Construction and analysis of base-paired regions of the 16S rRNA in the 30S ribosomal subunit determined by constraint satisfaction molecular modelling.

Structure models for each of the secondary structure regions from the Escherichia coli 16S rRNA (58 separate elements) were constructed using a constraint satisfaction modelling program to determine which helices deviated from classic A-form geometry. Constraints for each rRNA element included the comparative secondary structure, H-bonding conformations predicted from patterns of base-pair covariation, tertiary interactions predicted from covariation analysis, chemical probing data, rRNA-rRNA crosslinking information, and coordinates from solved structures. Models for each element were built using the MC-SYM modelling algorithm and subsequently were subjected to energy minimization to correct unfavorable geometry. Approximately two-thirds of the structures that result from the input data are very similar to A-form geometry. In the remaining instances, the presence of internal loops and bulges, some sequences (and sequence covariants) and accessory information require deviation from A-form geometry. The structures of regions containing more complex base-pairing arrangements including the central pseudoknot, the 530 region, and the pseudoknot involving base-pairing between G570-U571/A865-C866 and G861-C862/G867-C868 were predicted by this approach. These molecular models provide insight into the connection between patterns of H-bonding, the presence of unpaired nucleotides, and the overall geometry of each element.

Arrangement of the central pseudoknot region of 16S rRNA in the 30S ribosomal subunit determined by site-directed 4-thiouridine crosslinking.

The 16S rRNA central pseudoknot region in the 30S ribosomal subunit has been investigated by photocrosslinking from 4-thiouridine (s4U) located in the first 20 nt of the 16S rRNA. RNA fragments (nt 1-20) were made by in vitro transcription to incorporate s4U at every uridine position or were made by chemical synthesis to incorporate s4U into one of the uridine positions at +5, +14, +17, or +20. These were ligated to RNA containing nt 21-1542 of the 16S rRNA sequence and, after gel purification, the ligated RNA was reconstituted into 30S subunits. Long-range intramolecular crosslinks were produced by near-UV irradiation; these were separated by gel electrophoresis and analyzed by reverse transcription reactions. A number of crosslinks are made in each of the constructs, which must reflect the structural flexibility or conformational heterogeneity in this part of the 30S subunit. All of the constructs show crosslinking to the 559-562, 570-571, and 1080-1082 regions; however, other sites are crosslinked specifically from each s4U position. The most distinctive crosslinking sites are: 341-343 and 911-917 for s4U(+5); 903-904 (very strong), 1390-1397, and 1492 for s4U(+14); and 903-904 (moderate) for s4U(+17); in the 1070-1170 region in which there are different patterns for each s4U position. These results indicate that part of the central pseudoknot is in close contact with the decoding region, with helix 27 in the 885-912 interval and with part of domain III RNA. Crosslinking between s4U(+14) and 1395-1397 is consistent with base pairing at U14-A1398.

Short-range RNA-RNA crosslinking methods to determine rRNA structure and interactions.

We describe details of procedures to analyze RNA-RNA crosslinks made by far-UV irradiation (< 300 nm) or made by irradiation with near-UV light (320-365 nm) on RNA containing photosensitive nucleotides, in the present case containing 4-thiouridine. Zero-length crosslinks of these types must occur because of the close proximity of the participants through either specific interactions or transient contacts in the folded RNA structure, so they are valuable monitors of the conformation of the RNA. Procedures to produce crosslinks in the 16S ribosomal RNA and between the 16S rRNA and mRNA or tRNA are described. Gel electrophoresis conditions are described that separate the products according to their structure to allow the determination of the number and frequency of the crosslinking products. Gel electrophoresis together with an ultracentrifugation procedure for the efficient recovery of RNA from the polyacrylamide gels allows the purification of molecules containing different crosslinks. These separation techniques allow the analysis of the sites of crosslinking by primer extension and RNA sequencing techniques. The procedures are applicable to other types of RNA molecules with some differences to control levels of crosslinking and separation conditions.

UV-induced crosslinks in the 16S rRNAs of Escherichia coli, Bacillus subtilis and Thermus aquaticus and their implications for ribosome structure and photochemistry.

Sixteen long-range crosslinks are induced in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA by far-UV irradiation. Crosslinking patterns in two other organisms, Bacillus subtilis and Thermus aquaticus, were investigated to determine if the number and location of crosslinks in E.coli occur because of unusually photoreactive nucleotides at particular locations in the rRNA sequence. Thirteen long-range crosslinks in B.subtilis and 15 long-range crosslinks in T.aquaticus were detected by gel electrophoresis and 10 crosslinks in each organism were identified completely by reverse transcription analysis. Of the 10 identified crosslinks in B.subtilis, eight correspond exactly to E.coli crosslinks and two crosslinks are formed close to sites of crosslinks in E.coli. Of the 10 identified crosslinks in T.aquaticus, five correspond exactly to E.coli crosslinks, three are formed close to E.coli crosslinking sites, one crosslink corresponds to a UV laser irradiation-induced crosslink in E.coli and the last is not seen in E.coli. The overall similarity of crosslink positions in the three organisms suggests that the crosslinks arise from tertiary interactions that are highly conserved but with differences in detail in some regions.

Initiation factor 3-induced structural changes in the 30 S ribosomal subunit and in complexes containing tRNA(f)(Met) and mRNA.

Initiation factor 3 (IF3) acts to switch the decoding preference of the small ribosomal subunit from elongator to initiator tRNA. The effects of IF3 on the 30 S ribosomal subunit and on the 30 S.mRNA. tRNA(f)(Met) complex were determined by UV-induced RNA crosslinking. Three intramolecular crosslinks in the 16 S rRNA (of the 14 that were monitored by gel electrophoresis) are affected by IF3. These are the crosslinks between C1402 and C1501 within the decoding region, between C967xC1400 joining the end loop of a helix of 16 S rRNA domain III and the decoding region, and between U793 and G1517 joining the 790 end loop of 16 S rRNA domain II and the end loop of the terminal helix. These changes occur even in the 30 S.IF3 complex, indicating they are not mediated through tRNA(f)(Met) or mRNA. UV-induced crosslinks occur between 16 S rRNA position C1400 and tRNA(f)(Met) position U34, in tRNA(f)(Met) the nucleotide adjacent to the 5' anticodon nucleotide, and between 16 S rRNA position C1397 and the mRNA at positions +9 and +10 (where A of the initiator AUG codon is +1). The presence of IF3 reduces both of these crosslinks by twofold and fourfold, respectively. The binding site for IF3 involves the 790 region, some other parts of the 16 S rRNA domain II and the terminal stem/loop region. These are located in the front bottom part of the platform structure in the 30 S subunit, a short distance from the decoding region. The changes that occur in the decoding region, even in the absence of mRNA and tRNA, may be induced by IF3 from a short distance or could be caused by the second IF3 structural domain.

Organization of the 16S rRNA around its 5' terminus determined by photochemical crosslinking in the 30S ribosomal subunit.

The organization of the 5' terminus region in the 16S rRNA was investigated using a series of RNA constructs in which the 5' terminus was extended by 5 nt or was shortened to give RNA molecules that started at positions -5, +1, +5, +8, +14, or +21. The structural and functional effects of the 5' extension/truncations were determined after the RNAs were reconstituted. 30S subunits containing 16S rRNA with 5' termini at -5, +1, +5, +8 and +14 had similar structures (judged by UV-induced crosslinking) and exhibited a gradual reduction in tRNA binding activity compared to that seen with 30S subunits reconstituted with native 16S rRNA. To create the 5' terminal site-specific photocrosslinking agent, the reagent azidophenacylbromide (APAB) was attached to the 5' terminus of 16S rRNA through a guanosine monophosphorothioate and the APA-16S rRNAs were reconstituted. Crosslinking carried out with the APA revealed sites in six regions around positions 300-340, 560, 900, 1080, the 16S rRNA decoding region, and at 1330. Differences in the pattern and efficiency of crosslinking for the different constructs allow distance estimates for the crosslinked sites from nucleotide G9. These measurements provide constraints for the arrangement of the RNA elements in the 30S subunit. Similar experiments carried out in the 70S ribosome resulted in a five- to tenfold lower frequency of crosslinking. This is most likely due to a repositioning of the 5' terminus upon subunit association.

Identity and geometry of a base triple in 16S rRNA determined by comparative sequence analysis and molecular modeling.

Comparative sequence analysis complements experimental methods for the determination of RNA three-dimensional structure. This approach is based on the concept that different sequences within the same gene family form similar higher-order structures. The large number of rRNA sequences with sufficient variation, along with improved covariation algorithms, are providing us with the opportunity to identify new base triples in 16S rRNA. The three-dimensional conformations for one of our strongest candidates involving U121 (C124:G237) and/or U121 (U125:A236) (Escherichia coli sequence and numbering) are analyzed here with different molecular modeling tools. Molecular modeling shows that U121 interacts with C124 in the U121 (C124:G237) base triple. This arrangement maintains isomorphic structures for the three most frequent sequence motifs (approximately 93% of known bacterial and archaeal sequences), is consistent with chemical reactivity of U121 in E. coli ribosomes, and is geometrically favorable. Further, the restricted set of observed canonical (GU, AU, GC) base-pair types at positions 124:237 and 125:236 is consistent with the fact that the canonical base-pair sets (for both base pairs) that are not observed in nature prevent the formation of the 121 (124:237) base triple. The analysis described here serves as a general scheme for the prediction of specific secondary and tertiary structure base pairing where there is a network of correlated base changes.

Effects of tetracycline and spectinomycin on the tertiary structure of ribosomal RNA in the Escherichia coli 30 S ribosomal subunit.

Structural analysis of the 16 S rRNA in the 30 S subunit and 70 S ribosome in the presence of ribosome-specific antibiotics was performed to determine whether they produced rRNA structural changes that might provide further insight to their action. An UV cross-linking procedure that determines the pattern and frequency of intramolecular 16 S RNA cross-links was used to detect differences reflecting structural changes. Tetracycline and spectinomycin have specific effects detected by this assay. The presence of tetracycline inhibits the cross-link C967xC1400 completely, increases the frequency of cross-link C1402x1501 twofold, and decreases the cross-link G894xU244 by one-half without affecting other cross-links. Spectinomycin reduces the frequency of the cross-link C934xU1345 by 60% without affecting cross-linking at other sites. The structural changes occur at concentrations at which the antibiotics exert their inhibitory effects. For spectinomycin, the apparent binding site and the affected cross-linking site are distant in the secondary structure but are close in tertiary structure in several recent models, indicating a localized effect. For tetracycline, the apparent binding sites are significantly separated in both the secondary and the three-dimensional structures, suggesting a more regional effect.

Neighborhood of 16S rRNA nucleotides U788/U789 in the 30S ribosomal subunit determined by site-directed crosslinking.

Site-specific photo crosslinking has been used to investigate the RNA neighborhood of 16S rRNA positions U788/ U789 in Escherichia coli 30S subunits. For these studies, site-specific psoralen (SSP) which contains a sulfhydryl group on a 17 A side chain was first added to nucleotides U788/U789 using a complementary guide DNA by annealing and phototransfer. Modified RNA was purified from the DNA and unmodified RNA. For some experiments, the SSP, which normally crosslinks at an 8 A distance, was derivitized with azidophenacylbromide (APAB) resulting in the photoreactive azido moiety at a maximum of 25 A from the 4' position on psoralen (SSP25APA). 16S rRNA containing SSP, SSP25APA or control 16S rRNA were reconstituted and 30S particles were isolated. The reconstituted subunits containing SSP or SSP25APA had normal protein composition, were active in tRNA binding and had the usual pattern of chemical reactivity except for increased kethoxal reactivity at G791 and modest changes in four other regions. Irradiation of the derivatized 30S subunits in activation buffer produced several intramolecular RNA crosslinks that were visualized and separated by gel electrophoresis and characterized by primer extension. Four major crosslink sites made by the SSP reagent were identified at positions U561/U562, U920/U921, C866 and U723; a fifth major crosslink at G693 was identified when the SSP25APA reagent was used. A number of additional crosslinks of lower frequency were seen, particularly with the APA reagent. These data indicate a central location close to the decoding region and central pseudoknot for nucleotides U788/U789 in the activated 30S subunit.

Dependence of the 16S rRNA decoding region structure on Mg2+, subunit association, and temperature.

The effects of Mg2+ concentration, subunit association, and temperature on the structure of 16S rRNA in the Escherichia coli ribosome were investigated using UV cross-linking and gel electrophoresis analysis. Mg2+ concentrations between 1 and 20 mM and temperatures between 5 and 55 degreesC had little effect on the frequency of 12 of the 14 cross-links in 30S subunits and modest effects on the same cross-links in 70S ribosomes. In contrast, two cross-links, C967 x C1400 and C1402 x C1501, involving rRNA in the decoding region are present in 30S subunits only above 3 mM Mg2+, increase in frequency at higher Mg2+ concentration, and are both more frequent when 50S subunits are included in the reactions. In 70S ribosomes, the cross-link C1402 x C1501 increases but the cross-link C967 x C1400 decreases at higher Mg2+ concentrations. One cross-link, C1397 x U1495, is detected only in 70S ribosomes and decreases in frequency as Mg2+ concentration is increased. An additional cross-link, A1093 x C1182, decreases upon subunit association. The cross-link frequency differences indicate that the arrangement of the decoding region of the 16S rRNA, but not in the rest of the subunit, is readily altered by Mg2+ ions and subunit association.

Exact determination of UV-induced crosslinks in 16S ribosomal RNA in 30S ribosomal subunits.

Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunits were UV-irradiated to induce intramolecular crosslinks in the 16S rRNA. Intact 16S rRNA was purified and subjected to gel electrophoresis, under denaturing conditions, to separate molecules on the basis of the crosslinked loop size. Molecules separated this way were enriched for specific crosslinks and could be analyzed by the reverse transcription arrest assay to determine exact crosslinking sites. Thirteen crosslinking sites have been identified at single nucleotide resolution. Of these, eight are within or adjacent to secondary structure elements: one of these (C582 x G760) involves an interaction between nucleotides within an interior loop, one (C1402 x X1501) involves an interaction between nucleosides in adjacent base pairs, and the others involve interactions between nucleotides that are within junction regions (A441 x G494, U562 x U884, C934 x U1345, and U991 x U1212) or are interactions between nucleotides (C54 x A353 and U1052 x C1200) that somehow cross known base pairs. Five other crosslinks connect sites distant in the secondary structure and provide global constraints for the arrangement of RNA regions within RNA domains I and II (U244 x G894, G894 x A1468, C967 x C1400) and within domain III (U1126 x C1281 and A1093 x G1182). These crosslinks, known at single-nucleotide resolution, are useful in the prediction of local RNA regions, as well as the global structure.

Structural changes in base-paired region 28 in 16 S rRNA close to the decoding region of the 30 S ribosomal subunit are correlated to changes in tRNA binding.

Escherichia coli 30 S ribosomal subunits undergo a reversible change under low monovalent or divalent cation concentration and become inactive in tRNA binding and 50 S subunit association. In the inactive form, 16 S rRNA base-pairs (921-922).(1395-1396) and (923-925).(1391-1393), which are part of region 28, are unstable and an alternate arrangement, (921-923).(1532-1534), is detected by psoralen photochemical crosslinking. Site-directed mutagenesis has been used to investigate whether changes in base-paired region 28 or the alternate secondary structure is responsible for the inactivity of the subunit. 30 S subunits with the substitution C1533A or with deletion of nucleotides 1534 to 1542 can still be inactivated like the wild-type 30 S subunit. On the other hand, 30 S subunits that contain sequence changes in the 920 to 926 region show moderate to severe decreases in tRNA binding even under activating conditions. When 30 S subunits containing these mutations were subjected to chemical probing, they failed to show the normal hyper-reactivity of nucleotide G926 and, instead, reactivity was shifted to G925 or to G928, and G929. Two mutations in the 920 region result in structures in which A1394 is base-paired rather than being unpaired as normal; deletion but not substitution of A1394 resulted in loss of tRNA binding activity and depression of the reactivity of G926. Mutations were made to insert or delete a nucleotide at position 920. The deletion mutant but not the insertion mutant has decreased tRNA binding activity and also low reactivity of G926. We conclude that structural changes in region 28 account for the active/inactive difference in tRNA binding. Molecular models of region 28 were made using the program MC-SYM. Models that include a hydrogen bond interaction between A1394 and G1392 account for the G926 reactivity in the wild-type sequence and account for the effects of most of the mutations in changing the G926 reactivity.

Distribution of cross-links between mRNA analogues and 16 S rRNA in Escherichia coli 70 S ribosomes made under equilibrium conditions and their response to tRNA binding.

The interaction between mRNA and Escherichia coli ribosomes has been studied by photochemical cross-linking using mRNA analogues that contain 4-thiouridine (s4U) or s4U modified with azidophenylacyl bromide (APAB), either two nucleotides upstream or eight nucleotides downstream from the nucleotide sequence ACC, the codon for tRNA(Thr). The sequences of the mRNA analogues were described earlier (Stade, K., Rinke-Appel, J., and Brimacombe, R. (1989) Nucleic Acids Res. 17, 9889-9908; Rinke-Appel, J., Stade, K., and Brimacombe, R. (1991) EMBO J. 10, 2195-2202). Under equilibrium conditions, both of these mRNA analogues bind and cross-link to 70 S ribosomes without the presence of tRNA(Thr); however, there are significant increases both in binding and particularly in cross-linking in the presence of the tRNA(Thr). Four regions contain cross-linking sites that increase in the presence of tRNA, C1395, A532, A1196 (and minor sites around these three positions), and C1533/U1532. Three other cross-linking sites, U723, A845, and U1381, show very little change in extent of cross-linking when tRNA is present. A conformational change in the 30 S subunit allowing additional accessibility to the 16 S rRNA by the mRNA analogues upon tRNA binding best explains the behavior of the tRNA-dependent and tRNA-independent mRNA-16 S rRNA cross-linking sites.

Three dimensional model for the 16S ribosomal RNA in the Escherichia coli ribosome.

Molecular modeling has been performed to help correct and refine an approximate three dimensional structure for Eschericia coli 16S rRNA that originated as hand-built wire model. The wire model was built to accommodate the base pairs in 16S rRNA (1), mRNA.16S rRNA interactions (2,3), rRNA.ribosomal protein interactions (see 4), ribosomal protein-ribosomal protein distances (5), intramolecular RNA-RNA UV-crosslinks (6,7) and site-directed mutagenesis experiments (8). In the computer model, individual base-paired regions were constructed separately and then were installed into the expected locations to produce the entire structure. We describe here the considerations, steps and results of this refinement process.

Three dimensional model for the 16S ribosomal RNA that incorporates information for the mRNA track.

A three dimensional model for the 16S rRNA in the ribosome is described that accommodates information for mRNA.16S rRNA interactions as well as accommodating information that has been used as constraints for determining the internal 16S rRNA structure. mRNA.16S rRNA interactions have been summarized from experiments that employ photoaffinity crosslinking to identify sites at which the mRNA comes into close contact with the 16S rRNA. The mRNA track that has been constructed follows a path completely around the middle of the 30S subunit, occupying a space above 16S rRNA domains I and II and below 16S rRNA domain III. The mRNA track contains regions associated with contacts with the 16S rRNA in, and just upstream of, the P tRNA site, associated with contacts around the A site and associated with neighborhoods upstream of the Shine-Dalgarno region and downstream of the decoding region. Structural constraints that come from UV-induced RNA-RNA crosslinks, suggest that the mRNA decoding region lies in a groove between three 16S rRNA duplex regions facing the 50S subunit.

mRNA binding track in the human 80S ribosome for mRNA analogues randomly substituted with 4-thiouridine residues.

The interaction between mRNA and 18S rRNA in human 80S ribosomes has been studied using synthetic mRNA analogues randomly substituted with 4-thiouridine, which can be photoactivated for cross-linking. Two mRNA analogues with different sequences have been used for complex formation with ribosomes without or with the presence of a cognate tRNA. Cross-linked 18S rRNA nucleotides were identified by reverse transcription analysis. The base U630 in 18S rRNA was the main target of cross-linking for both of the mRNA analogues studied, and three minor sites of cross-linking, A1060, U1046, and U966, were also identified. Thus, in the case of human 80S ribosomes, the set of nucleotide residues cross-linked to the mRNA analogues is significantly smaller than the twelve sites seen for Escherichia coli with these same two mRNA analogues [Bhangu, R., & Wollenzien, P. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 5937-5944]. The residue U630 is within a highly conserved region corresponding to the 530 loop region of eubacterial 16S rRNA; the cross-link to this site indicates that it plays a key role in interacting with mRNA on 80S ribosomes independently of the presence of a cognate tRNA at the P site.

Cross-linking of mRNA analogues containing 4-thiouridine residues on the 3'- or 5'-side of the coding triplet to the mRNA binding center of the human ribosome.

The interaction between mRNA and 18S rRNA within complexes of human placenta 80S ribosomes has been investigated by photochemical cross-linking experiments using mRNA analogues substituted with 4-thiouridine at specific locations. mRNA analogues 51 or 54 nucleotides long were prepared from synthetic DNA templates. These mRNA analogues contained either the sequence GGGACC (coding for glycine and threonine, respectively) or the single triplet GGG together with 2-4 4-thiouridine residues located at various positions with respect to the coding triplets. The products of cross-linking of the mRNA analogues to 18S rRNA within different model complexes without tRNA or in the presence of cognate tRNAs were analyzed by reverse transcription. Two cross-linking sites in the 18S rRNA were detected. The first site, U630, was cross-linked by mRNA 8' (s4U at +20, +22, +24, and +26), mRNA 9e' (s4U at -16, -18, and -20), and mRNA 10 (s4U at +4, +6, -1, and -3) but, unexpectedly, not with either mRNA 10b (s4U at +4 and +6) or mRNA 10c (s4U at -1 and -3). The second site, U1111/A1112, was cross-linked by mRNA 10 and mRNA 10c but not by any of the other mRNA analogues. There is significant tRNA dependence on cross-linking only for mRNA analogue 9e'. Both of the sites detected correspond to sites of mRNA cross-linking in Escherichia coli 16S rRNA.

Arrangement of messenger RNA on Escherichia coli ribosomes with respect to 10 16S rRNA cross-linking sites.

The arrangement of the mRNA on the Escherichia coli ribosome with respect to ribosomal RNA sites has been investigated by photochemical cross-linking experiments. mRNA analogues 51-54 nucleotides in length contained a Shine-Dalgarno sequence, a single codon for tRNA(Gly), and 4-thiouridine (s4U) in the 5' third of the mRNA (-20 to -12), in the middle third of the mRNA (-3 to +6), or in the 3' third of the mRNA (+20 to +26), where the position numbers are counted from the first nucleotide of the codon. Complexes were formed with these mRNAs and 70S ribosomes in the absence or presence of tRNA(Gly) and were irradiated. The extent of cross-linking and the identity of cross-linked rRNA sites were determined on agarose gels and by primer extension. 16S rRNA nucleotides A412, A532, G693 (weakly), U723, and U1381 (weakly) cross-linked with s4U in the 3' third; A532, G693, U723, A1167 (weakly), U1381, G818 (weakly), and A845 cross-linked with s4U in the middle; A532, G693, U723, A1167, G818 (weakly), and A845 cross-linked with s4U in the 5' third. All of these cross-links occur with tRNA independence. Cross-links at C1395 and A1196 occur for all three mRNAs with tRNA dependence. The pattern of these sites provides information about the order of the rRNA sites along the mRNA track, and they also point out the apparent overlapping neighborhoods for the mRNA track. Models for the track of the mRNA on the 30S subunit are considered to explain this pattern of interactions.