Exploration of potential immune mechanisms in cervical dystonia.

BACKGROUND: Although there are many possible causes for cervical dystonia (CD), a specific etiology cannot be identified in most cases. Prior studies have suggested a relationship between autoimmune disease and some cases of CD, pointing to possible immunological mechanisms. OBJECTIVE: The goal was to explore the potential role of multiple different immunological mechanisms in CD. METHODS: First, a broad screening test compared neuronal antibodies in controls and CD. Second, unbiased blood plasma proteomics provided a broad screen for potential biologic differences between controls and CD. Third, a multiplex immunoassay compared 37 markers associated with immunological processes in controls and CD. Fourth, relative immune cell frequencies were investigated in blood samples of controls and CD. Finally, sequencing studies investigated the association of HLA DQB1 and DRB1 alleles in controls versus CD. RESULTS: Screens for anti-neuronal antibodies did not reveal any obvious abnormalities. Plasma proteomics pointed towards certain abnormalities of immune mechanisms, and the multiplex assay pointed more specifically towards abnormalities in T lymphocytes. Abnormal immune cell frequencies were identified for some CD cases, and these cases clustered together as a potential subgroup. Studies of HLA alleles indicated a possible association between CD and DRB1*15:03, which is reported to mediate the penetrance of autoimmune disorders. CONCLUSIONS: Altogether, the association of CD with multiple different blood-based immune measures point to abnormalities in cell-mediated immunity that may play a pathogenic role for a subgroup of individuals with CD.

Clinical Implications of Difference in Antigenicity of Different Botulinum Neurotoxin Type A Preparations: Clinical Take-Home Messages from Our Research Pool and Literature.

The three different botulinum toxin type A (BoNT/A) preparations being licensed in Europe and the U.S. differ in protein content, which seems to be a major factor influencing the antigenicity of BoNT/A. In the present study, several arguments out of our research pool were collected to demonstrate that the clinical response and antigenicity were different for the three BoNT/A preparations: some results of (1) a cross-sectional study on clinical outcome and antibody formation of 212 patients with cervical dystonia (CD) being treated between 2 and 22 years; 2) another cross-sectional study on the clinical aspects and neutralizing antibody (NAB) induction of 63 patients having developed partial secondary treatment under abobotulinum (aboBoNT/A) onabotulinumtoxin (onaBoNT/A) who were switched to incobotulinumtoxin (incoBoNT/A) in comparison to 32 patients being exclusively treated with incoBoNT/A. These results imply that (1) the presence of NAB cannot be concluded from the course of treatment, that (2) an increase in the dose and variability of outcome with treatment duration indicates the ongoing induction of NABs over time, that (3) the higher protein load of BoNT/A goes along with a higher incidence and prevalence of NAB induction and that (4) the best response to a BoNT/A is also dependent on the protein load of the preparation.

The Regions on the Light Chain of Botulinum Neurotoxin Type A Recognized by T Cells from Toxin-Treated Cervical Dystonia Patients. The Complete Human T-Cell Recognition Map of the Toxin Molecule.

We have recently mapped the in vitro proliferative responses of T cells from botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNT/A)-treated cervical dystonia (CD) patients with overlapping peptides encompassing BoNT/A heavy chain (residues 449-1296). In the present study, we determined the recognition profiles, by peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from the same set of patients, of BoNT/A light (L) chain (residues 1-453) by using 32 synthetic overlapping peptides that encompassed the entire L chain. Profiles of the T-cell responses (expressed in stimulation index, SI; Z score based on transformed SI) to the peptides varied among the patients. Samples from 14 patients treated solely with BoNT/A recognized 3-13 (average 7.2) peptides/sample at Z > 3.0 level. Two peptide regions representing residues 113-131 and 225-243 were recognized by around 40% of these patients. Regarding treatment parameters, treatment history with current BOTOX® only group produced significantly lower average T-cell responses to the 32 L-chain peptides compared to treatments with mix of type A including original and current BOTOX®. Influence of other treatment parameters on T-cell recognition of the L-chain peptides was also observed. Results of the submolecular T-cell recognition of the L chain are compared to those of the H chain and the T-cell recognition profile of the entire BoNT/A molecule is discussed. Abbreviations used: BoNT/A, botulinum neurotoxin type A; BoNT/Ai, inactivated BoNT/A; BoNT/B, botulinum neurotoxin type B; CD, cervical dystonia; L chain, the light chain (residues 1-448) of BoNT/A; LNC, lymph node cells; H chain, the heavy chain (residues 449-1296) of BoNT/A; HC, C-terminal domain (residues 855-1296) of H chain; HN, N-terminal domain (residues 449-859) of H chain; MPA, mouse protection assay; SI, stimulation index (SI = cpm of 3H-thymidine incorporated by antigen-stimulated T cells/cpm incorporated by unstimulated cells); TeNT, tetanus neurotoxin; TeNTi, inactivated TeNT.

Submolecular recognition regions of the HN domain of the heavy chain of botulinum neurotoxin type A by T cells from toxin-treated cervical dystonia patients.

We have recently reported the submolecular T-cell recognition profile of the C-terminal half (HC, residues 855-1296) of the heavy (H) chain of botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNT/A) with peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from 25 BoNT-treated cervical dystonia (CD) patients. In the current study, we describe the mapping of the T-cell responses of the patients to the N-terminal half (HN, residues 449-859) of the heavy chain by using 29 synthetic overlapping peptides encompassing the entire HN domain of BoNT/A. The profiles of the T-cell responses to the peptides varied among the patients. Samples from 14 patients treated solely with BoNT/A recognized 1-9 (average 3.7) peptides/sample at Z>3.0 level. Three peptide regions representing residues 631-649, 659-677 and 743-761 were frequently recognized by 29-64% of the patients. In patients with positive anti-BoNT/A antibody responses the overall positive T cell responses to the HN peptides were significantly increased compared to antibody-negative patients. Influence of treatment parameters on the T-cell recognition of the HN peptides was also observed. The results were compared with those of previously identified HC region.

Submolecular recognition of the C-terminal domain of the heavy chain of botulinum neurotoxin type A by T cells from toxin-treated cervical dystonia patients.

We determined the T-cell proliferative responses of the peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from 25 botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT)-treated patients to 31 overlapping synthetic peptides encompassing the C-terminal half (residues 855-1296) of BoNT/A heavy chain. Responses of PBL to HC peptides varied among patients. Samples from 14 patients treated solely with BoNT/A recognized 2-13 (average 6.4) peptides/sample at Z>3.0 level. Six peptide regions representing residues 855-873, 1023-1041, 1051-1069, 1093-1111, 1135-1153 and 1247-1265 were frequently recognized by 36-57% of these PBLs. Influence of treatment parameters on T-cell recognition of the peptides was also investigated.

Very early reduction in efficacy of botulinum toxin therapy for cervical dystonia in patients with subsequent secondary treatment failure: a retrospective analysis.

The objective of this study was to estimate the probability of development of partial secondary treatment failure (PSTF) in patients with cervical dystonia (CD) who had been treated over up to 9 years with repetitive intramuscular injections of botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNT/A). The temporal course of treatment response in patients in whom PSTF was detected retrospectively was compared to patients with a normal clinical response. For this purpose, charts of all CD patients treated in our outpatient clinic between 1988 and 2001 were retrospectively analyzed. Extracted data included time of all injections, dose per visit, disease severity measured by TSUI scores, and time of determination of neutralizing antibodies. Final data analysis using a special formal definition of PSTF was based on charts of 568 patients having exclusively been treated with abobotulinumtoxinA. PSTF onset was observed in our CD cohort during the entire treatment period analyzed, with no clustering at any time point. Probability to develop PSTF was 14.5 % in 9 years. Thus, mean PSTF incidence was 1.6 % per year. The mean TSUI score of patients with retrospectively defined PSTF (n = 33) became already significantly worse after the second injection when compared with the group without PSTF (n = 535). Our data indicate that clinical response in patients developing PSTF later on differs from that of patients without PSTF already very early in the course of botulinum neurotoxin type A treatment, and that PSTF remains undetected at this early stage. Reduced response may therefore be present in a number of CD patients who think they still respond normally to continuous BoNT/A treatment.

Efficacy, tolerability, and immunogenicity of onabotulinumtoxina in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial for cervical dystonia.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the efficacy, tolerability, and neutralizing antibodies in the treatment of cervical dystonia with onabotulinumtoxinA (BOTOX). METHODS: Subjects received onabotulinumtoxinA (containing original bulk toxin) treatment in a 10-week open-label period (period 1). Eligible subjects who completed this period were randomized to onabotulinumtoxinA or placebo in a 10-week double-blind period (period 2). The primary outcome measures were the Cervical Dystonia Severity Scale and the physician Global Assessment Scale at week 6 in period 2. Serum samples for immunogenicity tests were taken at baseline and study exit. The potential impact of preexisting neutralizing antibodies (nAbs) was examined across subgroups for period 1 and by analysis of covariance for period 2. RESULTS: Of 214 subjects enrolled in period 1, 170 enrolled in period 2 and received placebo (n = 82) or onabotulinumtoxinA (n = 88). In period 1, subjects with preexisting nAbs responded similarly to those without preexisting nAbs. In period 2, onabotulinumtoxinA produced significantly greater improvements than placebo on the Cervical Dystonia Severity Scale (-1.81 vs -0.31 points; P = 0.012) and physician Global Assessment Scale (61.7% vs. 41.6% improved; P = 0.022) at the primary time point week 6, using baseline severity and neutralizing antibody (nAb) status at study entry as covariates. Two subjects seroconverted from nAb negative at baseline to nAb positive at study exit but remained responsive to onabotulinumtoxinA during both the open and blinded treatment periods. Rhinitis and treatment-related dysphagia were reported significantly more frequently with onabotulinumtoxinA than placebo. CONCLUSION: OnabotulinumtoxinA was well tolerated and more effective than placebo for the treatment of cervical dystonia. Subject nAb status at baseline was not a clear predictor of response to onabotulinumtoxinA.

Immunogenicity and long-term efficacy of botulinum toxin type B in the treatment of cervical dystonia: report of 4 prospective, multicenter trials.

OBJECTIVE: Therapeutic botulinum toxins are antigenic proteins with the potential to produce antibodies (Abs). It is, however, unclear whether Abs to Myobloc® (rimabotulinumtoxinB, botulinum toxin type B, BoNT-B) impact the efficacy and safety of BoNT-B treatment of cervical dystonia (CD). The objective was to determine if Abs to BoNT-B impact the efficacy or safety of long-term BoNT-B treatment of CD. METHODS: Four separate prospective clinical trials, with a combined total of 1134 subjects evaluable for immunogenicity over total treatment durations of up to 6+ years, were conducted studying the efficacy, safety, and immunogenicity of BoNT-B treatment of CD. Botulinum toxin type B injections were administered approximately every 3 months. Efficacy was assessed using the Toronto Western Spasmodic Torticollis Rating Scale-Total Score, the Subject Global Assessment, or the Treatment Assessment Scale. The presence of Abs to BoNT-B was assessed using the mouse neutralizing antibody (MNA) assay. Cross-sectional and longitudinal statistical analyses were performed to compare efficacy by MNA status at each time point and over time in Ab-positive individuals before and after seroconversion. Safety was assessed by summarizing adverse events by Ab status. RESULTS: Long-term efficacy was observed with multiple treatments of BoNT-B. Across all 4 studies, there was no correlation between MNA status and rates of clinical response, study withdrawal, or safety profile. CONCLUSIONS: Botulinum toxin type B is effective and safe in the repeat, long-term treatment of CD. The presence of Abs to BoNT-B as detected by the MNA assay does not have any meaningful clinical impact or correlation.

Immunoresistance in cervical dystonia patients after treatment with abobotulinumtoxinA.

Formation of antibodies against botulinum toxin type A has been observed following treatment of Cervical Dystonia (CD). We present the immunological findings from two 12-week Phase III prospective, randomized, double-blind, single-dose, placebo-controlled studies (Study 1, n = 116; Study 2, n = 136). Patients in both studies were administered abobotulinumtoxinA 500U or placebo intramuscularly at baseline. Patients could receive up to three or four additional treatments (250-1000U) in an open-label follow-up period. Blood samples were collected at baseline and during treatment to test for antibodies to abobotulinumtoxinA using a radioimmunoprecipitation assay (Study 2 only) and a mouse protection assay. Loss of response was predefined using the Toronto Western Spasmodic Torticollis Rating Scale (TWSTRS) total score at 4 weeks following injection. No subjects in Study 1 and one individual in Study 2 developed neutralizing antibodies (nABs) during the double-blind treatment phase; the individual who developed immunoresistance had received botulinum toxin type A treatment prior to the study and did not respond to treatment. Two subjects demonstrated a change in nAB status during open-label treatment and overall responsiveness was maintained in these patients. In conclusion, the development of immunoresistance was rare and, in the presence of circulating nABs, patients may still gain benefit from intramuscular abobotulinumtoxinA treatment.

Molecular immune recognition of botulinum neurotoxin B. The light chain regions that bind human blocking antibodies from toxin-treated cervical dystonia patients. Antigenic structure of the entire BoNT/B molecule.

We recently mapped the regions on the heavy (H) chain of botulinum neurotoxin, type B (BoNT/B) recognized by blocking antibodies (Abs) from cervical dystonia (CD) patients who develop immunoresistance during toxin treatment. Since blocking could also be effected by Abs directed against regions on the light (L) chain, we have mapped here the L chain, using the same 30 CD antisera. We synthesized, purified and characterized 32 19-residue L chain peptides that overlapped successively by 5 residues (peptide L32 overlapped with peptide N1 of the H chain by 12 residues). In a given patient, Abs against the L chain seemed less intense than those against H chain. Most sera recognized a limited set of L chain peptides. The levels of Abs against a given region varied with the patient, consistent with immune responses to each epitope being under separate MHC control. The peptides most frequently recognized were: L13, by 30 of 30 antisera (100%); L22, by 23 of 30 (76.67%); L19, by 15 of 30 (50.00%); L26, by 11 of 30 (36.70%); and L14, by 12 of 30 (40.00%). The activity of L14 probably derives from its overlap with L13. The levels of Ab binding decreased in the following order: L13 (residues 169-187), L22 (295-313), L19 (253-271), and L26 (351-369). Peptides L12 (155-173), L18 (239-257), L15 (197-215), L1 (1-19) and L23 (309-327) exhibited very low Ab binding. The remaining peptides had little or no Ab-binding activity. The antigenic regions are analyzed in terms of their three-dimensional locations and the enzyme active site. With the previous localization of the antigenic regions on the BoNT/B H chain, the human Ab recognition of the entire BoNT/B molecule is presented and compared to the recognition of BoNT/A by human blocking Abs.

Human T-cell responses to botulinum neurotoxin. Responses in vitro of lymphocytes from patients with cervical dystonia and/or other movement disorders treated with BoNT/A or BoNT/B.

We have previously reported that botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNT/A)-specific T-cell responses occur in a majority of patients treated with botulinum neurotoxins (BoNT). In this study, we first determined if T-cell responses against BoNT/A and tetanus toxin (TeNT) differ between cervical dystonia (CD) patients and other movement disorder cases. Secondly, we have examined in CD cases the treatment parameters that may have an effect on the T-cell responses against BoNT/A. We found that T-cell responses to BoNT/A were significantly higher in patients with CD than in those with other movement disorders. An increase in TeNT T-cell response in CD was observed when compared to un-treated controls. CD patients who were injected with BoNT/B mounted higher responses to BoNT/A than patients treated with BoNT/A only. Frequent injections (more than 2.1/year) were associated with a significantly higher T-cell response to BoNT/A in CD. T cell responses to BoNT/A did not differ between CD patients who had clinically responsive and non-responsive status at the time of enrollment.

Reduction of antibody response against botulinum neurotoxin A by synthetic monomethoxypolyethylene glycol-peptide conjugates.

Recently, we determined the molecular locations on BoNT/A of the antigenic regions recognized by blocking Abs of cervical dystonia patients immunoresistant to BoNT/A treatment. In the present work we tested the possibility of reducing the levels of the Ab response against immunodominant antigenic sites on the heavy chain of BoNT/A in order to diminish immunoresistance caused by blocking Abs. Four antigenic regions on BoNT/A represented by peptides N8 (residues 547-565), N25 (785-803), C15 (1051-1069) and C31 (1275-1296) were tested for suppressing Ab responses against the correlate regions. The conjugates were synthesized with monomethoxypolyethylene glycol (mPEG) attached to the peptide N-termini. Tolerization with a given mPEG-peptide reduced the Ab levels against the correlate region and the antisera became less protective than antisera of untolerized controls that were immunized only with inactive BoNT/A. On days 31 and 52 in the immunization course mPEG-N8 was most effective and the antisera of tolerized mice were weaker and less protective relative to controls. Other mPEG-peptides were also suppressed the Ab responses to various extents. Bleeds up to 5 months showed that tolerization can be made to persist for the entire period. The results indicated that the tolerization procedure might be potentially useful for clinical applications to immunoresistant patients.

Regions of botulinum neurotoxin A light chain recognized by human anti-toxin antibodies from cervical dystonia patients immunoresistant to toxin treatment. The antigenic structure of the active toxin recognized by human antibodies.

This work was aimed at determining the BoNT/A L-chain antigenic regions recognized by blocking antibodies in human antisera from cervical dystonia patients who had become immunoresistant to BoNT/A treatment. Antisera from 28 immunoresistant patients were analyzed for binding to each of 32 overlapping synthetic peptides that spanned the entire L-chain. A mixture of the antisera showed that antibodies bound to three peptides, L11 (residues 141-159), L14 (183-201) and L18 (239-257). When mapped separately, the antibodies were bound only by a limited set of peptides. No peptide bound antibodies from all the patients and amounts of antibodies bound to a given peptide varied with the patient. Peptides L11, L14 and L18 were recognized predominantly. A small but significant number of patients had antibodies to peptides L27 (365-383) and L29 (379-397). Other peptides were recognized at very low and perhaps insignificant antibody levels by a minority (15% or less) of patients or had no detectable antibody with any of the sera. In the 3-dimensional structure, antibody-binding regions L11, L14 and L18 of the L-chain occupy surface areas and did not correlate with electrostatic potential, hydrophilicity/hydrophobicity, or temperature factor. These three antigenic regions reside in close proximity to the belt of the heavy chain. The regions L11 and L18 are accessible in both the free light chain and the holotoxin forms, while L14 appears to be less accessible in the holotoxin. Antibodies against these regions could prevent delivery of the L-chain into the neurons by inhibition of the translocation.

Neutralizing antibodies and secondary therapy failure after treatment with botulinum toxin type A: much ado about nothing?

OBJECTIVES: As the indications and duration of treatment of botulinum toxin type A (BoNT-A) increase, so do reports of patients who fail therapy after initially responding well. Although a loss of efficacy is commonly thought to be associated with neutralizing antibodies (NAbs), this relationship is not strongly correlated, and other factors may play a significant role. To explore this issue, we evaluated levels of NAbs in a large selected cohort of secondary nonresponders to BoNT-A using the highly sensitive mouse phrenic nerve-hemidiaphragm assay. METHODS: Serum samples from 503 patients treated with BoNT-A who had a variety of diagnoses were tested for the presence of NAbs. RESULTS: Fewer than half of the patients (n = 224, 44.5%) were found to be NAb-positive, indicating that in more than half of the secondary nonresponders, lack of efficacy is not due to NAb formation. The proportion of secondary nonresponders with NAbs was greater for higher dose indications (focal spasticity and spasmodic torticollis) than for lower dose indications (blepharospasm and hemifacial spasm) and increased with shorter injection intervals. Neutralizing antibody development was independent of the commercial preparation used. CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that although NAb formation does play a role in secondary treatment failure with BoNT-A, this is not the cause in all patients, and the influence of other factors needs to be investigated. Gaining a better understanding of the underlying mechanisms for secondary treatment failure may help in the prediction, diagnosis, management, and prevention of this problem.

Immune recognition of BoNTs A and B: how anti-toxin antibodies that bind to the heavy chain obstruct toxin action.

We localized the BoNT regions that bind blocking Abs from 28 BoNT/A- and 30 BoNT/B-treated dystonia patients who became unresponsive to, and whose sera protected mice against LD100 of, the correlate BoNT. We analyzed Ab binding to BoNT/A- and BoNT/B-peptide panels, each of which consisted of 60, 19-residue peptides that overlapped consecutively by 5 residues and covered the entire H chain of the correlate toxin. Abs bound to a limited set of peptides but levels varied with patient, consistent with responses to each epitope being under separate MHC control. BoNT/B-treated patients had higher anti-toxin Ab levels and bound more H regions (at least 11) than BoNT/A-treated patients (5 regions). The epitopes were on surface areas that did not correlate with surface electrostatic potential, hydrophilicity, hydrophobicity, or temperature factor. Some epitopes within the two toxins display substantial homology and occupy equivalent 3-D locations, occasionally showing a small shift relative to one another, consistent with recognition adjustments accommodating structural differences between the two BoNTs. Blocking Abs bound to BoNT/A at sites that coincided or overlapped with those involved in synaptosome-binding, thus preventing its binding and blocking its entry into the neuron. On BoNT/B, Ab-binding regions overlapped with the sites that bind to mouse and rat synaptotagmin II or to ganglioside, thereby explaining Ab blocking of BoNT/B action.

Molecular recognition of botulinum neurotoxin B heavy chain by human antibodies from cervical dystonia patients that develop immunoresistance to toxin treatment.

We determined the entire profile of the continuous antigenic regions recognized by blocking antibodies (Abs) in sera from 30BoNT/B-treated cervical dystonia (CD) patients who developed unresponsiveness to treatment. The sera protected mice against a lethal dose of BoNT/B. We analyzed Ab binding to a panel of 60 synthetic 19-residue peptides (peptide C31 was 24 residues) that overlapped consecutively by 5 residues and encompassed the entire BoNT/B heavy (H) chain (residues 442-1291). Most Abs recognized a limited set of peptides but the pattern and Ab levels bound varied with the patient, consistent with genetic control of immune responses and with responses to each epitope being separately controlled. Abs were bound by peptides (in decreasing order): C1 (residues 848-866), C10 (974-992), C16 (1058-1076), C14 (1030-1048), N15 (638-656), N21/N22 (722-740/736-754), N24/N25 (764-782/778-796) and N29 (834-852). Peptides N3/N4 (470-488/484-502), N27 (806-824), C2 (862-880), C4 (890-908), C6/C7 (918-936/932-950), C17 (1072-1090), C24 (1170-1188), C29 (1240-1258) and C31 (1268-1291) exhibited low Ab binding. The remaining peptides bound little or no Abs. Of the 30 antisera, 28 (93.3%) had Abs that bound to peptides C1, C10, C14 or C16, and 27 (90.0%) bound to peptide N22. No peptide was recognized by all the antisera, but peptide combinations N24+C1, N22+N24+C1, N24+C1+C10, C10+C14+C16, N22+N24+C1+C10, C1+C10+C14+C16 or N22+N24+C1+C10+C14 bound blocking Abs in 30 (100%) antisera. BoNT/B-treated CD patients had higher Ab levels and bound to more epitopes (at least 11) than did BoNT/A-treated patients (5 regions). The regions recognized by anti-BoNT/B Abs occupied surface areas that displayed no correlation to surface electrostatic potential, hydrophilicity, hydrophobicity, or temperature factor. These regions afford candidates for epitope-specific manipulation of anti-toxin immune responses.

Long-term treatment with botulinum toxin type A in cervical dystonia has low immunogenicity by mouse protection assay.

To evaluate the immunogenicity of botulinum toxin type A (BoNTA; BOTOX) in cervical dystonia (CD). Subjects diagnosed with CD for > or =1 year and previously naïve to BoNTs were treated with BoNTA in a prospective, open-label, multicenter study. Serum samples were analyzed for BoNTA neutralizing antibodies using the Mouse Protection Assay (MPA). Clinical resistance was assessed with a test injection of 20 U BoNTA placed unilaterally into the frontalis (Frontalis Antibody Test; FTAT) or corrugator muscle (Unilateral Brow Injection; UBI). Efficacy was assessed and adverse events were recorded. Of 326 subjects enrolled, 251 (77%) completed the study. Subjects received a median of 9 BoNTA treatments (mean dose per session ranged from 148.4 to 213.0 U over a mean of 2.5 years [range: 3.2 months-4.2 years]). Only 4 of 326 subjects (1.2%) tested positive for antibodies in the MPA; three of these subjects stopped responding clinically to BoNTA (of whom one also showed clinical resistance in the FTAT) and one continued to respond. Consistent improvements in the signs/symptoms of CD were noted. The most frequent treatment-related adverse events were mild to moderate weakness, dysphagia, neck pain, and injection-site pain. The current formulation of BoNTA rarely causes neutralizing antibody formation in CD subjects treated < or =4 years.

Mapping of the regions on the heavy chain of botulinum neurotoxin A (BoNT/A) recognized by antibodies of cervical dystonia patients with immunoresistance to BoNT/A.

The purpose of this work was to map the entire recognition profile of the H chain of botulinum neurotoxin A (BoNT/A) by Abs in sera that have protective anti-BoNT/A Abs by the mouse protection assay (MPA) from cervical dystonia (CD) patients who had been treated with botulinum neurotoxin, serotype A (BOTOX). In previous studies we found that human anti-tetanus neurotoxin (TeNT) Abs cross-react with BoNT/A and BoNT/B. In the present work we devised an assay procedure for measuring specific anti-BoNT/A Abs in human sera by absorbing out or inhibiting the anti-TeNT Abs with TeNT before analyzing the sera for the anti-BoNT/A Abs. The sera were obtained from 28 CD patients who had become unresponsive to treatment with BoNT/A and the sera were found to protect mice against a lethal dose of BoNT/A. For localization of the Ab-binding regions on the H chain we employed a set of sixty, 19-residue synthetic peptides (except for peptide C31 which was 22 residues) that encompassed the entire H chain sequence 449-1296 and overlapped consecutively by five residues. The pattern of Ab recognition varied from patient to patient, but a very limited set of peptides were recognized by most of the patients. These were, in decreasing amounts of Ab binding, peptide N25 (H chain residues 785-803), C9/C10 (967-985/981-999), C31 (1275-1296), C15 (1051-1069), C20 (1121-1139), N16 (659-677), N22 (743-761), and N4 (491-509). But not every serum recognized all these peptides. The finding that the binding profile was not the same for all the patients is consistent with previous observations that immune responses to protein antigens are under genetic control and that the response to each epitope within a protein is under separate genetic control. Except for the region within C9/C10, the other regions either coincided (N16 and C31), or overlapped (N4, N22, N25, C15 and C20), with the recently mapped synaptosomes (snps)-binding regions on the H chain. The molecular and clinical implications of these findings are discussed.

Molecular bases of protective immune responses against botulinum neurotoxin A--how antitoxin antibodies block its action.

In studies from this laboratory, we localized the regions on the H chain of botulinum neurotoxin A (BoNT/A) that are recognized by anti-BoNT/A antibodies (Abs) and block the activity of the toxin in vivo. These Abs were obtained from cervical dystonia patients who had been treated with BoNT/A and had become unresponsive to the treatment, as well as blocking Abs raised in mouse, horse, and chicken. We also localized the regions involved in BoNT/A binding to mouse brain synaptosomes (snp). Comparison of spatial proximities in the three-dimensional structure of the Ab-binding regions and the snp binding showed that except for one, the Ab-binding regions either coincide or overlap with the snp regions. It should be folly expected that protective Abs when bound to the toxin at sites that coincide or overlap with snp binding would prevent the toxin from binding to nerve synapse and therefore block toxin entry into the neuron. Thus, analysis of the locations of the Ab-binding and the snp-binding regions provides a molecular rationale for the ability of protecting Abs to block BoNT/A action in vivo.

Clinico-immunologic aspects of botulinum toxin type B treatment of cervical dystonia.

In this multicenter study of 100 patients with cervical dystonia, we examined the immunogenicity of botulinum toxin type B (BTX-B) and correlated the clinical response with the presence of blocking antibodies (Abs) using a novel mouse protection assay. One-third of the patients who were negative for BTX-B Abs at baseline became positive for BTX-B Abs at last visit. Thus, the high antigenicity of BTX-B limits its long-term efficacy.