Non-strategic ignorance: Considering the potential for a paradigm shift in evidence-based mental health.

Randomised controlled trials form a central building block within the prevailing evidence-based mental health paradigm. Both methodology and paradigm have been widely problematised since their emergence in the mid-late twentieth century. We draw on the concept of 'strategic ignorance' to understand why the paradigm still prevails. We present focus group data gathered from 37 participants (service users, public, carers, general practitioners, commissioners) concerning the way they made sense of a randomised controlled trial of psychotherapy for treatment-resistant depression. Thematic analysis of the findings revealed an overall critique of randomised controlled trial methods which we refer to as 'non-strategic ignorance'. Specifically, participants problematised the construct of depression, unseating the premise of the randomised controlled trial; they were sceptical about the purpose and highlighted its failure to show how therapy works or who might benefit; the randomised controlled trial was seen as inadequate for informing decisions about how to select a therapy. Participants assumed the treatment would be cost-effective given the client group and nature of the therapy, irrespective of any randomised controlled trial findings. Each area of lay ('non-strategic') critique has an analogous form within the methodological expert domain. We argue that 'expert' critiques have generally failed to have paradigmatic impact because they represent strategic ignorance. Yet parallel non-strategic critiques have common sense appeal, highlighting the potential power of lay voices. The discussion considers whether the evidence-based mental health paradigm is faced with epistemological problems of such complexity that the conditions exist for a new paradigm in which service user views are central and randomised controlled trials peripheral.

Experimental Characterization of Hb Flurlingen (HBA2: c.177 C > G, p.His > Gln) and Hb Boghé (HBA2: c.177 C > A, p.His > Gln) Reveals Contradictory HBA2 Expression and Translation Patterns Despite Identical Amino Acid Substitutions.

In this study, we describe the clinical features and provide experimental analyses of Hb Flurlingen (HBA2: c.177 C > G, p.His > Gln) that contrasted with Hb Boghé (HBA2: c.177 C > A, p.His > Gln). Despite the identical amino acid substitution in both variants, Hb Flurlingen shows the phenotype of α-thalassemia (α-thal), whereas Hb Boghé has no impact on α2-globin (HBA2) production. For in vitro transcription analysis, HBA2 expression constructs carrying the HBA2-WT (wild type), Hb Flurlingen and Hb Boghé sequences were generated and expressed in human bladder carcinoma 5637 cells for downstream analyses by quantitative real time-polymerase chain reaction (qReTi-PCR) and immunofluorochemistry (IFC). In silico analysis of secondary folding structures of the HBA2-WT, Hb Flurlingen and Hb Boghé mRNA sequences was performed using Mfold software. The gene transcription and translation analyses revealed that cells transfected with the Hb Flurlingen construct had significantly lower HBA2 transcription (-55.4%, p ≤ 0.01) and reduced protein synthesis when compared to the wild type group. In contrast, cells transfected with the Hb Boghé construct showed no significant changes in HBA2 transcription or translation activities when compared to the wild type group. The in silico prediction of possible effects of these mutations on the folding structures of the HBA2 transcripts showed a change of secondary folding pattern in the Hb Flurlingen transcript when compared to those of HBA2-WT and Hb Boghé. Our experimental findings support the clinical presentation of an α-thalassemic phenotype for Hb Flurlingen in contrast with Hb Boghé, despite identical amino acid substitutions. The results confirm the importance of experimental analysis in establishing the impact of novel base substitutions.

Molecular and cellular analysis of three novel alpha2-globin gene promoter mutations [HBA2: c.-59C>T], [HBA2: c.-81C>A] and [HBA2: c.-91G>A] reveal varying patterns of transcriptional and translational activities.

While point mutations affecting the promoter region of ß-globin gene are widely described, there are no well characterised reports of any point mutations currently found in the promoter of the α2-globin (HBA2) gene. We present clinical and experimental data for three novel HBA2 gene core and proximal promoter mutations. Using an in vitro system designed to assess the impact of point mutations, the three novel [HBA2:c.-59C>T], [HBA2:c.-81C>A] and [HBA2:c.-91G>A] promoter mutations identified in three unrelated patients were analysed for HBA2 gene transcriptional and translational activities. Following the generation and transfection of expression vectors carrying each mutation, the HBA2 transcription activity of the promoters from each mutant was analysed with quantitative real time-PCR (qReTi-PCR) technique. Immunofluorochemistry (IFC) was used to analyse HBA2 protein synthesis. The analyses showed that [HBA2:c.-59C>T] and [HBA2:c.-91G>A] mutant constructs caused significant reduction in the HBA2 transcription levels by 53.7% (p = 0.0008) and 36.2% (p = 0.004), respectively, resulting in markedly lower HBA2 protein labelling when compared to the wild type as shown with subsequent IFC analysis. Conversely, the [HBA2:c.-81C>A] construct showed no significant changes in either transcription (p = 0.089) or in protein labelling when compared to the wild type. The equal pAmp transcription levels found in each group confirmed that the observed labelling differences were not due to varying transfection efficiencies. This study emphasises the importance of in vitro studies to establish the impact of base substitutions on the level of gene expression, and the value of these studies in clinicopathological correlation so that appropriate advice can be given in genetic counselling.

Finding a voice: a journey towards being assertive.

This is a case study of two depressed women who were able to benefit from a 16-week course of Interpersonal Psychotherapy. This well-established brief psychotherapy has become increasingly available throughout the UK. The focus of this biopsychosocial approach that is on change within the patients interpersonal world means a more active goal-focused approach that addresses symptomatic and emotional concerns using the individuals narrative. In both cases, there was a significant reported change in their depression, initial presenting problems, understanding of their difficulties and interpersonal functioning.