124I PET Assessment of Response of Bone Metastases to Initial Radioiodine Treatment of Differentiated Thyroid Cancer.

Iodine-positive bone metastases (BMs) are often resistant after initial radioiodine therapy applying the standard-activity approach. A comprehensive lesion-based response study for BMs has not, to our knowledge, yet been performed. In this study, pretherapy and follow-up 124I PET/CT data on BMs from differentiated thyroid cancer patients were retrospectively analyzed to assess the relationship between absorbed dose (AD) of radiation and response after initial radioiodine treatment. METHODS: Before and after initial radioiodine therapy, patients underwent serial PET/CT scanning after administration of 20-40 MBq of 124I. The pretherapy PET data were used to segment BM volumes and to predict the average ADs after administration of dosimetry-guided 131I activity. The lower volume limit of determinability of the applied segmentation method was a sphere volume of 0.16 mL. This volume limit classified the BMs into known-volume and fixed-volume groups with their respective average and minimum ADs. Follow-up 124I and 18F-FDG PET/CT data after treatment were analyzed to assess lesion-based therapy response. Response rates at different AD thresholds were calculated and were expressed as the percentage of completely responding BMs above the respective AD threshold. BMs with a maximum extent greater than twice the PET spatial resolution were visually scored for nonuniformity. RESULTS: In total, 61 BMs in 10 patients were included, of which 46 and 15 comprised the known-volume group and the fixed-volume group, respectively. The median follow-up time was 5.6 mo (range, 3.7-23.2 mo). The median average and median minimum ADs in therapy were 183 Gy (range, 39-3,600 Gy) and 270 Gy (range, 63-1,300 Gy), respectively. A range of response rate of 70%-80% was achieved at an AD threshold range of 350-650 Gy. There were 26 BMs that were amenable to visual assessment of nonuniformity, of which two thirds (17/26) were scored as clearly nonuniform, and the majority (11/17) of these nonuniform BMs responded incompletely. CONCLUSION: Both the high AD threshold associated with high response rates and the low median AD per unit of 131I activity elucidate the difficulty in achieving therapeutic efficacy for BMs when a single standard activity is administered. The relatively high AD threshold range is possibly a result of distinct levels of spatial nonuniformity in ADs.

Assessment of lesion response in the initial radioiodine treatment of differentiated thyroid cancer using 124I PET imaging.

UNLABELLED: (124)I PET/CT images from differentiated thyroid cancer patients were retrospectively analyzed to assess the relationship between absorbed radiation dose (AD) to lesions and their response after radioiodine therapy. METHODS: Patients received serial (124)I PET/CT scans before and after their first radioiodine treatment. The pretherapy PET data were used to segment the lesion volumes and to predict the therapy-delivered ADs after administration of the therapeutic (131)I activity. The segmentation method's lower volume limit of determinability was a sphere of 0.80 mL, which classified the lesions into a known-volume group (>0.80 mL) or a small-volume group (≤0.80 mL) with their respective average and minimum ADs. The posttherapy PET data were used to assess the lesion-based therapy success. In the known-volume group, the response rate was calculated on the basis of lesions that received average ADs above the generally accepted threshold of 85 Gy for metastases and 300 Gy for thyroid remnants (TRs) and was expressed as the percentage of completely responding lesions. In the small-volume group, the metastasis and TR responses were evaluated for 3 minimum-AD groups: 5 to 10 Gy (TR, 5 to 30 Gy), >10 to 85 Gy (TR, >30 to 300 Gy), and >85 Gy (TR, >300 Gy). Their response rates were calculated in terms of the percentage of completely responding lesions in each minimum-AD group. RESULTS: In total, 59 lesions in 17 patients were amenable to reliable volume estimation. The response rates were 63%, 88%, and 90% for lymph node metastases (LMs), pulmonary metastases, and TRs, respectively. The response rates of 168 small lesions in 34 patients were more than 82% for LMs and more than 91% for TRs in each of the 3 minimum-AD groups; all small pulmonary metastases responded completely. CONCLUSION: In the known-volume group, the response rate for TRs matched well with historical data derived using (131)I scintigraphy imaging, whereas the response rate for LMs was not as high as expected, which may be explained by too short a follow-up time for a few LMs and a higher sensitivity of PET imaging. Small lesions were treated effectively, suggesting that they are considerably smaller than 0.80 mL.