ABSTRACT
A longstanding trope in Indian psychiatry, and in popular representations of it, involves the efficacy of incantations and exorcism in healing afflictions of the mind, notably hysteria. In many accounts, from nineteenth century medical journals to twenty-first century popular films, a medicine deemed at once 'Western' and universal is granted the ability to diagnose neurotic afflictions, but rendered incapable of curing them, while bodily techniques referred to as 'Indian' are granted efficacy. In this article, I explore the subtleties and implications of this recurrent knowledge paradigm. I argue that a particular arrangement-one in which difference is established through equivalence-undergirds the terms by which medicine comes to be viewed as a cultural encounter. As these progressive formulations are often founded on stories about women's madness, I ask, what are the implications of an arguably pragmatic ethos founded on an uneven-and deeply gendered-resolution to postcolonial knowledge problems?
Subject(s)
Anthropology, Medical , Singing , Spiritual Therapies , Female , Humans , Hysteria/ethnology , India , MaleABSTRACT
CASE REPORTS: In this study, we will describe three observations of depression "masked" by persecution delirium and/or hallucinations, to illustrate the role that the cultural factor could play in the expression and care of depression. In the first two observations, the persecutor was a group that was apparently difficult to circumscribe: the persecution appeared more important than the persecutor. In these two cases, persecution also had a depreciating role for the patient. In the third observation, the hallucinatory manifestations cast a slur on self-esteem and caused narcissistic injury. DISCUSSION: Analysis of the cultural context allows us to understand the depressive significance of such psychotic symptoms. In the traditional societies, depression is strongly related to the cultural context, it is often expressed by the fear of being punished or denied by the group, and a feeling of treason towards the community. The punishment can be direct or indirect, carried out by imaginary beings, "the djinn", or by any disease. According to Freud, the guilt is expressed by the fear of the vengeance of a dead man's spirit, which is then going to persecute the culprit. This persecution, which has a value of punishment, is based on the mechanism of the projection. In the same sense, Freud explained that the death, as a sequel of the disease, is the vengeance of the dead man's spirit in the living. In all religions, the impulses, the thoughts disapproved by the community, are attributed to Satan who etymologically means "the enemy" or "the opponent". This latter plays an important role in relieving fears, the sense of guilt and the disapproved thoughts. There is also involvement of the projection mechanism. So, guilt could be expressed by delirious ideas such as the conviction of being the victim of a demonic possession, to be under a spell or to be persecuted. CONCLUSION: Thus, taking the cultural context into account would allow us to fundamentally understand the depressive meaning of the delirious symptomatology of persecution, which is taken from a popular theory of misfortune shared and validated by the familial and the social circle of acquaintances. Plantine postulates that the psychotic conflict takes the subject away from the standards of his own culture. In the case of our three patients, we should try to establish a form of communication, to prevent them from falling into alienation. Thus, we must think about our attitude facing a patient who is diagnosed as depressed or even psychotic, while the patient believes he/she is possessed by a "Djinn". The therapeutic attitude should be adapted to the cultural dimension of the case. Thus, in situations similar to the studied cases, the therapy should be essentially based on the development of a psychotherapeutic relationship, rather than a pharmacotherapy, one should be careful not to compromise the cultural means of restoring psychic disorders such as the traditional therapy.
Subject(s)
Affective Disorders, Psychotic/diagnosis , Affective Disorders, Psychotic/ethnology , Cross-Cultural Comparison , Delusions/diagnosis , Delusions/ethnology , Depressive Disorder, Major/diagnosis , Depressive Disorder, Major/ethnology , Hallucinations/diagnosis , Hallucinations/ethnology , Adult , Affective Disorders, Psychotic/psychology , Affective Disorders, Psychotic/rehabilitation , Africa, Northern , Antidepressive Agents, Tricyclic/therapeutic use , Antipsychotic Agents/adverse effects , Antipsychotic Agents/therapeutic use , Combined Modality Therapy , Delusions/psychology , Delusions/rehabilitation , Depressive Disorder, Major/psychology , Depressive Disorder, Major/rehabilitation , Diagnosis, Differential , Female , Hallucinations/psychology , Hallucinations/rehabilitation , Humans , Hysteria/diagnosis , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/psychology , Hysteria/rehabilitation , Male , Middle Aged , Narcissism , Psychiatric Status Rating Scales , Psychotherapy , Psychotic Disorders/diagnosis , Psychotic Disorders/ethnology , Psychotic Disorders/psychology , Rehabilitation, Vocational , Self Concept , Social EnvironmentABSTRACT
This paper examines the history of the trope of psychoanalytic therapy in musical dramas, from Richard Wagner to Kurt Weill, concluding that psychoanalysis and the musical drama are, in some ways, companions and take cues from each other, beginning in the mid-19th century. In Wagner's music dramas, psychoanalytic themes and situations - specifically concerning the meaning and analysis of dreams - are presaged. In early modernist music dramas by Richard Strauss and Arnold Schoenberg (contemporaries of Freud), tacit representations of the drama of hysteria, its aetiology and "treatment" comprise key elements of the plot and resonate with dissonant musical soundscapes. By the middle of the 20th century, Kurt Weill places the relationship between analyst and patient in the foreground of his musical "Lady in the Dark," thereby making manifest what is latent in a century-spanning chain of musical works whose meaning centres, in part, around representations of psychoanalysis.
Subject(s)
Dreams , Hysteria , Music , Physician-Patient Relations , Psychoanalytic Therapy , Symbolism , Authorship , Dreams/physiology , Dreams/psychology , Freudian Theory/history , History, 20th Century , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Hysteria/psychology , Language , Music/history , Music/psychology , Psychoanalysis/education , Psychoanalysis/history , Psychoanalytic Interpretation , Psychoanalytic Therapy/educationABSTRACT
Factitious disorder is the deliberate simulation of illness for the purpose of seeking the sick role. It is a 20th-century diagnosis, though the grounds for its introduction are uncertain. While previous authors have considered the social changes contributing to growth in the disorder, this article looks at some of the pressures on doctors that may have created the diagnostic need for a disorder between hysteria and malingering. The recent history of those disorders suggests that malingering would no longer be acceptable when applied to the potentially larger numbers involved in workers' compensation or in mass conscription. Equally, the absolution given to hysteria on the basis of the Freudian subconscious would survive only as long as that model retained credibility. Growing egalitarianism and changing doctor-patient relationships in the 20th century would no longer tolerate a sharp division between culpable malingering and exculpated hysteria, which may previously have been made on grounds of class or gender. They would contribute to the need for a mediating diagnosis, such as factitious disorder.
Subject(s)
Conversion Disorder , Factitious Disorders , Hysteria , Malingering , Munchausen Syndrome , Social Behavior , Conversion Disorder/ethnology , Conversion Disorder/history , Conversion Disorder/psychology , Diagnosis , Factitious Disorders/ethnology , Factitious Disorders/history , Factitious Disorders/psychology , Gender Identity , History, 20th Century , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Hysteria/psychology , Malingering/ethnology , Malingering/history , Malingering/psychology , Munchausen Syndrome/ethnology , Munchausen Syndrome/history , Munchausen Syndrome/psychology , Physicians/economics , Physicians/history , Physicians/legislation & jurisprudence , Physicians/psychology , Social Class/history , Socioeconomic FactorsABSTRACT
Beginning with a discussion of the sources in Darwin's writing for Freud's theory of the hysterical symptom, this essay proceeds to a symptomatic reading of Darwin himself. With reference to "The Origin of Species," "The Descent of Man," and "The Expression of the Emotions," this essay shows that Darwin's theories of involuntary expressive behavior and of aesthetic preference in sexual selection are linked by their role in his understanding of racial difference and also by their reliance on the idea that learned habits can be inherited as instincts, a view often identified with Lamarck. They are thus at once theories of the foreign body and theories that appear as foreigners within the body of Darwin's work.
Subject(s)
Habits , Hysteria , Instinct , Psychoanalysis , Selection, Genetic , Behavioral Symptoms/ethnology , Behavioral Symptoms/history , History, 19th Century , History, 20th Century , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Personal Construct Theory , Psychoanalysis/education , Psychoanalysis/historySubject(s)
Homicide , Hysteria , Judicial Role , Public Opinion , Social Conditions , Women's Health , Women's Rights , Anthropology, Cultural/education , Anthropology, Cultural/history , Crime/economics , Crime/ethnology , Crime/history , Crime/legislation & jurisprudence , Crime/psychology , Crime Victims/economics , Crime Victims/education , Crime Victims/history , Crime Victims/legislation & jurisprudence , Crime Victims/psychology , Female , Feminism/history , France/ethnology , Gender Identity , History, 19th Century , Homicide/economics , Homicide/ethnology , Homicide/history , Homicide/legislation & jurisprudence , Homicide/psychology , Homosexuality, Female/ethnology , Homosexuality, Female/history , Homosexuality, Female/psychology , Humans , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Hysteria/psychology , Judicial Role/history , Poisoning/ethnology , Poisoning/history , Poisoning/psychology , Psychoanalysis/education , Psychoanalysis/history , Sexology/education , Sexology/history , Social Conditions/economics , Social Conditions/history , Social Conditions/legislation & jurisprudence , Social Control Policies/economics , Social Control Policies/history , Social Control Policies/legislation & jurisprudence , Virtues , Women's Health/economics , Women's Health/ethnology , Women's Health/history , Women's Health/legislation & jurisprudence , Women's Rights/economics , Women's Rights/educationSubject(s)
Coitus , Hysteria , Infertility , Marriage , Sexual Maturation , Spouses , Vaginismus , Women's Health , Coitus/physiology , Coitus/psychology , Culture , Erectile Dysfunction/ethnology , Erectile Dysfunction/history , Erectile Dysfunction/psychology , Europe/ethnology , Female , History, 19th Century , History, 20th Century , Homosexuality, Female/ethnology , Homosexuality, Female/history , Homosexuality, Female/psychology , Humans , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Hysteria/psychology , Infertility/ethnology , Infertility/history , Infertility/psychology , Interpersonal Relations , Male , Marriage/ethnology , Marriage/history , Marriage/legislation & jurisprudence , Marriage/psychology , Men's Health/economics , Men's Health/ethnology , Men's Health/history , Men's Health/legislation & jurisprudence , Psychosexual Development/physiology , Sexual Abstinence/ethnology , Sexual Abstinence/history , Sexual Abstinence/physiology , Sexual Abstinence/psychology , Sexual Behavior/ethnology , Sexual Behavior/history , Sexual Behavior/physiology , Sexual Behavior/psychology , Sexual Development/physiology , Sexual Maturation/physiology , Sexual Partners/psychology , Sexuality/ethnology , Sexuality/history , Sexuality/physiology , Sexuality/psychology , Social Change/history , Spouses/education , Spouses/ethnology , Spouses/historySubject(s)
Adolescent Psychiatry , Child Psychiatry , Crisis Intervention , Hysteria/therapy , Schools , Spiritual Therapies , Adolescent , Child , Dangerous Behavior , Humans , Hysteria/ethnology , Mexico , ShamanismABSTRACT
Isotretinoin (Accutane) is a drug closely related to the chemical structure of Vitamin A. The pharmacology and toxicology of these two retinoids is similar enough to warrant comparison. Accutane is a powerful drug which its manufacturer, Roche, indicates is limited for severe recalcitrant nodular acne. This potency is also reflected in Accutane's well-known ability to produce severe birth defects if taken during pregnancy. Less well-known is the risk of this lipid soluble chemical to affect the Central Nervous System. Reports of intracranial hypertension, depression, and suicidal indeation with Accutane use have prompted an examination of this serious and life threatening potential. Though Roche has added a warning to its product label for signs of depression and suicidal ideation, this product is being overprescribed for all forms of acne, including mild cases and moderate acne that have not been treated with alternative medications, which have a lesser risk of depression and suicide. There is no contesting that this drug is effective at clearing up the most severe forms of acne, but the public must be informed of its proper, limited indication for use; depression and suicide can follow in patients with no prior history of psychiatric symptoms or suicide attempts.
Subject(s)
Dermatologic Agents/adverse effects , Hypervitaminosis A/etiology , Hysteria/etiology , Isotretinoin/adverse effects , Animals , Arctic Regions/epidemiology , Diet , Foodborne Diseases/complications , Foodborne Diseases/ethnology , Foodborne Diseases/history , History, 16th Century , History, 20th Century , Humans , Hypervitaminosis A/ethnology , Hypervitaminosis A/history , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Inuit , Liver , Psychoses, Substance-Induced/ethnology , Psychoses, Substance-Induced/etiology , Psychoses, Substance-Induced/history , UrsidaeSubject(s)
Ethnicity/psychology , Hysteria/ethnology , Mass Behavior , Psychology, Adolescent , Superstitions/psychology , Adolescent , Cross-Sectional Studies , Educational Status , Female , Humans , Hysteria/diagnosis , Hysteria/psychology , Logistic Models , Peer Group , Personality Inventory , Students/psychology , Taiwan/ethnologyABSTRACT
The case of a 31-member family displaying mass hysteria in up to 10 members at one time is reported. The mass hysteria emerged in the context of the strong religious and cultural beliefs held by this closely knit family. The varied presentations included somatoform disorder, recurrent vomiting, conversion, dissociative and possession attacks. Two members had bipolar affective disorder that was recognized by the family as a 'medical' illness in contrast to other problems attributed to religiosity. The rarity of mass hysteria in a family and issues related to its medical and social management are highlighted.
Subject(s)
Conversion Disorder/genetics , Disease Outbreaks , Family Relations , Hysteria/genetics , Adolescent , Adult , Bipolar Disorder/ethnology , Bipolar Disorder/psychology , Child , Conversion Disorder/ethnology , Conversion Disorder/psychology , Cultural Characteristics , Dissociative Disorders/ethnology , Dissociative Disorders/genetics , Dissociative Disorders/psychology , Female , Humans , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/psychology , India/ethnology , Male , Pedigree , Recurrence , Religion , Somatoform Disorders/ethnology , Somatoform Disorders/genetics , Somatoform Disorders/psychology , Vomiting/psychologySubject(s)
Hysteria , Mysticism , Psychosomatic Medicine , Religion and Psychology , Women's Health , Catholicism/history , Catholicism/psychology , Faith Healing/education , Faith Healing/history , Faith Healing/psychology , History, 19th Century , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Mysticism/history , Mysticism/psychology , Paralysis/ethnology , Paralysis/history , Psychosomatic Medicine/education , Psychosomatic Medicine/history , Symbolism , Women's Health/ethnology , Women's Health/historySubject(s)
Disease Outbreaks , Hysteria , Mortality , Syphilis , Therapeutics , Disease Outbreaks/history , Europe/ethnology , History, 16th Century , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Men's Health/ethnology , Men's Health/history , Mortality/ethnology , Mortality/history , Social Conditions/history , Syphilis/ethnology , Syphilis/history , Therapeutics/history , Therapeutics/psychology , Women's Health/ethnology , Women's Health/historySubject(s)
Biology , Gender Identity , Morals , Prisoners , Psychiatry , Women's Health , Anthropology, Cultural/education , Anthropology, Cultural/history , Biology/economics , Biology/education , Biology/history , Biology/legislation & jurisprudence , Capital Punishment/history , Capital Punishment/legislation & jurisprudence , Crime/economics , Crime/ethnology , Crime/history , Crime/legislation & jurisprudence , Crime/psychology , History, 20th Century , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Hysteria/psychology , Prisoners/education , Prisoners/history , Prisoners/legislation & jurisprudence , Prisoners/psychology , Psychiatry/economics , Psychiatry/education , Psychiatry/history , Psychiatry/legislation & jurisprudence , Punishment/history , Punishment/psychology , Religion/history , Spain/ethnology , Warfare , Women/education , Women/history , Women/psychology , Women's Health/economics , Women's Health/ethnology , Women's Health/history , Women's Health/legislation & jurisprudence , Women's Rights/economics , Women's Rights/education , Women's Rights/history , Women's Rights/legislation & jurisprudenceSubject(s)
Hysteria , Mental Disorders , Military Personnel , Shock, Traumatic , Wounds and Injuries , Disabled Persons/education , Disabled Persons/history , Disabled Persons/legislation & jurisprudence , Disabled Persons/psychology , Electroconvulsive Therapy/history , Electroconvulsive Therapy/psychology , Europe/ethnology , History, 20th Century , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Hysteria/psychology , Mental Disorders/ethnology , Mental Disorders/history , Mental Disorders/psychology , Military Medicine/economics , Military Medicine/education , Military Medicine/history , Military Medicine/legislation & jurisprudence , Military Personnel/education , Military Personnel/history , Military Personnel/legislation & jurisprudence , Military Personnel/psychology , Military Psychiatry/economics , Military Psychiatry/education , Military Psychiatry/history , Military Psychiatry/legislation & jurisprudence , Patients/history , Patients/psychology , Physicians/history , Physicians/psychology , Shock, Traumatic/ethnology , Shock, Traumatic/history , Shock, Traumatic/psychology , Therapeutics/history , Therapeutics/psychology , Torture/history , Torture/psychology , World War I , Wounds and Injuries/ethnology , Wounds and Injuries/history , Wounds and Injuries/psychologySubject(s)
Black or African American , Gynecology , Hysteria , Neurology , Obstetrics , Psychiatry , Race Relations , Racial Groups , Women , Black or African American/ethnology , Black or African American/history , Female , Gynecology/history , History, 19th Century , Humans , Hysteria/diagnosis , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Neurology/history , Obstetrics/history , Prejudice , Psychiatry/history , Race Relations/history , Racial Groups/ethnology , Racial Groups/history , Racial Groups/psychology , United States/ethnology , Women/history , Women/psychologySubject(s)
Combat Disorders , Mental Disorders , Military Personnel , Military Psychiatry , World War I , Combat Disorders/ethnology , Combat Disorders/history , Cultural Characteristics/history , Germany/ethnology , History, 20th Century , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Mental Disorders/ethnology , Mental Disorders/history , Military Medicine/economics , Military Medicine/education , Military Medicine/history , Military Personnel/education , Military Personnel/history , Military Personnel/legislation & jurisprudence , Military Personnel/psychology , Military Psychiatry/education , Military Psychiatry/history , Psychiatry/education , Psychiatry/history , Science/economics , Science/education , Science/historySubject(s)
Anthropology, Cultural , Civil Disorders , Jurisprudence , Prejudice , Witchcraft , Anthropology, Cultural/education , Anthropology, Cultural/history , Civil Disorders/ethnology , Civil Disorders/history , Civil Disorders/psychology , History, 16th Century , History, 17th Century , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/history , Hysteria/psychology , Jurisprudence/history , Medicine, Traditional/history , Medicine, Traditional/legislation & jurisprudence , Social Change/history , Sweden/ethnology , Witchcraft/history , Witchcraft/psychology , Women's Health/economics , Women's Health/ethnology , Women's Health/history , Women's Health/legislation & jurisprudence , Women's Rights/economics , Women's Rights/education , Women's Rights/history , Women's Rights/legislation & jurisprudenceABSTRACT
In March 1990, a mysterious outbreak of illness spread suddenly among thousands of ethnic Albanian high school students in Kosovo (Yugoslavia). It was an unprecedented event on the worldwide scale both in terms of the number of cases and in terms of controversies concerning the aetiology. A retrospective analysis indicated that the epidemic consisted mainly of cases who felt ill in the absence of exposure to any physical agent. It is suggested that in an atmosphere of severe tension between the two ethnic groups living in Kosovo an increased frequency of respiratory infections may have triggered mass sociogenic illness.
Subject(s)
Disease Outbreaks , Hysteria/epidemiology , Psychophysiologic Disorders/epidemiology , Adolescent , Adult , Albania/ethnology , Female , Humans , Hysteria/ethnology , Hysteria/psychology , Male , Mass Behavior , Psychophysiologic Disorders/ethnology , Psychophysiologic Disorders/psychology , Retrospective Studies , Yugoslavia/epidemiologyABSTRACT
We report on the diagnostic comparative study of the Chinese Classification of Mental Disorders-Second Edition (CCMD-2) and the DSM-III-R in a field trial in China. The Adult Diagnostic Interview Schedule-Second Edition (ADIS-2), a modified diagnostic interview schedule that can generate both CCMD-2 and DSM-III-R diagnoses, was used to test 254 psychiatric patients in China. It was found that the reliability and validity of the CCMD-2 and DSM-III-R are compatible in most diagnostic categories such as schizophrenia, delusional disorder, bipolar disorders, and depressive disorders. The discrepancies between Chinese and American diagnostic systems were found mainly in neurasthenia and hysterical neuroses. Such discrepancies may have resulted from frequent changes of the diagnostic terms in the West, such as the phenomenon of neurasthenia, or from creating a new disorder entity in CCMD-2, such as "Eastern gymnastic exercises-induced mental disorder. "Further cross-cultural studies focusing on these discrepant disorders are urgently needed to understand the cultural influences on diagnosis, as well as to improve the professional classification of mental disorders in different diagnostic systems.