Factors impeding the discovery of an intervention-based treatment for type 1 diabetes.

Type 1 diabetes (T1D) is one of the most common and severe chronic diseases affecting both children and adults. The aetiology of the disease remains unknown, and thus far no 'true' cure for those affected is available. Indeed, exogenous insulin replacement therapy to manage glucose metabolism to the best degree possible remains the current standard of care. However, despite a recent array of truly impressive improvements designed to enhance disease management (e.g. insulin analogues, continuous glucose monitoring, insulin pumps), it is still difficult for the vast majority of patients to reach recommended target HbA1C levels (< 7.0%). As a result of suboptimal disease management, far too many patients with T1D have an increased risk for disease-associated complications such as nephropathy, neuropathy and retinopathy, as well as hypoglycaemia. New treatment modalities are therefore needed urgently to bring a 'true' cure (disease prevention/disease reversal) to patients with T1D. Here we consider issues that collectively pose a major stumbling block in T1D research with respect to identifying a means to prevent and/or cure the disease. We begin this Perspective by discussing new insights emanating from studies of the pancreas in human T1D; findings which may, at least in part, explain why previous interventions seeking disease prevention/reversal have yielded insufficient benefit. We then turn to suggestions that could optimise the outcome of future clinical trials. Finally, we direct attention to recommendations for the global T1D research community; messages we deem to have the potential to improve our chances of finding the elusive T1D 'cure'.

Emerging immune therapies in type 1 diabetes and pancreatic islet transplantation.

In type 1 diabetes (T1D) the immune system attacks insulin-producing pancreatic ß-cells. Unfortunately, our ability to curb this pathogenic autoimmune response in a disease- and organ-specific manner is still very limited due to the inchoate understanding of the exact nature and the kinetics of the immunological pathomechanisms that lead to T1D. None of the clinical immune interventions thus far, which focused primarily on new-onset disease, were successful in producing lasting remission or curbing recurrent autoimmunity. However, these studies do provide us access to a tremendous amount of clinical data and specimens, which will aid us in revising our therapeutical approaches and defining the highly needed paradigm shift in T1D immunotherapy. Analysing the foundation and the results of the most current T1D immunotherapeutic trials, this article gives an outlook for future directions of the field.

Immunology in the clinic review series: focus on type 1 diabetes and viruses: the role of viruses in type 1 diabetes: a difficult dilemma.

Convincing evidence now indicates that viruses are associated with type 1 diabetes (T1D) development and progression. Human enteroviruses (HEV) have emerged as prime suspects, based on detection frequencies around clinical onset in patients and their ability to rapidly hyperglycaemia trigger in the non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse. Whether or not HEV can truly cause islet autoimmunity or, rather, act by accelerating ongoing insulitis remains a matter of debate. In view of the disease's globally rising incidence it is hypothesized that improved hygiene standards may reduce the immune system's ability to appropriately respond to viral infections. Arguments in favour of and against viral infections as major aetiological factors in T1D will be discussed in conjunction with potential pathological scenarios. More profound insights into the intricate relationship between viruses and their autoimmunity-prone host may lead ultimately to opportunities for early intervention through immune modulation or vaccination.

Incidental CD8 T cell reactivity against caspase-cleaved apoptotic self-antigens from ubiquitously expressed proteins in islets from prediabetic human leucocyte antigen-A2 transgenic non-obese diabetic mice.

Apoptosis is known as a major mechanism which contributes to beta cell decay in type 1 diabetes. Commitment to this pathway generally involves caspase-mediated protein cleavage and was found to induce cross-presentation of a specific antigen repertoire under certain inflammatory conditions. We aimed to assess the significance of the CD8 T cell population reactive against such caspase-cleaved apoptotic self-antigens in pancreatic islets of prediabetic human leucocyte antigen (HLA)-A2 transgenic non-obese diabetic chimeric monochain transgene construct (NOD.HHD) mice. We have reproduced a unique peptide library consisting of human CD8 T cell-derived apoptosis-specific antigens, all of which belong to structural proteins expressed ubiquitously in human islets. Pancreatic islets from prediabetic NOD.HHD mice, harbouring humanized major histocompatibilty complex (MHC) class I, were isolated and handpicked at various ages, and islet-infiltrating CD8 T cells were expanded in vitro and used as responders in an interferon (IFN)-γ enzyme-linked immunospot (ELISPOT) assay. Human T2 cells were used as antigen-presenting cells (APC) to avoid endogenous antigen presentation. Analogous to the interindividual variability found with peptides from known islet autoantigens such as islet-specific glucose-6-phosphatase catalytic subunit related protein (IGRP) and insulin, some mice showed variable, low-degree CD8 T cell reactivity against caspase-cleaved self-antigens. Because reactivity was predominantly minor and often undetectable, we conclude that beta cell apoptosis does not routinely provoke the development of dominant cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) reactive against caspase-cleaved self-antigens in the NOD.HHD model.

Anti-thymoglobulin (ATG) treatment does not reverse type 1 diabetes in the acute virally induced rat insulin promoter-lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (RIP-LCMV) model.

Immune modulators such as anti-thymoglobulin (ATG) are under clinical evaluation for the treatment of type 1 diabetes (T1D). Although such agents have cured T1D in the non-obese diabetic (NOD) model, their clinical efficacy has been much lower. In order to improve the odds of successful translation from bench to bedside, we propose to evaluate this agent under more stringent conditions. Here, we evaluated the capacity of ATG to reverse T1D in the acute rat insulin promoter-lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (RIP-LCMV) model. RIP-LCMV-glycoprotein (GP) mice were treated after new-onset T1D with murine ATG antibodies. Although ATG treatment did not impair viral clearance it failed to reverse new-onset T1D in this model. The CD4:CD8 ratio was reduced drastically upon LCMV infection due to an expansion of CD8 effectors but ameliorated in ATG-treated mice. Although the percentage of CD4(+) CD25(+) regulatory T cells (T(regs) ) within the CD4(+) population was increased significantly after ATG therapy, their frequency in the periphery was reduced dramatically and never returned to normal baseline. The inability of ATG treatment to cure T1D in a stringent viral model (RIP-LCMV mice) is due at least partially to the inability to maintain or increase a sufficient CD4(+) CD25(+) T(regs) frequency, in striking contrast with what was reported in the NOD model. Our data would argue for the use of multiple animal models to assess efficacy of promising immune-based interventions and select the most potent therapies for future clinical trials.

99th Dahlem conference on infection, inflammation and chronic inflammatory disorders: viruses, autoimmunity and immunoregulation.

Based on studies in animal models, viral infections, in particular by enteroviruses, can accelerate or halt type 1 diabetes (T1D) development. Among factors that determine the outcome are the degree of viral replication in the target organ (viral titres), the tropism of the virus for beta cells, and the precise time-point of infection in relation to the diabetogenic process. Mechanisms underlying these phenomena have been assessed in mouse studies and should now be verified for human T1D. For enhancement of diabetes development, up-regulation of interferon pathways, expression of class-I major histocompatibility complexes and Toll-like receptor-dependent immunity appear important. In contrast, prevention of T1D involves pathways that the immune system usually invokes to shut down anti-viral responses to limit immunopathology, and which can 'clean out' autoreactive memory effector T cells as a bystander phenomenon: up-regulation of inhibitory molecules and invigoration of regulatory T cell (T(reg)) function. Importantly, these immunoregulatory processes also appear to foster and sustain persistent viral infections. Induction of immunoregulatory mechanisms, and in particular the phenotype and function of T(regs), is of interest therapeutically and will be discussed.

Mouse Models for Type 1 Diabetes.

Our understanding of the genetics, aetiology and pathogenesis of Type 1 Diabetes (T1D) was propelled by the discovery of animal models of T1D in the late 1970s and early 1980s, particularly the non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse. Since then, transgenic and gene-targeting technologies allowed the generation of many models with reduced genetic and pathogenic complexity. These models allowed researchers to zoom in on specific aspects of this complex disease. In this review, we provide an overview of currently available mouse models for T1D.

IL-10 and the resolution of infections.

Chronic viral infections pose serious health concerns, as secondary complications such as immunodeficiencies and cancers are common. Treating such infections with conventional vaccine approaches has proved to be difficult. Studies in animals and humans suggest that vaccine failure is probably due to exhaustion of antiviral T cell responses, which occurs in a number of chronic infections. Attempts to elucidate the causes of impairment of antiviral immunity have pointed to a role for the immunomodulatory cytokine IL-10 in the ability of viruses to establish persistence. Induction of IL-10 production by the host during chronic infection appears to be one of the viral means to alter the class of the antiviral immune response and induce generalized immune suppression. Recent work by us and others suggests that it is possible to resuscitate antiviral immunity by interfering with the IL-10 signalling pathway. Targeting IL-10 thus constitutes a promising alternative to conventional vaccine strategies which have not proved to be successful in treating chronic infections. In addition, sterile cure may be achieved with minimal side-effects by combining agents that alter the IL-10 signalling pathway with other compounds, such as antiviral drugs or interferon, but also agents neutralizing other crucial elements of T cell exhaustion, such as PD-1.

Coupling of oral human or porcine insulin to the B subunit of cholera toxin (CTB) overcomes critical antigenic differences for prevention of type I diabetes.

Our earlier investigations have demonstrated a critical difference in the efficacy of orally administered porcine compared to human or mouse insulin (no effect) in preventing type I diabetes in two distinct experimental models. Based on these findings one has to assume that certain insulins might not be suitable for the induction of oral 'tolerance'/bystander suppression, which might be one cause for recent failures in human oral antigen trials. Here we demonstrate that coupling to the non-toxic subunit of cholera toxin (CTB) can abolish these differences in efficacy between human and porcine insulin. As expected, an added benefit was the much smaller oral antigen dose required to induce CD4+ insulin-B specific regulatory cells that bystander-suppress autoaggressive responses. Mechanistically we found that uptake or transport of insulin-CTB conjugates in the gut occurs at least partially via binding to GM-1, which would explain the enhanced clinical efficacy. Both B chains bound well to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II, indicating comparable immunological potential once uptake and processing has occurred. Thus, our findings delineate a pathway to overcome issues in oral antigen choice for prevention of type I diabetes.

The cholera toxin B subunit is a mucosal adjuvant for oral tolerance induction in type 1 diabetes.

When conjugated to various proteins, the nontoxic B-chain of cholera toxin (CTB) significantly increases the ability of these proteins to induce immunological tolerance after oral administration. Here, we investigated if a nonconjugated form of CTB enhances the induction of immune tolerance after oral insulin administration. Induction of immunological tolerance was studied after oral administration of insulin preparations in three mouse models; an insulin/ovalbumin coimmunization model, a model of virus-induced diabetes in transgenic RIP-LCMV-NP mice and in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice serving as a model of spontaneous diabetes. In the immunization model, we demonstrate that mixing with CTB increases the tolerogenic potential of insulin, approximately 10 fold. Titration of the CTB concentration in this system revealed that an insulin : CTB ratio of 100 : 1 was optimal for the induction of bystander suppression. Further studies revealed that this insulin : CTB ratio also was optimal for the prevention of diabetes in a virus-induced, transgenic diabetes model. In addition, the administration of this optimal insulin-CTB preparation significantly prevented the onset of diabetes in old NOD mice with established islet infiltration. The data presented here demonstrate that CTB, even in its unconjugated form, functions as a mucosal adjuvant, increasing the specific tolerogenic effect of oral insulin.

Infection-triggered regulatory mechanisms override the role of STAT 4 in control of the immune response to influenza virus antigens.

Accurate control of the balance of the T1 and T2 cells during antiviral immunity is essential for optimizing immune effector functions and for avoiding potentially severe immunopathology. We examined the in vivo role of the signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT) 4 in regulating the T1/T2 balance during the response to live influenza virus and isolated viral proteins. We found that the differentiation of gamma interferon (IFN-gamma)-producing Th1 and Tc1 cells after inoculation of live virus occurred independently of STAT 4 expression. Influenza virus-specific T2 and Tc2 responses were well controlled in such STAT 4-deficient mice unless IFN-gamma was eliminated as well. In contrast, the STAT 4-dependent signaling pathway played a more essential role in regulating the T1/T2 balance after immunization with viral proteins and, in particular, inactivated nonreplicating virus. Pulmonary infection was cleared even in the absence of both functional STAT 4 genes and functional IFN-gamma genes because virus-neutralizing antibodies were still generated, consistent with a substantial redundancy in different antiviral effector pathways. Thus, replicating agents such as live influenza virus can elicit IFN-gamma and control T2 immunity independently of STAT 4, whereas the profile of immunity to isolated proteins is more reliant on an intact STAT 4 signaling pathway.

Protection from type 1 diabetes in the face of high levels of activated autoaggressive lymphocytes in a viral transgenic mouse model crossed to the SV129 strain.

In comparing the incidence of virally induced type 1 diabetes in F(1) crosses of RIP-LCMV mice to three different mouse strains identical at the major histocompatibility complex H-2D(b) locus, we surprisingly found that disease development was reduced by 80% in F(1) crosses to the SV129 genetic background and by 60% after eight backcrosses to the original C57BL/6 RIP-LCMV mice. In this model, diabetes is strongly dependent on a virally induced H-2D(b)-restricted cytotoxic T-cell (CTL) response. Importantly, numbers and effector functions of autoaggressive CD4 and CD8 lymphocytes were not decreased in the protected mice, and CTLs were still able to kill syngeneic islet cells in vitro with equal efficacy compared with CTLs from the original RIP-LCMV strain. Furthermore, CTLs were able to extravasate into islets in vivo, and no evidence for induction of regulatory cells was observed. However, regeneration of beta-cells in islets under "attack" occurred only in the protected SV129-crossed animals, whereas it was not evident at any time in any mice that developed diabetes. Thus, genetic factors can "override" the diabetogenic potential of high numbers of autoaggressive lymphocytes through, for example, increased islet regeneration. This finding has important implications for interpreting numbers and pathogenicity of autoreactive lymphocytes in prediabetic patients of genetically diverse backgrounds.

Design of immune-based interventions in autoimmunity and viral infections--the need for predictive models that integrate time, dose and classes of immune responses.

The outcome of both autoimmune reactions and antiviral responses depends on a complex network of multiple components of the immune system. For example, most immune reactions can be viewed as a balance of aggressive and regulatory processes. Thus, a component of the immune system that has beneficial effects in one situation might have detrimental effects elsewhere: organ-specific immunity and autoimmunity are both governed by this paradigm. Additionally, the precise timing and magnitude of an immune response can frequently be more critical than its composition for determining efficacy as well as damage. These issues make the design of immune-based interventions very difficult, because it is frequently impossible to predict the outcome. For example, certain cytokines can either cure or worsen autoimmune processes depending on their dose and timing in relation to the ongoing disease process. Consequently, there is a strong need for models that can predict the outcome of immune-based interventions taking these considerations into account.

A dual role for TNF-alpha in type 1 diabetes: islet-specific expression abrogates the ongoing autoimmune process when induced late but not early during pathogenesis.

We report here that islet-specific expression of TNF-alpha can play a dual role in autoimmune diabetes, depending on its precise timing in relation to the ongoing autoimmune process. In a transgenic model (rat insulin promoter-lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus) of virally induced diabetes, TNF-alpha enhanced disease incidence when induced through an islet-specific tetracycline-dependent promoter system early during pathogenesis. Blockade of TNF-alpha during this phase prevented diabetes completely, suggesting its pathogenetic importance early in disease development. In contrast, TNF-alpha expression abrogated the autoimmune process when induced late, which was associated with a reduction of autoreactive CD8 lymphocytes in islets and their lytic activities. Thus, the fine-tuned kinetics of an autoreactive process undergo distinct stages that respond in a differential way to the presence of TNF-alpha. This observation has importance for understanding the complex role of inflammatory cytokines in autoimmunity.

Tolerance induction with agonist peptides recognized by autoaggressive lymphocytes is transient: therapeutic potential for type 1 diabetes is limited and depends on time-point of administration, choice of epitope and adjuvant.

Immunization with agonist peptides recognized by autoaggressive lymphocytes has been used successfully in several animal models for type 1 diabetes (T1D) or multiple sclerosis (MS) to prevent disease. Depending on the timing of immunization, use of adjuvant and route of administration either elimination of autoaggressive T cells or induction of regulation reflected by cytokine shifts were described. Since it was also reported that such agonist peptides could enhance autoimmunity by activating aggressive lymphocytes, our goal was to re-evaluate their efficacy in an antigen-specific model of virally-induced T1D that allowed us to precisely track the autoaggressive response. We find that rather than the route of administration (oral versus sc) the precise timing is important for inducing tolerance to self-antigens. Tolerance is transient and only immunization during a susceptible phase 10 to 20 days prior to the induction of disease but not in prediabetic mice resulted in protection. Further, use of a stronger adjuvant (CFA) compared to IFA enhanced the protective effect. Mechanistically, a transient loss of autoaggressive T cells was responsible for preventing disease, the effect was quantitative and no regulatory lymphocytes or cytokine shifts were induced by any of our treatments. Thus, MHC class I-restricted agonist peptides might only find a limited use in treating autoimmune disorders, because tolerance induction is transient and treatment has to be given very early, ideally prior to activation of the aggressive response.

Structural and functional identification of major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted self-peptides as naturally occurring molecular mimics of viral antigens. Possible role in CD8+ T cell-mediated, virus-induced autoimmune disease.

Structural similarity (molecular mimicry) between viral epitopes and self-peptides can lead to the induction of autoaggressive CD4(+) as well as CD8(+) T cell responses. Based on the flexibility of T cell receptor/antigen/major histocompatibility complex recognition, it has been proposed that a self-peptide could replace a viral epitope for T cell recognition and therefore participate in pathophysiological processes in which T cells are involved. To address this issue, we used, as a molecular model of viral antigen, the H-2D(b)-restricted immunodominant epitope nucleoprotein (NP)-(396-404) (FQPQNGQFI) of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV). We identified peptide sequences from murine self-proteins that share structural and functional homology with LCMV NP-(396-404) and that bound to H-2D(b) with high affinity. One of these self-peptides, derived from tumor necrosis factor receptor I (FGPSNWHFM, amino acids 302-310), maintained LCMV-specific CD8(+) T cells in an active state as observed both in vitro in cytotoxic assays and in vivo in a model of virus-induced autoimmune diabetes, the rat insulin promoter-LCMV NP transgenic mouse. The natural occurrence and molecular concentration at the surface of H-2(b) spleen cells of tumor necrosis factor receptor I-(302-310) were determined by on-line micro-high pressure liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry and supported its biological relevance.

Virus-induced autoimmune diabetes: most beta-cells die through inflammatory cytokines and not perforin from autoreactive (anti-viral) cytotoxic T-lymphocytes.

Autoimmune diabetes is caused by selective loss of insulin-producing pancreatic beta-cells. The main factors directly implicated in beta-cell death are autoreactive, cytotoxic (islet-antigen specific) T-lymphocytes (CTL), and inflammatory cytokines. In this study, we have used an antigen-specific model of virally induced autoimmune diabetes to demonstrate that even high numbers of autoreactive CTL are unable to lyse beta-cells by perforin unless major histocompatibility complex class I is upregulated on islets. This requires the presence of inflammatory cytokines induced by viral infection of the exocrine pancreas but not of the beta-cells. Unexpectedly, we found that the resulting perforin-mediated killing of beta-cells by autoreactive CTL is not sufficient to lead to clinically overt diabetes in vivo, and it is not an absolute prerequisite for the development of insulitis, as shown by studies in perforin-deficient transgenic mice. In turn, destruction of beta-cells also requires a direct effect of gamma-interferon (IFN-gamma), which is likely to be in synergy with other cytokines, as shown in double transgenic mice that express a mutated IFN-gamma receptor on their beta-cells in addition to the viral (target) antigen and do not develop diabetes. Thus, destruction of most beta-cells occurs as cytokine-mediated death and requires IFN-gama in addition to perforin. Understanding these kinetics could be of high conceptual importance for the design of suitable interventions in prediabetic individuals at risk to develop type 1 diabetes.