Characterization of human costal cartilage: is it an adapt tissue as graft for articular cartilage repair?

Several techniques and different biological or artificial tissues have been proposed as graft to restore articular defects. However, among the numerous and heterogeneous procedures proposed over time, the current literature findings are not conclusive. The aim of the current study is to evaluate if human costal cartilage can be suitable as graft for restoring articular cartilage defects. Knee articular cartilage and costal cartilage samples were obtained respectively from patients that underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (samples from notch plasty) or knee joint replacement and ear reconstruction or rhinoplasty through rib graft. The samples were stained with hematoxylin eosin, safranine-O, Gomori paraldehyde-fuchsin and Von Kossa for light microscopy. Immunohistochemistry was performed using anti-collagen I, II, IV and anti-SOX9 antibodies. Furthermore, samples were analyzed by transmission electron microcopy (TEM). In both cartilage, the cells are arranged in quite similar layers and the matrix show the same hyaline appearance: presence of type II collagen and solphated glycosaminoglycans, and absence of type I collagen and SOX-9. The bigger difference between the two hyaline tissues is the presence of perichondrium that surrounds all the specimens of costal cartilage. It consists of two separate layers where the inner one seems to get thinner with aging. The results show that rib cartilage seems to be an adapt tissue as graft for articular cartilage repair from a histological point of view. However, to date its therapeutic potential remains to be clearly defined by animal and clinical studies.

Long-Term Comparison of Rib and Ear Cartilage Grafts in Autologous and Allogenic Fascia Lata: An Experimental Study in a White Rabbit Model.

BACKGROUND: Diced cartilage in fascia has become the graft material of choice for dorsal grafts in rhinoplasty. Allogenic fascia lata has not yet been investigated as an isolated fascial graft or as a combined graft with ear and rib cartilage, especially in comparison with autologous fascia and over a long implantation period. METHODS: Ten different grafts were built from either autologous or allogenic fascia lata alone or as diced cartilage in fascia grafts with diced costal or ear cartilage and implanted into the dorsal skin of 15 rabbits. After 3 or 9 months, the grafts were explanted and analyzed histologically. Chondrocytes and cartilage matrix characteristics, including calcification, ossification, formation of bone marrow, fibrosis ingrowth and fibrotic transformation, the presence of immune reactions, vascular ingrowth, regenerative capacity, and capsule formation, were examined in a semiquantitative manner. RESULTS: All grafts were vital and without inflammatory response. The cartilage showed regular nuclei, a normal matrix, and regenerative capacity. A higher grade of calcification and ossification was observed in the fascia/cartilage grafts than in isolated cartilage grafts, and was more pronounced for costal cartilage. Both types of fascia were shown to be equally stable and without degradation. There were no significant differences in the diced cartilage in fascia grafts built with autologous compared to allogenic fascia. CONCLUSIONS: This study shows the equivalency of diced cartilage in fascia grafts and isolated fascial grafts using allogenic fascia lata compared to autologous fascia. The type of cartilage used accounts for different long-term characteristics of diced cartilage in fascia grafts.