Does DeLee suction at the perineum prevent meconium aspiration syndrome?

OBJECTIVE: We attempted to determine the impact of "early" (before delivery of the chest) oronasopharyngeal DeLee suctioning at the perineum in the prevention of meconium aspiration syndrome and to confirm that meconium aspiration syndrome is a postnatal event. STUDY DESIGN: We compared infants with meconium-stained fluid who underwent "early" oronasopharyngeal DeLee suctioning with a similar group of infants whose airways were suctioned "late" (after chest delivery). Practicing obstetricians did not know the study was being conducted by the pediatric staff, and an independent observer documented whether obstetricians performed "early" or "late" oronasopharyngeal DeLee suctioning. Immediate postnatal tracheal suctioning was performed in both groups. The study was conducted in a private tertiary care center averaging 5800 deliveries annually. A consecutive sample of 438 infants with meconium-stained fluid was analyzed. Of these infants, 221 received "early" oronasopharyngeal DeLee suctioning, while 217 infants were suctioned "late". RESULTS: Of the 438 infants with meconium-stained fluid, meconium aspiration syndrome developed in 38 (9%). These infants had higher rates of fetal distress (i.e., abnormal fetal heart rates) and lower Apgar scores (< or = 6) than infants without meconium aspiration syndrome (58% vs 17% and 65% vs 13%, respectively; p < 0.001). Forty-five percent of the infants with meconium aspiration syndrome had renal failure during the first 20 hours of life. In spite of "early" oronasopharyngeal DeLee suctioning, 53% of the infants in this group had meconium below the vocal cords and meconium aspiration syndrome developed in 7%. The time of oronasopharyngeal DeLee suctioning did not affect the rate of meconium aspiration syndrome or the presence of meconium below the vocal cords. CONCLUSIONS: We concluded that "early" oronasopharyngeal DeLee suctioning at the perineum does not affect the rate of meconium aspiration syndrome. We speculate that meconium aspiration syndrome is predominantly an intrauterine event associated with fetal distress and that meconium in the airways is merely a "marker" of previous fetal hypoxia.

Failure to prevent meconium aspiration syndrome.

To determine the impact of routine naso-oropharyngeal DeLee and tracheal suction on the prevention of meconium aspiration syndrome, we compared 755 infants with meconium-stained fluid, born during a 12-month period (1983), with a similar group of 742 infants born in a previous year (1975) when these suctioning techniques were not routinely used. Morbidity and mortality data from meconium aspiration syndrome in 103 infants, using combined DeLee and tracheal suction during a five-year period (1979-1983), were also analyzed retrospectively. In spite of a combined DeLee and tracheal approach toward the prevention of meconium aspiration, the rate of meconium aspiration syndrome (2%) was not different in 1975 and 1983. Timing of obstetric DeLee suction (whether before or after delivery of the chest) did not influence the presence of meconium below the vocal cords (37 versus 36%, respectively). Even though significant morbidity remained associated with meconium aspiration in both periods studied, a drastic reduction occurred in neonatal mortality, from 46%, in 1975 to 12.5% in 1983, which was probably aided by major advances in perinatal care and supports routine prophylactic suctioning of meconium at birth. From these findings, we suggest that meconium aspiration syndrome is predominantly an intrauterine event secondary to fetal distress, and that DeLee and tracheal suctioning reduce only its severity.