Comparative Analysis of Tear Proteins in Keratoconic Scleral Lens Wearers with Variation in Limbal Clearance.

SIGNIFICANCE: Cytokine and protease analysis revealed relative changes in the post-lens tear film of scleral lenses with low and high limbal clearances. Results from this study indicate that midperipheral lens fit is an important fitting feature that can impact the inflammatory response of a keratoconic eye. PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to investigate changes in levels of inflammatory mediators in the post-lens tear film of keratoconic scleral lens wearers with varying limbal clearance designs. METHODS: Twenty-two keratoconic eyes were fitted with two sets of scleral lenses that were consistent in lens diameter and central sagittal depth but varied in limbal clearance by approximately 50 µm. Lenses were worn in a randomly assigned order for a 2-week period each. At each follow-up visit, immediately after lens removal, tear samples were collected with a microcapillary tube (10 µL, 0.5 mm in diameter) from the bowl of the inverted scleral lens. Tear cytokine and protease analysis was performed using a multiplex electrochemiluminescent array (Meso Scale Discovery, Rockville, MD) instrument. Levels of interleukins 1, 6, and 8; tumor necrosis factor α; and matrix metalloproteinases 1 and 9 were compared and analyzed. RESULTS: Levels of interleukin 1ß, tumor necrosis factor α, and matrix metalloproteinase 1 increased with high limbal clearance (P = .01, .006, and .02, respectively). No change in interleukins 6 and 8 levels was found (P > .05). A decrease in matrix metalloproteinase 9 was noted in post-lens tear film of scleral lenses with high limbal clearance (P = .10). DISCUSSION: Relative changes in the cytokine and protease levels were found when comparing low and high limbal clearance, indicating that the midperipheral lens fit is an important feature that can impact the inflammatory response of the keratoconic eye.

Objective and Subjective Evaluation of Clinical Performance of Scleral Lens with Varying Limbal Clearance in Keratoconus.

SIGNIFICANCE: This study evaluates how limbal clearance (LC) may impact the clinical performance of scleral lenses based on subjective response on comfort and ocular responses. Limbal zone designs in scleral lenses might affect the integrity of the limbal epithelial tissue as a result of a combined hypoxic and compression-related etiology. PURPOSE: This study aimed to investigate the clinical performance and ocular and subjective responses to the wear of scleral lenses having varying LC. METHODS: Lenses with varying LC with a difference of 50 µm were fitted on and compared among keratoconic participants. The lenses were worn during a 2-week period. Visual analog scales concerning subjective comfort were completed. Ocular surface findings including hyperemia, limbal staining, and corneal swelling were compared. RESULTS: Participants reported greater comfort achieved with high LC. No difference in limbal and bulbar hyperemia was found (P > .05). Corneal response to scleral lens wear with both low and high LCs seems to result in similar perilimbal staining and negative corneal staining. An increase in corneal pachymetric values was noted at the central and peripheral cornea, with no difference between low- and high-LC lenses (all, P < .05). Quadrant-specific analysis indicated that all meridians at both 6 and 8 mm were increased for the low-LC lenses (all, P < .05) and only the temporal region for the high-LC lenses (P = .02). CONCLUSIONS: Limbal clearance may play an important role in subjective performance in scleral lenses but does not impact the degree of hyperemia in either the limbal or bulbar region. Although low LC might result in more compression-related changes to ocular surface, high LC is associated with greater comfort and greater edematous changes. Limbal zone designs in scleral lenses might affect the integrity of the limbal epithelial tissue as a result of a combined hypoxic and compression-related etiology.

Scleral Lens Clearance Assessment with Biomicroscopy and Anterior Segment Optical Coherence Tomography.

SIGNIFICANCE: It is important to be able to accurately estimate the central corneal clearance when fitting scleral contact lenses. Tools available have intrinsic biases due to the angle of viewing, and therefore an idea of the amount of error in estimation will benefit the fitter. PURPOSE: To compare the accuracy of observers' ability to estimate scleral contact lens central corneal clearance (CCC) with biomicroscopy to measurements using slit-lamp imaging and anterior segment optical coherence tomography (AS-OCT). METHODS: In a Web-based survey with images of four scleral lens fits obtained with a slit-lamp video imaging system, participants were asked to estimate the CCC. Responses were compared with known values of CCC of these images determined with an image-processing program (digital CCC) and using the AS-OCT (AS-OCT CCC). Bland-Altman plots and concordance correlation coefficients were used to assess the agreement of CCC measured by the various methods. RESULTS: Sixty-six participants were categorized for analysis based on the amount of experience with scleral lens fitting into novice, intermediate, or advanced fitters. Comparing the estimated CCC to the digital CCC, all three groups overestimated by an average of +27.3 ± 67.3 µm. The estimated CCC was highly correlated to the digital CCC (0.79, 0.92, and 0.94 for each group, respectively). Compared with the CCC measurements using AS-OCT, the three groups of participants overestimated by +103.3 µm and had high correlations (0.79, 0.93, and 0.94 for each group). DISCUSSION: Results from this study validate the ability of contact lens practitioners to observe and estimate the CCC in scleral lens fittings through the use of biomicroscopic viewing. Increasing experience with scleral lens fitting does not improve the correlation with measured CCC from digital or the AS-OCT. However, the intermediate and advanced groups display significantly less inter-observer variability compared with the novice group.

Change in over-refraction after scleral lens settling on average corneas.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to determine the change in over-refraction, if any, after a scleral lens settled on the eye for 6-8 h. METHODS: Sixteen patients of varying refractive errors and normal corneal curvatures (measured with Pentacam™ Oculus) were fitted with trial Mini-Scleral Design (MSD) scleral lenses (15.8 mm diameter) in one eye. The sagittal depths of the scleral lenses were selected by adding 350 µm to the corneal sagittal heights measured at a chord length of 15 mm with the Visante™ optical coherence tomographer (OCT) anterior segment scans and picking the closest available trial lens in the set. Initial measurements were taken 30 min after lens insertion and included an auto-refraction, subjective refraction, and best sphere refraction over the contact lens. Visual acuities and Visante™ OCT anterior segment scans were also taken. These measurements were repeated after 6-8 h of lens wear. RESULTS: Over the trial wearing period, the average change in the spherical component of the over-refraction was +0.06 D (S.D. 0.17) (p = 0.16). The average change in cylinder was +0.04 D (S.D. 0.19) (p = 0.33). The average absolute change in axis was 1.06° (S.D. 12.11) (p = 0.74). The average change in best sphere was +0.13 ± 0.30 D (p = 0.12). There was no significant change in visual acuity with the best sphere over-refraction over the 6-8 h wearing period. There was a significant change in central corneal clearance over the wearing period of 83 µm (S.D. 22) (p < 0.0001). CONCLUSION: Despite a significant change in the central corneal clearance due to thinning of the fluid reservoir as the scleral lens settled (an average decrease of 83 µm after wearing the lenses for 6-8 h), there was not a statistically significant change in the subjective over-refraction (sphere, cylinder, and axis) or best sphere or visual acuity. This study has confirmed that there is no link between reduction in central corneal clearance and change in over-refraction for average corneas.