The Impact of DNA Polymerase and Number of Rounds of Amplification in PCR on 16S rRNA Gene Sequence Data.

PCR amplification of 16S rRNA genes is a critical yet underappreciated step in the generation of sequence data to describe the taxonomic composition of microbial communities. Numerous factors in the design of PCR can impact the sequencing error rate, the abundance of chimeric sequences, and the degree to which the fragments in the product represent their abundance in the original sample (i.e., bias). We compared the performance of high fidelity polymerases and various numbers of rounds of amplification when amplifying a mock community and human stool samples. Although it was impossible to derive specific recommendations, we did observe general trends. Namely, using a polymerase with the highest possible fidelity and minimizing the number of rounds of PCR reduced the sequencing error rate, fraction of chimeric sequences, and bias. Evidence of bias at the sequence level was subtle and could not be ascribed to the fragments' fraction of bases that were guanines or cytosines. When analyzing mock community data, the amount that the community deviated from the expected composition increased with the number of rounds of PCR. This bias was inconsistent for human stool samples. Overall, the results underscore the difficulty of comparing sequence data that are generated by different PCR protocols. However, the results indicate that the variation in human stool samples is generally larger than that introduced by the choice of polymerase or number of rounds of PCR.IMPORTANCE A steep decline in sequencing costs drove an explosion in studies characterizing microbial communities from diverse environments. Although a significant amount of effort has gone into understanding the error profiles of DNA sequencers, little has been done to understand the downstream effects of the PCR amplification protocol. We quantified the effects of the choice of polymerase and number of PCR cycles on the quality of downstream data. We found that these choices can have a profound impact on the way that a microbial community is represented in the sequence data. The effects are relatively small compared to the variation in human stool samples; however, care should be taken to use polymerases with the highest possible fidelity and to minimize the number of rounds of PCR. These results also underscore that it is not possible to directly compare sequence data generated under different PCR conditions.

[Letter to the Editor] Many commercial hot-start polymerases demonstrate activity prior to thermal activation.

Address correspondence to Martin A. Kennedy, Department of Pathology & Carney Centre for Pharmacogenomics, University of Otago, Christchurch, PO Box 4345, Christchurch, New Zealand. E-mail: martin.kennedy@otago.ac.nz.

The enhancement of homogenous mass extension reaction: comparison of two enzymes.

Reliable and efficient PCR and extension reactions using standardized procedures are key elements for successful single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping projects. To improve the cost efficiency and overall performance of SNP genotyping we evaluated two commercial thermostable DNA polymerases used for the extension reaction in the homogeneous mass extension MassARRAY genotyping system. The aim was to study whether the quality, accuracy, and expenses of a new TERMIPol DNA polymerase are competitive to the commonly used ThermoSequenase DNA polymerase. We compared the enzymes by testing 96 SNPs genotyped for DNA samples of 31 unrelated individuals and one water control. The success rates, congruence between the genotypes and completeness of extension reactions support the use of TERMIPol, especially when the amplification of the higher mass allele is difficult. Further, using TERMIPol enabled successful genotyping (>93%) of several SNPs that failed (<80% success) when using ThermoSequenase.

Towards an international standard for PCR-based detection of foodborne thermotolerant campylobacters: interaction of enrichment media and pre-PCR treatment on carcass rinse samples.

As part of a large EU project for standardisation of polymerase chain reaction (PCR), a systematic evaluation of the interaction of enrichment media, type of DNA polymerase and pre-PCR sample treatment for a PCR detecting thermotolerant campylobacters was carried out. The growth-supporting capacity and PCR compatibility of enrichment in Preston, Mueller-Hinton and Bolton broth (blood-containing and blood-free) were evaluated. The effect of resin-based DNA extraction and DNA extraction by boiling on the final PCR assay was investigated. The time-course studies indicated that a 20-h sample enrichment in blood-containing Bolton broth, followed by a simple resin-based extraction of DNA and a PCR amplification using Tth polymerase, resulted in strong and clear PCR amplicons for target (287 bp) and internal amplification control (IAC, 124 bp). The enrichment PCR-based method, tested on 68 presumably naturally contaminated poultry-rinse samples, showed a diagnostic sensitivity of 97.5% (39 PCR-positive/40 total positive samples) and a diagnostic specificity of 100% (28 PCR-negative/28 total negative samples; P=0.32) when compared to a standard bacteriological method (ISO 10272).

Increased single-nucleotide discrimination of PCR by primer probes bearing hydrophobic 4'C modifications.

We report on significantly increased selectivity of real-time PCR through employment of primer probes that bear hydrophobic 4'C modifications at the 3'-terminal nucleotide. The primer probes were designed to bind the target sequences in such a way that the 3'-terminal nucleotide defines whether a matched or a single mismatched basepair is present depending on the respective target sequence. Several commercially available thermostable DNA polymerases belonging to different DNA polymerase families were tested for their efficacy in discriminating between PCR amplification of matched substrates and duplexes that contain a single mismatch. It turned out that, depending on the 4'C modification and the employed DNA polymerase, significantly increased differentiation between single matches and mismatches could be observed with real-time PCR. The degrees of the observed effects varied with the employed 4'C modification and the sequence context studied. The system is robust enough to work faithfully under several buffer conditions. Our approach should be useful for the direct diagnosis of single nucleotide variations within genes, like single nucleotide polymorphisms or mutations, by PCR without the need for further time- and cost-intensive post-PCR analysis.

Detection of immunoglobulin heavy chain genes rearrangements in B-cell leukemias, lymphomas, multiple myelomas, monoclonal and polyclonal gammopathies.

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) based assays were found to be a realistic alternative to Southern blot hybridization for the assessment of clonal immunoglobulin heavy chain gene rearrangements. However, a comparison of the different PCR based studies reveals considerable variation in experimental design and marked differences in the reported results. This study compared different single- and double-step PCR assays relying on various FR3, FR2, FR1 and JH based primers for the detection of B cell clonality in acute lymphoblastic leukemias (ALL), non-Hodgkin's-lymphoma (NHL), multiple myeloma (MM), monoclonal gammopathies of unknown significance (MGUS) and three polyclonal gammopathies (PG). The highest monoclonality rate was observed using seminested CDR-III region amplification. This method achieved a monoclonal product in 6 of 13 pro-B ALL 21 of 29 c-ALL, 7 of 8 pre-B-ALL, 18 of 21 B-ALL, 14 of 17 B-NHL (intermediate or high grade) with bone marrow involvement, 0 of 9 B-NHL without bone marrow involvement, 9 of 9 low grade B-NHL (immunocytoma and including chronic lymphocytic leucemia), 13 of 19 MM, 2 of 9 MGUS, and 0 of 3 PG. Additional monoclonality was detected with nested CDR I PCR in 1 pro-B-ALL, 1 c-ALL, and 2 MM. CDR III IgH PCR has been confirmed as an efficient method for determining clonality in B-cell neoplasias. Some additional monoclonal products can be seen with CDR I-based PCR. Detection of monoclonality depends on the maturation grade of the neoplastic B-cell population.

Methods and reagents. Better competent cells and DNA polymerase contaminants.

Methods and reagents is a unique monthly column that highlights current discussions in the newsgroup bionet.molbio.methods-reagents, available on the Internet. This month's column discusses a new method for harvesting Escherichia coli cells for transformation, and contaminants found in DNA polymerase stocks used for the polymerase chain reaction. For details on how to partake in the newsgroup, see the accompanying box.