Engineered CRISPR/Cas9 enzymes improve discrimination by slowing DNA cleavage to allow release of off-target DNA.

CRISPR/Cas9 is a programmable genome editing tool widely used for biological applications and engineered Cas9s have increased discrimination against off-target cleavage compared with wild-type Streptococcus pyogenes (SpCas9) in vivo. To understand the basis for improved discrimination against off-target DNA containing important mismatches at the distal end of the guide RNA, we performed kinetic analyses on the high-fidelity (Cas9-HF1) and hyper-accurate (HypaCas9) engineered Cas9 variants. We show that DNA cleavage is impaired by more than 100- fold for the high-fidelity variants. The high-fidelity variants improve discrimination by slowing the observed rate of cleavage without increasing the rate of DNA rewinding and release. The kinetic partitioning favors release rather than cleavage of a bound off-target substrate only because the cleavage rate is so low. Further improvement in discrimination may require engineering increased rates of dissociation of off-target DNA.

Kinetic characterization of Cas9 enzymes.

Bacterial adaptive immune systems employ clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) along with their CRISPR-associated genes (Cas) to form CRISPR RNA (crRNA)-guided surveillance complexes, which target foreign nucleic acids for destruction. Cas9 is unique in that it is composed of a single polypeptide that utilizes both a crRNA and a trans-activating crRNA (tracrRNA) or a single guide RNA to create double-stranded breaks in sequences complementary to the RNA via the HNH and RuvC nuclease domains. Cas9 has become a revolutionary tool for gene-editing applications. Here, we describe methods for studying the cleavage activities of Cas9. We describe protocols for rapid quench-flow and stopped-flow kinetics and interpretation of the results. The protocols detailed here will be paramount for understanding the mechanistic basis for specificity of this enzyme, especially in efforts to improve accuracy for clinical use.

DNA Unwinding Is the Primary Determinant of CRISPR-Cas9 Activity.

Bacterial adaptive immunity utilizes RNA-guided surveillance complexes comprising Cas proteins together with CRISPR RNAs (crRNAs) to target foreign nucleic acids for destruction. Cas9, a type II CRISPR-Cas effector complex, can be programed with a single-guide RNA that base pairs with the target strand of dsDNA, displacing the non-target strand to create an R-loop, where the HNH and the RuvC nuclease domains cleave opposing strands. While many structural and biochemical studies have shed light on the mechanism of Cas9 cleavage, a clear unifying model has yet to emerge. Our detailed kinetic characterization of the enzyme reveals that DNA binding is reversible, and R-loop formation is rate-limiting, occurring in two steps, one for each of the nuclease domains. The specificity constant for cleavage is determined through an induced-fit mechanism as the product of the equilibrium binding affinity for DNA and the rate of R-loop formation.

An Epigenetic Role for Disrupted Paternal Gene Expression in Postzygotic Seed Abortion in Arabidopsis Interspecific Hybrids.

Interspecific hybrids often increase the levels of heterozygosity and hybrid vigor, but some interspecific hybrid seeds are aborted shortly after fertilization. The mechanism behind this postzygotic seed abortion is poorly understood. Here, we report genome-wide analysis of allelic expression changes in developing siliques and seeds in three F1 interspecific crosses between Arabidopsis thaliana (Col, Ler, or C24) and Arabidopsis arenosa. The majority of maternally expressed genes (MEGs) were shared among all three F1 interspecific crosses, whereas ∼90% of 272 paternally expressed genes (PEGs) were found only in one or two F1 crosses, suggesting a role for disrupted paternal gene expression in seed abortion that varies in different crosses. Consistent with this notion, 12 PEGs in the infertile interspecific hybrids matched MEGs in fertile intraspecific hybrids. This disruption of PEGs in the interspecific hybrids was consistent with the upregulation of the genes in the paternal-excess interploidy cross (2X6) between a diploid mother and a hexaploid father, leading to the seed abortion. Moreover, a subset of PEGs in the interspecific crosses were also upregulated in the intraspecific hybrid met1XWT or meaXWT, in which the mutant of MET1 (DNA METHYLTRANSFERASE1) or MEDEA, a Polycomb Repressive Complex2 gene, was used as the maternal parent. These data suggest that maternal epigenetic factors and paternal gene expression play important roles in the postzygotic seed abortion in interspecific hybrids or neo-allopolyploids.