R-loop-derived cytoplasmic RNA-DNA hybrids activate an immune response.

R-loops are RNA-DNA-hybrid-containing nucleic acids with important cellular roles. Deregulation of R-loop dynamics can lead to DNA damage and genome instability1, which has been linked to the action of endonucleases such as XPG2-4. However, the mechanisms and cellular consequences of such processing have remained unclear. Here we identify a new population of RNA-DNA hybrids in the cytoplasm that are R-loop-processing products. When nuclear R-loops were perturbed by depleting the RNA-DNA helicase senataxin (SETX) or the breast cancer gene BRCA1 (refs. 5-7), we observed XPG- and XPF-dependent cytoplasmic hybrid formation. We identify their source as a subset of stable, overlapping nuclear hybrids with a specific nucleotide signature. Cytoplasmic hybrids bind to the pattern recognition receptors cGAS and TLR3 (ref. 8), activating IRF3 and inducing apoptosis. Excised hybrids and an R-loop-induced innate immune response were also observed in SETX-mutated cells from patients with ataxia oculomotor apraxia type 2 (ref. 9) and in BRCA1-mutated cancer cells10. These findings establish RNA-DNA hybrids as immunogenic species that aberrantly accumulate in the cytoplasm after R-loop processing, linking R-loop accumulation to cell death through the innate immune response. Aberrant R-loop processing and subsequent innate immune activation may contribute to many diseases, such as neurodegeneration and cancer.

RNA:DNA hybrids are a novel molecular pattern sensed by TLR9.

The sensing of nucleic acids by receptors of the innate immune system is a key component of antimicrobial immunity. RNA:DNA hybrids, as essential intracellular replication intermediates generated during infection, could therefore represent a class of previously uncharacterised pathogen-associated molecular patterns sensed by pattern recognition receptors. Here we establish that RNA:DNA hybrids containing viral-derived sequences efficiently induce pro-inflammatory cytokine and antiviral type I interferon production in dendritic cells. We demonstrate that MyD88-dependent signalling is essential for this cytokine response and identify TLR9 as a specific sensor of RNA:DNA hybrids. Hybrids therefore represent a novel molecular pattern sensed by the innate immune system and so could play an important role in host response to viruses and the pathogenesis of autoimmune disease.

Modifications in small interfering RNA that separate immunostimulation from RNA interference.

Synthetic small interfering RNA (siRNA) can suppress the expression of endogenous mRNA through RNA interference. It has been reported that siRNA can induce type I IFN production from plasmacytoid dendritic cells, leading to off-target effects. To separate immunostimulation from the desired gene-specific inhibitory activity, we designed RNA strands with chemical modifications at strategic positions of the ribose or nucleobase residues. Substitution of uridine residues by 2'-deoxyuridine or thymidine residues was found to decrease type I IFN production upon in vitro stimulation of human PBMC. Thymidine residues in both strands of a siRNA duplex further decreased immunostimulation. Fortunately, the thymidine residues did not affect gene-silencing activity. In contrast, 2'-O-methyl groups at adenosine and uridine residues reduced both IFN-alpha secretion and gene-silencing activity. Oligoribonucleotides with 2'-O-methyladenosine residues actively inhibited IFN-alpha secretion induced by other immunostimulatory RNAs, an effect not observed for strands with 2'-deoxynucleosides. Furthermore, neither 5-methylcytidine nor 7-deazaguanosine residues in the stimulatory strands affected IFN-alpha secretion, suggesting that recognition does not involve sites in the major groove of duplex regions. The activity data, together with structure prediction and exploratory UV-melting analyses, suggest that immunostimulatory sequences adopt folded structures. The results show that immunostimulation can be suppressed by suitable chemical modifications without losing siRNA potency by introducing seemingly minor structural changes.

The critical DNA flanking sequences of a CpG oligodeoxynucleotide, but not the 6 base CpG motif, can be replaced with RNA without quantitative or qualitative changes in Toll-like receptor 9-mediated activity.

Double- and single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides containing unmethylated cytosine-guanosine (CpG) dinucleotides (CpG-ODN) activate immune cells via TLR9. In this report we synthesized hybrid DNA-RNA molecules (HDR) in order to further explore the structure-immune function relationship of CpG-ODN in TLR9 signaling and the potential immunomodulatory properties of RNA. We demonstrate that replacement of the deoxyadenosine flanking sequences, critical for the immune activating properties of CpG-ODN, with a similar number of adenosines, although not guanosines, cytosines, or uracils, maintains complete immunostimulatory activity of the hybrid oligonucleotide in vitro, whereas a similar RNA replacement of even 1 base of the required unmethylated 6 base DNA motif (purine-purine-CpG-pyrimidine-pyrimidine) results in a complete loss of activity. Regardless of whether the critical flanking sequence was RNA or DNA there was no significant change in the quantitative or qualitative immune-stimulating activity, or TLR-specificity of the resulting sequences, thus underscoring the relatively permissive functional role of the flanking sequence, and the more specific role of the motif in mediating TLR9 signaling. These data further support a potential role for RNA in immunomodulation.

Intra- and intermolecular triplex DNA formation in the murine c-myb proto-oncogene promoter are inhibited by mithramycin.

Mithramycin inhibits transcription by binding to G/C-rich sequences, thereby preventing regulatory protein binding. However, it is also possible that mithramycin inhibits gene expression by preventing intramolecular triplex DNA assembly. We tested this hypothesis using the DNA triplex adopted by the murine c-myb proto-oncogene. The 5'-regulatory region of c-myb contains two polypurine:polypyrimidine tracts with imperfect mirror symmetry, which are highly conserved in the murine and human c-myb sequences. The DNA binding drugs mithramycin and distamycin bind to one of these regions as determined by DNase I protection assay. Gel mobility shift assays, nuclease and chemical hypersensitivity and 2D-gel topological analyses as well as triplex-specific antibody binding studies confirmed the formation of purine*purine:pyrimidine inter- and pyrimidine*purine:pyrimidine intra-molecular triplex structures in this sequence. Mithramycin binding within the triplex target site displaces the major groove-bound oligonucleotide, and also abrogates the supercoil-dependent H-DNA formation, whereas distamycin binding had no such effects. Molecular modeling studies further support these observations. Triplex-specific antibody staining of cells pretreated with mithramycin demonstrates a reversal of chromosomal triplex structures compared to the non-treated and distamycin-treated cells. These observations suggest that DNA minor groove-binding drugs interfere with gene expression by precluding intramolecular triplex formation, as well as by physically preventing regulatory protein binding.

Isolation and characterization of a monoclonal anti-quadruplex DNA antibody from autoimmune "viable motheaten" mice.

A cell line that produces an autoantibody specific for DNA quadruplex structures has been isolated and cloned from a hybridoma library derived from 3-month-old nonimmunized autoimmune, immunodeficient "viable motheaten" mice. This antibody has been tested extensively in vitro and found to bind specifically to DNA quadruplex structures formed by two biologically relevant sequence motifs. Scatchard and nonlinear regression analyses using both one- and two-site models were used to derive association constants for the antibody-DNA binding reactions. In both cases, quadruplexes had higher association constants than triplex and duplex molecules. The anti-quadruplex antibody binds to the quadruplex formed by the promoter-region-derived oligonucleotide d(CGCG4GCG) (Ka = 3.3 x 10(6) M-1), and has enhanced affinity for telomere-derived quadruplexes formed by the oligonucleotides d(TG4) and d(T2G4T2G4T2G4T2G4) (Ka = 5.38 x 10(6) and 1.66 x 10(7) M-1, respectively). The antibody binds both types of quadruplexes but has preferential affinity for the parallel four-stranded structure. In vitro radioimmunofilter binding experiments demonstrated that purified anti-DNA quadruplex antibodies from anti-quadruplex antibody-producing tissue culture supernatants have at least 10-fold higher affinity for quadruplexes than for triplex and duplex DNA structures of similar base composition and length. The antibody binds intramolecular DNA triplexes formed by d(G4T3G4T3C4) and d(C4T3G4T3G4), and the duplex d(CGCGCGCGCG)2 with an affinities of 6. 76 x 10(5), 5.59 x 10(5), and 8.26 x 10(5) M-1, respectively. Competition experiments showed that melted quadruplexes are not effective competitors for antibody binding when compared to native structures, confirming that the quadruplex is bound structure-specifically. To our knowledge, this is the first immunological reagent known to specifically recognize quadruplex structures. Subsequent sequence analysis demonstrates homologies between the antibody complementarity determining regions and sequences from Myb family telomere binding proteins, which are hypothesized to control cell aging via telomeric DNA interactions. The presence of this antibody in the autoimmune repertoire suggests a possible linkage between autoimmunity, telomeric DNA binding proteins, and aging.

Somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes in human neonates.

The antibody response in the young infant is limited in several ways; in particular, responses generally are of low affinity and restricted to IgM. This raises the question whether the affinity maturation process, consisting of somatic mutation of immunoglobulin genes coupled with selection of high-affinity variants, is operative in the neonate. Re-arranged V(H)6 genes were amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) from cord blood and from peripheral blood of infants. Heteroduplex analysis detected mutation in only 2/18 cord blood samples, while mutations were seen from about 10 days of age onwards. Cloning and sequencing of mutated neonatal V(H)6 genes showed that mutated sequences contained relatively few mutations (one to three mutations per sequence) compared with published values of about 10 in adult IgM sequences. Selection was not evident in the majority of neonatal samples. Thus mutation can occur in the human neonate, but is minimal and generally not accompanied by selection. The age at which affinity maturation develops effectively is yet to be defined.

Clonal predominance, but preservation of a polyclonal reservoir, in the normal alpha beta T-cell repertoire.

We recently demonstrated that the peripheral gamma delta T-cell repertoire becomes oligoclonal with increasing age. Although this junctional homogeneity should not severely affect the ability of gamma delta T cells to respond to foreign antigens, we reasoned that a similar oligoclonal repertoire of alpha beta T cells would lead to a profound impairment of the MHC-restricted response. We used heteroduplex analysis in this research to study the clonal complexity of the peripheral alpha beta T-cell repertoire in human subjects and supply evidence for the presence of alpha beta clonal expansions. Clonal predominance in the alpha beta T-cell repertoire of normal subjects was not simply related to age, since the PBL of young donors also showed clonal expansions and did not always correlate with a numeric increase in the corresponding V beta family. However, the type of alpha beta expansion appears to be strikingly different from the gamma delta expansions. In the case of alpha beta T cells, even in the presence of clonal dominance, evidence for a residual polyclonal background was found in all the donors tested, irrespective of age. The observation that true oligoclonality is exceptionally rare among alpha beta T lymphocytes could mean that maintenance of a highly diversified reservoir of TCR is primary for these cells throughout life.

Anti-cruciform monoclonal antibody and cruciform DNA interaction.

Cruciform DNA structure, as a structural feature, has been associated with regulation of transcription, recombination and replication. Previously used to successfully modify DNA replication and affinity-purify origins and autonomously replicating sequences. Using enzyme protection assays, their binding activity has been localized to the base (elbow) of the cruciform stem. We report here the hydroxyl radical footprinting of 2D3 (kappa IgG1) anti-cruciform monoclonal antibody on a stable cruciform structure created by heteroduplexing fragments from two plasmids, identical except for two centrally located palindromes of different sequence. The footprinting was performed at near-physiological salt concentrations, conditions favouring the stacked X-structure of the cruciform. Our data show that binding by the antibody occurs at the four-way junction (elbows) of the stable cruciform. The binding of the antibody seems also to cause associated structural distortions in the heteroduplex, which generally result in greater sensitivity to hydroxyl radicals at the tips of the cruciforms. The data are consistent to hydroxyl radicals at the tips of the cruciforms. The data are consistent with the binding of a single antibody to an antigen-combining site. The results of this study compare favourably with the hydroxyl radical footprinting studies reported recently for a human cruciform binding protein (CBP), which binds at the base of the stem-loop structure and causes similar distortions of the stable cruciform structure. These studies indicate that the four-way junction of the cruciform possesses certain unique structural qualities that are antigenic; the association of this structural determinant with DNA replication and the existence of a novel cellular protein, CBP, of similar binding specificity as the antibody specificity support a role for cruciforms as important regulatory recognition signals in replication.

Monoclonal antibodies to cruciform DNA structures.

Two monoclonal antibodies, 2D3 and 4B4, have been raised against a cruciform structure in a heteroduplex DNA molecule. Antibody binding to DNA fragments was determined by a radioimmunoassay in which DNA--antibody complexes were separated from unbound DNA by acrylamide gel electrophoresis. These antibodies seem to recognize conformational determinants specific to cruciform structures. 2D3 and 4B4 antibodies do not bind to linear double-stranded homoduplex DNA fragments, linear single-stranded DNA or single-stranded simian virus 40 DNA containing a stem--loop structure, but do bind to the original cruciform and to a different cruciform with one shortened arm. 2D3 also bound to a T-shaped double-stranded DNA molecule, while 4B4 binding to this structure was weak. The monoclonal antibodies 2D3 and 4B4 were found to be immunoglobulin G1 and immunoglobulin M, respectively.