Commotio cordis: Another cardiac arrest "sine materia". The 1707 early report and interpretation by G.M. Lancisi.

Sudden death by commotio cordis is rare. It is the consequence of a blunt trauma of the chest overlying the heart. The mechanism is a cardiac arrest by ventricular fibrillation in the absence of grossly or microscopically apparent myocardial injury. It has been reproduced in animals. The first historical case was reported by Giovanni Maria Lancisi in his book "De Subitaneis Mortibus'' published in 1707. Sudden death occurred in a man receiving a powerful blow under the xiphoid cartilage. Lancisi advanced the hypothesis of acute heart failure by a diastolic stand still ("death in diastole'').

The role of the autopsy in the diagnosis of commotio cordis lethal cases: Review of the literature.

Commotio Cordis (CC) diagnosis is based on the occurrence of a blunt, non-penetrating blow to the chest preceding cardiovascular collapse and the absence of structural damage that would explain any observed effects. In CC lethal cases, the execution of the autopsy represents a possible diagnostic tool. Nevertheless, to date in the literature no author expresses an opinion about the use of the autopsy. In the light of the above, the authors propose a review of the literature about this topic. The review consents to state that the occurrence of a blunt blow to the chest is a necessary element for a lethal CC diagnosis, but it cannot be considered enough. Indeed, because CC is a recognized cause of sudden cardiac death, the autopsy should be always performed to exclude the presence of structural damage that would explain any observed effects. This approach is fundamental in order to achieve an accurate diagnosis and to distinguish CC from other causes of sudden cardiac death. In addition, the authors sustain that in case of autopsy data's lack the authors should not identify CC diagnosis as definitive but as possible.

Pathological wave dynamics: a postulate for sudden cardiac death in athletes.

Sudden death (SD) in young athletes is a shocking and disturbing event with significant societal impact. Previous studies have demonstrated that sudden cardiac death (SCD) is the leading medical cause of SD in athletes. Various structural and pathological cardiovascular abnormalities have identified as the underlying causes of SCD in young athletes. However, there have been reported cases of SCD in athletes with no structural or pathological cardiovascular disorders. Our proposed hypothesis in this article is that abnormalities in aortic wave dynamics and coronary wave dynamics may be responsible for SCD in these athletes. These abnormal waves-pathological waves-can act as a trigger toward cardiac death in the presence of cardiovascular diseases. These waves may initiate SCD in the absence of apparent cardiovascular abnormalities. In summary, when the aortic and coronary wave dynamics are abnormal, the myocardial oxygen demand can exceed the oxygen delivery during exercise, hence creating acute ischemia which leads to death. It is explained in this article how increased oxygen demand may be the result of pathological aortic waves while reduced oxygen delivery is mainly due to pathological coronary waves. Additionally, our pathological wave hypothesis is able to provide a plausible explanation for Commotio Cordis.

[Sudden death due to commotio cordis associated to non compacted myocardium]. / Muerte súbita por conmoción cardiaca (Commotio cordis) asociada a miocardio no compactado.

Non compact of the left ventricular myocardium is a rare congenital cardiomyopathy characterized by the presence of multiple and prominent deep trabeculations in the ventricular wall, that define recesses communicated with the main ventricular chamber. This is a condition with low incidence and prevalence, diagnosed through imaging techniques such as Doppler echocardiogram (DE), multi-slice computed tomography (MSCT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Clinically, it may be asymptomatic or manifested by cardiac arrhythmias, heart failure or thromboembolism. This is a report on a 33 year old asymptomatic man who suffered a blow on his chest (commotio cordis) during a sports competition that produced a cardiac arrest. The electrocardiogram showed ventricular flutter that required electrical defibrillation. A DE obtained initially, did not show any significant abnormality, but another DE, a MSCT and a RMN obtained after discharge, certified isolated non-compacted myocardium, ruling out coronary artery disease. He received beta blocker and antiplatelet therapy and the placement of an automatic cardioverter defibrillator was considered. The pathophysiology of the association of these two infrequent and potentially lethal conditions is discussed.

Muerte súbita por conmoción cardíaca (Commotio cordis) asociada a miocardio no compactado / Sudden death due to commotio cordis associated to non compacted myocardium

El miocardio no compactado es una rara miocardiopatía congénita caracterizada por la presencia de múltiples y prominentes trabeculaciones profundas en la pared ventricular que definen hendiduras comunicantes con el compartimiento ventricular principal. Es una entidad de baja incidencia y prevalencia que se diagnostica mediante estudios de imágenes como el ecocardiograma Doppler (ED), la tomografía computarizada multicorte (TCM) y la resonancia magnética cardíaca (RMC). Puede ser asintomática o manifestarse mediante arritmias, insuficiencia cardíaca o eventos tromboembólicos. Se presenta el caso de un hombre de 33 años, asintomático, que durante la práctica deportiva sufre una conmoción cardíaca (commotio cordis) que le produce un paro cardiorrespiratorio. El electrocardiograma mostró un ritmo de aleteo ventricular que requirió cardiodesfibrilación eléctrica. En un ED efectuado inicialmente no se observaron anormalidades significativas, pero otro ED, una TCM y una RMN obtenidos luego del alta, certificaron el hallazgo de miocardio no compactado aislado, descartando coronariopatía. Recibió tratamiento beta bloqueante y antiagregante y se discutió la colocación del cardiodesfibrilador implantable. Se plantea la fisiopatología de la asociación de estas dos infrecuentes y potencialmente letales afecciones.

Non compact of the left ventricular myocardium is a rare congenital cardiomyopathy characterized by the presence of multiple and prominent deep trabeculations in the ventricular wall, that define recesses communicated with the main ventricular chamber. This is a condition with low incidence and prevalence, diagnosed through imaging techniques such as Doppler echocardiogram (DE), multi-slice computed tomography (MSCT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Clinically, it may be asymptomatic or manifested by cardiac arrhythmias, heart failure or thromboembolism. This is a report on a 33 year old asymptomatic man who suffered a blow on his chest (commotio cordis) during a sports competition that produced a cardiac arrest. The electrocardiogram showed ventricular flutter that required electrical defibrillation. A DE obtained initially, did not show any significant abnormality, but another DE, a MSCT and a RMN obtained after discharge, certified isolated non-compacted myocardium, ruling out coronary artery disease. He received beta blocker and antiplatelet therapy and the placement of an automatic cardioverter defibrillator was considered. The pathophysiology of the association of these two infrequent and potentially lethal conditions is discussed.

An autopsy case of commotio cordis from a motor scooter accident.

A motor scooter carrying two 15-year-old boys collided with the back of an open, parked truck. The tailgate of the truck was down and in a horizontal position. At the autopsy of the driver, horizontal tramline bruises were found on the anterior chest, but the thoracic cage was intact. There was a transverse tear of the ascending aorta with adventitial hematoma, but significant bleeding was not found in the pericardial sac or the thoracic cavities. Therefore, it was obvious that cardiovascular collapse occurred immediately after the accident. Neither injuries nor diseases that would cause the instantaneous death were found on examination of the whole body. We determined that the driver died of commotio cordis due to blunt force to the anterior chest.