Uterus transplantation: A scoping review focused on obstetric outcomes.

BACKGROUND: Congenital uterine anomalies include a wide diversity of uterine malformations that can compromise reproductive potential. Uterus transplantation (UTx) proposes an innovative treatment for absolute uterine factor infertility; however, there is a lack of standardized protocols to guide clinical management among this population. OBJECTIVES: To describe recipient and donor characteristics and obstetric outcomes in patients undergoing UTx. SEARCH STRATEGY: We performed a literature search using the PubMed database to retrieve available scientific articles. We analyzed the references of included articles to assess additional articles that could be eligible to be included in the review. Likewise, we identified further studies using other methods, including Google Scholar. SELECTION CRITERIA: Titles and abstracts were screened in duplicate to select original reports with information available for the outcomes of interest. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: This review assessed the advantages and disadvantages of the techniques used, patient characteristics, obstetric and non-obstetric complications, functional duration of the organ, and neonatal outcomes. MAIN RESULTS: Among the 36 reports included in this review we found 55 pregnancies and 38 live births following UTx and a higher success rate for in vivo uterine donations. The most common obstetric complications reported included miscarriage, pre-eclampsia, and gestational hypertension. The most common non-obstetric complications reported include episodes of rejection, acute kidney injury, anemia, and cholestasis. Living donors required a comprehensive preoperative workup, decreasing organ rejection, infection, and vascular complications. CONCLUSIONS: More studies are needed to standardize the UTx procedure and improve obstetric, fetal, and neonatal outcomes. Further understanding of which recipient and donor characteristics minimize complications will significantly decrease the risk of adverse outcomes.

Uterus Transplantation as Infertility Treatment in Gynecological Cancer Survivors: A Systematic Review.

Background: The aim of this systematic review is to summarize the evidence regarding the acceptance of uterine transplantation as infertility treatment among gynecological cancer survivors, surgical and pregnancy outcomes post-transplantation for gynecological cancer survivors, as well as relevant adverse events. Methods: PubMed and Embase were searched for records published since 2000, and extensive reference screening was performed. Results: Out of 1901 unique records identified, 7 are included in this review; 4 examined the proportion of gynecological cancer survivors among applicants for uterine transplantation, 2 examined rejection rates, pregnancy rates, and outcomes after uterine transplantation among gynecological cancer survivors, and 2 reported the frequency of relevant adverse events. Among the applicants, 60/701 (8.6%) were gynecological cancer survivors, only 1 transplanted patient was a cervical cancer survivor and achieved two live births after eight embryo transfers, and 2/27 (7.4%) of uterus transplantation recipients were diagnosed with CIN post-transplantation. Conclusions: Uterus transplantation can be regarded as an infertility treatment for absolute uterine factor infertility (AUFI), although only one gynecological cancer survivor has received a uterus transplantation. The efficacy, safety, and ethical considerations for gynecological cancer survivors need to be addressed for uterine transplantation to become an infertility treatment option for AUFI among gynecological cancer survivors.

Exploring Divergent Views: A Comparative Study of Uterus Transplantation Perceptions among Transplant and Obstetrics/Gynecology Providers.

Background: Uterus transplantation (UTx) provides women with absolute uterine-factor infertility (AUFI) the opportunity to carry their own pregnancy and deliver a child. There are multiple ethical and medical concerns associated with UTx. Since the last survey of US provider perceptions of UTx in 2018, there have been additional reports of successful transplantations and pregnancies. This study aimed to identify the perception of UTx among providers involved in the diagnosis of AUFI and on the transplant team to help us understand knowledge gaps and determine what barriers must be overcome for UTx to be used in general clinical practice. Methods: We administered REDCap surveys to conference attendees at the 2023 American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) conference and 2023 American Transplant Congress (ATC). Participants were recruited by medical student volunteers. Results: Two hundred ACOG and ATC attendees completed the survey. Medical concerns related to UTx were reported by 42% of providers from ACOG compared to 22% of providers from ATC. Overall, 76% of participants agreed that UTx should be an option for patients with congenital AUFI. Lastly, 68% of participants agreed that the procedure should be presented as an option for transgender women. Conclusions: This study further elucidates the perception of UTx among obstetricians/gynecologists and transplant physicians. We found greater support for the procedure than in previous studies. This study also demonstrates provider support for presenting this procedure as an option for transgender women.

Midwifery students' spiritual and ethical values and their views and attitudes towards uterine transplantation: A qualitative study.

This qualitative study was conducted to examine the relationship between Muslim midwives' spiritual values and ethical orientations and their attitudes towards uterine transplantation. The phenomenological study sample group consisted of students in the Midwifery undergraduate programme of a public university in Istanbul (n:26). The data were collected in semi-structured focus group interviews. It was among the student midwives, it was determined that some students rejected uterine transplantation with thoughts such as "I am a Muslim, according to my religious belief, I should go to the grave without damaging my organs" or "This transplantation is not a vital necessity", as well as students who considered uterine transplantation as religious and ethically appropriate. It was determined that midwife candidates who will provide reproductive health services have different ethical and moral views regarding uterus transplantation, and there are some who see this method as religiously acceptable, and there are also students who emphasize that it is not suitable for Islam. In addition, training programs are planned to increase students' awareness and knowledge on this subject, aiming to be beneficial to the women they will care for in the future.

Cette étude qualitative a été menée pour examiner la relation entre les valeurs spirituelles et les orientations éthiques des sages-femmes musulmanes et leurs attitudes à l'égard de la transplantation utérine. Le groupe échantillon de l'étude phénoménologique était composé d'étudiants du programme de premier cycle de sages-femmes d'une université publique d'Istanbul (n : 26). Les données ont été recueillies lors d'entretiens de groupe semi-structurés. Parmi les étudiantes sages-femmes, il a été déterminé que certaines étudiantes rejetaient la transplantation utérine avec des pensées telles que "Je suis musulmane, selon ma croyance religieuse, je devrais aller dans la tombe sans endommager mes organes" ou "Cette transplantation n'est pas une nécessité vitale", ainsi que des étudiants qui considéraient la transplantation utérine comme religieusement et éthiquement appropriée. Il a été déterminé que les candidates sages-femmes qui fourniront des services de santé reproductive ont des opinions éthiques et morales différentes concernant la transplantation d'utérus. Certaines personnes considèrent cette méthode comme religieusement acceptable, et d'autres étudiants soulignent qu'elle n'est pas adaptée à l'Islam. De plus, des programmes de formation sont prévus pour accroître la sensibilisation et les connaissances des étudiants sur ce sujet, dans le but d'être bénéfiques aux femmes dont elles s'occuperont à l'avenir.

Motherhood and attitudes towards motherhood in women with Mayer-Rokitansky-Küster-Hauser syndrome.

OBJECTIVES: The aim of the study was to find out what proportion of women with MRKHS have decided to become mothers and have children or would like to have children and consider various options for motherhood. Additionally, the survey aimed at identifying factors that might influence the women's decisions and opinions regarding adoption, gestational surrogacy (GS) and uterus transplantation (UTx). MATERIAL AND METHODS: The study group consisted of 100 adult women with MRKHS who filled out questionnaires consisting of 56 questions. The survey was self-administered and anonymous. RESULTS: Most of the study participants were under 30, lived in large cities (> 150 000 inhabitants) and declared to be heterosexuals in a steady relationship (p < 0.05). While 11 participants had children, 66 out of 89 childless women (74%) expressed a desire for motherhood, but as many as 80 surveyed women have felt pressured to have children. The number of participants for whom a biological relationship with offspring was significant and insignificant respectively equaled (p = 1.000). The majority of the study participants supported the process of legalizing GS in Poland (95 vs 4) yet would opt for commercial rather than altruistic GS (64 vs 31) (p < 0.05). Most respondents stated that UTx is consistent with their faith and conscience (91 vs 4) and found UTx ethical (88 vs 4) (p < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: The majority of Polish women with MRKHS express the need to become a mother, but only one in ten has a child. The women's interest in biological motherhood is significant.

Attitudes toward uterus transplantation. An option for motherhood?

INTRODUCTION: Uterus transplantation is a novel surgical procedure that allows women with absolute uterine factor infertility to carry a pregnancy and give birth. While previous studies have explored the attitudes of women with absolute uterine factor infertility toward uterus transplantation, none have surveyed and compare their views with other groups of interest (Morris syndrome women, relatives of Morris syndrome and Rokitansky syndrome women, infertile women and women of childbearing age) in the same sociocultural setting. The objective of this study was to evaluate attitudes and insights regarding uterus transplantation among women with Rokitansky syndrome and other groups of interest. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We designed a cross-sectional study including five groups of women: women with Rokitansky syndrome, women with Morris syndrome, relatives of women with Morris and Rokitansky syndrome, infertile women, and childbearing-age women. We conducted an online survey through the REDCap platform. The link was distributed by mail, telephone and in hospital outpatient visits. Baseline demographic information was assessed and information regarding motherhood preferences, attitude toward uterus transplantation, preferred uterus graft and perception of risk of the procedure was collected. RESULTS: We obtained a total of 200 responses, with a mean participant age of 34.5 years (±9.8). Overall, 17.5% (n = 35) were women with Rokitansky syndrome, 5.5% (n = 11) Morris syndrome women, 21.5% (n = 43) infertile women, 26.5% (n = 53) relatives of Morris and Rokitansky syndrome women and 29% (n = 58) childbearing-age women. 71.5% of women with Rokitansky syndrome would undergo uterus transplantations ahead of adoption and surrogacy with no statistically significant differences found between groups. Overall, more than one-half (58%) would prefer deceased over living donor. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this survey indicate that uterus transplantation is desired by most women who would benefit from the procedure, including those with either Morris syndrome or absolute uterine factor infertility. This was also the preferred option for motherhood if absolute uterine factor infertility was diagnosed among surveyed infertility patients or women of childbearing age with no known reproductive difficulties. Overall, most respondents indicated a deceased donor was preferable to a living donor and that patients may not be sufficiently aware of potential risks of uterus transplantation, highlighting the importance of adequate counseling by medical providers.

A new bicornuate model of rat uterus transplantation.

INTRODUCTION: Uterus transplantation has revolutionized reproductive medicine for women with absolute uterine factor infertility, resulting in more than 40 reported successful live births worldwide to date. Small animal models are pivotal to refine this surgical and immunological challenging procedure aiming to enhance safety for both the mother and the child. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We established a syngeneic bicornuate uterus transplantation model in young female Lewis rats. All surgical procedures were conducted by an experienced and skilled microsurgeon who organized the learning process into multiple structured steps. Animals underwent meticulous preoperative preparation and postoperative care. Transplant success was monitored by sequential biopsies, monitoring graft viability and documenting histological changes long-term. RESULTS: Bicornuate uterus transplantation were successfully established achieving an over 70% graft survival rate with the passage of time. The bicornuate model demonstrated safety and feasibility, yielding outcomes comparable to the unicornuate model in terms of ischemia times and complications. Longitudinal biopsies were well-tolerated, enabling comprehensive monitoring throughout the study. CONCLUSIONS: Our novel bicornuate rat uterus transplantation model provides a distinctive opportunity for sequential biopsies at various intervals after transplantation and, therefore, comprehensive monitoring of graft health, viability, and identification of potential signs of rejection. Furthermore, this model allows for different interventions in each horn for comparative studies without interobserver differences contrary to the established unicornuate model. By closely replicating the clinical setting, this model stands as a valuable tool for ongoing research in the field of uterus transplantation, promoting further innovation and deeper insights into the intricacies of the uterus transplant procedure.

Uterus transplantation: what the world's religions have to say.

Uterus transplantation (UTx) has evolved from a purely experimental procedure to a clinical treatment option available outside the clinical trial context, offering women with absolute uterine-factor infertility an opportunity to experience pregnancy. As UTx becomes better established and more widely known and performed, it is likely to be sought out by geographically and culturally diverse patients, particularly those whose religious beliefs impose barriers to other paths to achieve parenthood, such as gestational surrogacy and adoption. Many religions do not currently have official positions on UTx, meaning that clinicians involved in screening candidates can expect questions about how the UTx process aligns with various religious beliefs. This article provides a broad background on the current positions major world religions have taken on UTx (or its components) and the alternative paths to parenthood of gestational surrogacy and adoption. It is intended to help clinicians communicate the information necessary for individuals interested in uterus donation or transplantation to determine-in consultation with their spiritual advisors or religious authorities when needed-how these options align with religious beliefs or teachings.

Unique risk factors for unplanned preterm delivery in the uterus transplant recipient.

STUDY QUESTION: Do characteristics of the lower uterine segment and cervix modify the risk of preterm delivery in uterus transplant (UTx) recipients? SUMMARY ANSWER: The cervical length showed little association with preterm delivery, however, cervical inflammation deserves further exploration as a cause of preterm delivery. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: UTx recipients do not have the risk factors normally used to stratify pregnancies that would benefit from cervical length assessment. In addition, unique factors related to absent tissues, a different blood supply, inflammatory processes of rejection, cervical biopsies, and a different microbiome challenge the normal progressive remodeling of the cervix and thus cervical competence. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: This is a subanalysis of a clinical trial of 20 women undergoing uterus transplantation at Baylor University Medical Center from 2016 to 2020, in addition to two women who received transplantation outside of a research protocol at our institution through September 2022. In this report, the first 16 UTx recipients that achieved live birth are included. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: The focus of this study was 20 pregnancies that reached the second trimester in 16 women following UTx. We analyzed recipient, transplant, and donor factors to determine if characteristics were associated with delivery outcome. We compared obstetrical outcomes, including planned versus unplanned delivery, by factors such as number of superior venous anastomoses, warm ischemia and cold ischemia times, donor factors including cesarean sections, cervical biopsy results, and cervical ultrasound results. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Planned term deliveries occurred in 44% (8/18) of live births. Of the preterm births, 30% (3/10) were planned and 70% (7/10) were unplanned. Unplanned deliveries occurred in women with spontaneous preterm labor, severe rejection, subchorionic hematoma, and placenta previa. Cervical length in UTx recipients averaged 33.5 mm at 24 weeks and 31.5 mm at 28 weeks, comparable to values from the general population. No relationship was seen between delivery outcome and number of veins used, ischemic time, or number of previous cesarean sections. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: The study's small size allows limited conclusions. The obstetric history of all donors was limited to mode of delivery. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: Cervical length measurements in the UTx population are not expected to deviate from those with a native uterus. While cervical length surveillance remains important, attention must be paid to the results of cervical biopsies which are obtained to monitor rejection. Inflammatory processes seem most predictive of preterm delivery. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): No funding was provided for this study. The authors report no conflicts of interest. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT02656550.

'The law is very, very outdated and not keeping up with the technology': novel forms of assisted gestation, legal challenges, and perspectives of reproductive rights advocates in England and Wales.

A growing body of literature examines the ethico-legal challenges resulting from novel forms of assisted gestation like uterus transplantation and artificial placentas (also known as 'artificial wombs'). However, there has not yet been consideration of reproductive rights organizations/advocates' understandings of novel forms of assisted gestation and their challenges. These perspectives provide critical insight into how novel procreative practices are understood and the problems and pressures that might arise from their use. This is the first legal article to engage with reproductive rights organizations/advocates and thus it provides important contextual grounding to existing scholarship about assisted gestation. Focus group discussion epitomized the need for legal reform in key areas surrounding reproduction. Themes were constructed that exemplify what participants highlighted as critical: the need to re-evaluate the fundamentals of legal parenthood, consideration of how novel technologies could further enable the policing of gestation, and the space and time needed for law-making.

Estimation of the prevalence of uterine infertility and its different causes in France according to data from a literature review.

INTRODUCTION: Uterine infertility (UI) is defined as the complete absence of a uterus (absolute uterine infertility or AUI) or the presence of a non functional uterus (non-absolute uterine infertility or NAUI). The exact prevalence of uterine infertility is currently unknown. Our aim was to assess the number of French women concerned by Uterine Infertility according to a recent literature review. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We have previously conducted a systematic review of the literature on UI and its various causes in the world. Based on these study and demographic data of 2022 from INSEE (Institut National de la Statistique et des Études Économiques), we attempted to estimate the number of women under 40 years of age in France affected by potential UI using direct standardization. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION: Based on the estimation from INSEE data, approximately 2066 women of childbearing age would have MRKH syndrome in France, 380 the Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome and 3700 had an haemostasis hysterectomy in France. We did not find data on the prevalence of hysterectomies before the age of 40 in France. For the following pathologies: uterine malformations, radiation uterus, synechiae, myomas and adenomyosis there was a huge amount of missing data, which does not allow us to estimate the number of potentially infertile patients. CONCLUSION: Prevalence of UI is poorly known. UI probably concerns several thousand patients in France. The creation of a UI registry would make enable to assess the number of patients potentially eligible for adoption, uterus transplantation or even surrogacy.

Three-year follow-up results of two children born from a transplanted uterus.

AIMS: To evaluate the 3-year follow-up results of two children delivered at our institution in 2019 from mothers with a transplanted uterus. METHODS: Observational data on pregnancy outcomes, neonatal course, and growth trajectory in two children born to mothers after uterus transplantation, including 3-year follow-up and neurodevelopmental status assessed using the Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development, third edition (Bayley-III). RESULTS: Both children were born prematurely via uneventful caesarean sections, to mothers with Mayer-Rokitansky-Küster-Hauser syndrome and a transplanted uterus. An acute caesarean section was performed in one mother because of the onset of regular uterine contractions at 34 weeks and 6 days of pregnancy; in the other mother, an elective caesarean section was performed at 36 weeks and 2 days of gestation. The children were born healthy with no congenital malformations. They had an uneventful postnatal course and showed a normal growth trajectory during 3 years of follow-up. The Bayley-III neurodevelopmental scores of both children were within the normal ranges at ages 2 and 3 years. CONCLUSION: Though pregnancy after uterus transplantation is associated with the risk of premature delivery, no abnormalities were observed in the neonatal course and 3-year follow-up results, including the neurodevelopmental status, of two children born prematurely to mothers with a transplanted uterus. This is the first report on neurodevelopmental outcomes in children born after uterus transplantation. More data on children born after this radical procedure of uterine factor infertility treatment are required to support our promising results.

Mayer-Rokitansky-Küster-Hauser syndrome patients' interest, expectations and demands concerning uterus transplantation.

OBJECTIVE: To better understand patients' conditions and expectations before starting a uterus transplantation (UTx) program for women suffering from Mayer-Rokitansky-Küster-Hauser syndrome (MRKH syndrome). METHOD: A web-based survey was conducted among MRKH patients via the French national association network from March to August 2020. The questionnaire comprised twenty-eight questions about their desire for parenthood, their condition's characteristics and previous reconstructive procedures, opinions and knowledge about UTx. RESULTS: Among the 148 participants, 88 % reported a desire for parenthood, and 61 % opted for UTx as their first choice to reach this aim. The possibility of bearing a child and having the same genetic heritage were the main motivations. Once informed about the usual course of an UTx protocol, only 13 % of the participants changed their mind and 3 out of 4 of them opted for UT. CONCLUSION: Uterus transplantation seems to be the first option to reach motherhood in patients suffering from MRKH syndrome. The development of UTx programs could meet the demands of this already well-informed population.

Persistence Pays Off: Live Birth after Uterus Transplant, Overcoming Recurrent Pregnancy Loss with Cerclage Placement.

Recipients of uterus transplantation have unique factors that may increase their risk of cervical insufficiency. This report describes a uterus transplant recipient with cervical insufficiency resulting in two second-trimester miscarriages. After McDonald cerclages (one that failed), she underwent an interval transabdominal cerclage and delivered a healthy term child in her third pregnancy. The longitudinal information of this case provides observations from which we can propose testable hypotheses that address venous outflow and inflammation. This case also suggests that there could be a role for prophylactic cerclage placement at the time of transplantation.

Hypothermic machine perfusion for uterus transplantation.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the feasibility of hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) in uterus transplantation (UT) to potentially improve the preservation of the uterus and enhance graft preservation in the donation after brainstem death (DBD) context. Uterus transplantation is a new surgical approach to treating absolute uterine infertility; it can be performed after living donation or after DBD. In the DBD context, the uterus is typically the last organ removed after other vital organs, with the exception of the Baylor team, which removes the uterus first. This key aspect imposes an unavoidable mild temperature ischemia for >1 hour on the uterus during the removal of the vital abdominal and chest organs. In renal transplantation, the perfusion machine reduces the risk of delayed graft function; thus, we hypothesized that machine perfusion could result in a reduction of uterus graft dysfunction. The uterus graft dysfunction could be expressed by a low embryo implantation rate, pregnancy loss, or vascular pregnancy diseases such as preeclampsia or fetal growth restriction." To date, static cold storage of the uterus is the only standard method for preservation before transplantation. HMP is an emerging method that could potentially improve the preservation of the uterus to enhance graft preservation in the DBD context. DESIGN: This video article shows all the technical details of using the HMP for uterine transplantation. SETTING: University. ANIMALS: Porcine model. INTERVENTION: Porcine uterus was retrieved from a DBD domestic animal model and flushed with KPS MP (Bridge To Life Ltd in UK) at 4 °C. After vascular preparation on the back table, the uterus was perfused using KPS MP through a cannula in the aorta using the VitaSmart device (Bridge To Life Ltd in UK) for 18 hours. Then, the uterus was transplanted to the porcine recipient. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The macroscopic appearance of the uterus at the end of HMP and the assessment of the uterus vascularization after transplantation in the recipient compared with the native uterus. RESULTS: This video shows the cannulation of the iliac vessels, cooling and removal of the uterus on a porcine model, uterus preservation using HMP during 18 hours, and then UT in a new recipient pig with the reperfusion of the transplanted uterus next to the native, intact uterus of the recipient. The macroscopic appearance of the uterus at the end of HMP appeared viable and was perfectly flushed. The assessment of the uterus vascularization after transplantation in the recipient was similar to that of the native uterus. To our knowledge, we describe here for the first time the UT procedure in DBD context on an animal model and the use of HMP for uterus preservation in UT programs; this could increase the number of uterine grafts available for a greater number of female recipients. CONCLUSION: Hypothermic machine perfusion could allow the duration of cold ischemia to be prolonged without altering the uterine graft. Nevertheless, this assertion has to be validated in a human context.

Awareness and Interest in Uterus Transplantation over Time: Analysis of Those Seeking Surgical Correction for Uterine-Factor Infertility in the US.

This study describes the characteristics of women who contacted an active program performing uterus transplantation (UTx) in the US, expressing interest in becoming a uterus transplant recipient or a living donor. Basic demographic and self-reported clinical information was collected from women who contacted any of the three US UTx programs from 2015 to July 2022. The three centers received 5194 inquiries about becoming a UTx recipient during the study timeframe. Among those reporting a cause of infertility, almost all of the reports (4066/4331, 94%) were absence of a uterus, either congenitally (794/4066, 20%) or secondary to hysterectomy (3272/4066, 80%). The mean age was 34 years, and 49% (2545/5194) had at least one child at the time of application. The two centers using living donors received 2217 inquiries about becoming living donors. The mean age was 34 years, and 60% (1330/2217) had given birth to ≥1 child. While most of the UTx clinical trial evidence has focused on young women with congenital absence of the uterus, these results show interest from a much broader patient population in terms of age, cause of infertility, and parity. These results raise questions about whether and to what extent the indications and eligibility criteria for UTx should be expanded as the procedure transitions from the experimental phase to being offered as a clinical treatment.

Imaging of Uterine Transplantation.

Uterus transplantation (UTx) is a novel procedure being studied as a treatment of absolute uterine factor infertility. Imaging plays an important role throughout the life cycle of a uterus transplant. In this review, we will first describe the surgical technique of UTx. The article will then focus on the importance of imaging in the evaluation of potential recipients and donors and during the immediate post-surgical time course as graft viability is established. Imaging as part of including in vitro fertilization, pregnancy, and complications will also be discussed.

Uterus Transplantation as a Surgical Innovation.

Uterus transplantation (UTx) research has been introduced in several countries, with trials in Sweden and the United States producing successful outcomes. The growing interest in developing UTx trials in other countries, such as Spain, the Netherlands, Japan, and Australia, raises important questions regarding the ethics of surgical innovation research in the field of UTx. This paper examines the current state of UTx in the context of the surgical innovation paradigm and IDEAL framework and discusses the ethical challenges faced by those considering the introduction of new trials. We argue that UTx remains an experimental procedure at a relatively early stage of the IDEAL framework, especially in the context of de novo trials, where protocols are likely to deviate from those used previously and where researchers are likely to have limited experience of UTx. We conclude that countries considering the introduction of UTx trials should build on the strengths of the reported outcomes to consolidate the evidence base and shed light on the uncertainties of the procedure. Authorities responsible for the ethical governance of UTx trials are advised to draw on the ethical framework used in the oversight of surgical innovation.

Equality-enhancing potential of novel forms of assisted gestation: Perspectives of reproductive rights advocates.

Novel forms of assisted gestation-uterus transplantation and artificial placentas-are highly anticipated in the ethico-legal literature for their capacity to enhance reproductive autonomy. There are also, however, significant challenges anticipated in the development of novel forms of assisted gestation. While there is a normative exploration of these challenges in the literature, there has not yet, to my knowledge, been empirical research undertaken to explore what reproductive rights organisations and advocates identify as potential benefits and challenges. This perspective is invaluable. These organisations/individuals have an awareness not only of the needs of individuals but also of the political landscape in which regulatory decisions are made and which individuals navigate when seeking reproductive assistance. In this study, data was generated from two semi-structured focus groups (n = 11). Reflective thematic analysis was used to examine the views raised by study participants in these focus groups. This paper explores two of the themes constructed in the data. First, the equality-enhancing potential of assisted gestation exploring the multifaceted ways in which assisted gestation has structural benefits for marginalised groups. Second, realising the equality-enhancing potential of assisted gestation explores the intersecting barriers to access to reproductive technologies and how they may impede the benefits of these technologies in practice. These results can enhance conceptual understanding of the importance of novel forms of assisted gestation and ensure that attention is paid to practical barriers in further normative research.

Differences between living and deceased donation in human uterus transplantation: A narrative review.

The decision to use a living or deceased donor to perform uterus transplantation (UTx) is an evaluation of benefit and harm and is based on the medical team's choices. The current study determines the differences between living and deceased donation in human UTx according to determinant factors in choosing the donor type. For this review study, the PubMed database was searched without time, language, and location limitations up to May 2022. From 113 identified articles, 45 papers were included in the study for review. According to the results, in comparison to living donation, the biggest advantage of deceased donation is the lack of surgical and or psychological risks for the donor. In contrast, a comprehensive pre-transplantation medical assessment is less possible in deceased donation, and preplanned surgery cannot be realized. According to published peer-reviewed clinical trials on UTx, the graft failure rates in living and deceased donor UTx are 21% and 36%, respectively. Supposing all recipients who did not have graft failure underwent embryo transfer, live birth rates in living and deceased donor UTx procedures are almost 63% and 71%, respectively. Currently, considering the occurrence of live births from both donations, particularly from nulliparous deceased donor, increased demand for UTx in the near future, shortage of uterus grafts, and lack of sufficient data for a comprehensive comparison between the 2 types of donation, the use of both donations still seems necessary and rational.