Convergent evolution in the supercoiling of prokaryotic flagellar filaments.

The supercoiling of bacterial and archaeal flagellar filaments is required for motility. Archaeal flagellar filaments have no homology to their bacterial counterparts and are instead homologs of bacterial type IV pili. How these prokaryotic flagellar filaments, each composed of thousands of copies of identical subunits, can form stable supercoils under torsional stress is a fascinating puzzle for which structural insights have been elusive. Advances in cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM) make it now possible to directly visualize the basis for supercoiling, and here, we show the atomic structures of supercoiled bacterial and archaeal flagellar filaments. For the bacterial flagellar filament, we identify 11 distinct protofilament conformations with three broad classes of inter-protomer interface. For the archaeal flagellar filament, 10 protofilaments form a supercoil geometry supported by 10 distinct conformations, with one inter-protomer discontinuity creating a seam inside of the curve. Our results suggest that convergent evolution has yielded stable superhelical geometries that enable microbial locomotion.

The structure of EXTL3 helps to explain the different roles of bi-domain exostosins in heparan sulfate synthesis.

Heparan sulfate is a highly modified O-linked glycan that performs diverse physiological roles in animal tissues. Though quickly modified, it is initially synthesised as a polysaccharide of alternating ß-D-glucuronosyl and N-acetyl-α-D-glucosaminyl residues by exostosins. These enzymes generally possess two glycosyltransferase domains (GT47 and GT64)-each thought to add one type of monosaccharide unit to the backbone. Although previous structures of murine exostosin-like 2 (EXTL2) provide insight into the GT64 domain, the rest of the bi-domain architecture is yet to be characterised; hence, how the two domains co-operate is unknown. Here, we report the structure of human exostosin-like 3 (EXTL3) in apo and UDP-bound forms. We explain the ineffectiveness of EXTL3's GT47 domain to transfer ß-D-glucuronosyl units, and we observe that, in general, the bi-domain architecture would preclude a processive mechanism of backbone extension. We therefore propose that heparan sulfate backbone polymerisation occurs by a simple dissociative mechanism.

Crystal structure of the carbapenem intrinsic resistance protein CarG.

In the Gram-negative enterobacterium Erwinia (Pectobacterium) and Serratia sp. ATCC 39006, intrinsic resistance to the carbapenem antibiotic 1-carbapen-2-em-3-carboxylic acid is mediated by the CarF and CarG proteins, by an unknown mechanism. Here, we report a high-resolution crystal structure for the Serratia sp. ATCC 39006 carbapenem resistance protein CarG. This structure of CarG is the first in the carbapenem intrinsic resistance (CIR) family of resistance proteins from carbapenem-producing bacteria. The crystal structure shows the protein to form a homodimer, in agreement with results from analytical gel filtration. The structure of CarG does not show homology with any known antibiotic resistance proteins nor does it belong to any well-characterised protein structural family. However, it is a close structural homologue of the bacterial inhibitor of invertebrate lysozyme, PliI-Ah, with some interesting structural variations, including the absence of the catalytic site responsible for lysozyme inhibition. Both proteins show a unique ß-sandwich fold with short terminal α-helices. The core of the protein is formed by stacked anti-parallel sheets that are individually very similar in the two proteins but differ in their packing interface, causing the splaying of the two sheets in CarG. Furthermore, a conserved cation binding site identified in CarG is absent from the homologue.

Geometric principles in the assembly of α-helical bundles.

α-Helical coiled coils are usually stabilized by hydrophobic interfaces between the two constituent α-helices, in the form of 'knobs-into-holes' packing of non-polar residues arranged in repeating heptad patterns. Here we examine the corresponding 'hydrophobic cores' that stabilize bundles of four α-helices. In particular, we study three different kinds of bundle, involving four α-helices of identical sequence: two pack in a parallel and one in an anti-parallel orientation. We point out that the simplest way of understanding the packing of these 4-helix bundles is to use Crick's original idea that the helices are held together by 'hydrophobic stripes', which are readily visualized on the cylindrical surface lattice of the α-helices; and that the 'helix-crossing angle'--which determines, in particular, whether supercoiling is left- or right-handed--is fixed by the slope of the lattice lines that contain the hydrophobic residues. In our three examples the constituent α-helices have hydrophobic repeat patterns of 7, 11 and 4 residues, respectively; and we associate the different overall conformations with 'knobs-into-holes' packing along the 7-, 11- and 4-start lines, respectively, of the cylindrical surface lattices of the constituent α-helices. For the first two examples, all four interfaces between adjacent helices are geometrically equivalent; but in the third, one of the four interfaces differs significantly from the others. We provide a geometrical explanation for this non-equivalence in terms of two different but equivalent ways of assembling this bundle, which may possibly constitute a bistable molecular 'switch' with a coaxial throw of about 12 Å. The geometrical ideas that we deploy in this paper provide the simplest and clearest description of the structure of helical bundles. In an appendix, we describe briefly a computer program that we have devised in order to search for 'knobs-into-holes' packing between α-helices in proteins.

A "mechanistic" explanation of the multiple helical forms adopted by bacterial flagellar filaments.

The corkscrew-like flagellar filaments emerging from the surface of bacteria such as Salmonella typhimurium propel the cells toward nutrient and away from repellents. This kind of motility depends upon the ability of the flagellar filaments to adopt a range of distinct helical forms. A filament is typically constructed from ~30,000 identical flagellin molecules, which self-assemble into a tubular structure containing 11 near-longitudinal protofilaments. A "mechanical" model, in which the flagellin building block has the capacity to switch between two principal interfacial states, predicts that the filament can assemble into a "canonical" family of 12 distinct helical forms, each having unique curvature and twist: these include two "extreme" straight forms having left- and right-handed twists, respectively, and 10 intermediate helical forms. Measured shapes of the filaments correspond well with predictions of the model. This report is concerned with two unanswered questions. First, what properties of the flagellin determine which of the 12 discrete forms is preferred? Second, how does the interfacial "switch" work, at a molecular level? Our proposed solution of these problems is based mainly on a detailed examination of differences between the available electron cryo-microscopy structures of the straight L and R filaments, respectively.

Amyloidogenicity and aggregate cytotoxicity of human glucagon-like peptide-1 (hGLP-1).

The potential of human glucagon-like peptide-1 (hGLP-1) as a therapeutic agent is limited by its high aggregation propensity. We show that hGLP-1 forms amyloid-like structures that are preceded by cytotoxic aggregates, suggesting that aggregation of biopharmaceuticals could present a cytotoxic risk to patients besides the reported increased risk in immunogenicity.

Complementing structural information of modular proteins with small angle neutron scattering and contrast variation.

Many macromolecules in the cell function by forming multi-component assemblies. We have applied the technique of small angle neutron scattering to study a nucleic acid-protein complex and a multi-protein complex. The results illustrate the versatility and applicability of the method to study macromolecular assemblies. The neutron scattering experiments, complementing X-ray solution scattering data, reveal that the conserved catalytic domain of RNase E, an essential ribonuclease in Escherichia coli (E. coli), undergoes a marked conformational change upon binding a 5'monophosphate-RNA substrate analogue. This provides the first evidence in support of an allosteric mechanism that brings about RNA substrate cleavage. Neutron contrast variation of the multi-protein TIM10 complex, a mitochondrial chaperone assembly comprising the subunits Tim9 and Tim10, has been used to determine a low-resolution shape reconstruction of the complex, highlighting the integral subunit organization. It shows characteristic features involving protrusions that could be assigned to the six subunits forming the complex.

Design and chance in the self-assembly of macromolecules.

The principles of self-assembly are described for naturally occurring macromolecules and for complex assemblies formed from simple synthetic constituents. Many biological molecules owe their function and specificity to their three-dimensional folds, and, in many cases, these folds are specified entirely by the sequence of the constituent amino acids or nucleic acids, and without the requirement for additional machinery to guide the formation of the structure. Thus sequence may often be sufficient to guide the assembly process, starting from denatured components having little or no folds, to the completion state with the stable, equilibrium fold that encompasses functional activity. Self-assembly of homopolymeric structures does not necessarily preserve symmetry, and some polymeric assemblies are organized so that their chemically identical subunits pack stably in geometrically non-equivalent ways. Self-assembly can also involve scaffolds that lack structure, as seen in the multi-enzyme assembly, the degradosome. The stable self-assembly of lipids into dynamic membraneous sheets is also described, and an example is shown in which a synthetic detergent can assemble into membrane layers.

Structure, mechanism and catalytic duality of thiamine-dependent enzymes.

Thiamine is an essential cofactor that is required for processes of general metabolism amongst all organisms, and it is likely to have played a role in the earliest stages of the evolution of life. Here, we review from a structural perspective the enzymatic mechanisms that involve this cofactor. We explore asymmetry within homodimeric thiamine diphosphate (ThDP)-dependent enzyme structures and discuss how this may be correlated with the kinetic properties of half-of-the-sites reactivity, and negative cooperativity. It is likely these structural and kinetic hallmarks may arise through reciprocal coupling of active sites. This mode of communication between distant active sites is not unique to ThDP-dependent enzymes, but is widespread in other classes of oligomeric enzyme. Thus, it appears likely to be a general phenomenon reflecting a powerful mechanism of accelerating the rate of a chemical pathway. Finally, we speculate on the early evolutionary history of the cofactor and its ancient association with protein and RNA.

Crystal structure of the Escherichia coli RNA degradosome component enolase.

The crystal structure of Escherichia coli enolase (EC 4.2.1.11, phosphopyruvate hydratase), which is a component of the RNA degradosome, has been determined at 2.5 A. There are four molecules in the asymmetric unit of the C2 cell, and in one of the molecules, flexible loops close onto the active site. This closure mimics the conformation of the substrate-bound intermediate. A comparison of the structure of the E. coli enolase with the eukaryotic enolase structures available (lobster and yeast) indicates a high degree of conservation of the hydrophobic core and the subunit interface of this homodimeric enzyme. The dimer interface is enriched in charged residues compared with other protein homodimers, which may explain our observations from analytical ultracentrifugation that dimerisation is affected by ionic strength. The putative role of enolase in the RNA degradosome is discussed; although it was not possible to ascribe a specific role to it, a structural role is possible.

The role of the TolC family in protein transport and multidrug efflux. From stereochemical certainty to mechanistic hypothesis.

Gram-negative bacteria are enveloped by a system of two membranes, and they use specialized multicomponent, energy-driven pumps to transport molecules directly across this double-layered partition from the cell interior to the extra-cellular environment. One component of these pumps is embedded in the outer-membrane, and the paradigm for its structure and function is the TolC protein from Escherichia coli. A common component of a wide variety of efflux pumps, TolC and its homologues are involved in the export of chemically diverse molecules ranging from large protein toxins, such as alpha-hemolysin, to small toxic compounds, such as antibiotics. TolC family members thus play important roles in conferring pathogenic bacteria with both virulence and multidrug resistance. These pumps assemble reversibly in a transient process that brings together TolC or its homologue, an inner-membrane-associated periplasmic component, an integral inner-membrane translocase and the substrate itself. TolC can associate in this fashion with a variety of different partners to participate in the transport of diverse substrates. We review here the structure and function of TolC and the other components of the efflux/transport pump.

Expression of the Oct-1 transcription factor and characterization of its interactions with the Bob1 coactivator.

The Oct-1 transcription factor regulates a variety of tissue-specific and general housekeeping genes by recruiting specialized coactivators of transcription. It acts synergistically with the B-cell-specific coactivator Bob1 (OCA-B, OBF-1) to stimulate transcription of immunoglobulin genes. To analyze Oct-1's interactions with Bob1 and other regulatory proteins, we have overexpressed and purified different functional domains of the recombinant proteins. A version of Oct-1 that encompasses the amino-terminal activation region and the POU DNA-binding domain was extensively characterized (OctDeltaC1; comprising residues 1-445). Using an in vitro transcription assay, we demonstrate that this fragment is sufficient and necessary to stimulate transcription from an immunoglobulin promoter with Bob1. It also coactivates from the herpes simplex virus ICPO promoter element in the presence of VP16. Using a range of spectroscopic and biophysical techniques, we demonstrate that the activation domains of Oct-1 and Bob1 have little globular structure and that they do not physically interact. Thus, their functional synergy is likely to arise by the co-recruitment of common factors as part of a larger regulatory assembly. We propose a hypothesis to explain why the activation domains of these and other transcription factors of metazoans have little if any intrinsic structure.

Molecular shapes of transcription factors TFIIB and VP16 in solution: implications for recognition.

The molecular shapes of transcription factors TFIIB and VP16 have been studied by small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). We interpret the shapes and discuss the implications for the specific recruitment of these proteins into regulatory assemblies. Human transcription factor TFIIB, a universal component of the transcription preinitiation complex, has a triangular form resulting from intramolecular associations between its two principal structural domains. A segment linking the two domains appears to be conformationally flexible. The solution shape of TFIIB can be well fitted with the crystal structure of the DNA-bound C-terminal domain together with the NMR structure of the N-terminal domain; however, the shape cannot accommodate the NMR structure of the isolated C-terminal domain. We discuss how the conformational differences between the solution structures of the isolated C-terminal domain and the intact protein might result from interdomain allostery. Docking the SAXS shape of intact TFIIB into the preinitiation complex suggests that the flexible linker region may contact the 3' flanking region of the TATA element in the major groove. Transcription rates can be enhanced by activator proteins, and the classical example is the herpes simplex virus factor VP16 (alpha-TIF), which associates with cellular transcription factors, including TFIIB. The shape reconstruction of VP16 from its SAXS profile reveals a globular structural core that can be well modeled by the crystal structure of a conserved, central region of the protein. However, the carboxy terminus extends from this core and is essentially disordered. As it makes defined protein-protein interactions in the activation complex, the flexible segment is likely to condense upon assembly with its partners.

How to untwist an alpha-helix: structural principles of an alpha-helical barrel.

Recent crystallographic studies have revealed that 12 alpha-helices can pack in an anti-parallel fashion to form a hollow cylinder of nearly uniform radius. In this architecture, which we refer to as an alpha-barrel, the helices are inclined with respect to the cylindrical axis, and thus they curve and twist. As with conventional coiled-coils, the helices of the barrel associate via "knobs-into-holes" interactions; however, their packing is distinct in several important ways. First, the alpha-barrel helices untwist in comparison with the helices found in two-stranded coiled-coils and, as a consequence of this distortion, their knobs approach closely one end of the complementary holes. This effect defines a requirement for particular size and shape of the protruding residues, and it is associated with a relative axial translation of the paired helices. Second, as each helix packs laterally with two neighbours, the helices have two sequence patterns that are phased to match the two interfaces. The two types of interface are not equivalent and, as one travels around the circumference of the cylinder's interior, they alternate between one type where the knobs approach the holes straight-on, and a second type in which they are inclined. The choice of amino acid depends on the interface type, with small hydrophobic side-chains preferred for the direct contacts and larger aliphatic side-chains for the inclined contacts. Third, small residues are found preferentially on the inside of the tube, in order to make the "wedge" angle between helices compatible with a 12-member tube. Finally, hydrogen-bonding interactions of side-chains within and between helices support the assembly. Using these salient structural features, we present a sequence template that is compatible with some underlying rules for the packing of helices in the barrel, and which may have application to the design of higher-order assemblies from peptides, such as nano-tubes. We discuss the general implications of relative axial translation in coiled-coils and, in particular, the potential role that this movement could play in allosteric mechanisms.

A duplicated fold is the structural basis for polynucleotide phosphorylase catalytic activity, processivity, and regulation.

BACKGROUND: Polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase) is a polyribonucleotide nucleotidyl transferase (E.C.2.7.7.8) that degrades mRNA in prokaryotes. Streptomyces antibioticus PNPase also assays as a guanosine 3'-diphosphate 5'-triphosphate (pppGpp) synthetase (E.C.2.7.6.5). It may function to coordinate changes in mRNA lifetimes with pppGpp levels during the Streptomyces lifecycle. RESULTS: The structure of S. antibioticus PNPase without bound RNA but with the phosphate analog tungstate bound at the PNPase catalytic sites was determined by X-ray crystallography and shows a trimeric multidomain protein with a central channel. The structural core has a novel duplicated architecture formed by association of two homologous domains. The tungstate derivative structure reveals the PNPase active site in the second of these core domains. Structure-based sequence analysis suggests that the pppGpp synthetase active site is located in the first core domain. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first structure of a PNPase and shows the structural basis for the trimer assembly, the arrangement of accessory RNA binding domains, and the likely catalytic residues of the PNPase active site. A possible function of the trimer channel is as a contribution to both the processivity of degradation and the regulation of PNPase action by RNA structural elements.

Crystal structure of the bacterial membrane protein TolC central to multidrug efflux and protein export.

Diverse molecules, from small antibacterial drugs to large protein toxins, are exported directly across both cell membranes of gram-negative bacteria. This export is brought about by the reversible interaction of substrate-specific inner-membrane proteins with an outer-membrane protein of the TolC family, thus bypassing the intervening periplasm. Here we report the 2.1-A crystal structure of TolC from Escherichia coli, revealing a distinctive and previously unknown fold. Three TolC protomers assemble to form a continuous, solvent-accessible conduit--a 'channel-tunnel' over 140 A long that spans both the outer membrane and periplasmic space. The periplasmic or proximal end of the tunnel is sealed by sets of coiled helices. We suggest these could be untwisted by an allosteric mechanism, mediated by protein-protein interactions, to open the tunnel. The structure provides an explanation of how the cell cytosol is connected to the external environment during export, and suggests a general mechanism for the action of bacterial efflux pumps.

Characterization of sequence-specific DNA binding by the transcription factor Oct-1.

The DNA-binding domain of the Oct-1 transcription factor, POU, recognizes a defined DNA sequence known as the octamer element to regulate the expression of both general and cell-type-specific genes. The two-part DNA-binding domain partially encircles the DNA to recognize the eight base pairs of the octamer element. We have characterized the binding of Oct-1/POU to an octamer element using isothermal titration calorimetry. As found for other cognate protein/DNA complexes, the formation of the Oct-1 POU/DNA complex is associated with a large negative heat capacity change, DeltaC(p)()(, obs). However, the observed change is much greater than expected by empirical relationships with buried surface area. Supported by data from proteolysis studies on the free and DNA-bound protein, we propose that the discrepancy in heat capacity arises principally from the partial folding of the Oct-1 POU protein upon complex formation. Formation of the Oct-1 POU/DNA complex is strongly dependent on ionic strength, and the detailed quantification of this relationship suggests that six charged contacts are made between the protein and the phosphate groups of the DNA. This agrees with observations from the crystal structure of an Oct-1 POU/DNA complex.

Oxidation of selenomethionine: some MADness in the method!

Since it was first reported, the multiwavelength anomalous diffraction (MAD) technique for the determination of protein structures has become widely accepted and increasingly popular. Here, it is demonstrated that the anomalous signal from selenomethione (SeMet) substituted proteins can be significantly enhanced by oxidation.

The virtuoso of versatility: POU proteins that flex to fit.

During the evolution of eukaryotes, a new structural motif arose by the fusion of genes encoding two different types of DNA-binding domain. The family of transcription factors which contain this domain, the POU proteins, have come to play essential roles not only in the development of highly specialised tissues, such as complex neuronal systems, but also in more general cellular housekeeping. Members of the POU family recognise defined DNA sequences, and a well-studied subset have specificity for a motif known as the octamer element which is found in the promoter region of a variety of genes. The structurally bipartite POU domain has intrinsic conformational flexibility and this feature appears to confer functional diversity to this class of transcription factors. The POU domain for which we have the most structural data is from Oct-1, which binds an eight base-pair target and variants of this octamer site. The two-part DNA-binding domain partially encircles the DNA, with the sub-domains able to assume a variety of conformations, dependent on the DNA element. Crystallographic and biochemical studies have shown that the binary complex provides distinct platforms for the recruitment of specific regulators to control transcription. The conformability of the POU domain in moulding to DNA elements and co-regulators provides a mechanism for combinatorial assembly as well as allosteric molecular recognition. We review here the structure and function of the diverse POU proteins and discuss the role of the proteins' plasticity in recognition and transcriptional regulation.