Ctenophora: Illustrated Guide and Taxonomy.

Ctenophores or comb jellies represent the first diverging lineage of extant animals - sister to all other Metazoa. As a result, they occupy a unique place in the biological sciences. Despite their importance, this diverse group of marine predators has remained relatively poorly known, with both the species and higher-level taxonomy of the phylum in need of attention. We present a checklist of the phylum based on a review of the current taxonomic literature and illustrate their diversity with images. The current classification presented remains substantially in conflict with recent phylogenetic results, and many of the taxa are not monophyletic or untested. This chapter summarizes the existing classification focusing on recognized families and genera with 185 currently accepted, extant species listed. We provide illustrative examples of ctenophore diversity covering all but one of the 33 families and 47 of the 48 genera, as well as about 25-30 undescribed species. We also list the 14 recognized ctenophore fossil species and note others that have been controversially attributed to the phylum. Analyses of unique ctenophore adaptations are critical to understanding early animal evolution and adaptive radiation of this clade of basal metazoans.

Gene Expression Patterns in the Ctenophore Pleurobrachia bachei: In Situ Hybridization.

In situ hybridization is a powerful and precise tool for revealing cell- and tissue-specific gene expression and a critical approach to validating single-cell RNA-seq (scRNA-seq). However, applying it to highly fragile animals such as ctenophores is challenging. Here, we present an in situ hybridization protocol for adult Pleurobrachia bachei (Cydippida)-a notable reference species representing the earliest-branching metazoan lineage, Ctenophora, sister to the rest of Metazoa. We provided expression patterns for several markers of cell phenotypes, as illustrated examples. The list includes predicted small secretory molecules/neuropeptides, WntX, genes encoding RNA-binding proteins (Musashi, Elav, Dicer, Argonaut), Neuroglobin, and selected transcription factors such as BarX. Both cell- and organ-specific expression of these genes further support the convergent evolution of many ctenophore innovations, which are remarkably distinct from tissue and organ specification in other basal metazoan lineages.

DNA Isolation Long-Read Genomic Sequencing in Ctenophores.

Long-read sequencing has proven the necessity for high-quality genomic assemblies of reference species, including enigmatic ctenophores. Obtaining high-molecular-weight genomic DNA is pivotal to this process and has proven highly problematic for many species. Here, we discuss different methodologies for gDNA isolation and present a protocol for isolating gDNA for several members of the phylum Ctenophora. Specifically, we describe a Pacific Biosciences library construction method used in conjunction with gDNA isolation methods that have proven successful in obtaining high-quality genomic assemblies in ctenophores.

Expression, Purification, and Determination of Sensitivity to Calcium Ions of Ctenophore Photoproteins.

Light-sensitive Ca2+-regulated photoproteins of ctenophores are single-chain polypeptide proteins of 206-208 amino acids in length comprising three canonical EF-hand Ca2+-binding sites, each of 12 contiguous residues. These photoproteins are a stable complex of apoprotein and 2-hydroperoxy adduct of coelenterazine. Addition of calcium ions to photoprotein is only required to trigger bright bioluminescence. However, in contrast to the related Ca2+-regulated photoproteins of jellyfish their capacity to bioluminescence disappears on exposure to light over the entire absorption spectral range of ctenophore photoproteins. Here, we describe protocols for expression of gene encoding ctenophore photoprotein in Escherichia coli cells, obtaining of the recombinant apoprotein of high purity and its conversion into active photoprotein with synthetic coelenterazine as well as determination of its sensitivity to calcium ions using light-sensitive Ca2+-regulated photoprotein berovin from ctenophore Beroe abyssicola as an illustrative case.

RNA Isolation from Ctenophores.

RNA-seq or transcriptome analysis of individual cells and small cell populations is essential for virtually any biomedical field. Here, we examine and discuss the different methods of RNA isolation specific to ctenophores. We present a convenient, inexpensive, and reproducible protocol for RNA-seq libraries that are designed for low quantities of samples. We demonstrated these methods on early (one, two, four, eight cells) embryonic and developmental stages, tissues, and even a single aboral organ from the ctenophore Pleurobrachia bachei and other ctenophore species (e.g., Mnemiopsis, Bolinopsis, and Beroe).

Characterization of the Mitochondrial Proteome in the Ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi Using MitoPredictor.

Mitochondrial proteomes have been experimentally characterized for only a handful of animal species. However, the increasing availability of genomic and transcriptomic data allows one to infer mitochondrial proteins using computational tools. MitoPredictor is a novel random forest classifier, which utilizes orthology search, mitochondrial targeting signal (MTS) identification, and protein domain content to infer mitochondrial proteins in animals. MitoPredictor's output also includes an easy-to-use R Shiny applet for the visualization and analysis of the results. In this article, we provide a guide for predicting and analyzing the mitochondrial proteome of the ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi using MitoPredictor.

Gap Junctions in Ctenophora.

Gap junction proteins form specialized intercellular communication channels, including electrical synapses, that regulate cellular metabolism and signaling. We present a molecular inventory of the gap junction proteins-innexins (INX-like) in ctenophores, focusing on two reference species, Pleurobrachia bachei and Mnemiopsis leidyi. Innexins were identified in more than 15 ctenophore species, including such genera as Euplokamis, Pukia, Hormiphora, Bolinopsis, Cestum, Ocyropsis, Dryodora, Beroe, benthic ctenophores, Coeloplana and Vallicula, and undescribed species of Mertensiidae. The observed diversity of innexins resulted from the independent expansion of this family from the common ancestor of ctenophores. Innexins show the conserved topology with four transmembrane domains connected by two extracellular loops, which bridge intracellular gaps. However, INX-like genes have highly diverse exon organization and low percentage identity for their amino acid sequences within the same species and between ctenophore species. Such a broad scope of molecular diversity differs from innexins in other phyla. We predicted posttranslational modifications in innexins: 249 and 188 for M. leidyi and P. bachei, respectively. Neither their number nor their locations were conserved within or between species. When the number of posttranslational modifications is factored into the innexins' radiation, the potential for molecular and physiological diversity within gap junctions of ctenophores is almost unfathomable. RNA-seq and in situ hybridization data revealed that innexins are expressed across embryogenesis, including early cleavage stages and gastrulation. They are abundant in all adult tissues, with the highest expression level in the aboral organ (the major integrative center and the gravity sensor in ctenophores), followed by tentacles and comb plates. Nevertheless, each organ and tissue has a unique combination of innexins, suggesting their involvement in complex integrative functions and behaviors of ctenophores.

Functional Screening of cDNA Expression Library for Novel Ctenophore Photoproteins.

The functional screening of cDNA libraries (or functional cloning) enables isolation of cDNA genes encoding novel proteins with unknown amino acid sequences. This approach is the only way to identify a protein sequence in the event of shortage of biological material for obtaining pure target protein in amounts sufficient to determine its primary structure, since sensitive functional test for a target protein is only required to successfully perform functional cloning. Commonly, bioluminescent proteins from representatives belonging to different taxa significantly differ in sequences due to independent origin of bioluminescent systems during evolution. Nonetheless, these proteins are frequently similar in functions and can use even the same substrate of bioluminescence reaction, allowing the use of the same functional test for screening. The cDNA genes encoding unknown light-emitting proteins can be identified during functional screening with high sensitivity, which is provided by modern light recording equipment making possible the detection of a very small amount of a target protein. Here, we present the protocols for isolation of full-size cDNA genes for the novel bioluminescent protein family of light-sensitive Ca2+-regulated photoproteins in the absence of any sequence information by functional screening of plasmid cDNA expression library. The protocols describe all the steps from gathering animals to isolation of individual E. coli colonies carrying full-size cDNA genes using photoprotein berovin from ctenophore Beroe abyssicola as an illustrative example.

DNA Methylation in Ctenophores.

Epigenomic regulation and dynamic DNA methylation, in particular, are widespread mechanisms orchestrating the genome operation across time and species. Whole-genome bisulfite sequencing (WGBS) is currently the only method for unbiasedly capturing the presence of 5-methylcytosine (5-mC) DNA methylation patterns across an entire genome with single-nucleotide resolution. Bisulfite treatment converts unmethylated cytosines to uracils but leaves methylated cytosines intact, thereby creating a map of all methylated cytosines across a genome also known as a methylome. These epigenomic patterns of DNA methylation have been found to regulate gene expression and influence gene evolution rates between species. While protocols have been optimized for vertebrate methylome production, little adaptation has been done for invertebrates. Creating a methylome reference allows comparisons to be made between rates of transcription and epigenomic patterning in animals. Here we present a method of library construction for bisulfite sequencing optimized for non-bilateral metazoans such as the ctenophore, Mnemiopsis leidyi. We have improved upon our previously published method by including spike-in genomic DNA controls to measure methylation conversion rates. By pooling two bisulfite conversion reactions from the same individual, we also produced sequencing libraries that yielded a higher percentage of sequenced reads uniquely mapping to the reference genome. We successfully detected 5-mC in whole-animal methylomes at CpG, CHG, and CHH sites and visualized datasets using circos diagrams. The proof-of-concept tests were performed both under control conditions and following injury tests with changes in methylation patterns of genes encoding innexins, toxins and neuropeptides. Our approach can be easily adapted to produce epigenomes from other fragile marine animals.

Parallel Evolution of Transcription Factors in Basal Metazoans.

Transcription factors (TFs) play a pivotal role as regulators of gene expression, orchestrating the formation and maintenance of diverse animal body plans and innovations. However, the precise contributions of TFs and the underlying mechanisms driving the origin of basal metazoan body plans, particularly in ctenophores, remain elusive. Here, we present a comprehensive catalog of TFs in 2 ctenophore species, Pleurobrachia bachei and Mnemiopsis leidyi, revealing 428 and 418 TFs in their respective genomes. In contrast, morphologically simpler metazoans have a reduced TF representation compared to ctenophores, cnidarians, and bilaterians: the sponge Amphimedon encodes 277 TFs, and the placozoan Trichoplax adhaerens encodes 274 TFs. The emergence of complex ctenophore tissues and organs coincides with significant lineage-specific diversification of the zinc finger C2H2 (ZF-C2H2) and homeobox superfamilies of TFs. Notable, the lineages leading to Amphimedon and Trichoplax exhibit independent expansions of leucine zipper (BZIP) TFs. Some lineage-specific TFs may have evolved through the domestication of mobile elements, thereby supporting alternative mechanisms of parallel TF evolution and body plan diversification across the Metazoa.

Brief History of Ctenophora.

Ctenophores are the descendants of the earliest surviving lineage of ancestral metazoans, predating the branch leading to sponges (Ctenophore-first phylogeny). Emerging genomic, ultrastructural, cellular, and systemic data indicate that virtually every aspect of ctenophore biology as well as ctenophore development are remarkably different from what is described in representatives of other 32 animal phyla. The outcome of this reconstruction is that most system-level components associated with the ctenophore organization result from convergent evolution. In other words, the ctenophore lineage independently evolved as high animal complexities with the astonishing diversity of cell types and structures as bilaterians and cnidarians. Specifically, neurons, synapses, muscles, mesoderm, through gut, sensory, and integrative systems evolved independently in Ctenophora. Rapid parallel evolution of complex traits is associated with a broad spectrum of unique ctenophore-specific molecular innovations, including alternative toolkits for making an animal. However, the systematic studies of ctenophores are in their infancy, and deciphering their remarkable morphological and functional diversity is one of the hot topics in biological research, with many anticipated surprises.

Ocean to Tree: Leveraging Single-Molecule RNA-Seq to Repair Genome Gene Models and Improve Phylogenomic Analysis of Gene and Species Evolution.

Understanding gene evolution across genomes and organisms, including ctenophores, can provide unexpected biological insights. It enables powerful integrative approaches that leverage sequence diversity to advance biomedicine. Sequencing and bioinformatic tools can be inexpensive and user-friendly, but numerous options and coding can intimidate new users. Distinct challenges exist in working with data from diverse species but may go unrecognized by researchers accustomed to gold-standard genomes. Here, we provide a high-level workflow and detailed pipeline to enable animal collection, single-molecule sequencing, and phylogenomic analysis of gene and species evolution. As a demonstration, we focus on (1) PacBio RNA-seq of the genome-sequenced ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi, (2) diversity and evolution of the mechanosensitive ion channel Piezo in genetic models and basal-branching animals, and (3) associated challenges and solutions to working with diverse species and genomes, including gene model updating and repair using single-molecule RNA-seq. We provide a Python Jupyter Notebook version of our pipeline (GitHub Repository: Ctenophore-Ocean-To-Tree-2023 https://github.com/000generic/Ctenophore-Ocean-To-Tree-2023 ) that can be run for free in the Google Colab cloud to replicate our findings or modified for specific or greater use. Our protocol enables users to design new sequencing projects in ctenophores, marine invertebrates, or other novel organisms. It provides a simple, comprehensive platform that can ease new user entry into running their evolutionary sequence analyses.

Expression and Functional Analysis of Ctenophore Glutamate Receptor Genes.

The functional analysis of ctenophore neurotransmitter receptors, transporters, and ion channels can be greatly simplified by use of heterologous expression systems. Heterologous expression allows the characterization of individual membrane proteins, expressed at high levels in cells, where background activity by endogenous ion channels and transporters is with few exceptions minimal. The goal of such experiments is to gain an in-depth understanding of the behavior and regulation of individual molecular species, which is challenging in native tissue, but especially so in the case of ctenophores and other marine organisms. Coupled with transcriptome analysis, and immunohistochemical studies of receptor expression in vivo, experiments with heterologous expression systems can provide valuable insight into cellular activity, prior to more challenging functional studies on native tissues.

Extracellular DNA traps in a ctenophore demonstrate immune cell behaviors in a non-bilaterian.

The formation of extracellular DNA traps (ETosis) is a first response mechanism by specific immune cells following exposure to microbes. Initially characterized in vertebrate neutrophils, cells capable of ETosis have been discovered recently in diverse non-vertebrate taxa. To assess the conservation of ETosis between evolutionarily distant non-vertebrate phyla, we observed and quantified ETosis using the model ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi and the oyster Crassostrea gigas. Here we report that ctenophores - thought to have diverged very early from the metazoan stem lineage - possess immune-like cells capable of phagocytosis and ETosis. We demonstrate that both Mnemiopsis and Crassostrea immune cells undergo ETosis after exposure to diverse microbes and chemical agents that stimulate ion flux. We thus propose that ETosis is an evolutionarily conserved metazoan defense against pathogens.

The ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi deploys a rapid injury response dating back to the last common animal ancestor.

Regenerative potential is widespread but unevenly distributed across animals. However, our understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying regenerative processes is limited to a handful of model organisms, restricting robust comparative analyses. Here, we conduct a time course of RNA-seq during whole body regeneration in Mnemiopsis leidyi (Ctenophora) to uncover gene expression changes that correspond with key events during the regenerative timeline of this species. We identified several genes highly enriched in this dataset beginning as early as 10 minutes after surgical bisection including transcription factors in the early timepoints, peptidases in the middle timepoints, and cytoskeletal genes in the later timepoints. We validated the expression of early response transcription factors by whole mount in situ hybridization, showing that these genes exhibited high expression in tissues surrounding the wound site. These genes exhibit a pattern of transient upregulation as seen in a variety of other organisms, suggesting that they may be initiators of an ancient gene regulatory network linking wound healing to the initiation of a regenerative response.

Stepwise emergence of the neuronal gene expression program in early animal evolution.

The assembly of the neuronal and other major cell type programs occurred early in animal evolution. We can reconstruct this process by studying non-bilaterians like placozoans. These small disc-shaped animals not only have nine morphologically described cell types and no neurons but also show coordinated behaviors triggered by peptide-secreting cells. We investigated possible neuronal affinities of these peptidergic cells using phylogenetics, chromatin profiling, and comparative single-cell genomics in four placozoans. We found conserved cell type expression programs across placozoans, including populations of transdifferentiating and cycling cells, suggestive of active cell type homeostasis. We also uncovered fourteen peptidergic cell types expressing neuronal-associated components like the pre-synaptic scaffold that derive from progenitor cells with neurogenesis signatures. In contrast, earlier-branching animals like sponges and ctenophores lacked this conserved expression. Our findings indicate that key neuronal developmental and effector gene modules evolved before the advent of cnidarian/bilaterian neurons in the context of paracrine cell signaling.

An in silico analysis on the photoproteins Mnemiopsin 1 and Mnemiopsin 2 to explain the experimental results.

Mnemiopsin 1 (Mn1) and Mnemiopsin 2 (Mn2) are photoproteins found in Mnemiopsis leidyi. We have tried to answer the question of whether the structural features of photoproteins can explain the observed activity data. According to the activity measurements data, they have the same characteristic wavelength. However, the initial intensity of Mn2 is significantly higher than that of Mn1, and decay time of Mn1 (0.92 s-1 ) is lower than that of Mn2 (1.46 s-1 ). The phylogenetic analysis demonstrates that, compared with Obelin and Aequorin from Obelia longissima and Aequorea victoria, respectively, a gene modification event may have caused the expansion of the N-terminal side of all photoproteins from M. leidyi. An in silico study has shown that the stability of the photoprotein-substrate complex of Mn2 is higher than that of Mn1, indicating a higher affinity of the substrate for Mn2 compared with Mn1. It was revealed that the active EF-hand loops 1 and III in Mn2 is locally more rigid compared with those in Mn1. We concluded that different stability of the photoprotein complexes leads to different initial intensity. While different patterns of the local dynamics of loops I and III may influence the decay rate.

[Spatial Reconstruction of TRPC Mechanoreceptors of the Ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi A. Agassiz, 1865].

The ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi A. Agassiz, 1865 responds to gentle mechanical stimulus with intense luminescence; however, the mechanism of this phenomenon is unknown. We searched for possible mechanosensitive receptors that initiate signal transduction resulting in photoprotein luminescence. The three orthologous genes of mouse (5z96) and drosophila (5vkq) TRPC-proteins, such as ML234550a-PA (860 a.a.), ML03701a-PA (828 a.a.), and ML038011a-PA (1395 a.a.), were found in the M. leidyi genome. The latter protein contains a long ankyrin helix consisting of 16 ANK domains. Study of the annotated domains and the network of interactions between the interactome proteins suggests that the ML234550a-PA and ML03701a-PA proteins carry out cytoplasmic transduction, but ML038011a-PA provides intranuclear transduction of mechanical signals. Spatial reconstruction of the studied proteins revealed differences in their structure, which may be related to various functions of these proteins in the cell. The question of which of these proteins is involved in the initiation of luminescence after mechanical stimulation is discussed.

Mosquito (MS), a DD37E Family of Tc1/Mariner, Displaying a Distinct Evolution Profile from DD37E/TRT and DD37E/L18.

Diverse Tc1/mariner elements with the DD37E signature have been detected. However, their evolutionary relationship and profiles are largely unknown. Using bioinformatics methods, we defined the evolution profile of a Tc1/Mariner family, which harbors the catalytic domain with the DD37E signature, and renamed it DD37E/Mosquito (MS). MS transposons form a separate monophyletic clade in the phylogenetic tree, distinct from the other two groups of elements with the DD37E signature, DD37E/L18 and DD37E/TRT (transposon related to Tc1), and represent a very different taxonomic distribution from that of DD37E/TRT. MS is only detected in invertebrate and is mostly present in Arthropoda, as well as in Cnidaria, Ctenophora, Mollusca, Nematoda, and Platyhelminthes, with a total length of about 1.3 kb, containing an open reading frame (ORF) encoding about 340 amino acids transposases, with a conserved DD37E catalytic domain. The terminal inverted repeat (TIR) lengths range from 19 bp to 203 bp, and the target site duplication (TSD) is TA. We also identified few occurrences of MS horizontal transfers (HT) across lineages of diptera. In this paper, the distribution characteristics, structural characteristics, phylogenetic evolution, and horizontal transfer of the MS family are fully analyzed, which is conducive to supplementing and improving the Tc1/Mariner superfamily and excavating active transposons.

Cytoplasmic Polyadenylation Is an Ancestral Hallmark of Early Development in Animals.

Differential regulation of gene expression has produced the astonishing diversity of life on Earth. Understanding the origin and evolution of mechanistic innovations for control of gene expression is therefore integral to evolutionary and developmental biology. Cytoplasmic polyadenylation is the biochemical extension of polyadenosine at the 3'-end of cytoplasmic mRNAs. This process regulates the translation of specific maternal transcripts and is mediated by the Cytoplasmic Polyadenylation Element-Binding Protein family (CPEBs). Genes that code for CPEBs are amongst a very few that are present in animals but missing in nonanimal lineages. Whether cytoplasmic polyadenylation is present in non-bilaterian animals (i.e., sponges, ctenophores, placozoans, and cnidarians) remains unknown. We have conducted phylogenetic analyses of CPEBs, and our results show that CPEB1 and CPEB2 subfamilies originated in the animal stem lineage. Our assessment of expression in the sea anemone, Nematostella vectensis (Cnidaria), and the comb jelly, Mnemiopsis leidyi (Ctenophora), demonstrates that maternal expression of CPEB1 and the catalytic subunit of the cytoplasmic polyadenylation machinery (GLD2) is an ancient feature that is conserved across animals. Furthermore, our measurements of poly(A)-tail elongation reveal that key targets of cytoplasmic polyadenylation are shared between vertebrates, cnidarians, and ctenophores, indicating that this mechanism orchestrates a regulatory network that is conserved throughout animal evolution. We postulate that cytoplasmic polyadenylation through CPEBs was a fundamental innovation that contributed to animal evolution from unicellular life.