Reactivity of Metal Clusters.

We summarize here the research advances on the reactivity of metal clusters. After a simple introduction of apparatuses used for gas-phase cluster reactions, we focus on the reactivity of metal clusters with various polar and nonpolar molecules in the gas phase and illustrate how elementary reactions of metal clusters proceed one-step at a time under a combination of geometric and electronic reorganization. The topics discussed in this study include chemical adsorption, addition reaction, cleavage of chemical bonds, etching effect, spin effect, the harpoon mechanism, and the complementary active sites (CAS) mechanism, among others. Insights into the reactivity of metal clusters not only facilitate a better understanding of the fundamentals in condensed-phase chemistry but also provide a way to dissect the stability and reactivity of monolayer-protected clusters synthesized via wet chemistry.

Photoelectron imaging spectroscopy of niobium mononitride anion NbN(.).

In this gas-phase photoelectron spectroscopy study, we present the electron binding energy spectrum and photoelectron angular distributions of NbN(-) by the velocity-map imaging technique. The electron binding energy of NbN(-) is measured to be 1.42 ± 0.02 eV from the X band maximum which defines the 0-0 transition between ground states of anion and neutral. Theoretical binding energies which are the vertical and adiabatic detachment energies are computed by density functional theory to compare them with experiment. The ground state of NbN(-) is assigned to the (2)Δ3/2 state and then the electronic transitions originating from this state into X(3)ΔΩ (Ω = 1-3), a(1)Δ2, A(3)Σ1 (-), and b(1)Σ0 (+) states of NbN are reported to interpret the spectral features. As a prospective study for catalytic materials, spectral features of NbN(-) are compared with those of isovalent ZrO(-) and Pd(-).

Structure, Reactivity, and Fragmentation of Small Multi-Charged Methane Clusters.

Small methane clusters (CH4)n are irradiated using intense femtosecond laser excitation at 624 nm. The ionized species and those resulting from their fragmentation are detected via time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOF MS). We find evidence of bound, multiply charged methane molecules and clusters resulting from Coulomb explosion upon exposure to highly energetic, ultrafast radiation. The assignment of the mass spectra is done after first-principles calculations (at the (R)MP2/aug-cc-pVXZ (X = D,T) level) on the charged (CH4)n(q+) clusters (n = 1-4, q = 1-4). We also considered the cluster stabilities and fragments that may result from intracluster molecular reactivity. Complex intracluster ion-molecule reactions induced by photoionization are expected to occur. Interestingly, we show that multi charged small methane clusters undergo intracluster reactions and fragmentations which are different from those observed for isolated methane ions or for large ionized methane clusters.

What determines if a ligand activates or passivates a superatom cluster?

Quantum confinement in small metal clusters leads to a bunching of states into electronic shells reminiscent of shells in atoms, enabling the classification of clusters as superatoms. The addition of ligands tunes the valence electron count of metal clusters and appears to serve as protecting groups preventing the etching of the metallic cores. Through a joint experimental and theoretical study of the reactivity of methanol with aluminum clusters ligated with iodine, we find that ligands enhance the stability of some clusters, however in some cases the electronegative ligand may perturb the charge density of the metallic core generating active sites that can lead to the etching of the cluster. The reactivity is driven by Lewis acid and Lewis base active sites that form through the selective positioning of the iodine and the structure of the aluminum core. This study enriches the general knowledge on clusters including offering insight into the stability of ligand protected clusters synthesized via wet chemistry.

Direct experimental observation of weakly-bound character of the attached electron in europium anion.

Direct experimental determination of precise electron affinities (EAs) of lanthanides is a longstanding challenge to experimentalists. Considerable debate exists in previous experiment and theory, hindering the complete understanding about the properties of the atomic anions. Herein, we report the first precise photoelectron imaging spectroscopy of europium (Eu), with the aim of eliminating prior contradictions. The measured EA (0.116 ± 0.013 eV) of Eu is in excellent agreement with recently reported theoretical predictions, providing direct spectroscopic evidence that the additional electron is weakly attached. Additionally, a new experimental strategy is proposed that can significantly increase the yield of the lanthanide anions, opening up the best opportunity to complete the periodic table of the atomic anions. The present findings not only serve to resolve previous discrepancy but also will help in improving the depth and accuracy of our understanding about the fundamental properties of the atomic anions.

Mimicking the magnetic properties of rare earth elements using superatoms.

Rare earth elements (REs) consist of a very important group in the periodic table that is vital to many modern technologies. The mining process, however, is extremely damaging to the environment, making them low yield and very expensive. Therefore, mimicking the properties of REs in a superatom framework is especially valuable but at the same time, technically challenging and requiring advanced concepts about manipulating properties of atom/molecular complexes. Herein, by using photoelectron imaging spectroscopy, we provide original idea and direct experimental evidence that chosen boron-doped clusters could mimic the magnetic characteristics of REs. Specifically, the neutral LaB and NdB clusters are found to have similar unpaired electrons and magnetic moments as their isovalent REs (namely Nd and Eu, respectively), opening up the great possibility in accomplishing rare earth mimicry. Extension of the superatom concept into the rare earth group not only further shows the power and advance of this concept but also, will stimulate more efforts to explore new superatomic clusters to mimic the chemistry of these heavy atoms, which will be of great importance in designing novel building blocks in the application of cluster-assembled nanomaterials. Additionally, based on these experimental findings, a novel "magic boron" counting rule is proposed to estimate the numbers of unpaired electrons in diatomic LnB clusters.

Joint photoelectron imaging spectroscopic and theoretical characterization on the electronic structures of the anionic and neutral ZrC2 clusters.

We present a joint photoelectron imaging spectroscopic and theoretical investigation on the triatomic ZrC2(-) anion. Vibrationally resolved spectrum was acquired at 532 nm photon energy. Electron affinity for the neutral ZrC2 cluster was determined to be 1.60 ± 0.07 eV. The CCSD(T) level of theory was used to explore the ground-state geometries and vibrational frequencies of the anionic and neutral ZrC2 clusters. Our vibrationally resolved photoelectron spectrum reveals two vibrational frequencies (564.6 and 1774.0 cm(-1)) of the neutral ZrC2 cluster, which correspond to the symmetric Zr-C2 and C-C stretching modes, and these experimental findings are in good agreement with the calculated values. Additionally, the molecular orbitals and chemical bonding in the anionic and neutral ZrC2 clusters are also discussed to disclose the interaction between the transition metal atom (Zr) and C2 unit.

Reactivity of silver clusters anions with ethanethiol.

We have investigated the gas-phase reactivity of silver clusters with ethanethiol in a fast-flow tube reactor. The primary cluster products observed in this reaction are AgnSH(-) and AgnSH2(-), indicating C-S bond activation, together with interesting byproducts H3S(-) and (H3S)2(-). Agn(-) clusters with an odd number of valence electrons (n = even) were observed to be more reactive than those with an even number of electrons-a feature previously only observed in the reactivity of Agn(-) with triplet oxygen, indicating that radical active sites play a role in their reactivity. Furthermore, the reactivity dramatically increases with large flow rate of ethanethiol being introduced in the flow tube. Theoretical investigations on the reactivity of Ag13(-) and Ag8(-) with ethanethiol indicate that both Ag13(-) and Ag8(-) face significant barriers to reactivity with a single ethanethiol molecule. However, Ag8(-) reacts readily in a cooperative reaction with two ethanethiol molecules, consistent with the dramatic increase in reactivity with a large flow rate. Further hydrogen-transfer reactions may then release an ethylene molecule or an ethyl radical resulting in the observed AgnSH(-) species.

Boron substitution in aluminum cluster anions: magic clusters and reactivity with oxygen.

We have studied the size-selective reactivity of AlnBm(-) clusters m = 1,2 with O2 to investigate the effect of congener substitution in energetic aluminum clusters. Mixed-metal clusters offer an additional strategy for tuning the electronic and geometric structure of clusters and by substituting an atom with a congener; we may investigate the effect of structural changes in clusters with similar electronic structures. Using a fast-flow tube mass spectrometer, we formed aluminum boride cluster anions and exposed them to molecular oxygen. We found multiple stable species with Al12B(-) and Al11B2(-) being highly resistant to reactivity with oxygen. These clusters behave in a similar manner as Al13(-), which has previously been found to be stable in oxygen because of its icosahedral geometry and its filled electronic shell. Al13(-) and Al12B(-) have icosahedral structures, while Al11B2(-) forms a distorted icosahedron. All three of these clusters have filled electronic shells, and Al12B(-) has a larger HOMO-LUMO gap due to its compact geometry. Other cluster sizes are investigated, and the structures of the AlnB(-) series are found to have endohedrally doped B atoms, as do many of the AlnB2(-) clusters. The primary etching products are found to be a loss of two Al2O molecules, with boron likely to remain in the cluster.

S-P coupling induced unusual open-shell metal clusters.

Metal clusters featuring closed supershells or aromatic character usually exhibit remarkably enhanced stability in their cluster series. However, not all stable clusters are subject to these fundamental constraints. Here, by employing photoelectron imaging spectroscopy and ab initio calculations, we present experimental and theoretical evidence on the existence of unexpectedly stable open-shell clusters, which are more stable than their closed-shell and aromatic counterparts. The stabilization of these open-shell Al-Mg clusters is proposed to originate from the S-P molecular orbital coupling, leading to highly stable species with increased HOMO-LUMO gaps, akin to s-p hybridization in an organic carbon atom that is beneficial to form stable species. Introduction of the coupling effect highlighted here not only shows the limitations of the conventional closed-shell model and aromaticity but also provides the possibility to design valuable building blocks.

Observation of d-p hybridized aromaticity in lanthanum-doped boron clusters.

The concept of aromaticity has been advanced beyond the framework of organic chemistry, and multiple aromaticity (σ, π, and δ) has been observed to account for the highly symmetric structures or unusual stability of the clusters. In the present study, the electronic structures and chemical bonding of small monolanthanum boride clusters are investigated using photoelectron imaging spectroscopy and first principles electronic structure calculations. Accurate electron affinities of 1.32 ± 0.04 and 1.13 ± 0.06 eV for the neutral LaB2 and LaB3 clusters are obtained by the vibrationally-resolved photoelectron spectra of the LaB2(-) and LaB3(-) clusters, respectively. It is shown that LaB2(-) and LaB3 exhibit enhanced stability in their respective cluster series, as evidenced from the calculated removal energies and HOMO-LUMO gaps. Molecular orbital analysis discloses that these two clusters possess doubly aromatic characters (σ and π), responsible for their enhanced stability. Interestingly, unlike conventional σ-, π-, and δ-aromaticity formed by the delocalization of unhybridized p or d orbitals, the σ and π delocalized molecular orbitals shown here are formed through the effective overlap between the 5d atomic orbital of the La atom and the p orbitals of the remaining boron atoms, representing an intriguing d-p hybridized aromaticity.

Probing the electronic structures and relative stabilities of monomagnesium oxide clusters MgO(x)- and MgO(x) (x = 1-4): a combined photoelectron imaging and theoretical investigation.

The electronic and structural properties of small monomagnesium oxide clusters, MgO(x)(-) and MgO(x) (x = 1-4), have been investigated using a synergistic approach combining photoelectron imaging spectroscopy and first principles electronic structure calculations. The adiabatic detachment energy (ADE) and vertical detachment energy (VDE) of MgO(x)(-) clusters along with the photoelectron angular distributions (PADs) are determined experimentally. The measured PADs of the clusters are dependent on both the orbital symmetry and electron kinetic energies. Density-functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed to explore the optimized geometries of neutral and anionic MgO(x) clusters. The theoretical ADE and VDE values calculated according to the optimized geometries are in good agreement with our experimental measurements. In addition, MgO(-) and MgO4 clusters are found to have enhanced relative stability in the corresponding anionic and neutral series, based on both theoretical parameters and the experimental cluster distribution.

Probing the valence orbitals of transition metal-silicon diatomic anions: ZrSi, NbSi, MoSi, PdSi and WSi.

Evolution of electronic properties and the nature of bonding of the 4d-transition metal silicides (ZrSi, NbSi, MoSi and PdSi) are discussed, revealing interesting trends in the transition metal-silicon interactions across the period. The electronic properties of select transition metal silicide diatomics have been determined by anion photoelectron imaging spectroscopy and theoretical methods. The electron binding energy spectra and photoelectron angular distributions obtained by 2.33 eV (532 nm) photons have revealed the distinct features of these diatomics. The theoretical calculations were performed at the density functional theory (DFT) level using the unrestricted B3LYP hybrid functional and at the ab initio unrestricted coupled cluster singles and doubles (triplets) (UCCSD(T)) methods to assign the ground electronic states of the neutral and anionic diatomics. The excited electronic states were calculated by the DFT (TD-DFT)/UB3LYP method. We have observed that the valence molecular orbital configuration of the ZrSi and NbSi anions are significantly different from that of the MoSi and PdSi anions. By combining our experimental and theoretical results, we report that the composition of the highest occupied molecular orbitals shift from a majority of transition metal s- and d-orbital contribution in ZrSi and NbSi, to mainly silicon p-orbital contribution for MoSi and PdSi. We expect these observed atomic scale transition metal-silicon interactions to be of increasing importance with the miniaturization of devices approaching the sub-nanometer size regime.

Probing the magic numbers of aluminum-magnesium cluster anions and their reactivity toward oxygen.

We report a joint experimental and theoretical investigation into the geometry, stability, and reactivity with oxygen of alloy metal clusters Al(n)Mg(m)(-) (4 ≤ n+m ≤ 15; 0 ≤ m ≤ 3). Considering that Al and Mg possess three and two valence electrons, respectively, clusters with all possible valence electron counts from 11 to 46 are studied to probe the magic numbers predicted by the spherical jellium model, and to determine whether enhanced stability and reduced reactivity may be found for some Al(n)Mg(m)(-) at non-magic numbers. Al5Mg2(-) and Al11Mg3(-) exhibit enhanced stability corresponding to the expected magic numbers of 20 and 40 electrons, respectively; while Al7Mg3(-), Al11Mg(-), and Al11Mg2(-) turn out to be unexpectedly stable at electron counts of 28, 36, and 38, respectively. The enhanced stability at non-magic numbers is explained through a crystal-field-like splitting of degenerate shells by the geometrical distortions of the clusters. Al(n)Mg(m)(-) clusters appear to display higher oxidation than pure Al(n)(-) clusters, suggesting that the addition of Mg atoms enhances the combustion of pure aluminum clusters.

Photoelectron imaging of small aluminum clusters: quantifying s-p hybridization.

Photoelectron imaging experiments and detailed calculations are conducted on Al(n)(-) clusters (n = 3-6) and a calibration method is developed for connecting experimental observations of photoelectron angular distributions to theoretical predictions. It is shown that this method can be used to quantify the degree to which the molecular orbitals are built from s- or p-like atomic orbitals. The highest occupied molecular orbitals of these small aluminum clusters are found to contain varying degrees of s-p mixing, with Al(3)(-) containing the "most hybridized" orbital and Al(4)(-) containing the "least hybridized" orbital. It is shown experimentally that s-p hybridization is already present for the trimer species and, similar to other properties of small metal clusters, oscillates with cluster size.

Influence of group 10 metals on the growth and subsequent Coulomb explosion of small silicon clusters under strong light pulses.

Growth and ionization patterns of small silicon clusters are studied using ultrafast pulses centered at 624 nm by varying the metal electron source for cluster formation using group 10 transition metals. The silicon-cluster size was observed to change as the electron source was varied from Pd

Extreme ionization leading to Coulomb explosion of small palladium and zirconium oxide clusters and reactivity with carbon monoxide.

Reported herein are strong-field ionization studies of small, neutral Pd(x)O(y) and Zr(x)O(y) clusters made using ultrafast laser pulses (~100 fs) centered at 624 nm. An enhancement in ionization of nearly 1.5 orders of magnitude lower in laser intensity than predicted from literature values is observed for both systems due to clustering. The change in enhancement upon addition of carbon monoxide at different pressures was also studied. Enhancement of high charge states of palladium was found to decrease upon CO addition, whereas in the case of the zirconium system, high charge states of zirconium were observed to increase. Pd and ZrO showed similar reactivity trends with CO and were found to have similar reactivity ratios in accord with their isovalent nature.

Investigating the relative stabilities and electronic properties of small zinc oxide clusters.

We report a combined experimental and theoretical study investigating small zinc oxide clusters. A laser vaporization source and a time-of-flight (TOF) mass spectrometer are employed to produce and identify anionic clusters in the Zn(n)O(m) (n = 1-6, m = 1-7) size regime. The adiabatic detachment energy (ADE) and vertical detachment energy (VDE) of Zn(3)O(3)(-) and Zn(3)O(4)(-) clusters are determined via anion photoelectron spectroscopy. We have utilized density functional theory (DFT) calculations to explore the possible geometries of neutral and anionic Zn(3)O(m) (m = 3-5) clusters, while the theoretical ADE and VDE values are compared with experimental results. The experimentally observed relative abundances among the Zn(3)O(m)(-) (m = 3-5) clusters are investigated through calculations of the detachment energies, dissociation energies, and HOMO-LUMO gaps. We find that the Zn(3)O(3) cluster maintains enhanced stability compared to their oxygen-rich counterparts. Furthermore, by coupling the experimentally obtained photoelectron angular distributions of Zn(3)O(3)(-) and Zn(3)O(4)(-) with electronic structure calculations, the nature of the highest occupied molecular orbitals is discussed, with the goal of aiding the isolation (ligand-capped)/deposition of these building blocks.

Ionization enhancement in silicon clusters and germanium atoms in the presence of zirconium.

Molecules/clusters have been shown to undergo an enhancement in ionization under ultrafast laser pulses. This enhancement results in the lowering of the laser intensity required to observe ion signal from higher atomic charge states resulting from Coulomb explosion of clusters. Here, we explore the effect of using an early-group transition metal as an electron source in the formation of small silicon clusters on the observed enhancement in ionization. Intensity selective scanning is used to measure the onset of ion signal for the atomic charge states of silicon, germanium, zirconium, and oxygen. Additionally, the kinetic energy released values for the resulting high charge states of silicon are measured and compared to those previously observed using a copper electron source. A significant increase in ionization enhancement is observed upon using zirconium metal, despite a decrease in cluster size. Germanium metal with zirconium is studied for comparison and shows a larger enhancement in ion signal than silicon, indicating that atomic mass may be significant.

Spin accommodation and reactivity of silver clusters with oxygen: the enhanced stability of Ag13(-).

Spin accommodation is demonstrated to play a determining role in the reactivity of silver cluster anions with oxygen. Odd-electron silver clusters are found to be especially reactive, while the anionic 13-atom cluster exhibits unexpected stability against reactivity with oxygen. Theoretical studies show that the odd-even selective behavior is correlated with the excitation needed to activate the O-O bond in O(2). Furthermore, by comparison with the reactivity of proximate even-electron clusters, we demonstrate that the inactivity of Ag(13)(-) is associated with its large spin excitation energy, ascribed to a crystal-field-like splitting of the orbitals caused by the bilayer atomic structure, which induces a large gap despite not having a magic number of valence electrons.