captured along an estimated 6-8 cm trajectory above the right atrial contour. Directly after the application, the PN could be captured above the ablation level in 17 of 19 animals and after maximally 30 minutes in all animals. Fifteen animals were restudied after 3-13 weeks, and PN functionality was unaffected in all. Histological analysis in 5 animals in which the application had been delivered in the muscular sleeve just above the right atrium showed a transmural circular lesion. However, no lesion was found in the other animals in which the application had been delivered in the fibrous section more cranial in the SCV. CONCLUSIONS: Electroporation ablation at an energy level that may create deep myocardial lesions may spare the targeted right PN. These animal data suggest that electroporation may be a safe ablation modality near the right PN.

Safety and feasibility of closed chest epicardial catheter ablation using electroporation.

BACKGROUND: Permanent coronary artery damage is a hazardous complication of epicardial radiofrequency ablation. Irreversible electroporation (IRE) is a promising nonthermal ablation modality able to create deep myocardial lesions. We investigated the effects of epicardial IRE on luminal coronary artery diameter and lesion depth. METHODS AND RESULTS: In 5 pigs (60-75 kg), the pericardium was exposed using surgical subxiphoidal epicardial access. A custom deflectable octopolar 12-mm circular catheter with 2-mm ring electrodes was introduced in the pericardium via a steerable sheath. After coronary angiography (CAG), the proximal, mid, and distal left anterior descending, and circumflex coronary arteries were targeted with a single, cathodal 200 J application. CAG was repeated after IRE and after 3 months follow-up. Using quantitative CAG, the minimal luminal diameter at the lesion site was compared with the average of the diameters just proximal and distal to that lesion. Intimal hyperplasia and lesion size were measured histologically. CAG directly postablation demonstrated short-lasting luminal narrowing with normalization in the targeted area, suggestive of coronary spasm. After 3 months, all CAGs were identical to preablation CAGs: mean reference luminal diameter was 2.2±0.3 mm, mean luminal diameter at the lesion site was 2.1±0.3 mm (P=0.35). Average intimal hyperplasia in all arteries was 2±4%. Median lesion depth was 6.4±2.6 mm. CONCLUSIONS: Luminal coronary artery diameter remained unaffected 3 months after epicardial IRE, purposely targeting the coronary arteries. IRE can create deep lesions and is a safe modality for catheter ablation on or near coronary arteries.

Myocardial lesion size after epicardial electroporation catheter ablation after subxiphoid puncture.

BACKGROUND: Irreversible electroporation is a promising nonthermal ablation modality able to create deep myocardial lesions. We investigated lesion size after epicardial electroporation catheter ablation with various energy levels after subxiphoid pericardial puncture. METHODS AND RESULTS: In six 6-month-old pigs (60-75 kg), a custom deflectable octopolar 12-mm circular catheter with 2-mm ring electrodes was introduced via a deflectable sheath after pericardial access by subxiphoid puncture. Nonarcing, nonbarotraumatic, cathodal 50, 100, and 200 J electroporation applications were delivered randomly on the basal, mid and lateral left ventricle. After 3-month survival, myocardial lesion size and degree of intimal hyperplasia of the coronary arteries were analyzed histologically. Five animals survived the follow-up without complications and 1 animal died of shock after the subxiphoid puncture. At autopsy, whitish circular scars with indentation of the epicardium could be identified. Average lesion depths of the 50-, 100-, and 200-J lesions were 5.0±2.1, 7.0±2.0, and 11.9±1.5 mm, respectively. Average lesion widths of the 50-, 100-, and 200-J lesions were 16.6±1.1, 16.2±4.3, and 19.8±1.8 mm, respectively. In the 100- and 200-J cross sections, transmural left ventricular lesions and significant tissue shrinkage were observed. No intimal hyperplasia of the coronary arteries was observed. CONCLUSIONS: Epicardial electroporation ablation after subxiphoid pericardial puncture can create deep, wide, and transmural ventricular myocardial lesions. There is a significant relationship between the amounts of electroporation energy delivered epicardially and lesion size in the absence of major adverse events.