Laparoscopic versus open ventral hernia repair in the elderly: a propensity score-matched analysis.

BACKGROUND: Ventral hernia repair is common in the expanding aging population, but remains challenging due to their frequent comorbidities. The purpose of this study is to compare the surgical outcomes of open vs. laparoscopic ventral hernia repair in elderly patients. METHODS: Patients ≥ 65 years of age that underwent elective open or laparoscopic ventral hernia repair were identified from the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Project (NSQIP) database. To reduce potential selection bias, propensity scores were created for the likelihood of undergoing laparoscopic surgery based on patients' demographics and comorbidities. Patients were matched based on the logit of the propensity scores. Thirty-day surgical outcomes were compared after matching using Chi-square test for categorical variables and the Wilcoxon Rank-Sum test for continuous variables. RESULTS: 35,079 (71.1%) and 14,270 (28.9%) patients underwent open and laparoscopic ventral hernia repairs, respectively. Laparoscopic surgery was associated with a lower overall morbidity (5.9% vs. 9.1%; p < 0.001) compared to open repair. The incidence of surgical site infections (1.1% vs. 3.5%; p < 0.001), post-operative infections (2.7% vs. 3.6%; p < 0.001), and reoperation (1.7% vs. 2.1%; p = 0.009) were all lower after laparoscopic repair. All other major surgical outcomes were either better with laparoscopy or comparable between both treatment groups except for operative time. CONCLUSION: Although open surgery remains the most prevalent in the elderly population, the results of this study suggest that laparoscopic surgery is safe and associated with a lower risk of overall morbidity, surgical site infections, and reoperation.

The genetics of urinary tract malformations.

In this discussion I have excluded consideration of the genetics of purely renal malformations, such as polycystic kidneys, and of functional disorders of the kidney. Systematic family studies are available for renal agenesis, duplication of the ureters, vesico-ureteric reflux (each probably due to maldevelopment of the ureteric bud), bladder exstrophy and hypospadias as isolated malformations. Renal agenesis has a birth frequency of about 1.2 in 10 000 and the proportion affected of sibs is about 3 per cent. Duplication of the ureter has a birth frequency of about 1 per cent and the proportion affected of sibs and parents of probands is about 12 per cent. Vesico-ureteral reflux also has a prevalence in early childhood of about 1 per cent and the proportion of sibs affected is about 10 per cent. Bladder exstrophy has a birth frequency of about 1 in 20 000 and perhaps about 1 per cent of sibs are affected. Hypospadias has a birth frequency in boys of about 1 in 300 and the proportion affected of brothers is about 10 per cent. Further family studies are needed of these malformations when they occur in isolation. Either the multifactorial threshold model or dominant inheritance with reduced penetrance and varied expressivity would fit the data available.

Effect of genetic counselling on the prevalence of Huntington's chorea.

The relative fertility of sons and daughters of patients with Huntington's chorea was found to be a little under 0.5 if they had been told of their risk of transmitting the disease before they had started their families. The effect was much the same in those who had attended the genetic clinic at The Hospital for Sick Children on a single occasion and those who had been told of their risk directly, or indirectly through the patient's spouse or family doctor, by the neurologist who was looking after their affected parent at the National Hospital for Nervous Diseases. If all offspring of patients were informed of their risk the effect on the prevalence of the disorder would be substantial, especially if the mutation rate is low and the reproductive fitness of patients in the past has been close to 1.0. Men and women at risk of developing the disease should not be seen on just one occasion, however: they need continued support by being seen regularly at a special neurological genetic clinic.

A family study of isolated cleft palate.

A family study was based on 245 boy and 329 girl patients treated surgically for non-syndromic cleft palate between 1920 and 1929; 86 and 81 respectively were traced and had had children. These 167 were the probands for the family study and were interviewed in their homes. None was born to a consanguineous marriage. Altogether they had had 384 children of whom 11 had cleft palate (2.9 +/- 0.9%). They had 398 sibs of whom five had cleft palate, 117 grandchildren of whom one was affected, and 517 nephews and nieces of whom one was affected. This is the largest series yet available on which to base an estimate of the risks to children of patients with non-syndromic cleft palate. The risk is probably increased where a parent or sib of the proband is affected and increased to a lesser degree where a second or third degree relative is affected. The family patterns in these and other studies suggest that the aetiology of cleft palate is heterogeneous, with some families showing modified dominant inheritance. This is in contrast to cleft lip (+/- cleft palate) where the data are consistent with a multifactorial threshold model.

A three generation family study of cleft lip with or without cleft palate.

A family study of cleft lip, with or without cleft palate, was based on those treated by operation at The Hospital for Sick Children, London, between 1920 and 1939 in order to give information on the proportion affected of children and grandchildren. The probands were those who had survived, were successfully traced, and found to have had at least one child. Care was taken to exclude patients who were traced through a child, whether normal or affected, and not through the usual tracing procedure. Patients with recognised syndromes were also excluded. Because the series was based on patients who had survived and reproduced it was biased in favour of those with milder degrees of the malformation, and against those with any severe associated malformation. The proportion affected of children of probands was 3.15% (+/- 0.56), of sibs 2.79% (+/- 0.52), and of parents 1.18% (+/- 0.37), respectively. The lower proportion of parents affected is attributed to reduced reproductive fitness of patients born two generations ago. The proportion affected of nephews and nieces, aunts and uncles, and grandchildren was 0.47% (+/- 0.18), 0.59% (+/- 0.13), and 0.8% (+/- 0.6) respectively. The proportion affected of first cousins was 0.27% (+/- 0.08). The birth frequency of cleft lip (+/- cleft palate) is estimated to be about 0.1% in England. There were two first cousin and one second cousin marriages among the marriages of the parents. There was no increase of cleft palate among the relatives of the probands. The proportion of sibs affected increased with increasing severity of the malformation in the proband, where the proband was female, and where the proband had an affected parent or already had one affected sib. It was not, however, increased where a more remote relative was affected. The proportion of children affected was not increased when the proband had an affected parent or sib, but few families provided information. The most economical hypothesis to explain the findings is the multifactorial threshold model. The birth frequency of the malformation and the family patterns found make it improbable that one single mutant gene makes a major contribution to the liability to develop the condition.

A family study of craniosynostosis, with probable recognition of a distinct syndrome.

A family study was based on 184 consecutive patients who had undergone surgery for craniosynostosis at The Hospital for Sick Children, London, between 1953 and 1976. Of these, 127 were traced and visited and are the probands for this study. Crouzon syndrome was recognised in 16, Apert in 11, Saethre-Chotzen in nine, and Pfeiffer in two. In addition, two probands had Saethre-Chotzen-like facies and bilaterally broad big toes owing to partial or complete duplication of the distal phalanx. This syndrome is distinct from Pfeiffer syndrome, in which the facies more closely resembles that in Crouzon syndrome and in which it is the proximal phalanx of the big toe (and often of the thumb) which is abnormal. It is suggested that this newly recognised syndrome be called after Robinow and Sorauf, who appear to be the first to have described a family with the condition. One proband with coronal stenosis had a mother and brother affected, but no syndrome was recognised in them. Excluding this last case, no non-syndromic proband had an affected parent. The 58 probands with predominantly sagittal synostosis had 106 sibs, none of whom was affected. The 21 probands with predominantly coronal synostosis included one sib pair both affected; the remaining 17 sibs were unaffected. The four probands with predominantly metopic stenosis had 13 unaffected sibs and the four with multiple sutures involved had eight unaffected sibs. One sagittal proband had an unaffected monozygotic twin and another an unaffected dizygotic twin.

A family study of hydrocephalus resulting from aqueduct stenosis.

Stenosis of the aqueduct of Sylvius accounts for about one third of cases of congenital hydrocephalus. At least 32 families have been reported in which the aqueduct stenosis is inherited in an X linked fashion. In half of these families, flexed adducted thumbs were noted in some affected family members. Occasionally other male members were mentally retarded, suggesting limited expression of the gene. The problem of giving genetic advice to an isolated, clinically unremarkable, case of aqueduct stenosis remains, so a family study was undertaken based on 24 such cases seen at The Hospital for Sick Children over a 19-year period. There were 15 male and nine female index patients. The diagnosis was confirmed in all cases by air encephalogram. One boy had a radial club hand and another developed clasped thumbs secondary to spasticity. No cases had hyaloidoretinal dysplasia. The 15 boys had 18 brothers and 19 sisters, of whom one sister was similarly affected. The nine girls had 12 sibs, none of whom was affected. This study, combined with a similar study in the USA, suggests that the empirical risk of recurrence of a sporadic case of aqueduct stenosis is about 4.5%.

A family study of protracted diarrhoea in infancy.

A family study of undiagnosed protracted diarrhoea in infancy was undertaken, based on 67 such patients, seen at The Hospital for Sick Children, London, over a 6-year period. All were fully investigated with the exclusion of those with known cause, such as coeliac disease, cow's milk intolerance, or enteric infections. The families were traced and visited. The material is certainly heterogeneous. In the case of five patients the condition was associated with a syndrome. The remaining 62 index patients could be divided into a group of 15 with severe illness and 47 with a milder illness. Six had onset before one month of age, four died, and in five the diarrhoea lasted more than 12 months and the children persistently failed to thrive. These 15 severe cases had six affected sibs out of 22 (Weinberg proband method) and in all but one of these affected sibs the condition was also severe. Two further sibs had had protracted diarrhoea, but this had not been fully investigated. The 47 index patients with milder disease had 68 sibs of whom only one was affected (this boy was one of the severely affected index patients), and one other sib had protracted diarrhoea which was not fully investigated. It is proposed that the severe group includes one or more autosomal recessive entities, in which the basic defects are not yet known, but are likely to be inborn metabolic errors.

Children of those treated surgically for Hirschsprung's disease.

The risk of recurrence of Hirschsprung's disease in sibs is reasonably well established. Survivors of early successful operations (rectosigmoidectomy) are now reaching adult life and are asking about risks to their children. The authors report a preliminary study on which to base a risk estimate. Studies on sibs show that for short segment index patients the risk to brothers is about 1 in 20 and for sisters about 1 in 100. For long segment patients the risk is about 1 in 10 irrespective of sex. In the present study it was found that one son in 52 was possibly affected, and one daughter in 47 was certainly affected, of short segment index patients. Of long segment index patients one son in three was probably affected, and the one daughter was certainly affected. One long segment patient had a child with a short segment affected and one short segment patient had a child with a long segment affected. This confirms the impression, given by single case reports of parent and child affected, that there is less likelihood of concordance in length of aganglionic segment in parent and child than in sibs. For the present it is appropriate to give an estimated risk of about 2% for offspring of short segment index patients, but a relatively higher risk for offspring of long segment index patients.

The camptomelic syndrome in two female siblings.

A patient is reported whose only two pregnancies resulted in phenotypically and genotypically female infants with camptomelic syndrome of the long-limbed variety. Both infants died within a few minutes of birth.

A family study of bladder exstrophy.

The families of 102 index patients with bladder exstrophy treated at The Hospital for Sick Children, Great Ormond Street were studied in an attempt to arrive at an empirical risk of recurrence for sibs. Of the 102 patients, 89 had complete exstrophy, eight had partial exstrophy (variant), and five had exstrophy of the cloaca. In all they had 162 sibs, none of whom had bladder exstrophy. The risk to sibs, in this study and from reports by surgeons of sib pairs in their consecutive series, is low and probably less than 1%. There is a suggestion of an increase in central nervous system malformation in sibs as well as in the index patients.