Panic disorder in completed suicide.

BACKGROUND: Patients with panic disorder are reportedly at increased risk of suicidal behavior, but in psychological autopsy studies of completed suicides, a current diagnosis of panic disorder has been rare or absent. The comorbidity and other clinical characteristics of panic disorder among suicides are not known. METHOD: On the basis of data from a psychological autopsy study of all suicides (N = 1397) in Finland occurring during 1 year, all victims with current DSM-III-R panic disorder were retrospectively identified and examined in terms of comorbidity, suicide methods, history of suicide attempts, treatment setting, and duration of panic disorder. RESULTS: Seventeen victims with current panic disorder, 1.2% of all suicides, were identified. The prevalence of panic disorder was higher among female (2.8%, 9 of 320) than male suicides (0.7%, 8 of 1077; p = .007). All victims with panic disorder suffered concurrent Axis I disorders, and 8 (47%) Axis II disorders. Major depression was diagnosed in 10 (59%), and substance dependence or abuse in 8 (47%) of the cases. The mean duration of panic disorder before suicide was 8 years. In most cases, the onset of panic disorder preceded comorbid Axis I disorders and previous suicide attempts. Most victims with panic disorder had a history of psychiatric treatment. CONCLUSION: Current panic disorder, and noncomorbid panic disorder in particular, seem to be rare among completed suicides. Suicide in persons with panic disorder is associated with superimposed major depression and substance abuse, and with personality disorders. For recognizing panic disorder patients at risk of suicide, the assessment and monitoring of the overall psychopathology are essential.

Suicide among subjects with personality disorders.

OBJECTIVE: There have been few psychological autopsy studies of suicide among individuals with personality disorders. The possible specificity of characteristics of suicide among such individuals has been little investigated. METHOD: A random sample of 229 subjects who committed suicide, representing all suicide victims in Finland within a 12-month period, were comprehensively examined by using the psychological autopsy method and were diagnosed according to DSM-III-R criteria. Within this random sample the authors investigated all subjects with axis II personality disorders (N = 67) and divided them into clusters B (N = 43), C (N = 23), and A (N = 1). Individuals with clusters B and C personality disorders were separately compared with sex- and age-matched suicide victims without personality disorder, in terms of sociodemographic characteristics, comorbid axis I and III syndromes, treatment histories, previous suicide attempts, communication of suicide intent, and suicide methods. RESULTS: All suicide victims with a personality disorder received at least one axis I diagnosis. In 95% this included a depressive syndrome, a psychoactive substance use disorder, or both. Individuals with cluster B personality disorders were more likely than comparison subjects to have psychoactive substance use disorders (79% versus 40%) and previous nonfatal suicide attempts (70% versus 37%) and were less likely to have axis III physical disorders (29% versus 50%). Subjects with cluster C personality disorders were not found to differ from the control subjects in any of the variables examined. CONCLUSIONS: Suicide victims with personality disorders were almost always found to have had current depressive syndromes, psychoactive substance use disorders, or both. Suicide victims with cluster B personality disorders differed from other suicide victims in several characteristics, while those with cluster C personality disorders did not.

Mental disorders and suicide prevention.

In the research phase of the National Suicide Prevention Project, all suicides (n = 1397) in Finland between March 1987 and April 1988 were examined retrospectively using the psychological autopsy method. Careful retrospective diagnostic evaluation of the victims according to DSM-III-R criteria was done by weighing and integrating all available information. A series of studies addressing the mental disorders among suicide victims, the treatment received before death and the life events is now reviewed. Among a random sample of suicide victims from the natiowide suicide population, at least one psychiatric diagnosis was made for 93% of the victims. The most prevalent disorders were depressive syndromes (66%) and alcohol dependence/abuse (43%). The prevalence of major depression was higher among women than among men. Major depression as the principal diagnosis was more common among the elderly suicides. Among adolescent victims, depressive syndromes were also the most prevalent disorders. Adjustment disorders were common (25%) among male adolescent suicides. The majority of suicide victims of all ages suffered from comorbid mental disorders. Among suicide victims who had had contact with a health carer before death, inadequacy of treatment for mental disorders seems to have been common. Of the major depressive victims only 3% were found to have received adequate psychopharmacological treatment, and only 7% received weekly psychotherapy by a trained therapist. The analysis of the massive database collected in the research phase of the National Suicide Prevention Project in Finland is still ongoing, and the implications of the findings for suicide prevention will be refined during the research process. The necessity to improve recognition and treatment for comorbid depressive disorders in all age groups seems evident already.

Mental disorders in elderly suicide.

The purpose of this study was to investigate the prevalence and comorbidity of current mental disorders defined by DSM-III-R among elderly suicide victims and to compare them with the mental disorders among younger victims. Using a psychological autopsy method, we collected comprehensive data on all suicides in Finland during 1 year. Retrospective Axis I-III consensus diagnoses were assigned to a random sample consisting of 43 victims aged 60 years or over and 186 victims aged under 60 from the nationwide suicide population. At least one Axis I diagnosis was made for 91% of the elderly victims. Major depression as the principal diagnosis was more common among the elderly victims. Almost all elderly female victims were major depressives. Psychiatric comorbidity was more common among elderly male than among elderly female victims. More of the elderly victims (88%) than the younger (36%) received Axis III diagnoses. Suicide among the elderly without a diagnosable mental disorder and somatopsychiatric comorbidity seems to be rare.

Differences in recent life events between alcoholic and depressive nonalcoholic suicides.

The purpose of this study was to investigate the main differences in recent life events preceding suicide between alcoholic and depressive nonalcoholic suicide victims, how much these differences were sex- and age-dependent, and how social support varied between these groups. Using the psychological autopsy method, retrospective best-estimate diagnoses by DSM-III-R criteria were assigned to a randomized 16.4% sample (n = 229) of suicide victims drawn from a 1-year total nationwide suicide population (n = 1,397) in Finland. Life events during the last 3 months (32 items) and social support (6 items) of 75 suicide victims with alcohol abuse/dependence diagnoses were compared with those of 69 nonalcoholic depressive victims. Among male suicides, the alcoholics had experienced more separations and family discord, financial trouble, and unemployment, whereas the depressives had experienced more somatic illness. Among females, adverse interpersonal events had been common in both alcoholic and depressive victims. Among the alcoholics, unlike the depressives, the number of adverse interpersonal life events had not diminished with increasing age. Living alone had been twice as common among the alcoholic suicides and, in these cases, recent separation, unemployment, and financial trouble were remarkably common, suggesting a concurrent stressor effect. Our results confirm and extend the earlier findings of excess interpersonal stressors among alcoholic suicides compared with depressive suicides. The findings suggest that multiple adverse life events and living alone need to be taken into account in clinical practice when assessing psychosocial stress and suicidal danger in alcoholism.

Suicide in major depression.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to examine a sample representing all suicide victims with current DSM-III-R major depression in Finland within 1 year in aspects relevant to suicide prevention, including comorbidity, clinical history, current treatment, suicide methods, and communication of suicide intent. METHOD: Using the psychological autopsy method, the authors examined all 71 suicide victims with current unipolar DSM-III-R major depression, taken from a random sample of 229 subjects representing 16.4% of all suicide victims in Finland in 1 year. RESULTS: The majority (85%) were complicated cases with comorbid diagnoses, and comorbidity varied according to the subjects' sex and age. Three-quarters had a history of psychiatric treatment, but only 45% were receiving psychiatric treatment at the time of death. Most suicide victims had received no treatment for depression. Only 3% had received antidepressants in adequate doses, 7% weekly psychotherapy, and 3% ECT. None of the 24 psychotic subjects had received adequate psychopharmacological treatment. Few (8%) had used an antidepressant overdose as a suicide method. Men had received less treatment for depression and had more commonly used violent suicide methods. CONCLUSIONS: Although about half of the suicide victims with major depression were receiving psychiatric care at the time of death, few were receiving adequate treatment for depression. There were significant sex differences in current and previous treatment and suicide methods. For suicide prevention in major depression, it would seem crucial to improve treatment and follow-up, for males with major depression, in particular.

Mental disorders and comorbidity in suicide.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to investigate the prevalence and comorbidity of current mental disorders defined by DSM-III-R among a random sample of suicide victims from a nationwide suicide population. METHOD: Using a psychological autopsy method, the authors collected comprehensive data on all suicide victims in Finland during 1 year. Retrospective axis I-III consensus diagnoses were assigned to 229 (172 male, 57 female) victims. RESULTS: One or more diagnoses on axis I were made for 93% of the victims. The most prevalent disorders were depressive disorders (59%) and alcohol dependence or abuse (43%). The prevalence of major depression was higher among females (46%) than among males (26%). Alcohol dependence was more common among the males (39% versus 18% for females). A diagnosis on axis II was made for 31% and at least one diagnosis on axis III for 46% of the cases. Only 12% of the victims received one axis I diagnosis without any comorbidity. CONCLUSIONS: The majority of suicide victims suffered from comorbid mental disorders. Comorbidity needs to be taken into account when analyzing the relationship between suicide and mental disorders and in planning treatment strategies for suicide prevention in clinical practice.