Differential expression of BMP inhibitors gremlin and noggin in Hydra suggests distinct roles during budding and patterning of tentacles.

BACKGROUND: Mechanisms regulating BMP and Wnt pathways and their interactions are not well studied in Hydra. RESULTS: We report identification of BMP inhibitor gremlin, comparison of its expression with that of noggin and possible antagonism between Wnt and BMP signaling in Hydra. Gremlin is expressed in body column with high levels in budding region and in early buds. Noggin, on the other hand, is expressed in the hypostome, base of tentacles, lower body column, and basal disc. During budding, noggin is expressed at the sites of tentacle emergence. This was confirmed in ectopic tentacles in polyps treated with alsterpaullone (ALP), a GSK-3ß inhibitor that leads to upregulation of Wnt pathway. RT-PCR data show that upregulation of Wnt is accompanied by downregulation of bmp 5-8b though noggin and gremlin remain unaltered till 24 hours. CONCLUSIONS: Different expression patterns of gremlin and noggin suggest their roles in budding and patterning of tentacles, respectively. Further, bmp 5-8b inhibition by activated Wnt signaling does not directly involve noggin and gremlin in Hydra. Our data suggest that Wnt/BMP antagonism may have evolved early for defining the oral-aboral axis, while the involvement of BMP antagonists during axial patterning is a recent evolutionary acquisition within the Bilateria lineage.

An interview with Celina Juliano.

Celina Juliano is an Assistant Professor at UC Davis, where she uses Hydra as a model system to understand development and regeneration. She is co-founder of the Cnidarian Model Systems Meeting (Cnidofest) biennial conference and the OpenHydra Hydra resource platform. This year, she was awarded the Elizabeth D. Hay New Investigator award for outstanding developmental biology research during the early stages of her independent career by the Society for Developmental Biology (SDB). Following the virtual SDB 2020 meeting, we met with Celina over Zoom to hear more about her life and career.

Cell signaling molecules in hydra: insights into evolutionarily ancient functions of signaling pathways.

Hydra, a Cnidarian believed to have been evolved about 60 million years ago, has been a favorite model for developmental biologists since Abraham Trembley introduced it in 1744. However, the modern renaissance in research on hydra was initiated by Alfred Gierer when he established a hydra laboratory at the Max Plank Institute in Göttingen in the late 1960s. Several signaling mechanisms that regulate development and pattern formation in vertebrates, including humans, have been found in hydra. These include Wnt, BMP, VEGF, FGF, Notch, and RTK signaling pathways. We have been using hydra to understand the evolution of cell signaling for the past several years. In this article, I will summarize the work on cell signaling pathways in hydra with emphasis on our own work. We have identified and characterized, for the first time, the hydra homologs of the BMP inhibitors Noggin and Gremlin, the vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), fibroblast growth factor (FGF) and several receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs). Our work, along with that of others, clearly demonstrates that these pathways arose early in evolution to carry out functions that were often quite different from their functions in more complex animals. Apart from providing insights into morphogenesis and pattern formation in adult, budding and regenerating hydra, these findings bring out the utility of hydra as a model system to study evolutionarily ancient, in contrast to recently acquired, functions of various biological molecules.

Molecular signature of an ancient organizer regulated by Wnt/ß-catenin signalling during primary body axis patterning in Hydra.

Wnt/ß-catenin signalling has been shown to play a critical role during head organizer formation in Hydra. Here, we characterized the Wnt signalling regulatory network involved in formation of the head organizer. We found that Wnt signalling regulates genes that are important in tissue morphogenesis. We identified that majority of transcription factors (TFs) regulated by Wnt/ß-catenin signalling belong to the homeodomain and forkhead families. Silencing of Margin, one of the Wnt regulated homeodomain TFs, results in loss of the ectopic tentacle phenotype typically seen upon activation of Wnt signalling. Furthermore, we show that the Margin promoter is directly bound and regulated by ß-catenin. Ectopic expression of Margin in zebrafish embryos results in body axis abnormalities suggesting that Margin plays a role in axis patterning. Our findings suggest that homeobox TFs came under the regulatory umbrella of Wnt/ß-catenin signalling presumably resulting in the evolution of primary body axis in animal phyla.

Transgenesis in Hydra to characterize gene function and visualize cell behavior.

The freshwater polyp Hydra is a cnidarian used as a model organism in a number of fields, including the study of the origin and evolution of developmental mechanisms, aging, symbiosis and host-microbe interactions. Here, we describe a procedure for the establishment of stable transgenic Hydra lines by embryo microinjection. The three-stage protocol comprises (i) the design and preparation of a transgenic construct, (ii) the microinjection of the vector into early embryos of Hydra vulgaris, and (iii) the selection and enrichment of mosaic animals in order to develop uniformly transgenic clonal lines. The preparation of a transgenic construct requires ~2 weeks, and transgenic lines can be obtained within 3 months. The method allows constitutive or inducible gain- and loss-of-function approaches, as well as in vivo tracing of individual cells. Hydra polyps carrying transgenic cells reveal functional properties of the ancestral circuitry controlling animal development.

Emergence of form in embryogenesis.

The development of form in an embryo is the result of a series of topological and informational symmetry breakings. We introduce the vector-reaction-diffusion-drift (VRDD) system where the limit cycle of spatial dynamics is morphogen concentrations with Dirac delta-type distributions. This is fundamentally different from the Turing reaction-diffusion system, as VRDD generates system-wide broken symmetry. We developed 'fundamental forms' from spherical blastula with a single organizing axis (rotational symmetry), double axis (mirror symmetry) and triple axis (no symmetry operator in three dimensions). We then introduced dynamics for cell differentiation, where genetic regulatory states are modelled as a finite-state machine (FSM). The state switching of an FSM is based on local morphogen concentrations as epigenetic information that changes dynamically. We grow complicated forms hierarchically in spatial subdomains using the FSM model coupled with the VRDD system. Using our integrated simulation model with four layers (topological, physical, chemical and regulatory), we generated life-like forms such as hydra. Genotype-phenotype mapping was investigated with continuous and jump mutations. Our study can have applications in morphogenetic engineering, soft robotics and biomimetic design.

The publications of embryologist Lev V. Beloussov.

A list of papers and books of the late Lev V. Beloussov was compiled and is available in Word and EndNote Supplements. The breadth of his work is briefly described.

Real time dynamics of ß-catenin expression during Hydra development, regeneration and Wnt signalling activation.

Understanding the dynamic cellular behaviours driving morphogenesis and regeneration is a long-standing challenge in biology. Live imaging, together with genetically encoded reporters, may provide the necessary tool to address this issue, permitting the in vivo monitoring of the spatial and temporal expression dynamics of a gene of interest during a variety of developmental processes. Canonical Wnt/ß-catenin signalling controls a plethora of cellular activities during development, regeneration and adulthood throughout the animal kingdom. Several reporters have been produced in animal models to reveal sites of active Wnt signalling. In order to monitor in vivo Wnt/ß-catenin signalling activity in the freshwater polyp Hydra vulgaris, we generated a ß-cat-eGFP transgenic Hydra, in which eGFP is driven by the Hydra ß-catenin promoter. We characterized the expression dynamics during budding, regeneration and chemical activation of the Wnt/ß-cat signalling pathway using light sheet fluorescence microscopy. Live imaging of the ß-cat-eGFP lines recapitulated the previously reported endogenous expression pattern of ß-catenin and revealed the dynamic appearance of novel sites of Wnt/ß-catenin signalling, that earlier evaded detection by mean of in situ hybridization. By combining the Wnt activity read-out efficiency of the ß-catenin promoter with advanced imaging, we have created a novel model system to monitor in real time the activity of Hydra ß-cat regulatory sequences in vivo, and open the path to reveal ß-catenin modulation in many other physiological contexts.

Generation of transgenic Hydra by embryo microinjection.

As a member of the phylum Cnidaria, the sister group to all bilaterians, Hydra can shed light on fundamental biological processes shared among multicellular animals. Hydra is used as a model for the study of regeneration, pattern formation, and stem cells. However, research efforts have been hampered by lack of a reliable method for gene perturbations to study molecular function. The development of transgenic methods has revitalized the study of Hydra biology(1). Transgenic Hydra allow for the tracking of live cells, sorting to yield pure cell populations for biochemical analysis, manipulation of gene function by knockdown and over-expression, and analysis of promoter function. Plasmid DNA injected into early stage embryos randomly integrates into the genome early in development. This results in hatchlings that express transgenes in patches of tissue in one or more of the three lineages (ectodermal epithelial, endodermal epithelial, or interstitial). The success rate of obtaining a hatchling with transgenic tissue is between 10% and 20%. Asexual propagation of the transgenic hatchling is used to establish a uniformly transgenic line in a particular lineage. Generating transgenic Hydra is surprisingly simple and robust, and here we describe a protocol that can be easily implemented at low cost.

Nodal signalling determines biradial asymmetry in Hydra.

In bilaterians, three orthogonal body axes define the animal form, with distinct anterior-posterior, dorsal-ventral and left-right asymmetries. The key signalling factors are Wnt family proteins for the anterior-posterior axis, Bmp family proteins for the dorsal-ventral axis and Nodal for the left-right axis. Cnidarians, the sister group to bilaterians, are characterized by one oral-aboral body axis, which exhibits a distinct biradiality of unknown molecular nature. Here we analysed the biradial growth pattern in the radially symmetrical cnidarian polyp Hydra, and we report evidence of Nodal in a pre-bilaterian clade. We identified a Nodal-related gene (Ndr) in Hydra magnipapillata, and this gene is essential for setting up an axial asymmetry along the main body axis. This asymmetry defines a lateral signalling centre, inducing a new body axis of a budding polyp orthogonal to the mother polyp's axis. Ndr is expressed exclusively in the lateral bud anlage and induces Pitx, which encodes an evolutionarily conserved transcription factor that functions downstream of Nodal. Reminiscent of its function in vertebrates, Nodal acts downstream of ß-Catenin signalling. Our data support an evolutionary scenario in which a 'core-signalling cassette' consisting of ß-Catenin, Nodal and Pitx pre-dated the cnidarian-bilaterian split. We presume that this cassette was co-opted for various modes of axial patterning: for example, for lateral branching in cnidarians and left-right patterning in bilaterians.

FGFR-ERK signaling is an essential component of tissue separation.

Formation of a constriction and tissue separation between parent and young polyp is a hallmark of the Hydra budding process and controlled by fibroblast growth factor receptor (FGFR) signaling. Appearance of a cluster of cells positive for double phosphorylated ERK (dpERK) at the late separation site indicated that the RAS/MEK/ERK pathway might be a downstream target of the Hydra Kringelchen FGFR. In fact, inhibition of ERK phosphorylation by the MEK inhibitor U0126 reversibly delayed bud detachment and prevented formation of the dpERK-positive cell cluster indicating de novo-phosphorylation of ERK at the late bud base. In functional studies, a dominant-negative Kringelchen FGFR prevented bud detachment as well as appearance of the dpERK-positive cell cluster. Ectopic expression of full length Kringelchen, on the other hand, induced a localized rearrangement of the actin cytoskeleton at sites of constriction, localized ERK-phosphorylation and autotomy of the body column. Our data suggest a model in which (i) the Hydra FGFR targets, via an unknown pathway, the actin cytoskeleton to induce a constriction and (ii) FGFR activates MEK/ERK signaling at the late separation site to allow tissue separation.

A small molecule screen identifies a novel compound that induces a homeotic transformation in Hydra.

Developmental processes such as morphogenesis, patterning and differentiation are continuously active in the adult Hydra polyp. We carried out a small molecule screen to identify compounds that affect patterning in Hydra. We identified a novel molecule, DAC-2-25, that causes a homeotic transformation of body column into tentacle zone. This transformation occurs in a progressive and polar fashion, beginning at the oral end of the animal. We have identified several strains that respond to DAC-2-25 and one that does not, and we used chimeras from these strains to identify the ectoderm as the target tissue for DAC-2-25. Using transgenic Hydra that express green fluorescent protein under the control of relevant promoters, we examined how DAC-2-25 affects tentacle patterning. Genes whose expression is associated with the tentacle zone are ectopically expressed upon exposure to DAC-2-25, whereas those associated with body column tissue are turned off as the tentacle zone expands. The expression patterns of the organizer-associated gene HyWnt3 and the hypostome-specific gene HyBra2 are unchanged. Structure-activity relationship studies have identified features of DAC-2-25 that are required for activity and potency. This study shows that small molecule screens in Hydra can be used to dissect patterning processes.

Conservation of the nucleotide excision repair pathway: characterization of hydra Xeroderma Pigmentosum group F homolog.

Hydra, one of the earliest metazoans with tissue grade organization and nervous system, is an animal with a remarkable regeneration capacity and shows no signs of organismal aging. We have for the first time identified genes of the nucleotide excision repair (NER) pathway from hydra. Here we report cloning and characterization of hydra homolog of xeroderma pigmentosum group F (XPF) gene that encodes a structure-specific 5' endonuclease which is a crucial component of NER. In silico analysis shows that hydra XPF amino acid sequence is very similar to its counterparts from other animals, especially vertebrates, and shows all features essential for its function. By in situ hybridization, we show that hydra XPF is expressed prominently in the multipotent stem cell niche in the central region of the body column. Ectoderm of the diploblastic hydra was shown to express higher levels of XPF as compared to the endoderm by semi-quantitative RT-PCR. Semi-quantitative RT-PCR analysis also demonstrated that interstitial cells, a multipotent and rapidly cycling stem cell lineage of hydra, express higher levels of XPF mRNA than other cell types. Our data show that XPF and by extension, the NER pathway is highly conserved during evolution. The prominent expression of an NER gene in interstitial cells may have implications for the lack of senescence in hydra.

Organizer formation in Hydra is disrupted by thalidomide treatment.

Thalidomide is a drug that is well known for its teratogenic properties in humans. Surprisingly, thalidomide does not have teratogenic effects on mouse development. We investigated the effect of thalidomide on patterning in hydra, an early metazoan with a very simple axial symmetry. Hydra develops asexually via Wnt-dependent organizer formation, leading to the budding of a new organism. We observe both induction and inhibition of organizer formation depending on cellular context. Interestingly, thalidomide treatment altered budding and the developing organizer, but had little effect on the adult. Expression of Hybra1, a marker of the organizer increased upon thalidomide treatment. However when the organizer is induced by ectopic activation of Wnt signaling via GSK3 inhibition, thalidomide suppresses induction. We show that inhibition of Wnt signaling is not mediated by induction of the BMP pathway. We show that thalidomide activity on organizer formation in hydra depends on the activity of casein kinase1 and the abundance of ß-catenin. Finally, we find that interstitial cells, multipotent cells which give rise to nemoatocytes, neural, digestive and germline cells, are partially responsible for the inhibitory effect of thalidomide.

The head organizer in Hydra.

Organizers and organizing centers play critical roles in axis formation and patterning during the early stages of embryogenesis in many bilaterians. The presence and activity of an organizer was first described in adult Hydra about 100 years ago, and in the following decades organizer regions were identified in a number of bilaterian embryos. In an adult Hydra, the cells of the body column are constantly in the mitotic cycle resulting in continuous displacement of the tissue to the extremities where it is sloughed. In this context, the head organizer located in the hypostome is continuously active sending out signals to maintain the structure and morphology of the head, body column and foot of the animal. The molecular basis of the head organizer involves the canonical Wnt pathway, which acts in a self-renewing manner to maintain itself in the context of the tissue dynamics of Hydra. During bud formation, Hydra's mode of asexual reproduction, a head organizer based on the canonical Wnt pathway is set up to initiate and control the development of a new Hydra. As this pathway plays a central role in vertebrate embryonic organizers, its presence and activity in Hydra indicate that the molecular basis of the organizer arose early in metazoan evolution.

Hydra, a model system to trace the emergence of boundaries in developing eumetazoans.

In developing embryos, boundary formation between neighbouring groups of cells is essential to establish compartments which later fulfil specialized functions. The ability to form such boundaries has likely developed early in animal evolution - due to functional requirements imposed by the necessity to separate tissues which protect the animal, take up food or ensure propagation. Essential for boundary formation are local cues which may be provided by the intersection of diffusible molecules or set locally by activation of membrane-bound receptors and transcription factors. In the simple diploblastic Hydra, a representative of the basally branching metazoan Cnidaria, tissue boundaries are morphologically detectable between the body column and terminally differentiated head and foot structures. In adult polyps, these borders correspond to sharp lines of differential gene expression. They form de novo during regeneration and budding of a young polyp. Functional studies strongly suggest the involvement of FGFR/Notch signalling in the establishment of the parent-bud boundary, and it is very likely that these pathways interact with the WNT and BMP systems. How boundaries in the head and foot regions are generated is still unclear. Expression patterns of transcription factors like Cngsc, HyAlx, HyBra, HyOtx, Prdl-a, CnNK2 and Manacle show strong position dependency and may be involved in regulating gene expression on either side of the boundaries, by interpreting positional information during their formation and maintenance. Due to its simplicity, the easy accessibility to pharmacological interference and, recently, transgenesis, Hydra is an interesting prebilaterian model system to study the emergence of boundary-forming mechanisms during evolution.

Hydra, the everlasting embryo, confronts aging.

Existing data imply that the cnidarian Hydra vulgaris does not undergo senescence. In contrast, the related species Hydra oligactis shows increased mortality and physiological deterioration following sexual reproduction. Hydra thus offers the chance to study a striking difference in lifespan in members of the same genus. Adult Hydra possess three well-characterized stem cell populations, one of which gives rise to both somatic cells and gametes. The lack of senescence in Hydra vulgaris raises the question of how these stem cell populations are maintained over long periods of time. Investigation of the roles in Hydra of proteins involved in cellular stress responses in other organisms should provide insight into this issue. Proteins of particular interest include the Hsp70 family proteins and the transcription factor FoxO.

Critical behavior and axis defining symmetry breaking in Hydra embryonic development.

The formation of a hollow cellular sphere is often one of the first steps of multicellular embryonic development. In the case of Hydra, the sphere breaks its initial symmetry to form a foot-head axis. During this process a gene, ks1, is increasingly expressed in localized cell domains whose size distribution becomes scale-free at the axis-locking moment. We show that a physical model based solely on the production and exchange of ks1-promoting factors among neighboring cells robustly reproduces the scaling behavior as well as the experimentally observed spontaneous and temperature-directed symmetry breaking.

Modeling pattern formation in hydra: a route to understanding essential steps in development.

Modeling of pattern formation in hydra has revealed basic mechanisms that underlie the reproducible generation of complex and self-regulating patterns. Organizing regions can be generated by a local self-enhancing reaction that is coupled with an inhibitory effect of longer range. Such reactions enable pattern formation even in an initially almost homogeneous assembly of cells. A long-ranging feedback of the organizer onto the competence to perform the pattern-forming reaction stabilizes the polar axial pattern during growth and allows for regeneration with preserved polarity. Hypostome formation is assumed to be under the control of two positive feedback loops in which Wnt3 is a common element. In addition to the well-established loop employing beta-catenin, a second cell-local loop is involved, possibly with Brachyury as an additional component. This model accounts for the different expression patterns of beta-catenin and Wnt3. Wnt molecules are proposed to play a dual role, functioning as activators and, after processing, as inhibitors. Since Wnt genes code for complete pattern-forming systems, gene duplication and diversification lead to a family of genes whose expression regions have a precise relation to each other. Tentacle formation is an example of positioning a second pattern-forming system by medium-ranging activation and local exclusion exerted by the primary system. A model for bud formation suggests that a transient pre-bud signal is involved that initiates the formation of the foot of the bud, close to the normal foot, as well as close to the bud tip. Many dynamic regulations, as observed in classical and molecular observations, are reproduced in computer simulations. A case is made that hydra can be regarded as a living fossil, documenting an evolutionary early axis formation before trunk formation and bilaterality were invented. Animated simulations are available in the supplementary information accompanying this paper.

Evo-devo: Hydra raises its Noggin.

Noggin, along with other secreted bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) inhibitors, plays a crucial role in neural induction and neural tube patterning as well as in somitogenesis, cardiac morphogenesis and formation of the skeleton in vertebrates. The BMP signalling pathway is one of the seven fundamental pathways that drive embryonic development and pattern formation in animals. Understanding its evolutionary origin and role in pattern formation is, therefore, important to evolutionary developmental biology (evo-devo). We have studied the evolutionary origin of BMP-Noggin antagonism in hydra, which is a powerful diploblastic model to study evolution of pattern-forming mechanisms because of the unusual cellular dynamics during its pattern formation and its remarkable ability to regenerate. We cloned and characterized the noggin gene from hydra and found it to exhibit considerable similarity with its orthologues at the amino acid level. Microinjection of hydra Noggin mRNA led to duplication of the dorsoventral axis in Xenopus embryos, demonstrating its functional conservation across the taxa. Our data, along with those of others, indicate that the evolutionarily conserved antagonism between BMP and its inhibitors predates bilateral divergence. This article reviews the various roles of Noggin in different organisms and some of our recent work on hydra Noggin in the context of evolution of developmental signalling pathways.