Diversity of bacterial small RNAs drives competitive strategies for a mutual chaperone.

Hundreds of bacterial small RNAs (sRNAs) require the Hfq chaperone to regulate mRNA expression. Hfq is limiting, thus competition among sRNAs for binding to Hfq shapes the proteomes of individual cells. To understand how sRNAs compete for a common partner, we present a single-molecule fluorescence platform to simultaneously visualize binding and release of multiple sRNAs with Hfq. We show that RNA residents rarely dissociate on their own. Instead, clashes between residents and challengers on the same face of Hfq cause rapid exchange, whereas RNAs that recognize different surfaces may cohabit Hfq for several minutes before one RNA departs. The prevalence of these pathways depends on the structure of each RNA and how it interacts with Hfq. We propose that sRNA diversity creates many pairwise interactions with Hfq that allow for distinct biological outcomes: active exchange favors fast regulation whereas co-residence of dissimilar RNAs favors target co-recognition or target exclusion.

Mobility of Bacterial Protein Hfq on dsDNA: Role of C-Terminus-Mediated Transient Binding.

The mobility of protein is fundamental in the machinery of life. Here, we have investigated the effect of DNA binding in conjunction with DNA segmental fluctuation (internal motion) of the bacterial Hfq master regulator devoid of its amyloid C-terminus domain. Hfq is one of the most abundant nucleoid associated proteins that shape the bacterial chromosome and is involved in several aspects of nucleic acid metabolism. Fluorescence microscopy has been used to track a C-terminus domain lacking mutant form of Hfq on double-stranded DNA, which is stretched by confinement to a rectangular nanofluidic channel. The mobility of the mutant is strongly accelerated with respect to the wild-type variant. Furthermore, it shows a reverse dependence on the internal motion of DNA, in that slower motion results in slower protein diffusion. The results demonstrate the subtle role of DNA internal motion in controlling the mobility of a nucleoid associated protein, and, in particular, the importance of transient binding and moving DNA strands out of the way.

The bacterial protein Hfq: Stable modifications and growth phase-dependent changes in SPAM profiles.

In bacteria transcription is coupled to translation, and while it is broadly accepted that transcription-translation complexes (TTCs) are formed in growing bacterial cells, the exact spatial organization of these macromolecular assemblies is not known with certainty. Recent studies indicated the formation of orderly cytosolic superstructures in growing E. coli cells. The bacterial nucleic acid (NA)-binding protein Hfq has been shown to function at the interface of RNA synthesis-degradation machinery; multiple, independent studies link Hfq to orderly cytosolic assemblies. In this work, using fast cell lysis/2D-PAGE and in vitro reconstitution analyses we studied the Hfq modifications and small protein-associated molecules (SPAM). We demonstrate that native Hfq carries stable modifications and simulate 2D patterns of native Hfq-SPAM complexes in reconstitution experiments with purified Hfq and synthetic NA probes. We also demonstrate that genetically engineered Hfq lacking the conserved arginine residues positioned near the rim of the disc formed by the subunits' N-terminal domains binds DNA with a reduced affinity in comparison with wild-type Hfq. These results are consistent with the proposed Hfq-mediated DNA remodeling and point to the involvement of this patch of conserved arginines in interactions with DNA.

Structure and RNA-Binding Properties of Lsm Protein from Halobacterium salinarum.

The structure and the RNA-binding properties of the Lsm protein from Halobacterium salinarum have been determined. A distinctive feature of this protein is the presence of a short L4 loop connecting the ß3 and ß4 strands. Since bacterial Lsm proteins (also called Hfq proteins) have a short L4 loop and form hexamers, whereas archaeal Lsm proteins (SmAP) have a long L4 loop and form heptamers, it has been suggested that the length of the L4 loop may affect the quaternary structure of Lsm proteins. Moreover, the L4 loop covers the region of SmAP corresponding to one of the RNA-binding sites in Hfq, and thus can affect the RNA-binding properties of the protein. Our results show that the SmAP from H. salinarum forms heptamers and possesses the same RNA-binding properties as homologous proteins with the long L4 loop. Therefore, the length of the L4 does not govern the number of monomers in the protein particles and does not affect the RNA-binding properties of Lsm proteins.

RNA binding of Hfq monomers promotes RelA-mediated hexamerization in a limiting Hfq environment.

The RNA chaperone Hfq, acting as a hexamer, is a known mediator of post-transcriptional regulation, expediting basepairing between small RNAs (sRNAs) and their target mRNAs. However, the intricate details associated with Hfq-RNA biogenesis are still unclear. Previously, we reported that the stringent response regulator, RelA, is a functional partner of Hfq that facilitates Hfq-mediated sRNA-mRNA regulation in vivo and induces Hfq hexamerization in vitro. Here we show that RelA-mediated Hfq hexamerization requires an initial binding of RNA, preferably sRNA to Hfq monomers. By interacting with a Shine-Dalgarno-like sequence (GGAG) in the sRNA, RelA stabilizes the initially unstable complex of RNA bound-Hfq monomer, enabling the attachment of more Hfq subunits to form a functional hexamer. Overall, our study showing that RNA binding to Hfq monomers is at the heart of RelA-mediated Hfq hexamerization, challenges the previous concept that only Hfq hexamers can bind RNA.

MD simulations reveal the basis for dynamic assembly of Hfq-RNA complexes.

The conserved protein Hfq is a key factor in the RNA-mediated control of gene expression in most known bacteria. The transient intermediates Hfq forms with RNA support intricate and robust regulatory networks. In Pseudomonas, Hfq recognizes repeats of adenine-purine-any nucleotide (ARN) in target mRNAs via its distal binding side, and together with the catabolite repression control (Crc) protein, assembles into a translation-repression complex. Earlier experiments yielded static, ensemble-averaged structures of the complex, but details of its interface dynamics and assembly pathway remained elusive. Using explicit solvent atomistic molecular dynamics simulations, we modeled the extensive dynamics of the Hfq-RNA interface and found implications for the assembly of the complex. We predict that syn/anti flips of the adenine nucleotides in each ARN repeat contribute to a dynamic recognition mechanism between the Hfq distal side and mRNA targets. We identify a previously unknown binding pocket that can accept any nucleotide and propose that it may serve as a 'status quo' staging point, providing nonspecific binding affinity, until Crc engages the Hfq-RNA binary complex. The dynamical components of the Hfq-RNA recognition can speed up screening of the pool of the surrounding RNAs, participate in rapid accommodation of the RNA on the protein surface, and facilitate competition among different RNAs. The register of Crc in the ternary assembly could be defined by the recognition of a guanine-specific base-phosphate interaction between the first and last ARN repeats of the bound RNA. This dynamic substrate recognition provides structural rationale for the stepwise assembly of multicomponent ribonucleoprotein complexes nucleated by Hfq-RNA binding.

Role of Internal DNA Motion on the Mobility of a Nucleoid-Associated Protein.

Protein transport on DNA is at the core of the machinery of life. Here we investigated the influence of DNA internal motion on the mobility of Hfq, which is involved in several aspects of nucleic acid metabolism and is one of the nucleoid-associated proteins that shape the bacterial chromosome. Fluorescence microscopy was used to follow Hfq on double-stranded DNA that was stretched by confinement to a channel with a diameter of 125 nm. The protein mobility shows a strong dependence on the internal motion of DNA in that slower motion results in faster protein diffusion. A model of released diffusion is proposed that is based on three-dimensional diffusion through the interior of the DNA coil interspersed by periods in which the protein is immobilized in a bound state. We surmise that the coupling between DNA internal motion and protein mobility has important implications for DNA metabolism and protein-binding-related regulation of gene expression.

Determinants of RNA recognition by the FinO domain of the Escherichia coli ProQ protein.

The regulation of gene expression by small RNAs in Escherichia coli depends on RNA binding proteins Hfq and ProQ, which bind mostly distinct RNA pools. To understand how ProQ discriminates between RNA substrates, we compared its binding to six different RNA molecules. Full-length ProQ bound all six RNAs similarly, while the isolated N-terminal FinO domain (NTD) of ProQ specifically recognized RNAs with Rho-independent terminators. Analysis of malM 3'-UTR mutants showed that tight RNA binding by the ProQ NTD required a terminator hairpin of at least 2 bp preceding an 3' oligoU tail of at least four uridine residues. Substitution of an A-rich sequence on the 5' side of the terminator to uridines strengthened the binding of several ProQ-specific RNAs to the Hfq protein, but not to the ProQ NTD. Substitution of the motif in the malM-3' and cspE-3' RNAs also conferred the ability to bind Hfq in E. coli cells, as measured using a three-hybrid assay. In summary, these data suggest that the ProQ NTD specifically recognizes 3' intrinsic terminators of RNA substrates, and that the discrimination between RNA ligands by E. coli ProQ and Hfq depends both on positive determinants for binding to ProQ and negative determinants against binding to Hfq.

Crystal structure of an Escherichia coli Hfq Core (residues 2-69)-DNA complex reveals multifunctional nucleic acid binding sites.

Hfq regulates bacterial gene expression post-transcriptionally by binding small RNAs and their target mRNAs, facilitating sRNA-mRNA annealing, typically resulting in translation inhibition and RNA turnover. Hfq is also found in the nucleoid and binds double-stranded (ds) DNA with a slight preference for A-tracts. Here, we present the crystal structure of the Escherichia coli Hfq Core bound to a 30 bp DNA, containing three 6 bp A-tracts. Although previously postulated to bind to the 'distal' face, three statistically disordered double stranded DNA molecules bind across the proximal face of the Hfq hexamer as parallel, straight rods with B-DNA like conformational properties. One DNA duplex spans the diameter of the hexamer and passes over the uridine-binding proximal-face pore, whereas the remaining DNA duplexes interact with the rims and serve as bridges between adjacent hexamers. Binding is sequence-independent with residues N13, R16, R17 and Q41 interacting exclusively with the DNA backbone. Atomic force microscopy data support the sequence-independent nature of the Hfq-DNA interaction and a role for Hfq in DNA compaction and nucleoid architecture. Our structure and nucleic acid-binding studies also provide insight into the mechanism of sequence-independent binding of Hfq to dsRNA stems, a function that is critical for proper riboregulation.

An unexpected co-crystal structure of the calpain PEF(S) domain with Hfq reveals a potential chaperone function of Hfq.

Calpain is a Ca2+-activated, heterodimeric cysteine protease consisting of a large catalytic subunit and a small regulatory subunit. Dysregulation of this enzyme is involved in a range of pathological conditions such as cancer, Alzheimer's disease and rheumatoid arthritis, and thus calpain I is a drug target with potential therapeutic applications. Difficulty in the production of this enzyme has hindered structural and functional investigations in the past, although heterodimeric calpain I can be generated by Escherichia coli expression in low yield. Here, an unexpected structure discovered during crystallization trials of heterodimeric calpain I (CAPN1C115S + CAPNS1ΔGR) is reported. A novel co-crystal structure of the PEF(S) domain from the dissociated regulatory small subunit of calpain I and the RNA-binding chaperone Hfq, which was likely to be overproduced as a stress response to the recombinant expression conditions, was obtained, providing unexpected insight in the chaperone function of Hfq.

Vibrio cholerae YaeO is a Structural Homologue of RNA Chaperone Hfq that Inhibits Rho-dependent Transcription Termination by Dissociating its Hexameric State.

Rho-dependent transcription termination is a well-conserved process in bacteria. The Psu and YaeO proteins are the two established inhibitors of the ATP-dependent RNA helicase Rho protein of Escherichia coli. Here, we show a detailed sequence and phylogenetic analysis demonstrating that Vibrio cholerae YaeO (VcYaeO) is significantly distinct from its E. coli counterpart. VcYaeO induces significant growth defect on in vivo expression and inhibits in vitro functions of the V. cholerae Rho on directly binding to the latter. Through various biophysical techniques, we showed that interaction of VcYaeO disrupts the oligomeric state of the VcRho. Structure of VcYaeO solved at 1.75 Å resolution, the first crystal structure of a YaeO protein, demonstrates a beta-sandwich fold distinct from the NMR structure of the EcYaeO. Interestingly, VcYaeO structurally resembles the Hfq protein, and like the latter, it exhibits ssDNA/RNA-binding properties. Docking studies demonstrate probable interactions of VcYaeO with VcRho and mode of inhibition of RNA binding to Rho. We propose that VcYaeO inhibits the function of the Rho protein via disruption of the latter's hexameric assembly and also likely by sequestering the RNA from the Rho primarybinding sites.

Identification of protein-protein and ribonucleoprotein complexes containing Hfq.

Hfq is a RNA-binding protein that plays a pivotal role in the control of gene expression in bacteria by stabilizing sRNAs and facilitating their pairing with multiple target mRNAs. It has already been shown that Hfq, directly or indirectly, interacts with many proteins: RNase E, Rho, poly(A)polymerase, RNA polymerase… In order to detect more Hfq-related protein-protein interactions we have used two approaches, TAP-tag combined with RNase A treatment to access the role of RNA in these complexes, and protein-protein crosslinking, which freezes protein-protein complexes formed in vivo. In addition, we have performed microscale thermophoresis to evaluate the role of RNA in some of the complexes detected and used far-western blotting to confirm some protein-protein interactions. Taken together, the results show unambiguously a direct interaction between Hfq and EF-Tu. However a very large number of the interactions of proteins with Hfq in E. coli involve RNAs. These RNAs together with the interacting protein, may play an active role in the formation of Hfq-containing complexes with previously unforeseen implications for the riboregulatory functions of Hfq.

The bacterial endoribonuclease RNase E can cleave RNA in the absence of the RNA chaperone Hfq.

RNase E is a component of the RNA degradosome complex and plays a key role in RNA degradation and maturation in Escherichia coli RNase E-mediated target RNA degradation typically involves the RNA chaperone Hfq and requires small guide RNAs (sRNAs) acting as a seed by binding to short (7-12-bp) complementary regions in target RNA sequences. Here, using recombinantly expressed and purified proteins, site-directed mutagenesis, and RNA cleavage and protein cross-linking assays, we investigated Hfq-independent RNA decay by RNase E. Exploring its RNA substrate preferences in the absence of Hfq, we observed that RNase E preferentially cleaves AU-rich sites of single-stranded regions of RNA substrates that are annealed to an sRNA that contains a monophosphate at its 5'-end. We further found that the quaternary structure of RNase E is also important for complete, Hfq-independent cleavage at sites both proximal and distal to the sRNA-binding site within target RNAs containing monophosphorylated 5'-ends. Of note, genetic RNase E variants with unstable quaternary structure exhibited decreased catalytic activity. In summary, our results show that RNase E can degrade its target RNAs in the absence of the RNA chaperone Hfq. We conclude that RNase E-mediated, Hfq-independent RNA decay in E. coli requires a cognate sRNA sequence for annealing to the target RNA, a 5'-monophosphate at the RNA 5'-end, and a stable RNase E quaternary structure.

Caulobacter crescentus Hfq structure reveals a conserved mechanism of RNA annealing regulation.

We have solved the X-ray crystal structure of the RNA chaperone protein Hfq from the alpha-proteobacterium Caulobacter crescentus to 2.15-Å resolution, resolving the conserved core of the protein and the entire C-terminal domain (CTD). The structure reveals that the CTD of neighboring hexamers pack in crystal contacts, and that the acidic residues at the C-terminal tip of the protein interact with positive residues on the rim of Hfq, as has been recently proposed for a mechanism of modulating RNA binding. De novo computational models predict a similar docking of the acidic tip residues against the core of Hfq. We also show that C. crescentus Hfq has sRNA binding and RNA annealing activities and is capable of facilitating the annealing of certain Escherichia coli sRNA:mRNA pairs in vivo. Finally, we describe how the Hfq CTD and its acidic tip residues provide a mechanism to modulate annealing activity and substrate specificity in various bacteria.

Architectural principles for Hfq/Crc-mediated regulation of gene expression.

In diverse bacterial species, the global regulator Hfq contributes to post-transcriptional networks that control expression of numerous genes. Hfq of the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa inhibits translation of target transcripts by forming a regulatory complex with the catabolite repression protein Crc. This repressive complex acts as part of an intricate mechanism of preferred nutrient utilisation. We describe high-resolution cryo-EM structures of the assembly of Hfq and Crc bound to the translation initiation site of a target mRNA. The core of the assembly is formed through interactions of two cognate RNAs, two Hfq hexamers and a Crc pair. Additional Crc protomers are recruited to the core to generate higher-order assemblies with demonstrated regulatory activity in vivo. This study reveals how Hfq cooperates with a partner protein to regulate translation, and provides a structural basis for an RNA code that guides global regulators to interact cooperatively and regulate different RNA targets.

The binding of Class II sRNA MgrR to two different sites on matchmaker protein Hfq enables efficient competition for Hfq and annealing to regulated mRNAs.

MgrR is an Hfq-dependent sRNA, whose transcription is controlled by the level of Mg2+ ions in Escherichia coli MgrR belongs to Class II sRNAs because its stability in the cell is affected by mutations in Hfq differently than canonical, Class I sRNAs. Here, we examined the effect of mutations in RNA binding sites of Hfq on the kinetics of the annealing of MgrR to two different target mRNAs, eptB and ygdQ, by global data fitting of the reaction kinetics monitored by gel electrophoresis of intermediates and products. The data showed that the mutation on the rim of the Hfq ring trapped MgrR on Hfq preventing the annealing of MgrR to either mRNA. The mutation in the distal face slowed the ternary complex formation and affected the release of MgrR-mRNA complexes from Hfq, while the mutation in the proximal face weakened the MgrR binding to Hfq and in this way affected the annealing. Moreover, competition assays established that MgrR bound to both faces of Hfq and competed against other sRNAs. Further studies showed that uridine-rich sequences located in less structurally stable regions served as Hfq binding sites in each mRNA. Overall, the data show that the binding of MgrR sRNA to both faces of the Hfq ring enables it to efficiently anneal to target mRNAs. It also confers on MgrR a competitive advantage over other sRNAs, which could contribute to efficient cellular response to changes in magnesium homeostasis.

The unusual glycine-rich C terminus of the Acinetobacter baumannii RNA chaperone Hfq plays an important role in bacterial physiology.

Acinetobacter baumannii is a Gram-negative nosocomial pathogen that causes soft tissue infections in patients who spend a long time in intensive care units. This recalcitrant bacterium is very well known for developing rapid drug resistance, which is a combined outcome of its natural competence and mobile genetic elements. Successful efforts to treat these infections would be aided by additional information on the physiology of A. baumannii Toward that end, we recently reported on a small RNA (sRNA), AbsR25, in this bacterium that regulates the genes of several efflux pumps. Because sRNAs often require the RNA chaperone Hfq for assistance in binding to their cognate mRNA targets, we identified and characterized this protein in A. baumannii The homolog in A. baumannii is a large protein with an extended C terminus unlike Hfqs in other Gram-negative pathogens. The extension has a compositional bias toward glycine and, to a lower extent, phenylalanine and glutamine, suggestive of an intrinsically disordered region. We studied the importance of this glycine-rich tail using truncated versions of Hfq in biophysical assays and complementation of an hfq deletion mutant, finding that the tail was necessary for high-affinity RNA binding. Further tests implicate Hfq in important cellular processes of A. baumannii like metabolism, drug resistance, stress tolerance, and virulence. Our findings underline the importance of the glycine-rich C terminus in RNA binding, ribo-regulation, and auto-regulation of Hfq, demonstrating this hitherto overlooked protein motif to be an indispensable part of the A. baumannii Hfq.

Single-Molecule FRET Assay to Observe the Activity of Proteins Involved in RNA/RNA Annealing.

In recent years, single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET) has emerged as a powerful technique to study macromolecular interactions. The chief advantages of smFRET analysis compared to bulk measurements include the possibility to detect sample heterogeneities within a large population of molecules and the facility to measure kinetics without needing the synchronization of intermediate states. As such, the methodology is particularly well adapted to observe and analyze RNA/RNA and RNA/protein interactions involved in small noncoding RNA-mediated gene regulation networks. In this chapter, we describe and discuss protocols that can be used to measure the dynamics of these interactions, with a particular emphasis on the advantages-and experimental pitfalls-of using the smFRET methodology to study sRNA-based biological systems.

Techniques to Analyze sRNA Protein Cofactor Self-Assembly In Vitro.

Post-transcriptional control of gene expression by small regulatory noncoding RNA (sRNA) needs protein accomplices to occur. Past research mainly focused on the RNA chaperone Hfq as cofactor. Nevertheless, recent studies indicated that other proteins might be involved in sRNA-based regulations. As some of these proteins have been shown to self-assemble, we describe in this chapter protocols to analyze the nano-assemblies formed. Precisely, we focus our analysis on Escherichia coli Hfq as a model, but the protocols presented here can be applied to analyze any polymer of proteins. This chapter thus provides a guideline to develop commonly used approaches to detect prokaryotic protein self-assembly, with a special focus on the detection of amyloidogenic polymers.

A Modular Genetic System for High-Throughput Profiling and Engineering of Multi-Target Small RNAs.

RNA biology and RNA engineering are subjects of growing interest due to recent advances in our understanding of the diverse cellular functions of RNAs, including their roles as genetic regulators. The noncoding small RNAs (sRNAs) of bacteria are a fundamental basis of regulatory control that can regulate gene expression via antisense base-pairing to one or more target mRNAs. The sRNAs can be customized to generate a range of mRNA translation rates and stabilities. The sRNAs can be applied as a platform for metabolic engineering, to control expression of genes of interest by following relatively straightforward design rules (Kushwaha et al., ACS Synth Biol 5:795-809, 2016). However, the ab initio design of functional sRNAs to precise specifications of gene control is not yet possible. Consequently, there is a need for tools to rapidly profile uncharacterized sRNAs in vivo, to screen sRNAs against "new/novel" targets, and (in the case of metabolic engineering) to develop engineered sRNAs for regulatory function against multiple desired mRNA targets. To address this unmet need, we previously constructed a modular genetic system for assaying sRNA activity in vivo against specifiable mRNA sequences, using microtiter plate assays for high-throughput productivity. This sRNA design platform consists of three modular plasmids: one plasmid contains an inducible sRNA and the RNA chaperone Hfq; the second contains an inducible fluorescent reporter protein and a LacY mutant transporter protein for inducer molecules; and the third plasmid contains a second inducible fluorescent reporter protein. The second reporter gene makes it possible to screen for sRNA regulators that have activity against multiple mRNAs. We describe the protocol for engineering sRNAs with novel regulatory activity using this system. This sRNA prototyping regimen could also be employed for validating predicted mRNA targets of uncharacterized, naturally occurring sRNAs or for testing hypotheses about the predicted roles of genes, including essential genes, in cellular metabolism and other processes, by using customized antisense sRNAs to knock down or tune down gene expression.