Research on complementary/alternative medicine for patients with breast cancer: a review of the biomedical literature.

PURPOSE: This article reviews English-language articles published in the biomedical literature from 1980 to 1997 that reported results of clinical research on complementary and alternative medical treatments (CAM) of interest to patients with breast cancer. METHODS: We searched 12 electronic databases and the bibliographies of the retrieved papers, review articles, and books on CAM and breast cancer. The retrieved articles were grouped by end point: breast cancer (eg, tumor size, survival), disease-related symptoms, side effects of treatment, and immune function. Within each end point, we organized the articles by modality and assessed study design, findings, and qualitative aspects. RESULTS: Of the more than 1,000 citations retrieved, 51 fit our criteria for review. Of the articles reviewed, 17 were randomized clinical trials; three of these were trials of cancer-directed interventions, two of which involved the same treatment (melatonin). Seven articles described observational studies, and the remainder were reports of phase I or II trials. Relatively few CAM modalities reportedly used by many breast cancer patients were mentioned in articles retrieved by this process. Most articles had shortcomings. CONCLUSION: Although many studies had encouraging results, none showed definitively that a CAM treatment altered disease progression in patients with breast cancer. Several modalities seemed to improve other outcomes (eg, acupuncture for nausea, pressure treatments for lymphedema). If CAM studies are well-founded, well-designed, and meticulously conducted, and their hypotheses, methods, and results are reported clearly and candidly, research in this controversial area should acquire credibility both in the scientific community and among advocates of unconventional medicine.

Research on complementary and alternative therapies for cancer: issues and methodological considerations.

Recent evidence suggests that at least one cancer patient in three uses some form of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). We conducted a review of the published research on the efficacy of these treatments for breast cancer, which resulted in some observations about the current state of research and guidelines for future research. Although many of the papers reported encouraging results, the preponderance of phase I and II trials and other limitations precluded definitive conclusions about the efficacy of the treatments reported in these studies. A growing institutional base in this country has begun to facilitate improved research on CAM for cancer, yet many gaps remain. For example, there are no published reports of clinical trials or observational studies with survival endpoints for treatment agents used by many cancer patients. Clinical trials of a few CAM treatments are now in progress, but the results will not be available for several years. More complex and customized treatments may require innovative study designs and practitioner-investigator collaborations. Given the mounting evidence that CAM treatments are biologically active as well as widely used, CAM research may affect cancer outcomes.

Memory and anxiety in prepubertal boys at risk for delinquency.

OBJECTIVE: To examine the association between memory and anxiety symptoms in young urban-dwelling boys. METHOD: A series of 111 boys, aged 7 to 11 years, at risk for disruptive psychopathology received standardized assessments of psychopathology and neuropsychological abilities, including verbal and design memory ability. While neuropsychological ability was rated at an initial study wave, psychopathology was rated at both an initial and a follow-up study wave, separated by approximately 18 months. RESULTS: Anxiety symptoms were more strongly correlated with poor memory ability than with reduced intelligence. Disruptive symptoms, in contrast, were more strongly correlated with reduced intelligence than with poor memory ability. Finally, boys with an anxiety disorder exhibited reduced memory abilities relative to other boys in the sample. Relationships generally appeared strongest in longitudinal analyses, such that poorer memory ability at study intake predicted increased anxiety at follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: Anxiety is associated with reduced memory ability in young urban boys at risk for disruptive psychopathology.

Dichotic listening deficits and the prediction of substance use in young boys.

OBJECTIVE: Prior studies note relationships among verbal deficits, disruptive psychopathology, and substance use. The current study examines the relationship between verbal deficits, assessed through a dichotic listening test, and children's substance use. METHOD: A series of 87 young boys was prospectively followed over a 1- to 2-year period. A prior study in these boys noted a cross-sectional relationship between disruptive psychopathology and deficits on a dichotic consonant-vowel listening test. The current study examines the predictive relationship between this language-related deficit at one study wave and substance use assessed during a follow-up study wave. RESULTS: Reduced right ear accuracy, reflecting a deficit in left hemisphere processing ability, predicted substance use at follow-up. This association was independent of any other predictors, including cognitive or behavioral indices of substance use risk. CONCLUSIONS: A lateralized deficit in verbal processing on a dichotic listening task predicts change in substance use by follow-up. Findings are consistent with other evidence linking early childhood lateralization abnormalities to development of disruptive psychopathology.