Differential Activation of Canal and Otolith Afferents by Acoustic Tone Bursts in Rats.

Vestibular evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs) are routinely used to test otolith function, but which specific vestibular afferent neurons and central circuits are activated by auditory frequency VEMP stimuli remains unclear. To examine this question, we analyzed the sensitivity of individual vestibular afferents in adult Sprague-Dawley rats to tone bursts delivered at 9 frequencies (125-4000 Hz) and 3 intensity levels (60, 70, 80 dB SL re: acoustic brainstem response (ABR) threshold). Afferent neuron tone sensitivity was quantified by the cumulative probability of evoking a spike (CPE). Based on a threshold CPE of 0.1, acoustic stimuli in the present study evoked responses in 78.2 % (390/499) of otolith afferent neurons vs. 48.4 % (431/891) of canal afferent neurons. Organ-specific vestibular inputs to the central nervous system in response to tone bursts differ based on intensity and frequency content of the stimulus. At frequencies below 500 Hz, tone bursts primarily activated both otolith afferents, even at the highest intensity tested (80 dB SL re ABR threshold). At 1500 Hz, however, tone bursts activated the canal and otolith afferents at the moderate and high intensities tested (70, 80 dB SL), but activated only otolith afferents at the low intensity tested (60 dB SL). Within an end organ, diversity of sensitivity between individual afferent neurons correlated with spontaneous discharge rate and regularity. Examination of inner ear fluid mechanics in silico suggests that the frequency response and preferential activation of the otolith organs likely arise from inner ear fluid motion trapped near the oval and round windows. These results provide insight into understanding the mechanisms of sound activation of the vestibular system and developing novel discriminative VEMP testing protocols and interpretative guidelines in humans.

Sound-Evoked Responses in the Vestibulo-Ocular Reflex Pathways of Rats.

Vestibular evoked myogenic potentials (VEMP) have been used to assess otolith function in clinics worldwide. However, there are accumulating evidence suggesting that the clinically used sound stimuli activate not only the otolith afferents, but also the canal afferents, indicating canal contributions to the VEMPs. To better understand the neural mechanisms underlying the VEMPs and develop discriminative VEMP protocols, we further examined sound-evoked responses of the vestibular nucleus neurons and the abducens neurons, which have the interneurons and motoneurons of the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) pathways. Air-conducted clicks (50-80 dB SL re ABR threshold, 0.1 ms duration) or tone bursts (60-80 dB SL, 125-4,000 Hz, 8 ms plateau, 1 ms rise/fall) were delivered to the ears of Sprague-Dawley or Long-Evans rats. Among 425 vestibular nucleus neurons recorded in anesthetized rats and 18 abducens neurons recorded in awake rats, sound activated 35.9% of the vestibular neurons that increased discharge rates for ipsilateral head rotation (Type I neuron), 15.7% of the vestibular neurons that increased discharge rates for contralateral head rotation (Type II neuron), 57.2% of the vestibular neurons that did not change discharge rates during head rotation (non-canal neuron), and 38.9% of the abducens neurons. Sound sensitive vestibular nucleus neurons and abducens neurons exhibited characteristic tuning curves that reflected convergence of canal and otolith inputs in the VOR pathways. Tone bursts also evoked well-defined eye movements that increased with tone intensity and duration and exhibited peak frequency of ∼1,500 Hz. For the left eye, tone bursts evoked upward/rightward eye movements for ipsilateral stimulation, and downward/leftward eye movements for contralateral stimulation. These results demonstrate that sound stimulation results in activation of the canal and otolith VOR pathways that can be measured by eye tracking devices to develop discriminative tests of vestibular function in animal models and in humans.

Click-evoked responses in vestibular afferents in rats.

Sound activates not only the cochlea but also the vestibular end organs. Research on this phenomenon led to the discovery of the sound-evoked vestibular myogenic potentials recorded from the sternocleidomastoid muscles (cervical VEMP, or cVEMP). Since the cVEMP offers simplicity and the ability to stimulate each labyrinth separately, its values as a test of human vestibular function are widely recognized. Currently, the cVEMP is interpreted as a test of saccule function based on the assumption that clicks primarily activate the saccule. However, sound activation of vestibular end organs other than the saccule has been reported. To provide the neural basis for interpreting clinical VEMP testing, we employed the broadband clicks used in clinical VEMP testing to examine the sound-evoked responses in a large sample of vestibular afferents in Sprague-Dawley rats. Recordings were made from 924 vestibular afferents from 106 rats: 255 from the anterior canal (AC), 202 from the horizontal canal (HC), 177 from the posterior canal (PC), 207 from the superior vestibular nerve otolith (SO), and 83 from the inferior nerve otolith (IO). Sound sensitivity of each afferent was quantified by computing the cumulative probability of evoking a spike (CPE). We found that clicks activated irregular afferents (normalized coefficient of variation of interspike intervals >0.2) from both the otoliths (81%) and the canals (43%). The order of end organ sound sensitivity was SO = IO > AC > HC > PC. Since the sternocleidomastoid motoneurons receive inputs from both the otoliths and the canals, these results provide evidence of a possible contribution from both of them to the click-evoked cVEMP.

Frequency tuning of bone-conducted tone burst-evoked myogenic potentials recorded from extraocular muscles (BOVEMP) in normal human subjects.

OBJECTIVES: In this study, we characterized the frequency tuning of bone-conducted sound-evoked myogenic potentials recorded from extraocular muscles (BOVEMP) in normal human subjects. STUDY DESIGN: Experimental design. METHODS: In a sample of nine subjects, acoustic tone bursts (57 dB nHL, 8 ms plateau, 1 ms rise/fall, alternating polarity) with frequencies from 250 Hz to 2,000 Hz were delivered by a bone oscillator (Radioear B-71) placed on the left mastoid processes. Subjects were required to sit upright and maintain a straight gaze. The BOVEMPs were recorded from surface electrodes placed at four locations around the right eye (superior, inferior, nasal, and temporal) and referenced to an electrode placed at the nape of the neck over cervical vertebrate C7. Signals from electrodes were amplified (10,000 gain) and sampled at 10 kHz and were averaged over 500 repetitions. RESULTS: Short latency biphasic potential were present at each of the four recording sites around the eye. The average latency of the first peak (negative) and the second peak (positive) was 15.7 ± 0.3 ms and 23.3 ± 0.5 ms, respectively. The tuning curve of the BOVEMP was similar at each recording site with largest N1 amplitude following stimulation at 383 Hz (± 17 Hz) and largest P1 amplitude following stimulation at 440 Hz (± 22 Hz). CONCLUSIONS: Since the frequency tuning for the bone-conducted sound-evoked OVEMP (BOVEMP) was different from that of the air-conducted sound-evoked OVEMP (AOVEMP), we hypothesize that the BOVEMP and AOVEMP are generated by activation of different vestibular end organs.

Frequency tuning in the tone burst-evoked myogenic potentials in extraocular muscles in normal human subjects.

OBJECTIVE: In this cross-sectional study, we investigated the frequency tuning properties of sound-evoked vestibular myogenic potentials in extraocular muscles (OVEMPs) in normal human subjects. METHODS: Acoustic tone bursts (130 dB pSPL, 10 ms plateau, 1 ms rise/fall) with nine frequencies from 125 to 4000 Hz were presented monoaurally to 12 normal subjects while they sat upright and maintained centre gaze. Using surface electrodes, the OVEMPs were recorded at four locations surrounding the contralateral eye (superior, inferior, nasal, and temporal) and were referenced to an electrode placed at the nape of the neck over C7. To measure the amplitudes of the OVEMP, signals from the electrodes were amplified and sampled at 10 kHz and were averaged over 250 repetitions. RESULTS: We found that the OVEMPs recorded at the four sites exhibited similar well-defined frequency tuning with peak amplitude at ≈ 1000 Hz. CONCLUSION: Although several studies have examined the frequency tuning of the vestibular evoked myogenic potential measured from the sternocleidomastoid muscles (SVEMP), the reported results are quite variable as regards frequency, which produces peak amplitude. The well-defined OVEMP frequency tuning provides an alternative to the SVEMP for assessing vestibular function via acoustic stimulation. Further studies are needed to identify the extent to which each of the five vestibular end-organs is activated by sound and their contribution to the sound-evoked vestibular myogenic potentials.

The conjugacy of the vestibulo-ocular reflex evoked by single labyrinth stimulation in awake monkeys.

It is well known that the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) is conjugate when measured in the dark with minimal vergence. But the neural basis of the VOR conjugacy remains to be identified. In the present study, we measured the VOR conjugacy during single labyrinth stimulation to examine whether the VOR conjugacy depends on reciprocal stimulation of the two labyrinths. There are conflicting views on this issue. First, since the vestibular signals carried by the ascending tract of Deiters' are distributed exclusively to the motoneurons of the ipsilateral eye, the neural innervations after single labyrinth stimulation are not symmetrical for the two eyes. Thus, single labyrinth stimulation may generate disjunctive VOR responses. Second, the only published study on this issue was an electrooculography (EOG) study that reported disjunctive VOR responses during unilateral caloric irrigation (Wolfe in Ann Otol 88:79-85, 1979). Third, the VOR during unilateral caloric stimulation performed in clinical vestibular tests is routinely perceived to be conjugate. To resolve these conflicting views, the present study examined the VOR conjugacy during single labyrinth stimulation by recording binocular eye position signals in awake monkeys with a search coil technique. In contradiction to the previous EOG study and the prediction based on the asymmetry of the unilateral brainstem VOR circuits, we found that the VOR during unilateral caloric irrigation was conjugate over a wide range of conditions. We conclude that the net neural innervations received by the two eyes are symmetrical after single labyrinth stimulation, despite the apparent asymmetry in the unilateral VOR pathways. A novel role for the ascending tract of Deiters' in the VOR conjugacy is proposed.

Acoustic clicks activate both the canal and otolith vestibulo-ocular reflex pathways in behaving monkeys.

Acoustic activation of the vestibular system has been well documented in humans and animal models. In the past decade, sound-evoked myogenic potentials in the sternocleidomastoid muscle (cVEMP) and the extraocular muscles (oVEMP) have been extensively studied, and their potentials as new tests for vestibular function have been widely recognized. However, the extent to which sound activates the otolith and canal pathways remains controversial. In the present study, we examined this issue in a recently developed nonhuman primate model of acoustic activation of the vestibular system, i.e., sound-evoked vestibulo-ocular reflexes (VOR) in behaving monkeys. To determine whether the canal and otolith VOR pathways are activated by sound, we analyzed abducens neurons' responses to clicks that were delivered into either ear. The main finding was that clicks evoked short-latency excitatory responses in abducens neurons on both sides. The latencies of the two responses, however, were different. The mean latency of the contralateral and ipsilateral abducens neurons was 2.44 +/- 0.4 and 1.65 +/- 0.28 ms, respectively. A further analysis of the excitatory latencies, in combination with the known canal and otolith VOR pathways, suggests that the excitatory responses of the contralateral abducens neurons were mediated by the contralateral disynaptic VOR pathways that connect the lateral canal to the contralateral abducens neurons, and the excitatory responses of the ipsilateral abducens neurons were mediated by the ipsilateral monosynaptic VOR pathways that connect the utricle to the ipsilateral abducens neurons. These results provide new insights into the understanding of the neural basis for sound-evoked vestibular responses, which is essential for developing new tests for both canal and otolith functions in humans.

Multiplicative computation in the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR).

Multiplicative computation is a basic operation that is crucial for neural information processing, but examples of multiplication by neural pathways that perform well-defined sensorimotor transformations are scarce. Here in behaving monkeys, we identified a multiplication of vestibular and eye position signals in the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR). Monkeys were trained to maintain fixation on visual targets at different horizontal locations and received brief unilateral acoustic clicks (1 ms, rarefaction, 85 approximately 110 db NHL) that were delivered into one of their external ear canals. We found that both the click-evoked horizontal eye movement responses and the click-evoked neuronal responses of the abducens neurons exhibited linear dependencies on horizontal conjugate eye position, indicating that the interaction of vestibular and horizontal conjugate eye position was multiplicative. Latency analysis further indicated that the site of the multiplication was within the direct VOR pathways. Based on these results, we propose a novel neural mechanism that implements the VOR gain modulation by fixation distance and gaze eccentricity. In this mechanism, the vestibular signal from a single labyrinth interacts multiplicatively with the position signals of each eye (Principle of Multiplication). These effects, however, interact additively with the other labyrinth (Principle of Addition). Our analysis suggests that the new mechanism can implement the VOR gain modulation by fixation distance and gaze eccentricity within the direct VOR pathways.

Activity-dependent modulation: a non-linearity in the unilateral vestibulo-ocular reflex pathways.

It is well established that the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) depends not only on sensory stimulation but also on the behavioral context associated with the stimulation. Recent modeling studies suggested that including a non-linearity in the activation function of the VOR neurons achieves the desired context-dependence for the VOR without resorting to currently assumed complex cortical computations. With the non-linearity, neurons operate as non-linear summers of incoming activity with sensitivities modulated by their activation levels. In this study we examined whether such a non-linearity exists in the unilateral VOR pathways in behaving monkeys. Acoustic clicks were employed to evoke unilateral VOR responses during fixation, head motion and smooth pursuit. We found that the click-evoked unilateral VOR responses did not simply sum in a linear manner with the eye movements initiated by head or target motion. Instead, the same acoustic click evoked larger eye movements if the ongoing eye movements were in the same direction. We also showed that the interaction between the ongoing eye movement and the click-evoked response was close to being multiplicative. These results revealed a previous unknown non-linearity in the unilateral VOR pathways, which may have important implications on the neural implementation of the context-dependence for the VOR.