Primary culture of avian embryonic heart forming region cells to study the regulation of vertebrate early heart morphogenesis by vitamin A.

BACKGROUND: Important knowledge about the role of vitamin A in vertebrate heart development has been obtained using the vitamin A-deficient avian in ovo model which enables the in vivo examination of very early stages of vertebrate heart morphogenesis. These studies have revealed the critical role of the vitamin A-active form, retinoic acid (RA) in the regulation of several developmental genes, including the important growth regulatory factor, transforming growth factor-beta2 (TGFß2), involved in early events of heart morphogenesis. However, this in ovo model is not readily available for elucidating details of molecular mechanisms determining RA activity, thus limiting further examination of RA-regulated early heart morphogenesis. In order to obtain insights into RA-regulated gene expression during these early events, a reliable in vitro model is needed. Here we describe a cell culture that closely reproduces the in ovo observed regulatory effects of RA on TGFß2 and on several developmental genes linked to TGFß signaling during heart morphogenesis. RESULTS: We have developed an avian heart forming region (HFR) cell based in vitro model that displays the characteristics associated with vertebrate early heart morphogenesis, i.e. the expression of Nkx2.5 and GATA4, the cardiogenesis genes, of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF-A), the vasculogenesis gene and of fibronectin (FN1), an essential component in building the heart, and the expression of the multifunctional genes TGFß2 and neogenin (NEO). Importantly, we established that the HFR cell culture is a valid model to study RA-regulated molecular events during heart morphogenesis and that the expression of TGFß2 as well as the expression of several TGFß2-linked developmental genes is regulated by RA. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings reported here offer a biologically relevant experimental in vitro system for the elucidation of RA-regulated expression of TGFß2 and other genes involved in vertebrate early cardiovascular morphogenesis.

The expression of Stra6 and Rdh10 in the avian embryo and their contribution to the generation of retinoid signatures.

Two new components of the retinoic acid (RA) synthetic pathway, the cell surface receptor for retinol, Stra6, and the enzyme converting retinol into retinal, Rdh10, have recently been described. To understand how different tissues of the chick embryo generate different retinoid signatures, we describe the expression patterns of these two genes and ask whether they are altered by RA levels. We performed wholemount in situ hybridisation and altered RA levels by applying RA soaked beads and used vitamin A-deficient quail embryos. In some areas of the embryo, these two genes co-localised with a retinaldehyde dehydrogenase (Raldh), as might be expected allowing retinol to be taken into the cell and converted into RA. In other areas of the embryo, the domain of expression of Rdh10 was much smaller than that of the corresponding Raldh, suggesting that retinal is transferred between cells. In yet other areas, only one of the cytochrome P450 enzymes co-localises with Stra6. In the case of co-localisation with Cyp1B1 in the hindbrain mesenchyme, this reveals that retinol is taken up into the cells for conversion to RA by Cyp1B1 and used in establishing ventral progenitor domains in the hindbrain. In the case of co-localisation with a Cyp26, it suggests that other retinol dehydrogenases (Rdhs) have yet to be discovered. We propose that in certain regions of the embryo, there are new Rdhs and Raldhs yet to be discovered and that RA is not a major regulator of its synthetic enzymes.

Transforming growth factor beta2 is negatively regulated by endogenous retinoic acid during early heart morphogenesis.

Vitamin A-deficient (VAD) quail embryos lack the vitamin A-active form, retinoic acid (RA) and are characterized by a phenotype that includes a grossly abnormal cardiovascular system that can be rescued by RA. Here we report that the transforming growth factor, TGFbeta2 is involved in RA-regulated cardiovascular development. In VAD embryos TGFbeta2 mRNA and protein expression are greatly elevated. The expression of TGFbeta receptor II is also elevated in VAD embryos but is normalized by treatment with TGFbeta2-specific antisense oligonucleotides (AS). Administration of this AS or an antibody specific for TGFbeta2 to VAD embryos normalizes posterior heart development and vascularization, while the administration of exogenous active TGFbeta2 protein to normal quail embryos mimics the excessive TGFbeta2 status of VAD embryos and induces VAD cardiovascular phenotype. In VAD embryos pSmad2/3 and pErk1 are not activated, while pErk2 and pcRaf are elevated and pSmad1/5/8 is diminished. We conclude that in the early avian embryo TGFbeta2 has a major role in the retinoic acid-regulated posterior heart morphogenesis for which it does not use Smad2/3 pathways, but may use other signaling pathways. Importantly, we conclude that retinoic acid is a critical negative physiological regulator of the magnitude of TGFbeta2 signals during vertebrate heart formation.

Retinoid signalling is required for information transfer from mesoderm to neuroectoderm during gastrulation.

The hindbrain region of the vertebrate central nervous system (CNS) presents a complex regionalisation. It consists of 7-8 distinct morphological segments called rhombomeres, each with a unique identity provided by combinations of transcription factors. One class of signalling molecules, retinoids, have been shown to be crucial for hindbrain patterning through direct trans-activation of Hox genes in the neuroectoderm. However, how this morphogen acts is not yet fully understood. Here, we show that the retinoid receptor antagonist AGN193109 causes a posterior hindbrain defect in Xenopus, comparable to that seen in other vertebrates. We show that this defect arises during gastrulation. Blocking endogenous retinoid activity during gastrulation causes downregulation of the most 3' Hox genes (paralogues 1-5) in gastrula neuroectoderm, but their initial activation in gastrula non-organiser mesoderm is unaffected. Similar results were obtained in avian embryos: Vitamin A-deficient quail embryos have defective expression of 3 Hox genes (i.e. Hoxb1, Hoxb4 ) in the neural tube, but their early expression in the primitive streak and emerging paraxial and lateral mesoderm is not affected. In Xenopus, depletion of retinoids from mesoderm by targeted injection of mRNAs for the retinoic acid catabolising enzyme xCYP26 and the cellular retinoic acid binding protein xCRABP blocks 3 Hox gene expression in the overlying neuroectoderm. We propose that the gastrula non-organiser mesoderm and its later derivative, the paraxial mesoderm, is the source of a retinoid, which acts as a transforming (caudalising) signal for the future posterior hindbrain.

Vitamin A-not for your eyes only: requirement for heart formation begins early in embryogenesis.

Vitamin A insufficiency has profound adverse effects on embryonic development. Major advances in understanding the role of vitamin A in vertebrate heart formation have been made since the discovery that the vitamin A active form, all-trans-retinoic acid, regulates many genes, including developmental genes. Among the experimental models used, the vitamin A-deficient avian embryo has been an important tool to study the function of vitamin A during early heart formation. A cluster of retinoic acid-regulated developmental genes have been identified that participate in building the heart. In the absence of retinoic acid the embryonic heart develops abnormally leading to embryolethality.

Retinoic acid is a negative physiological regulator of N-cadherin during early avian heart morphogenesis.

The vitamin A-deficient (VAD) early avian embryo has a grossly abnormal cardiovascular system that is rescued by treating the embryo with the vitamin A-active form, retinoic acid (RA). Here we examine the role of N-cadherin (N-cad) in RA-regulated early cardiovascular morphogenesis. N-cad mRNA and protein are expressed globally in the presomite through HH14 normal and VAD quail embryos. The expression in VAD embryos prior to HH10 is significantly higher than that in normal embryos. Functional analyses of the N-cad overproducing VAD embryos reveal N-cad involvement in the RA-regulated cardiovascular development and suggest that N-cad expression may be mediated by Msx1. We provide evidence that in the early avian embryo, endogenous RA is a negative physiological regulator of N-cad. We hypothesize that a critical endogenous level of N-cad is needed for normal early cardiovascular morphogenesis to occur and that this level is ensured by stage-specific, developmentally regulated RA signaling.

A ryanodine receptor-dependent Ca(i)(2+) asymmetry at Hensen's node mediates avian lateral identity.

In mouse, the establishment of left-right (LR) asymmetry requires intracellular calcium (Ca(i)(2+)) enrichment on the left of the node. The use of Ca(i)(2+) asymmetry by other vertebrates, and its origins and relationship to other laterality effectors are largely unknown. Additionally, the architecture of Hensen's node raises doubts as to whether Ca(i)(2+) asymmetry is a broadly conserved mechanism to achieve laterality. We report here that the avian embryo uses a left-side enriched Ca(i)(2+) asymmetry across Hensen's node to govern its lateral identity. Elevated Ca(i)(2+) was first detected along the anterior node at early HH4, and its emergence and left-side enrichment by HH5 required both ryanodine receptor (RyR) activity and extracellular calcium, implicating calcium-induced calcium release (CICR) as the novel source of the Ca(i)(2+). Targeted manipulation of node Ca(i)(2+) randomized heart laterality and affected nodal expression. Bifurcation of the Ca(i)(2+) field by the emerging prechordal plate may permit the independent regulation of LR Ca(i)(2+) levels. To the left of the node, RyR/CICR and H(+)V-ATPase activity sustained elevated Ca(i)(2+). On the right, Ca(i)(2+) levels were actively repressed through the activities of H(+)K(+) ATPase and serotonin-dependent signaling, thus identifying a novel mechanism for the known effects of serotonin on laterality. Vitamin A-deficient quail have a high incidence of situs inversus hearts and had a reversed calcium asymmetry. Thus, Ca(i)(2+) asymmetry across the node represents a more broadly conserved mechanism for laterality among amniotes than had been previously believed.

Retinoids control anterior and dorsal properties in the developing forebrain.

We have previously shown that retinoic acid (RA) synthesized by the retinaldehyde dehydrogenase 2 (RALDH2) is required in forebrain development. Deficiency in RA due to inactivation of the mouse Raldh2 gene or to complete absence of retinoids in vitamin-A-deficient (VAD) quails, leads to abnormal morphogenesis of various forebrain derivatives. In this study we show that double Raldh2/Raldh3 mouse mutants have a more severe phenotype in the craniofacial region than single null mutants. In particular, the nasal processes are truncated and the eye abnormalities are exacerbated. It has been previously shown that retinoids act mainly on cell proliferation and survival in the ventral forebrain by regulating SHH and FGF8 signaling. Using the VAD quail model, which survives longer than the Raldh-deficient mouse embryos, we found that retinoids act in maintaining the correct position of anterior and dorsal boundaries in the forebrain by modulating FGF8 anteriorly and WNT signaling dorsally. Furthermore, BMP4 and FGF8 signaling are affected in the nasal region and BMP4 is ventrally expanded in the optic vesicle. At the optic cup stage, Pax6, Tbx5 and Bmp4 are ectopically expressed in the presumptive retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE), while Otx2 and Mitf are not induced, leading to a dorsal transdifferentiation of RPE to neural retina. Therefore, besides being required for survival of ventral structures, retinoids are involved in restricting anterior identity in the telencephalon and dorsal identity in the diencephalon and the retina.

Bmp2 and Gata4 function additively to rescue heart tube development in the absence of retinoids.

We used the vitamin A-deficient (VAD) quail model to investigate the retinoid-dependent mechanism that regulates heart tube development. We showed previously that decreased levels of Gata4 in cardiogenic mesoderm and endoderm correlate with the cardiomyopathy caused by VAD, but that this could be rescued by transplanting normal anterior endoderm. Bmp2 is a known cardiogenic factor that is expressed normally in lateral plate mesoderm and cardiac-associated pharyngeal endoderm. Here we show that (like Gata4) transcripts encoding Bmp2 and BMP-dependent signaling activity are decreased throughout the heart-forming region of the VAD embryo. Addition of Bmp2 protein or forced expression of Gata4 in cultured VAD embryos leads to a partial rescue of the cardiomyopathy, and addition of both Bmp2 and Gata4 has an additive positive effect. Our data are consistent with a requirement for retinoid signaling to maintain expression of Bmp2, which regulates Gata4, and in addition acts with Gata4 to regulate genes important for normal morphogenesis of the primitive heart tube.

Distinct roles for hindbrain and paraxial mesoderm in the induction and patterning of the inner ear revealed by a study of vitamin-A-deficient quail.

The hindbrain and cranial paraxial mesoderm have been implicated in the induction and patterning of the inner ear, but the precise role of the two tissues in these processes is still not clear. We have addressed these questions using the vitamin-A-deficient (VAD) quail model, in which VAD embryos lack the posterior half of the hindbrain that normally lies next to the inner ear. Using a battery of molecular markers, we show that the anlagen of the inner ear, the otic placode, is induced in VAD embryos in the absence of the posterior hindbrain. By performing grafting and ablation experiments in chick embryos, we also show that cranial paraxial mesoderm which normally lies beneath the presumptive otic placode is necessary for otic placode induction and that paraxial mesoderm from other locations cannot induce the otic placode. Two members of the fibroblast growth factor family, FGF3 and FGF19, continue to be expressed in this mesodermal population in VAD embryos, and these may be responsible for otic placode induction in the absence of the posterior hindbrain. Although the posterior hindbrain is not required for otic placode induction in VAD embryos, the subsequent patterning of the inner ear is severely disrupted. Several regional markers of the inner ear, such as Pax2, EphA4, SOHo1 and Wnt3a, are incorrectly expressed in VAD otocysts, and the sensory patches and vestibulo-acoustic ganglia are either greatly reduced or absent. Exogenous application of retinoic acid prior to 30 h of development is able rescue the VAD phenotype. By performing such rescue experiments before and after 30 h of development, we show that the inner ear defects of VAD embryos correlate with the absence of the posterior hindbrain. These results show that induction and patterning of the inner ear are governed by separate developmental processes that can be experimentally uncoupled from each other.

Critical role for retinol in the generation/differentiation of angioblasts required for embryonic blood vessel formation.

Numerous studies demonstrate that vitamin A (retinol) deficiency causes abnormal cardiovascular morphogenesis. We evaluated the impact of retinol deficiency on the regulation of the numbers of endothelial cells and angioblasts (endothelial progenitors) produced during embryonic quail development. At the one-somite stage, there were no discernible differences in the mean number of endothelial cells or angioblasts in normal and retinol-deficient embryos. However, retinol-deficient embryos at the three-somite stage had an increase in the mean number of endothelial cells but no difference in the mean number of angioblasts. By contrast, retinol-deficient embryos at the five-somite stage have 61% of the normal number of endothelial cells and 12% of the normal number of angioblasts. Similarly, retinol-deficient embryos at the 10-somite stage had 71% and 60% of normal numbers of endothelial cells in capillary-like networks and the sinuses venosus, respectively. Furthermore, we show that retinol deficiency did not elicit a global reduction in mesodermal cell numbers but was specific to cells of the endothelial lineage. Taken together, our findings suggest that vascular abnormalities observed under conditions of retinol deficiency are due to reduction in the number of angioblasts and consequently an insufficiency in the number of endothelial cells required to build complex vascular networks.

Vitamin a requirement for early cardiovascular morphogenesis specification in the vertebrate embryo: insights from the avian embryo.

Vitamin A is required throughout the life cycle, including crucial stages of embryonic and fetal development. With the identification of retinoic acid-specific nuclear transcription factors, the retinoid receptors, considerable advances have been made in understanding the molecular function of vitamin A. The requirement for vitamin A during early embryogenesis has successfully been examined in the vitamin A-deficient avian embryo during neurulation, when in the vertebrates crucial developmental decisions take place. These studies revealed that retinoic acid is essential during these early stages of embryogenesis for the initiation of organogenesis (i.e., formation of the heart). If retinoic acid is not present at this time, abnormal development ensues, leading to early embryonic death. Though the initial insult of the absence of vitamin A appears to be on the specification of cardiovascular tissues, subsequently all development is adversely affected and the embryo dies. Molecular and functional studies revealed that retinoic acid regulates the expression of the cardiogenic transcription factor GATA-4 and several heart asymmetry genes, which explains why the heart position is random in vitamin A-deficient quail embryos. During the crucial retinoic acid-requiring developmental window, retinoic acid transduces its signals to genes for heart morphogenesis via the receptors RARalpha2, RARgamma, and RXRalpha. Elucidation of the function of vitamin A during early embryonic development may lead to a better understanding of the cardiovascular birth defects prevalent in the Western world.

Function of RARgamma and RARalpha2 at the initiation of retinoid signaling is essential for avian embryo survival and for distinct events in cardiac morphogenesis.

Avian embryogenesis requires retinoid receptor activation by the vitamin A active form, retinoic acid (RA), during neurulation. We conducted loss-of-function analysis in quail embryos by nutritional deprivation of RA and by blocking generation of retinoid receptors. Here we identify a distinct role for RARalpha2 in cardiac inflow tract morphogenesis and for RARgamma in cardiac left/right orientation and looping morphogenesis. Blocking normal embryos with antisense oligonucleotides to RARalpha2 or RXRalpha diminishes GATA-4 transcripts, while blocking RARgamma or RXRalpha diminishes nodal and Pitx2 transcripts; the expression of these genes in the heart forming region resembles that of the vitamin A-deficient embryo. Blocking the function of RARgamma, RARalpha2, and RXRalpha recapitulates the complete vitamin A-deficient phenotype. RARgamma is the most potent mediator of the retinoid signal at this time of development. Our studies provide strong evidence that critical RA-requiring developmental events in the early avian embryo are regulated by means of distinct retinoid receptor signaling pathways.

Retinoid receptors and vitamin A deficiency: differential patterns of transcription during early avian development and the rapid induction of RARs by retinoic acid.

The functional links of specific retinoid receptors to early developmental events in the avian embryo are not known. Before such studies are undertaken, knowledge is required of the spatiotemporal expression patterns of the receptor genes and their regulation by endogenous retinoic acid levels during the early stages of development. Here, we report the expression patterns of mRNAs for RARalpha, RARalpha2, RARbeta2, RARgamma, RARgamma2, RXRalpha, and RARgamma from neurulation to HH10 in the normal and vitamin A-deficient (VAD) quail embryo. The transcripts for all retinoid receptors are detectable at HH5, except for RXRgamma, which is detected at the beginning of HH6. At the 4/5 somite stage of HH8, when retinoid signaling is initiated in the avian embryo, mRNAs of all receptors are present, with very strong and ubiquitous expression patterns for RARalpha, RARalpha2, RARgamma, RARgamma2, and RXRalpha, a persistent expression of RARgamma in the neural tissues, a strong expression of RARbeta2 in lateral plate mesoderm and somites, and an anterior expression of RXRgamma. All retinoid receptors are expressed in the heart primordia. In the VAD quail embryo, the general pattern of retinoid receptor transcript localization is similar to that of the normal, except that the expression of RARalpha2 and RARbeta2 is severely diminished. Administration of retinol or retinoic acid to VAD embryos at or before the 4/5 somite stage rescues the expression of RARalpha2 and RARbeta2 within approximately 45 min and restores normal development. RARbeta2 expression requires the expression of RARalpha2. After neurulation, the expression of all retinoid receptors in the VAD quail embryo becomes independent of vitamin A status and is similar to that of the normal. The mRNA levels and sites of expression of the key enzyme for retinoic acid biosynthesis, Raldh-2, are not affected by vitamin A status; the expression pattern is restricted and does not correspond to that of retinoid receptors at all sites. The general patterns and intensity of retinoid receptor gene expression during early quail development are comparable to those of the mammalian and thus validate the application of results from retinoid-regulated avian development studies to those of the mammalian.

A novel role for retinoids in patterning the avian forebrain during presomite stages.

Retinoids, and in particular retinoic acid (RA), are known to induce posterior fates in neural tissue. However, alterations in retinoid signalling dramatically affect anterior development. Previous reports have demonstrated a late role for retinoids in patterning craniofacial and forebrain structures, but an earlier role in anterior patterning is not well understood. We show that enzymes involved in synthesizing retinoids are expressed in the avian hypoblast and in tissues directly involved in head patterning, such as anterior definitive endoderm and prechordal mesendoderm. We found that in the vitamin A-deficient (VAD) quail model, which lacks biologically active RA from the first stages of development, anterior endodermal markers such as Bmp2, Bmp7, Hex and the Wnt antagonist crescent are affected during early gastrulation. Furthermore, prechordal mesendodermal and prospective ventral telencephalic markers are expanded posteriorly, Shh expression in the axial mesoderm is reduced, and Bmp2 and Bmp7 are abnormally expressed in the ventral midline of the neural tube. At early somite stages, VAD embryos have increased cell death in ventral neuroectoderm and foregut endoderm, but normal cranial neural crest production, whereas at later stages extensive apoptosis occurs in head mesenchyme and ventral neuroectoderm. As a result, VAD embryos end up with a single and reduced telencephalic vesicle and an abnormally patterned diencephalon. Therefore, we propose that retinoids have a dual role in patterning the anterior forebrain during development. During early gastrulation, RA acts in anterior endodermal cells to modulate the anteroposterior (AP) positional identity of prechordal mesendodermal inductive signals to the overlying neuroectoderm. Later on, at neural pore closure, RA is required for patterning of the mesenchyme of the frontonasal process and the forebrain by modulating signalling molecules involved in craniofacial morphogenesis.

Retinoid signaling regulates primitive (yolk sac) hematopoiesis.

It is known from nutritional studies that vitamin A is an important factor for normal hematopoiesis, though it has been difficult to define its precise role. The vitamin A-deficient (VAD) quail embryo provides an effective ligand "knockout" model for investigating the function of retinoids during development. The VAD embryo develops with a significant reduction in erythroid cells, which has not been noted previously. Activation of the primitive erythroid program and early expression of the erythroid marker GATA-1 occurs, though GATA-1 levels eventually decline, consistent with the erythropoietic and hemoglobin deficits. However, from its early stages, the GATA-2 gene fails to be expressed normally in VAD embryos. The bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)-signaling pathway regulates GATA-2, and BMP4 expression becomes reduced in the caudal embryonic region of VAD embryos. Adding BMP4 to cultured VAD-derived explants rescues the production of erythroid cells, whereas normal embryos cultured in the presence of the BMP antagonist noggin are defective in primitive hematopoiesis. We find that cell clusters of primitive blood islands undergo an inappropriate program of apoptosis in the VAD embryo, which can explain the deficit in differentiated primitive blood cells. We propose that vitamin A-derived retinoids are required for normal yolk sac hematopoiesis and that an embryonic retinoid-BMP-GATA-2 signaling pathway controls progenitor cell survival relevant to primitive hematopoiesis.