Applying the good publication practice 2022 guidelines in the Asia-Pacific region: a practical guide.

OBJECTIVE: The Asia-Pacific region (APAC) represents a unique environment for the publication of biomedical research, particularly industry-funded research. Awareness and adoption of international guidelines on ethical publication practices continues to increase across APAC, but the reframing and expansion of many of the recommendations in the Good Publication Practice (GPP) 2022 guidelines versus GPP3 published in 2015 have important implications for publishing industry-funded biomedical research in the region. METHODS: This manuscript provides practical guidance for stakeholders in APAC on interpreting and applying the recommendations made in the GPP 2022 guidelines. RESULTS: Key focus areas include navigating new opportunities for communicating industry-funded research, such as plain language summaries, social media, and preprints; implementing formal processes to improve the integrity of published research in APAC; and methods of promoting transparency and inclusion when publishing industry-funded research. Key APAC-specific issues, including encore presentations, leadership on publication ethics in the region, access to professional resources, and support for educating regional stakeholders are also discussed. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, this manuscript offers a pragmatic guide for stakeholders in industry-sponsored research on applying GPP 2022 in practice with a focus on effectively integrating these guidelines in an APAC context.

A retrospective study investigating requests for self-citation during open peer review in a general medicine journal.

INTRODUCTION: Peer review is a volunteer process for improving the quality of publications by providing objective feedback to authors, but also presents an opportunity for reviewers to seek personal reward by requesting self-citations. Open peer review may reduce the prevalence of self-citation requests and encourage author rebuttal over accession. This study aimed to investigate the prevalence of self-citation requests and their inclusion in manuscripts in a journal with open peer review. METHODS: Requests for additional references to be included during peer review for articles published between 1 January 2017 and 31 December 2018 in BMC Medicine were evaluated. Data extracted included total number of self-citations requested, self-citations that were included in the final published manuscript and manuscripts that included at least one self-citation, and compared with corresponding data on independent citations. RESULTS: In total, 932 peer review reports from 373 manuscripts were analysed. At least one additional citation was requested in 25.9% (n = 241) of reports. Self-citation requests were included in 44.4% of reports requesting additional citations (11.5% of all reports). Requests for self-citation were significantly more likely than independent citations to be incorporated in the published manuscript (65.1% vs 52.1%; chi-square p = 0.003). At the manuscript level, when requested, self-citations were incorporated in 76.6% of manuscripts (n = 72; 19.3% of all manuscripts) compared with 68.5% of manuscripts with independent citation requests (n = 102; 27.3% of manuscripts). A significant interaction was observed between the presence of self-citation requests and the likelihood of any citation request being incorporated (100% incorporation in manuscripts with self-citation requests alone versus 62.7-72.2% with any independent citation request; Fisher's exact test p<0.0005). CONCLUSIONS: Requests for self-citations during the peer review process are common. The transparency of open peer review may have the unexpected effect of encouraging authors to incorporate self-citation requests by disclosing peer reviewer identity.

A guide to applying the Good Publication Practice 3 guidelines in the Asia-Pacific region.

Numerous recommendations and guidelines aim to improve the quality, timeliness and transparency of medical publications. However, these guidelines use ambiguous language that can be challenging to interpret, particularly for speakers of English as a second language. Cultural expectations within the Asia-Pacific region raise additional challenges and several studies have suggested that awareness and application of ethical publication practices in the Asia-Pacific region is relatively low compared with other regions. However, guidance on applying ethical publication practice guidelines in the Asia-Pacific region is lacking. This commentary aims to improve publication practices in the Asia-Pacific region by providing guidance on applying the 10 principles of the Good Publication Practice 3 (GPP3) guidelines and the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) criteria for authorship. Recommendations are provided for encore presentations, applying the ICMJE authorship criteria in the context of regional cultural expectations, and the role of study sponsors and professional medical writers. Ongoing barriers to compliance with guidelines are also highlighted, and additional guidance is provided to support authors submitting manuscripts for publication. The roles of regional journals, regulatory authorities and professional bodies in improving practices are also discussed.

Domoic acid preconditioning and seizure induction in young and aged rats.

Clinical reports suggest that the elderly are hypersensitive to the neurological effects of domoic acid (DOM). In the present study we assessed DOM-induced seizures in young and aged rats, and seizure attenuation following low-dose DOM pretreatment (i.e. preconditioning). Seizure behaviours following saline or DOM administration (0.5-2mg/kg i.p.) were continuously monitored for 2.5h in naïve and DOM preconditioned rats. Competitive ELISA was used to determine serum and brain DOM concentrations. Dose- and age-dependent increases in seizure activity were evident in response to DOM. Lower doses of DOM in young and aged rats promoted low level seizure behaviours. Animals administered high doses (2mg/kg in young; 1mg/kg in aged) progressed through various stages of stereotypical behaviour (e.g., head tics, scratching, wet dog shakes) before ultimately exhibiting tonic-clonic convulsions. Serum and brain DOM analysis indicated impaired renal clearance as contributory to increased DOM sensitivity in aged animals, and this was supported by seizure analysis following direct intrahippocampal administration of DOM. Preconditioning young and aged animals with low-dose DOM 45-90 min before high-dose DOM significantly reduced seizure intensity. We conclude that age-related supersensitivity to DOM is related to reduced clearance rather than increased neuronal sensitivity, and that preconditioning mechanisms underlying an inducible tolerance to excitotoxins are robustly expressed in both young and aged CNS.

Detection of domoic acid in rat serum and brain by direct competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (cELISA).

In 1987 a large-scale incident of human poisoning in Canada was traced to commercial mussels contaminated with domoic acid (DOM). Since then, routine screening of shellfish domoic acid content has been carried out using a variety of assays, with liquid chromatography using ultraviolet absorbance detection (LC-UV) or mass spectrometric detection (LC-MS) being the currently accepted standard methodologies. Recently, a highly specific competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (cELISA) has been developed for the detection and analysis of DOM in commercial shellfish, but its accuracy relative to LC methods has not been independently verified in mammalian tissues. In this study we demonstrate that measurement of rat serum DOM concentration by cELISA gives a good correlation (r2 = 0.993) across a broad range of concentrations when compared to LC-MS analysis, with only a small (15%) overestimation of sample DOM content. In addition, we have developed an extraction method for analysis of DOM in rat brain by cELISA which yields complete recovery across a range of sample dilutions.

Kainate receptor agonists and antagonists mediate tolerance to kainic acid and reduce high-affinity GTPase activity in young, but not aged, rat hippocampus.

Domoic acid acts at both kainic acid (KA) and alpha-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methylisoxazole-4-propionate (AMPA)-sensitive glutamate receptors and induces tolerance against subsequent domoic acid insult in young but not aged rat hippocampus. To determine the receptor specificity of this effect, tolerance induction was examined in hippocampal slices from young and aged rats. Slices were preconditioned by exposure to low-dose KA to activate kainate receptors, or the AMPA-receptor selective agonist (S)-5-fluorowillardiine (FW), and following washout, tolerance induction was assessed by administration of high concentrations of KA or FW (respectively). FW preconditioning failed to induce tolerance to subsequent FW challenges, while KA-preconditioned slices were significantly resistant to the effects of high-dose KA. KA preconditioning failed to induce tolerance in aged CA1. Given the lasting nature of the tolerance effect, we examined G-protein-coupled receptor function. A number of ionotropic KA receptor agonists and antagonists significantly reduced constitutive GTPase activity in hippocampal membranes from young but not aged rats. Furthermore, in young CA1, low concentrations of the AMPA/KA blocker GYKI-52466 also induced tolerance to high-dose KA. Our findings suggest that tolerance is triggered by a selective reduction in constitutive KA-sensitive G-protein activity, and that this potential neuroprotective mechanism is lost with age.