Suprapatellar tibial nailing, why have we changed? / Enclavado de tibia suprapatelar, ¿por qué hemos cambiado?

INTRODUCTION: Endomedullary nailing using the infrapatellar approach (IP) is considered the gold standard for the treatment of tibial diaphyseal fractures, however, it has been associated with greater difficulty in reduction and complications such as malalignment in procurvatum and anterior knee pain. The suprapatellar approach (SP) arises as an alternative to solve these aspects, also being associated with a shorter intraoperative time and a lower dose and fluoroscopy time. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Retrospective comparative study between a group of 22 fractures treated by SP approach and another of 30 fractures intervened by IP transtendinous approach. Perioperative variables were analyzed, as well as clinical, radiological, and functional aspects in outpatient visits at 3, 6 and 12 months. RESULTS: No differences were found between groups in terms of intraoperative time, anemization, quality of reduction or complications during follow-up, among others. At 12 months, 12 (54.5%) SP cases and 16 (53.3%) IP presented anterior knee pain, without significant differences. In the evaluation scales, significant differences were recorded in the IKDC (International Knee Documentation Committee) in favor of the SP technique 88.45 (76.44-91.1) vs. IP 69 (49.95-80) (p=.006), with no significant differences in other functional scales analyzed. CONCLUSIONS: According to what has been described so far in the literature, the present study supports the tendency toward SP nailing by improving the functional results (IKDC) in the medium term compared to the traditional IP technique, without increasing complications. Likewise, surgeons perceive greater technical ease for reduction and simplicity in obtaining intraoperative radiological images.

Enclavado de tibia suprapatelar, ¿por qué hemos cambiado? / Suprapatellar tibial nailing, why have we changed?

Introducción: El enclavado endomedular mediante abordaje infrapatelar (IP) se considera el gold estándar del tratamiento de las fracturas diafisarias de tibia, sin embargo, se ha asociado a mayor dificultad para la reducción y complicaciones como la mala alineación en procurvatum y al dolor anterior de rodilla. El abordaje suprapatelar (SP) surge como alternativa para solventar estos aspectos, asociándose también con un menor tiempo intraoperatorio y menor dosis y tiempo de fluoroscopia. Material y métodos: Estudio retrospectivo comparativo entre: un grupo de 22 fracturas intervenidas mediante abordaje SP y otro de 30 fracturas intervenidas por abordaje IP trastendinoso. Se analizaron variables perioperatorias y aspectos clínicos, radiológicos y funcionales en consulta a los 3, 6 y 12 meses. Resultados: No se encontraron diferencias entre grupos en cuanto a tiempo intraoperatorio, anemización, calidad de la reducción, o complicaciones en el seguimiento, entre otros. A los 12 meses, 12 (54,5%) casos SP y 16 (53,3%) IP presentaban dolor anterior de rodilla, sin diferencias significativas. En las escalas de evaluación, se registraron diferencias significativas en la IKDC (International Knee Documentation Committee) a favor de la técnica SP (88,45 [76,44-91,1] vs. IP 69 [49,95-80]) (p=0,006), sin diferencias significativas en otras escalas funcionales analizadas. Conclusiones: En consonancia con lo hasta ahora descrito en la literatura, el presente estudio apoya la tendencia hacia el enclavado SP por mejorar los resultados funcionales (IKDC) a medio plazo respecto a la técnica tradicional IP, sin aumentar las complicaciones. Asimismo se percibe por los cirujanos una mayor facilidad técnica para la reducción y sencillez en la obtención de imágenes radiológicas intraoperatorias.(AU)

Introduction: Endomedullary nailing using the infrapatellar approach (IP) is considered the gold standard for the treatment of tibial diaphyseal fractures, however, it has been associated with greater difficulty in reduction and complications such as malalignment in procurvatum and anterior knee pain. The suprapatellar approach (SP) arises as an alternative to solve these aspects, also being associated with a shorter intraoperative time and a lower dose and fluoroscopy time. Material and methods: Retrospective comparative study between a group of 22 fractures treated by SP approach and another of 30 fractures intervened by IP transtendinous approach. Perioperative variables were analyzed, as well as clinical, radiological, and functional aspects in outpatient visits at 3, 6 and 12 months. Results: No differences were found between groups in terms of intraoperative time, anemization, quality of reduction or complications during follow-up, among others. At 12 months, 12 (54.5%) SP cases and 16 (53.3%) IP presented anterior knee pain, without significant differences. In the evaluation scales, significant differences were recorded in the IKDC (International Knee Documentation Committee) in favor of the SP technique 88.45 (76.44–91.1) vs. IP 69 (49.95–80) (p=.006), with no significant differences in other functional scales analyzed. Conclusions: According to what has been described so far in the literature, the present study supports the tendency toward SP nailing by improving the functional results (IKDC) in the medium term compared to the traditional IP technique, without increasing complications. Likewise, surgeons perceive greater technical ease for reduction and simplicity in obtaining intraoperative radiological images.(AU)

Suprapatellar tibial nailing, why have we changed? / Enclavado de tibia suprapatelar, ¿por qué hemos cambiado?

Introduction: Endomedullary nailing using the infrapatellar approach (IP) is considered the gold standard for the treatment of tibial diaphyseal fractures, however, it has been associated with greater difficulty in reduction and complications such as malalignment in procurvatum and anterior knee pain. The suprapatellar approach (SP) arises as an alternative to solve these aspects, also being associated with a shorter intraoperative time and a lower dose and fluoroscopy time. Material and methods: Retrospective comparative study between a group of 22 fractures treated by SP approach and another of 30 fractures intervened by IP transtendinous approach. Perioperative variables were analyzed, as well as clinical, radiological, and functional aspects in outpatient visits at 3, 6 and 12 months. Results: No differences were found between groups in terms of intraoperative time, anemization, quality of reduction or complications during follow-up, among others. At 12 months, 12 (54.5%) SP cases and 16 (53.3%) IP presented anterior knee pain, without significant differences. In the evaluation scales, significant differences were recorded in the IKDC (International Knee Documentation Committee) in favor of the SP technique 88.45 (76.44–91.1) vs. IP 69 (49.95–80) (p=.006), with no significant differences in other functional scales analyzed. Conclusions: According to what has been described so far in the literature, the present study supports the tendency toward SP nailing by improving the functional results (IKDC) in the medium term compared to the traditional IP technique, without increasing complications. Likewise, surgeons perceive greater technical ease for reduction and simplicity in obtaining intraoperative radiological images.(AU)

Introducción: El enclavado endomedular mediante abordaje infrapatelar (IP) se considera el gold estándar del tratamiento de las fracturas diafisarias de tibia, sin embargo, se ha asociado a mayor dificultad para la reducción y complicaciones como la mala alineación en procurvatum y al dolor anterior de rodilla. El abordaje suprapatelar (SP) surge como alternativa para solventar estos aspectos, asociándose también con un menor tiempo intraoperatorio y menor dosis y tiempo de fluoroscopia. Material y métodos: Estudio retrospectivo comparativo entre: un grupo de 22 fracturas intervenidas mediante abordaje SP y otro de 30 fracturas intervenidas por abordaje IP trastendinoso. Se analizaron variables perioperatorias y aspectos clínicos, radiológicos y funcionales en consulta a los 3, 6 y 12 meses. Resultados: No se encontraron diferencias entre grupos en cuanto a tiempo intraoperatorio, anemización, calidad de la reducción, o complicaciones en el seguimiento, entre otros. A los 12 meses, 12 (54,5%) casos SP y 16 (53,3%) IP presentaban dolor anterior de rodilla, sin diferencias significativas. En las escalas de evaluación, se registraron diferencias significativas en la IKDC (International Knee Documentation Committee) a favor de la técnica SP (88,45 [76,44-91,1] vs. IP 69 [49,95-80]) (p=0,006), sin diferencias significativas en otras escalas funcionales analizadas. Conclusiones: En consonancia con lo hasta ahora descrito en la literatura, el presente estudio apoya la tendencia hacia el enclavado SP por mejorar los resultados funcionales (IKDC) a medio plazo respecto a la técnica tradicional IP, sin aumentar las complicaciones. Asimismo se percibe por los cirujanos una mayor facilidad técnica para la reducción y sencillez en la obtención de imágenes radiológicas intraoperatorias.(AU)

Relação eletromiográfica integrada dos músculos vasto medial oblíquo e vasto lateral longo na marcha em sujeitos com e sem síndrome de dor femoropatelar / Relación electromiográfica integrada de los músculos vasto medial oblicuo y vasto lateral largo en marcha en individuos con y sin síndrome de dolor femoropatelar / Integrated electromyographic ratio of the vastus medialis oblique and vastus lateralis longus muscles in gait in subjects with and without patellofemoral pain syndrome

O objetivo deste estudo foi determinar se existe diferença na ativação dos músculos vasto medial oblíquo (VMO) e vasto lateral longo (VLL) durante a marcha em esteira plana e inclinada a 5° entre sujeitos clinicamente normais e portadores da síndrome da dor femoropatelar (SDFP). Dados eletromiográficos foram obtidos dos músculos VMO e VLL em 15 sujeitos clinicamente normais e em 12 portadores da SDFP. O valor da relação VMO/VLL foi determinado a partir da média de oito passadas, em cada condição, obtidas durante 12s. O teste t de Student mostrou não haver diferença significativa na relação VMO/VLL entre os dois grupos, independente da condição. Apesar de não haver diferença significativa, os sujeitos do grupo controle mostraram maiores valores na relação VMO/VLL, nas duas condições testadas, do que os sujeitos do grupo SDFP. Os achados sugerem que a relação da atividade elétrica dos músculos VMO e VLL, em indivíduos com e sem SDFP, é igual na marcha, tanto em superfície plana como em com inclinação de 5°.

The aim of this study was to determine if there is difference between the vastus medialis oblique and vastus lateralis longus (VMO/VLL) muscles activation during treadmill gait level and ascending to 5 percent degree between healthy subjects and others with patellofemoral pain syndrome. Electromyographic data from the VMO and VLL muscles were obtained in 15 subjects without and 12 with patellofemoral pain syndrome (PFPS) during treadmill gait with and without 5 degrees inclination. The value of the VMO/VLL ratio was determined from the mean of 8 strides, in each condition, during 12 s. The t-Student test did not show significant difference in the VMO/VLL ratio between the two groups, regardless the condition. Although there was not significant difference, the subjects of the control group showed higher values in the VMO/VLL ratio in the two tested conditions than the subject of the PFPS group. The findings suggest that the ratio of the electric activity of the VMO and VLL muscles in individuals with and without SDFP is equal in the gait on flat surface as well as slanted to 5 degrees.

El objetivo de este estudio ha sido determinar si existe diferencia en la activación de los músculos vasto medial oblicuo (VMO) y vasto lateral largo (VLL) durante la caminada en cinta plana ergométrica e inclinada a 5° entre individuos clínicamente normales y portadores de síndrome de dolor femoropatelar (SDFP). Datos electromiográficos se obtuvieron de los músculos VMO y VLL en 15 sujetos clínicamente normales y 12 portadores de SDFP. El valor de la relación VMO/VLL se determinó a partir de la media de 8 pasadas, a cada condición, durante 12 s. El test t de Student mostró que no hay diferencia significativa en la relación VMO/VLL entre los dos grupos, independiente de la condición. A pesar de no haber diferencia significativa, los integrantes del grupo control mostraron mayores valores en VMO/VLL, durante las dos condiciones probadas que los del grupo SDFP. Los hallazgos sugieren que la relación de actividad eléctrica de los músculos VMO y VLL, en individuos con y sin SDFP es igual en el trote tanto en superficie plana como la que tiene inclinación de 5°.