Fish is Fish: the use of experimental model species to reveal causes of skeletal diversity in evolution and disease.

Fishes are wonderfully diverse. This variety is a result of the ability of ray-finned fishes to adapt to a wide range of environments, and has made them more specious than the rest of vertebrates combined. With such diversity it is easy to dismiss comparisons between distantly related fishes in efforts to understand the biology of a particular fish species. However, shared ancestry and the conservation of developmental mechanisms, morphological features and physiology provide the ability to use comparative analyses between different organisms to understand mechanisms of development and physiology. The use of species that are amenable to experimental investigation provides tools to approach questions that would not be feasible in other 'non-model' organisms. For example, the use of small teleost fishes such as zebrafish and medaka has been powerful for analysis of gene function and mechanisms of disease in humans, including skeletal diseases. However, use of these fish to aid in understanding variation and disease in other fishes has been largely unexplored. This is especially evident in aquaculture research. Here we highlight the utility of these small laboratory fishes to study genetic and developmental factors that underlie skeletal malformations that occur under farming conditions. We highlight several areas in which model species can serve as a resource for identifying the causes of variation in economically important fish species as well as to assess strategies to alleviate the expression of the variant phenotypes in farmed fish. We focus on genetic causes of skeletal deformities in the zebrafish and medaka that closely resemble phenotypes observed both in farmed as well as natural populations of fishes.

The distributions of the duplicate oestrogen receptors ER-beta a and ER-beta b in the forebrain of the Atlantic croaker (Micropogonias undulatus): evidence for subfunctionalization after gene duplication.

Teleost fishes have three distinct oestrogen receptor (ER) subtypes: ER-alpha, ER-beta a (or ER-gamma) and ER-beta b. ER-beta a and ER-beta b arose from a duplication of an ancestral ER-beta gene early in the teleost lineage. Here, we describe the distribution of the three ER mRNAs in the hypothalamus and cerebellum of the Atlantic croaker to address two issues: the specific functions of multiple ERs in the neuroendocrine system and the evolution and fate of duplicated genes. ER-alpha was detected in nuclei of the preoptic area (POA) and hypothalamus previously shown to possess ER-alphas in teleosts. AcER-beta b, but not ER-beta a, labelling was detected in the magnocellular neurons of the POA, nucleus posterior tuberis, the nucleus recessus posterior and cerebellum. By contrast, acER-beta a, but not ER-beta b, was detected in the dorsal anterior parvocellular POA and suprachiasmatic nucleus. Both ER-betas were found in posterior parvocellular and ventral anterior POA nuclei, the ventral hypothalamus, and periventricular dorsal hypothalamus. The differences we observed in ER subtype mRNA distribution within well-characterized brain nuclei suggest that ER-beta a and ER-beta b have distinct functions in the neuroendocrine control of reproduction and behaviour, and provide evidence that the teleost ER-beta paralogues have partitioned functions of the ancestral ER-beta gene they shared with tetrapods.

The unusual binding properties of the third distinct teleost estrogen receptor subtype ERbetaa are accompanied by highly conserved amino acid changes in the ligand binding domain.

Three forms of estrogen receptor: ERalpha, ERbeta (ERbetab), and a second ERbeta, ERbetaa (formerly ERgamma) are present in teleost fish. All ERbetaas share amino acid changes in the ligand binding domain that may influence ligand specificity and receptor function. We compared binding specificities of the three ERs of the teleost fish, Atlantic croaker Micropogonias undulatus. Bacterially expressed Atlantic croaker (ac) ERalpha, -betab, and -betaa fusion proteins showed specific, high affinity binding to 17beta-[(3)H]estradiol, with K(d) values of 0.61 +/- 0.013, 0.40 +/- 0.006, and 0.38 +/- 0.059 nm, respectively. Rank orders of binding were: diethylstilbestrol >> ICI182780 > 4-hydroxytamoxifen > ICI164384 > estradiol >/= zearalenone > moxestrol > tamoxifen > estrone >/= 17alpha-estradiol > estriol > 2-hydroxyestrone = genistein >> RU486 for acERalpha; ICI182780 > diethylstilbestrol > 4-hydroxytamoxifen > estradiol > ICI164384 > genistein > moxestrol > tamoxifen > zearalenone = estrone > estriol = 17alpha-estradiol > 2-hydroxyestrone >> RU486 for acERbetab; and estradiol >/= diethylstilbestrol > 4-hydroxytamoxifen > ICI182780 > ICI 164384 > estriol >/= genistein > moxestrol > zearalenone > estrone > 17alpha-estradiol > RU486 >/= tamoxifen > 2-hydroxyestrone for acERbetaa. acERbetaa showed higher relative binding affinities for estradiol, estriol, and RU486 and lower relative binding affinities for synthetic estrogens and antiestrogens than previously characterized ERs. Mutation of the conserved teleost substitutions (acERbetaaPhe(396)) to the ERalpha or ERbetab counterpart shifted diethylstilbestrol and tamoxifen affinities toward those of wild-type acERalpha and acERbetab, supporting the hypothesis that the positions with conserved residue changes in teleost ERs are important to ER structure and function.

Identification of a third distinct estrogen receptor and reclassification of estrogen receptors in teleosts.

This paper describes three distinct estrogen receptor (ER) subtypes: ERalpha, ERbeta, and a unique type, ERgamma, cloned from a teleost fish, the Atlantic croaker Micropogonias undulatus; the first identification of a third type of classical ER in vertebrate species. Phylogenetic analysis shows that ERgamma arose through gene duplication from ERbeta early in the teleost lineage and indicates that ERgamma is present in other teleosts, although it has not been recognized as such. The Atlantic croaker ERgamma shows amino acid differences in regions important for ligand binding and receptor activation that are conserved in all other ERgammas. The three ER subtypes are genetically distinct and have different distribution patterns in Atlantic croaker tissues. In addition, ERbeta and ERgamma fusion proteins can each bind estradiol-17beta with high affinity. The presence of three functional ERs in one species expands the role of ER multiplicity in estrogen signaling systems and provides a unique opportunity to investigate the dynamics and mechanisms of ER evolution.

Gonadal stage-dependent effects of gonadal steroids on gonadotropin II secretion in the Atlantic croaker (Micropogonias undulatus).

Involvement of gonadal steroids in the control of gonadotropin II (GTH II) (homologous to LH) secretion was investigated in the Atlantic croaker (Micropogonias undulatus) using gonadectomy (Gx) and steroid replacement paradigms. Gonadectomy in males and females during the late gonadal recrudescence phase elicited significant increases in the gonadotropin response to stimulation by an LHRH analog (LHRHa), without altering basal GTH II secretion. Slow-release silicone elastomer implants of testosterone or estradiol significantly inhibited LHRHa-induced GTH II secretion in gonad-intact and Gx males, and in Gx females, whereas 5alpha-dihydrotestosterone, a nonaromatizable androgen, was ineffective. Pretreatment of fish with an aromatase inhibitor, 1,4, 6-androstatrien-3,17-dione, 2 days before the administration of testosterone implants, completely blocked the negative effect of testosterone on LHRHa-induced GTH II secretion in males, but only partially restored it in females. This suggests that the negative feedback of testosterone in males is primarily mediated by its conversion to estradiol at the level of the hypothalamus and/or pituitary gland, while in females the androgen may also exert a direct inhibitory effect on GTH II secretion, probably mediated via an androgen receptor. In addition, estradiol and testosterone exerted positive effects on basal and LHRHa-induced GTH II secretion during the early-recrudescence phase of the gonadal cycle. The steroids switched to a negative effect on LHRHa-induced GTH II secretion once the fish had fully developed gonads, possibly as a mechanism that prevents a precocious surge in GTH II secretion and final gamete maturation until gametogenesis is complete and the environmental conditions are appropriate for spawning.