Stratifying the risk of re-detachment: variables associated with outcome of vitrectomy for rhegmatogenous retinal detachment in a large UK cohort study.

INTRODUCTION: To identify variables associated with primary anatomical outcome following vitrectomy and internal tamponade for rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RD). METHODS: A retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data, using a database of RD treated with vitrectomy and internal tamponade. Collected data complied with the RCOphth Retinal Detachment Dataset. The main outcome measure was anatomical failure within six months of surgery. RESULTS: There were 6377 vitrectomies. 869 eyes were excluded, either because no outcome was recorded, or inadequate follow up, leaving 5508 operations for analysis. 63.9% of patients were male, and the median age was 62. Primary anatomical failure occurred in 13.9%. On multivariate analysis, the following were associated with increased risk of failure: age <45, or >79, inferior retinal breaks, total detachment, one quadrant or greater inferior detachment, low density silicone oil, and presence of proliferative vitreoretinopathy. C2F6 tamponade, cryotherapy, and 25 G vitrectomy, were associated with reduced risk of failure. The area under the receiver operator curve was 71.7%. According to this model, 54.3% of RD are at low risk (<10%), 35.6% are at moderate risk (10-25%), and 10.1% are at high risk (>25%) of failure. CONCLUSIONS: Previous attempts to identify high risk RD have been limited by small numbers, the inclusion of both scleral buckling and vitrectomy, or by excluding some types of RD. This study examined outcomes in unselected RD, treated by vitrectomy. Identification of the variables associated with anatomical outcome after RD surgery enables accurate risk stratification, which is valuable for patient counselling and selection, and for future clinical trials.

Factors affecting anatomical and visual outcome after macular hole surgery: findings from a large prospective UK cohort.

OBJECTIVES: To reassess the definition of a large macular hole, factors predicting hole closure and post-surgery visual recovery. DESIGN: Database study of 1483 primary macular hole operations. Eligible operations were primary MH operations treated with a vitrectomy and a gas or air tamponade. Excluded were eyes with a history of retinal detachment, high myopia, previous vitrectomy or trauma. RESULTS: A higher proportion of operations were performed in eyes from females (71.1%) who were 'on average' younger (p < 0.001), with slightly larger holes (p < 0.001) than male patients. Sulfur hexafluoride gas was generally used for smaller holes (p < 0.001). From 1253 operations with a known surgical outcome, successful hole closure was achieved in 1199 (96%) and influenced by smaller holes and complete ILM peeling (p < 0.001), but not post-surgery positioning (p = 0.072). A minimum linear diameter of ~500 µm marked the threshold where the success rate started to decline. From the 1056 successfully closed operations eligible for visual outcome analysis, visual success (defined as visual acuity of 0.30 or better logMAR) was achieved in 488 (46.2%) eyes. At the multivariate level, the factors predicting visual success were better pre-operative VA, smaller hole size, shorter duration of symptoms and the absence of AMD. CONCLUSIONS: Females undergoing primary macular hole surgery tend to be younger and have larger holes than male patients. The definition of a large hole should be changed to around 500 µm, and patients should be operated on early to help achieve a good post-operative VA.

Factors affecting visual recovery after successful repair of macula-off retinal detachments: findings from a large prospective UK cohort study.

OBJECTIVE: To identify risk factors affecting visual outcomes in successfully re-attached macula-off rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RD) surgery. DESIGN: A prospective study, using online databases, of visual outcomes for 2074 macula-off retinal detachments that were successfully re-attached by vitrectomy and internal tamponade. The database included detailed retinal diagrams of each detachment. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: The probability of achieving a post-operative visual acuity (VA) of ≤0.30 LogMAR (Snellen 6/12 or better). RESULTS: Male patients accounted for 64.9% of the sample and the median age was 63 years old. The median pre-operative VA was counting fingers (LogMAR 1.98); this improved to 0.41 LogMAR post-operatively. A post-operative VA of ≤0.30 LogMAR was achieved for 1012 (48.8%) eyes and the factors affecting this were the patient age and gender, pre-operative VA, duration of central vision loss, PVR grade, lens status, total RD and the presence of any ocular co-pathology where the model area under the receiver operator curve was 71.6%. CONCLUSIONS: From the identified risk factors that decrease the probability of achieving a post-operative visual acuity of ≤0.30 LogMAR, the most important modifiable risk factor was the duration of central vision loss. Recent macula-off retinal detachments should be repaired within 72 h of the loss of central vision.

Real world outcomes of ocriplasmin use by members of the British and Eire Association of Vitreoretinal Surgeons.

PurposeTo describe a survey of the use of ocriplasmin by members of the British and Eire Association of VitreoRetinal Surgeons (BEAVRS) for VitreoMacular Traction (VMT) and Full Thickness Macular Hole (FTMH) and compare it to published MIVI TRUST trial data.MethodsAll 173 BEAVRS members were contacted by email in October 2014 requesting data on all cases treated with ocriplasmin up to that date. The total number of cases, FTMH closure rate, VMT release rate and the frequency of adverse events were recorded. Results were compared with trial data.Results48 members responded reporting results from 241 eyes. The respective BEAVRS and MIVI TRUST trial closure rates for small FTMHs were 42.1 and 58.3% (P=0.09) and for medium FTMH 12.7 and 36.7% (P=0.01). The respective VMT release rates were 34.1 and 37.4% (P=NS). Retinal detachment was observed in 3.3% of the BEAVRS cohort compared with 0.4% in MIVI TRUST. Reduction in visual acuity to <6/60 was observed in 5.8% of the BEAVRS cohort and 0.6% in MIVI TRUST. Other complications not reported in the MIVI TRUST trial included an increase in FTMH basal diameter following unsuccessful ocriplasmin use in 46.9% of BEAVRS cases and zonular instability at the time of subsequent phacoemulsification in 2.4%.ConclusionMacular hole closure rates were lower in the BEAVRS survey than published in the MIVI TRUST trial data. The incidence of adverse events was greater than previously reported. The reasons for these disparities are unknown but could include positive reporting bias inherent to retrospective surveys, treatment and population differences.

The design and validation of an optical coherence tomography-based classification system for focal vitreomacular traction.

PURPOSE: To develop and validate a classification system for focal vitreomacular traction (VMT) with and without macular hole based on spectral domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT), intended to aid in decision-making and prognostication. METHODS: A panel of retinal specialists convened to develop this system. A literature review followed by discussion on a wide range of cases formed the basis for the proposed classification. Key features on OCT were identified and analysed for their utility in clinical practice. A final classification was devised based on two sequential, independent validation exercises to improve interobserver variability. RESULTS: This classification tool pertains to idiopathic focal VMT assessed by a horizontal line scan using SD-OCT. The system uses width (W), interface features (I), foveal shape (S), retinal pigment epithelial changes (P), elevation of vitreous attachment (E), and inner and outer retinal changes (R) to give the acronym WISPERR. Each category is scored hierarchically. Results from the second independent validation exercise indicated a high level of agreement between graders: intraclass correlation ranged from 0.84 to 0.99 for continuous variables and Fleiss' kappa values ranged from 0.76 to 0.95 for categorical variables. CONCLUSIONS: We present an OCT-based classification system for focal VMT that allows anatomical detail to be scrutinised and scored qualitatively and quantitatively using a simple, pragmatic algorithm, which may be of value in clinical practice as well as in future research studies.

Persistent subfoveolar fluid following retinal detachment surgery: an SD-OCT guided study on the incidence, aetiological associations, and natural history.

PURPOSE: To investigate the incidence and natural history of persistent subfoveolar fluid (PSF) following surgery for macular off rhegmatogenous retinal detachment and the effect of PSF on photoreceptor structure and final visual acuity. METHODS: Retrospective study of 61 cases with post-operative optical coherence tomography (OCT) performed within 12 weeks of surgery. Based on aetiology, cases were categorized into tractional retinal tears (TRT) group or atrophic round holes and dialyses (RHD) group to investigate the incidence and duration of PSF. A Kaplan-Meier graph was plotted to compare survival time of subfoveolar fluid for both groups. Following secondary reclassification of cases into those with and without PSF, the effect of PSF on final visual acuity and photoreceptor structure was investigated with Mann-Whitney U-test used for comparison. Spearman's correlation testing was used to probe associations between time to recorded resolution of PSF with final visual acuity and photoreceptor structure. RESULTS: Incidence of PSF was greater in the RHD group and persisted for longer compared with TRT group. No detectable adverse effect of PSF on final visual acuity was seen however an individual case of severe photoreceptor atrophy was observed. No significant correlation was found between the time to recorded resolution of PSF and the final visual acuity or to photoreceptor grading scores. CONCLUSIONS: A difference in incidence of PSF was detected between the aetiological groups. PSF was ubiquitous and slow to resolve in the RHD group. Most cases of PSF resolve without adverse sequelae; however, progressive photoreceptor atrophy and sub-optimal visual outcome may result in a minority.

Performance of a computerised visual acuity measurement device in subjects with age-related macular degeneration: comparison with gold standard ETDRS chart measurements.

PURPOSE: The aim of the study was to compare the performance of two different COMPlog computerised, single letter scoring, visual acuity (VA) measurements against gold standard Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) chart measurements in patients with age-related macular degeneration (AMD). One computerised algorithm presented five and the other presented three letters per line; both computerised algorithms utilised half, rather than the full-letter width spacing standard on ETDRS charts that might induce crowding, fixation problems, increased test-retest variability (TRV), and bias. METHODS: Fifty patients with AMD (mean age 83 years) underwent timed test and retest VA measurements using ETDRS charts and COMPlog five (C5) and three (C3) letters per line computerised VA measurement algorithms. All tests utilised single-letter scoring methodology. Bland and Altman methods were employed. Performance was measured in terms of bias, TRV, and test time. RESULTS: The C5 and C3 scores showed no bias compared with the ETDRS chart measurements. C5 measurements had equal TRV to the ETDRS chart (±0.13 logMAR) with similar median test times (105 and 96 s, respectively). C3 measurements were slightly more variable (TRV ±0.17 logMAR), but 30 s quicker than ETDRS chart measurements. CONCLUSIONS: The closer letter spacing employed in COMPlog testing algorithms appears to have no adverse effect on VA measurements compared with the gold standard ETDRS chart in patients with AMD. The three letter per line testing algorithm facilitates faster testing but with a two letter increase in TRV.

Prevalence of vitreomacular interface abnormalities on spectral domain optical coherence tomography of patients undergoing macular photocoagulation for centre involving diabetic macular oedema.

AIM: Macular traction may influence the formation and response to treatment of diabetic macular oedema (DME). The aim of this study was to determine the prevalence and associations of spectral domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) evident epiretinal membrane (ERM) and/or partial vitreomacular separation (pVMS) in consecutive patients undergoing macular photocoagulation for centre involving DME. METHODS: A single-centre retrospective cross-sectional observational study. RESULTS: 198 eyes of 198 patients were included. Twelve per cent of eyes demonstrated pVMS and 14% ERM. All cases of pVMS had vitreoretinal adhesion located in the Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study grid central 1 mm subfield. In 2/3 of ERM cases, ERM was either found in the central subfield or the thickening associated with ERM was contiguous with the thickening in the central subfield. Patients with signs of ERM or pVMS were significantly older and had significantly worse acuity than those without (mean age 67.2 vs 62.8 years (p=0.02); 0.49 vs 0.31 logMAR, p=0.0006). Macular thickness was similar in both groups. The prevalence of pVMS and/or ERM were 31% in Caucasian, 5% in Asian and 24% in Afro-Caribbean subjects (p=0.11). CONCLUSIONS: ERM or pVMS was found on SD-OCT scanning in 25% of patients undergoing laser for centre involving DME. In 20% of all patients, these potentially tractional elements were either present in the central subfield scan or the traction was contiguous with the central macular thickening, suggesting a possible role for surgical or enzymatic relief of traction in their management. This requires targeted investigation.

Validation of printed and computerised crowded Kay picture logMAR tests against gold standard ETDRS acuity test chart measurements in adult and amblyopic paediatric subjects.

AIMS: The impression exists that picture acuity scores may overestimate function when subjects are switched to letter charts. This has not been systematically investigated. The aims of this study were to validate both printed crowded Kay picture (pCKP) and computerised CKP (cCKP) logMAR test acuity measurements against gold standard ETDRS letter chart scores. METHODS: A total of 30 adult subjects with various ophthalmic disease and 40 amblyopic children underwent test and re-test visual acuity measurements using the ETDRS chart, the pCKP logMAR test, and the cCKP acuity scores taken, using the COMPlog visual acuity measurement system. Bland and Altman methods were employed. RESULTS: Computerised and printed Kay picture acuity scores agreed well. Both Kay picture test measurements were systematically biased when compared with ETDRS chart measurements. No significant proportional bias was found. The test retest variability (TRV) of all three tests was found to be similar between ± 0.14 and 0.16 logMAR in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: All three tests were similarly replicable and computerised Kay pictures appear to be a valid alternative to hard copy Kay pictures. Kay picture acuity measurements were systematically biased when compared with the gold standard ETDRS. Measurement error means that differences of up to 0.16 logMAR may be observed in clinically stable patients when re-measured using the same technique. A combination of TRV and systematic bias can however lead to differences of up to 0.40 logMAR in stable amblyopic patients when switched from CKPs to ETDRS chart acuity measurements.

Predicting visual success in macular hole surgery.

AIM: Data on the outcome of surgery facilitate informed preoperative patient counselling. Most studies on the outcome of surgery for idiopathic full thickness macular hole surgery have concentrated on rates of anatomical closure. The aim of this study was to identify factors predicting visual success (better than 20/40; 6/12 Snellen) following macular hole surgery. METHODS: A retrospective study of 133 patients undergoing standardised macular hole surgery with at least 3 months of postoperative follow-up. All patients underwent preoperative measurement of the maximum macular hole diameter using optical coherence tomography. RESULTS: Multivariable regression analysis identified that age, preoperative visual acuity and macular hole size were significant predictors of visual success. The resulting model correctly classified the visual outcome of 80% of cases. Predicted rates of visual success varied from 93% in patients <60 years old with visual acuity better than 6/24 and a hole diameter of <350 mum, to 2% in patients those >79 years old with visual acuity of 6/60 or worse and hole diameter of >500 microm. CONCLUSION: The results provide a simple and clinically useful model to employ when counselling patients on macular hole surgery.

Vitreoretinal management of the complications of sickle cell retinopathy by observation or pars plana vitrectomy.

PURPOSE: To describe the management of vitreoretinal complications of sickle cell retinopathy. DESIGN: A retrospective interventional case series. METHODS: Review of an electronic patient record and clinical notes of 27 patients with vitreoretinal complications of sickle retinopathy. RESULTS: Six male patients and 21 female patients presented with a mean age of 41 years (range 28-67), 12 left eyes and 16 right eyes. The mean follow-up was 15.5 months (range: 3-60). Two patients were SS, and the remainders were doubly heterozygous (SC). In all, 10 were observed without surgery- three with vitreous haemorrhage, four tractional retinal detachments (TRD), and three rhegmatogenous retinal detachments (RRD). Two patients demonstrated spontaneous flattening of the retina- one RRD and one TRD. Eighteen eyes had pars plana vitrectomies (PPVs)- seven with vitreous haemorrhage, three RRD, three TRD, three ERM (one bilateral), and two macular holes. In all, 15 patients (83%) had improved vision postoperatively. The mean logMar preoperative visual acuity was 1.07 (Snellen equivalent 6/70), SD 0.62 was significantly improved postoperatively (mean 0.42 (6/15), SD 0.48, P=0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Sickle retinopathy occasionally presents with vitreoretinal complications. These can often be observed and may spontaneously regress. If surgery is required eyes respond to vitrectomy procedures with segmentation of sea fan proliferation.

Severe folding of the inferior retina after relaxing retinectomy for proliferative vitreoretinopathy.

PURPOSE: Proliferative vitreoretinopathy (PVR) is a severe complication of retinal detachment, which can be treated surgically by relaxing retinectomy. In this study, we describe patients with severe inferior retinal folding after this surgical intervention (SIRF). METHODS: A retrospective review of the electronic patient records of 254 patients who received relaxing retinectomies was performed to identify patients with SIRF. RESULTS: Five patients (1.97% of those with retinectomy) were identified with SIRF, mean age, 51.4 years; mean follow-up, 36 months. Three patients had rhegmatogenous retinal detachment (RRD) with PVR, one had a dropped nucleus with RRD and PVR and one with giant retinal dialysis from ocular trauma. SIRF was noted from a mean 4.2 months after the retinectomy. All involved the macula and visions were hand movements or perception of light. CONCLUSIONS: SIRF is an uncommon but devastating complication of relaxing retinectomy with a poor visual outcome. This is the first description of this condition that we are aware of.

A new technique of combined retinal and choroidal biopsy.

AIMS: To evaluate a new technique in large retinal and choroidal biopsies in patients with uveitis of unknown aetiology and chorioretinal lesions or infiltrate. METHODS: Retrospective, non-comparative, consecutive interventional case series. Patients were identified from the computerised patient database and from histopathology records. RESULTS: A total of nine patients were included in the study. The commonest indication of biopsy was panuveitis of unknown aetiology. Positive histological diagnoses from the chorioretinal biopsies were made in five cases (55.6%). Complications included vitreous haemorrhages and one case of retinal detachment. CONCLUSION: The technique of large chorioretinal biopsy described appears to be safe. It produced good amounts of chorioretinal tissue for histopathological analysis. Positive histology results were seen in the majority of the sample and especially in those where vitreous biopsy alone proved to be inadequate.

Vitrectomy for diabetic macular oedema.

AIM: To briefly review and discuss the literature on vitrectomy for diabetic macular oedema. METHODS: Literature review. RESULTS: There is a copious literature on the subject of vitrectomy for diabetic macular oedema (DMO). The most commonly hypothesised mechanism for the potential benefit of vitrectomy is relief of vitreomacular traction; however, both transvitreal oxygenation and improved growth factor diffusion away from the premacular retina have also been suggested to be potentially beneficial effects. Other systemic and local factors including duration of oedema, extent of ischaemia and exudation, and extent of laser may result in permanent photoreceptor and capillary damage, which precludes anatomical or visual benefit. Much of the literature on the subject of vitrectomy for DMO is retrospective and uncontrolled but strongly suggestive of a benefit in terms of improved acuity and reduced macular thickness following vitrectomy. There are five published small randomised controlled trials on this subject. Taken as a whole, these studies do not suggest a benefit from surgery. Selection of patients for surgery on the basis of OCT partial vitreomacular separation or clinical signs of traction such as an epiretinal membrane or taut thickened hyaloid has been reported to be associated with a modest improvement in prospective studies but this has not been subjected to controlled study. CONCLUSION: The evidence at present suggests that vitrectomy for DMO should be restricted to those with clinical or OCT signs of traction.

Validation of a computerised logMAR visual acuity measurement system (COMPlog): comparison with ETDRS and the electronic ETDRS testing algorithm in adults and amblyopic children.

BACKGROUND/AIM: The COMPlog clinical visual acuity measuring system is being developed for both routine and research use. This study aimed to validate its performance in amblyopic children and both normal and diseased adults against the gold standard ETDRS chart and the E-ETDRS computerised acuity measurement algorithm. METHOD: Timed test and retest fully interpolated five letters per line logMAR visual acuity measurements were taken for 70 adults and 59 amblyopic children using the ETDRS chart and the COMPlog visual acuity measurement system. 39 of the adults also underwent computerised acuity testing using the E-ETDRS testing algorithm. The tested adults included normals as well as subjects with a range of ocular diseases. The methods of Bland and Altman were employed with test-retest variability (TRV) expressed as 95% confidence limits for agreement. RESULTS: No significant bias was observed between the gold standard ETDRS acuity measurements and those taken with either COMPlog or E-ETDRS. TRVs of +/-0.12 logMAR and +/-0.10 logMAR were respectively found for COMPlog measurements in the amblyopic children and adult groups compared with +/-0.12 logMAR for the ETDRS chart in both groups. The TRV of the E-ETDRS system was slightly greater at +/-0.16 logMAR. Median testing times for COMPlog and ETDRS were 95 and 85 s and 66 and 56 s respectively in the paediatric and adult groups and 120 s for the E-ETDRS measurements on adults. DISCUSSION: COMPlog measurements agree well with and are similarly reliable to the gold standard ETDRS chart with comparable test times. E-ETDRS algorithm measurements took approximately twice as long.

How effective is macula-off retinal detachment surgery. Might good outcome be predicted?

PURPOSE: To determine factors associated with anatomical and functional outcomes of macula-off retinal detachment surgery in a modern vitreoretinal unit. METHODS: A retrospective casenote review of 185 patients presenting with macula-off retinal detachment was performed. Demographic and ocular characteristics were determined. Logistic regression analysis was used to determine (1) the effect of these factors on visual outcome and (2) their effect on primary and final anatomical success. RESULTS: Primary and ultimate anatomical success were achieved in 76 and 84% of cases. Patients with oil in at final follow-up were considered to be anatomical failures. Statistically significant factors predicting primary anatomical success using a multiple variable model were preoperative logMAR visual acuity, preoperative PVR and number of breaks. Preop logMAR visual acuity and duration of macular detachment were the statistically significant factors predicting ultimate success. In all, 44% of patients regained 6/12 Snellen or better with a median improvement of 0.78 logMAR. For prediction of visual outcome (in patients with no ocular comorbidity) only preoperative logMAR visual acuity achieved statistical significance (P=0.001) at the P=0.05 level. CONCLUSION: In all, 76% of macula-off detachments may be repaired with one operation and 44% of patients regain at least 6/12 Snellen. The median logMAR acuity increment of 0.78 far exceeds that seen in cataract surgery. Preoperative visual acuity is the most important factor predicting primary and final anatomical success as well as visual outcome. Preoperative PVR, number of breaks and duration of detachment also affect outcomes.

Factors predicting outcome of vitrectomy for diabetic macular oedema: results of a prospective study.

AIM: To determine preoperative demographic, clinical, and optical coherence tomography (OCT) factors which might predict the visual and anatomical outcome at 1 year in patients undergoing vitrectomy and inner limiting membrane peel for diabetic macular oedema (DMO). METHODS: A prospective, interventional case series of 33 patients who completed 1 year follow up. Measurements were taken preoperatively and at 1 year. Outcome measures were logMAR visual acuity (VA) and OCT macular thickness. A priori explanatory variables included baseline presence of clinical and/or OCT signs suggesting macular traction, grade of diabetic maculopathy, posterior vitreous detachment, fluorescein leakage and ischaemia on angiography, presence of subretinal fluid, and peroperative indocyanine green (ICG) use. RESULTS: 33 patients completed 1 year follow up. On average VA deteriorated by 0.035 logMAR (p = 0.40). Macular thickness significantly improved by a mean of 139 microm (95% CI; 211 to 67, p<0.001). Patients with evidence of clinical and/or OCT macular traction significantly improved logMAR acuity (logMAR improvement = 0.08) compared with patients without traction (logMAR deterioration 0.11, p = 0.01). Presence of subretinal fluid significantly predicted worse postoperative result (p = 0.01) CONCLUSION: On average, patients showed a statistically significant improvement in central macular thickness following treatment but a marginal acuity worsening. Presence of subretinal fluid on OCT is hypothesised to be exudative rather than tractional in nature. The visual benefit of vitrectomy for DMO in this study was limited to patients who exhibit signs of macular traction either clinically and/or on OCT.