ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Shawn Shea's Chronological Assessment of Suicide Events (CASE approach) is worldwide, including the Netherlands, a well-known and widely used method for clinical interviewing a patient's suicidal state. However, the original description of the author is not always followed. AIM: Comparing the Dutch CASE approach with the original description. METHOD: The Dutch CASE approach has been explored on the basis of the text of the Dutch multidisciplinary guideline and current handbooks. This approach is compared with the original description. RESULTS: Three differences emerge. The main difference is that in the original CASE approach, seven validity techniques represent the foundation for investigation the suicidal state, while these are missing from the Dutch texts. Second, the chronological interview system in the Netherlands is interpreted differently than in the original CASE approach. Third, in the Netherlands, in contrast to the original approach, risk factors and protective factors are included in the study of the suicidal state. CONCLUSION: In the Netherlands, the CASE approach has been adopted in a simplified form, which is useful as a basic skill in the study of suicidal behavior. The diagnosis of suicidality can gain in depth, especially for advanced mental health professionals, by paying attention in training and education to the interviewing techniques of the original CASE approach.
Subject(s)
Suicidal Ideation , Suicide , Health Personnel , Humans , Research Design , Risk Factors , Suicide/psychologyABSTRACT
Background DESPITE VARIOUS NATIONAL INITIATIVES AND A STRONG MENTAL HEALTH CARE SYSTEM, THE NUMBER OF SUICIDES IN THE NETHERLANDS AND FLANDERS HAS NOT CHANGED AS HOPED. Aim TO PROVIDE INSIGHT INTO THE CURRENT SUICIDE PREVENTION POLICY IN THE NETHERLANDS AND FLANDERS, AND THE EVIDENCE ON THEIR EFFECTIVENESS. Method DISCUSSION OF UNIVERSAL, SELECTIVE AND INDICATED PREVENTION INITIATIVES, AND OF THE EVIDENCE FOR THE VARIOUS INITIATIVES, BASED ON THE USE OF REVIEWS AND META-ANALYSIS. Results THERE IS A NATIONAL SUICIDE PREVENTION AGENDA IN BOTH THE NETHERLANDS AND FLANDERS. IT IS DIFFICULT TO DEMONSTRATE THE DIRECT EFFECT OF THE VARIOUS INITIATIVES ON NATIONAL SUICIDE RATES, BECAUSE OF THE LOW BASE RATE, AND BECAUSE OF ITS MULTIPLE CAUSES. Conclusion THERE ARE LITTLE EVIDENCE FOR SUICIDE PREVENTION STRATEGIES. THIS DOES NOT MEAN SUICIDE PREVENTION HAS NO USE, BUT MODESTY SEEMS IN PLACE. Key words EVALUATION, POLICY, RCT, SUICIDE PREVENTION TIJDSCHRIFT VOOR PSYCHIATRIE 63(2021)2, 133-137.
Subject(s)
Suicide Prevention , Humans , NetherlandsABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Little is known about suicide among individuals with mild intellectual disabilities (mid).
AIM: To explore risk factors for suicide among a small group of clients with mid who committed suicide.
METHOD: Case files of 11 clients with mid were analysed using the Integrated Motivational Volitional model.
RESULTS: Most suicides seem to have taken place impulsively and not on the basis of a predetermined plan. Most clients had comorbid mental health problems, predominantly trauma-related, impulse control and externalizing behavioural problems. The (imminent) loss of contact, such as in the case of transfer from one ward to another ward or to a facility, seems an important risk factor for suicide.
CONCLUSION: Clients with mid residing in a treatment facility may have an increased risk of suicide because of an interaction between client characteristics and treatment context.
Subject(s)
Intellectual Disability , Suicide , Humans , Intellectual Disability/epidemiology , Risk FactorsABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Dutch policy aims to strengthen mental health care in general practices, to keep health care affordable. Recently, a new function (mental health nurses) and a new referral model for patients with mental health problems were introduced.
AIM: To explore to what extent the volume of mental health care in Dutch general practices has increased and to what extent the content changed in the period 2010-2015.
METHOD: This study employed: 1. analyses of medical records, and 2. a case study in a primary health care centre.
RESULTS: The number of general practices with at least one mental health nurse increased from 20% in 2010 to almost 90% in 2015. In the period 2010-2014, general practitioners (gps) and mental health nurses treated increasing numbers of patients with mental health problems. No task shifting from gps to mental health nurses was observed. In the period 2011-2015, the number of antidepressant prescriptions increased slightly. In 2014, gps in a well-prepared primary care centre allocated 87% of their patients with mental health problems to a treatment setting in line with the referral model.
CONCLUSION: Dutch general practices have recently provided more mental health care, thereby emphasising their important role in the mental health care system.
Subject(s)
Mental Disorders/diagnosis , Mental Disorders/therapy , Mental Health Services , Primary Health Care , Psychiatric Nursing , Antidepressive Agents/therapeutic use , General Practice , Humans , Mental Disorders/epidemiology , Mental Health Services/economics , Mental Health Services/standards , Netherlands , Primary Health Care/economicsABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The outreach emergency psychiatric service plays an important role in recognising, arranging interventions and preventing suicide and suicidal behaviour. However, little is known about the assessments that members of the emergency team make when faced with patients showing suicidal behaviour.
AIM: To describe the relationships that are revealed between patient characteristics, suicidal thoughts and attempted suicide during assessments made by the emergency psychiatric service in The Hague.
METHOD: The emergency service kept a detailed record of 14,705 consultations. We compared the characteristics of patients who had suicidal thoughts with those of patients who had no such thoughts and we also compared the characteristics of patients who had attempted to commit suicide with those of patients who had not. We drew these comparisons by using logistic regression models, adjusting for clustering.
RESULTS: 32.2% of the patients showed signs of suicidal behaviour and 9.2 % appeared likely to attempt suicide. Suicidal behaviour occurred most often in patients with depression. Suicidal patients were more often admitted to hospital than were non-suicidal patients and they were more likely to have been referred by a general practitioner or a general hospital. Medication was the most frequent means employed in attempts to commit suicide.
CONCLUSION: In about one third of the consultations of the outreach emergency psychiatric service, the patient showed suicidal behaviour. The actions and the policy of the emergency psychiatric service with regard to suicidal behaviour were diverse and dependent on factors that could change over the course of time.
Subject(s)
Behavior , Depression/psychology , Emergency Services, Psychiatric , Suicide, Attempted/psychology , Adult , Behavior/physiology , Depression/drug therapy , Depression/epidemiology , Female , Humans , Logistic Models , Male , Suicide, Attempted/statistics & numerical dataABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Suffering from a psychiatric disorder is a well-known risk factor for suicide and suicidal behavior. Treatment of psychiatric disorders can reduce the risk of suicidal behavior and suicide. In the Netherlands, however, since 2012 the treatment costs of some psychiatric disorders have no longer been covered by health insurance.
AIM: To find out what proportion of suicides were committed by patients with a psychiatric disorder for which treatment costs are no longer covered by health insurance since the rules changed in 2012.
METHOD: We studied the files of 314 patients who were known to one of the large mental health hospitals in the Netherlands and who had committed suicide between 1 January 1999 and January 2012. We were able to determine the various psychiatric disorders from which the patients were suffering at the time they died.
RESULTS: About 6% of the patients who committed suicide between 1999 and 2012 suffered from a psychiatric disorder for which treatment costs are now no longer covered by health insurance.
CONCLUSION: Given the results of this study, the increased rates of suicide in the Netherlands and the importance of scientific research into the characteristics of suicide, we recommend that patients with suicidal behavior are not excluded from adequate treatment in the event they may or may not have met the criteria for a DSM-IV classification.
Subject(s)
Insurance, Health , Mental Disorders/psychology , Suicide, Attempted/psychology , Suicide/psychology , Health Care Costs , Humans , Mental Disorders/therapy , Netherlands , Suicide, Attempted/prevention & control , Suicide PreventionABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: We investigated trends in suicidal behaviour as reported by Dutch general practices from 1983 to 2013. Also, we analysed the relationship with patient characteristics and with the financial crisis of 2008. DESIGN: Retrospective observational study. METHOD: We estimated age-adjusted and gender-specific trends in suicides (342) and attempted suicides (1614), as registered in 1983-2013 under ICPC code P77 by 40 Dutch general practices participating in the NIVEL Primary Care Database sentinel station. Secondary outcomes, on the basis of supplementary questions in the GP Information System (Huisartsen Informatie Systeem), were the relationship between suicidal behaviour, earlier treatments and patient characteristics. Also, we analysed separate frequencies for the periods 1983-2007 and 2008-2013. RESULTS: Join-point analyses revealed a significant rise in male suicides from 2008 (b = 0.32, SE = 0.1, p = 0.008), and an increase in male suicide attempts since 2009 (b = 0.19, SE = 0.04, p < 0.001). Female suicidal behaviour showed a steady decrease in 1989-2013: b = -0.03, SE = 0.007, p < 0.0001 for female suicide, b = -0.02, SE = 0.002, p < 0.001 for female attempts. Almost half of the suicidal patients had visited their GP one month before the event. In 31% of these patients, the GP had recognized suicidal behaviour. CONCLUSIONS: Since 2008, there was a rise in the male suicide rate while female suicide behaviour has continued to decline. Training in the early recognition of suicide ideation in depressive patients might improve suicide prevention in primary care.
Subject(s)
General Practice/statistics & numerical data , Suicide/statistics & numerical data , Adult , Female , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Netherlands , Retrospective Studies , Sex Factors , Suicide/psychology , Suicide, Attempted/psychology , Suicide, Attempted/statistics & numerical dataABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to examine mental health care provided by general practitioners and by mental health nurses working in general practices. DESIGN: Observational research. METHOD: We analysed how many consultations with patients with mental health problems were recorded in Dutch general practices in the period 2010-2014. General practices with and without a mental health nurse were compared, and we investigated which patients were mainly treated by mental health nurses. RESULTS: An increasing number of patients visited the GP for mental health problems in the period 2010-2014. GPs collaborating with a mental health nurse recorded a somewhat higher number of patients with mental health problems than GPs without a mental health nurse, but used as many consultations per patient. Mental health nurses mainly treat females, adult patients, and patients with common mental health problems. CONCLUSION: Mental health nurses do not take over care from GPs, but provide additional mental health care to patients with mental health problems. Collaborating with a mental health nurse might increase GPs' alertness to record mental health problems.
Subject(s)
Family Practice/methods , General Practice/methods , General Practitioners/psychology , Mental Disorders/nursing , Mental Health , Psychiatric Nursing , Adult , Female , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , NetherlandsABSTRACT
The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of the questions from the Beck Scale for Suicide Ideation on psychological well-being among healthy participants. In a randomized controlled study, 301 participants completed the same 4 questionnaires on psychopathology. The experimental group additionally answered 21 items of the Beck Scale for Suicide Ideation. The control group answered 19 items on Quality of Life. The experimental group showed a significantly smaller decrease of negative affect compared to the control condition. When analyzing participants with an increase in distress, 80% were part of the experimental group. For most participants, answering questions about suicide does not affect their mood. A small group of participants did react with some distress to the questions about suicide. As the questions about suicide were administered immediately before the questions about negative affect, the questions about suicide could have worked as a negative mood challenge. Future experimental research should further investigate the effect of questions about suicide among healthy participants, especially on the long term.
